Market Efficiency And Anomalies Essay

1645 words - 7 pages

FINC3017 Investments and Portfolio Management
Essay: Market Efficiency and Anomalies

Topic:Stock price momentum: Jegadeesh and Titman (1993)

Momentum anomaly and EMH
Anomaly is a stock return deviation that challenge efficient market hypothesis (EMH). Jegadeesh and Titman (1993) theorise price momentum anomaly in the stock market for the first time. It contradicted to efficient market hypothesis thereby is widely debated. EMH states that no consistent excess return can be achieved since security prices fully reflect all available information (Fama 1970). Therefore, future prices cannot be predicted through technical analysis of past prices. If the hypothesis is true, passive ...view middle of the document...

But underperformance will remain worse. Grundy and Martin (2001) show that round-trip cost above 1.5% makes the anomaly unprofitable.

It is difficult to explain price momentum use traditional risk-return model (Fama and French (1996), Grundy and Martin (2001)). But, momentum anomaly exists for reasons. The underlying mechanism of the anomaly can be explained from the perspective of behavioural finance and Knightian uncertainty. Both underreaction and delayed overreaction to the information can cause price momentum.

Barberis, Schleifer and Vishny (1998) show that because of conservatism (Edwards 1968), investors tend to underweighting new information at the beginning. Information slowly spread and slowly incorporates into share price. Therefore, current information can predict future price. Momentum anomaly exists. However, in the long term, overreaction will lead the stock price to reverse which is consistent with De Bondt and Thaler (1985).

Hong and Stein (1999) divide investors into ‘news watchers’ and ‘momentum traders’ groups. It demonstrates different functions of investors rather than cognitive bias. As information gradually circulate among news watchers, underreaction cause price momentum. With momentum traders start trading, market is overreacting, then price revert in the long run. Chan, Jegadeesh and Lakonishok (1996) arrived at the same conclusion. Besides, it asserts the inertia exist because of the prolonged revising of analyst forecasts.

On the other hand, Daniel, Hirshleifer and Subrahmanyam(1998) assume investors are overconfidence to private information. When information spread out, due to self-attribution phenomenon, investors will overreact and generate momentum profit.

Since current risk-return model cannot fully explain momentum effect, there might be some immeasurable risks exist to explain this anomaly. It is called Knightian uncertainty (Knight 1921). Ford, Kelsey and Pang (2005) believe most individuals are ambiguity-averse. When Knightian uncertainty exists, basic value of the stock cannot be estimated accurately. Trading frequency may increase to avoid risk, therefore cause price momentum. Herd behavior might be another reason as well.

However, Du (2012) calls for review explanation to momentum effect because neither risk nor behavioral biases in isolation can explain this anomaly.

Momentum effect across time and countries
Price momentum exists in the US market over time. Jegadeesh and Titman (1993) observe momentum effect from 1965 to 1989. Jegadeesh and Titman (2001) show the effect from 1965 to 1998. Jegadeesh and Titman (2011) confirm the effect exists from 1965 to 2005. Momentum strategy continuous to generate above average since it was first documented in 1990s.

Besides, price momentum was observed in many countries. Rouwenhorst (1998) finds momentum in 12 European countries from 1978 to 1995. Hu and Chan (2011) observe significant continuous excess returns across 48 countries from...

Other Papers Like Market Efficiency and Anomalies

Finance Essay

2010 words - 9 pages overreact to information. He argues that if anomalies split randomly between underreaction and overreaction, they are consistent with market efficiency. Secondly, he finds that long-term return anomalies are sensitive to methodology. They tend to become marginal or disappear when different models for expected returns or when different statistical approaches are used to measure them [Fama, 1998, p.284].In fact, research by DeBondt & Thaler (1985

Beaformativegroup Essay

668 words - 3 pages Basic Company Information Before looking at any of the different analysis techniques, it is good to spend some time doing a little bit of background research into the company you are investigating. This will help to put the technical analysis into an appropriate context and allow a greater level of insight into any anomalies the analysis throws up. * Brief History; * Description of Industry Membership, Main Business and Principal

Normalization

1733 words - 7 pages Values Of One Attribute Is Dependent On, Or Determined By, The Values Of Another Attribute Which Is Part Of The Composite Key. Partial Dependencies Are Not Good Due To duplication Of Data And Update Anomalies; l l If we know an ISBN, then we know the Book Title and the author(s) l ISBN è Book Title l ISBN è Author(s) If we know the VIN, then we know who is the Auto owner l VIN è Auto_Owner If we know Student-ID (SID), then we can

Mr. Wang

2285 words - 10 pages audited with the use of statistical and database methods to detect anomalies and contradictions: this eventually gives an indication of the characteristics of the anomalies and their locations. Several commercial software packages will let you specify constraints of various kinds (using a grammar that conforms to that of a standard programming language, e.g., JavaScript or Visual Basic) and then generate code that checks the data for violation of

Financial Management

2584 words - 11 pages criteria for collateral. As one partner says: "The ECB scheme seems overly generous. They have complained that the quality of collateral has diminished, but I suspect that it's the ECB that has lost sight of the objective." Q2. a.) Market Efficiency Efficient Markets ï‚· How well do markets respond to fresh information? If the market is very efficient, should it be possible to decide between a profitable investment and unprofitable

Global Health Issues in Behavioral Finance

1070 words - 5 pages anomalies to understand and possibly predict market and investor behavior. Of the biases, emotional biases are the most difficult to reconcile because they are impulse in nature and deeply rooted in the human psyche. When workers watch the news and learn of a growing pandemic or potentially global health issue they instantly become fearful of traveling, attending social events, and even working if they are forced to be in close contact with those who

Warren E Buffet

3296 words - 14 pages that he is looking for the market’s pricing anomalies. Looking for the anomalies (the rationality part) and waiting to find them (the discipline part) are not inconsistent with a market that generally prices securities efficiently. Indeed, one could argue that the activities of investors such as Buffett help to create the efficiency that he denies. • Information: By virtue of Berkshire’s large stockholdings in selected firms, Buffett holds

Finance Final

5233 words - 21 pages Announcements • Takeovers • Audit qualifications Market model of expected returns: Abnormal Returns: Abnormal returns is used to calculate abnormal returns generated from dividend announcements etc. • Strong Form Efficiency – Financial markets may not be efficient with respect to private information and therefore there is inconsistency with abnormal profits. Capital Market Anomalies Firm Size Affect – Small firms

Behavioral Finance Literature Summar

3294 words - 14 pages Pricing Model (BAPM) and capital asset pricing model (CAPM), stating that the asset pricing model of standard finance is moving away from CAPM toward Fama and French three-factor model, a model similar to the BAPM. Bloomfield’s article discusses anomalies that market price deviation from action of rational traders. The most robust anomaly is PEAD (Post-earnings-announcement drift), which is reported in 1968. PEAD describes market reaction to

The Controversy over Efficient Capital Markets

1006 words - 5 pages Discussing the empirical evidence supportive of and against market efficiency. Stock prices changes are said to have a similar distribution and sovereign of each other, meaning that they follow a random pattern and past movement and trends cannot be used to predict future price of a stock. Efficient market hypothesis (EMH) states that beating the market consistently is impossible as stock market efficiency causes existing share prices to always

Case Analysis

995 words - 4 pages the number of shares outstanding) to market value. A study by Fama and French 1 suggests that book-to-market value reflects a risk factor that is not accounted for by traditional one variable CAPM. For example, companies experiencing financial distress see the ratio of book to market value increase. Thus a more complex CAPM which includes book-to-market value as an explanatory variable should be used to test market anomalies. c. Stock price

Related Essays

Efficient Market Hypothesis Essay

582 words - 3 pages Market Efficiency and Anomalies Professor Lasse H. Pedersen Prof. Lasse H. Pedersen 1 Outline Versions of the Efficient Market Hypothesis (EMH) Random Walk What makes the market efficient? Problems with testing EMH Evidence in favor of EMH Evidence against EMH: Anomalies Prof. Lasse H. Pedersen 2 Versions of the Efficient Market Hypothesis (EMH) Weak-form efficiency: – prices reflect all information contained in past trading

Impact Of Public Holiday On Stock Returns

4200 words - 17 pages efficiency. In Semi strong form good or bad news are adjusted in stock prices and hence have no impact on stock market returns. Event study is usually conducted to check for semi form efficiency (Fama, 1991). Efficient market hypothesis is always being a controversial topic. Financial markets are not always efficient because there are some anomalies. Fama (1991) respond to anomalies that there is no room for seasonal movements in efficient market

Behavioral Economics Essay

610 words - 3 pages behavioral activities in making of decisions. A classical economic theory market is not all about demandand supply of sellers and buyers. A seller benefits more by giving a buyer more than he needs or selling at higher prices. According to Pareto efficiency that states that the distribution in the markets creates efficiency and both buyer and seller trades off well. This model does not benefit both parties;therefore, a more realistic model was adopted

Financial Management Essay

3076 words - 13 pages past most of the evidence seems to have been consistent with the EMH. Security prices were seen to follow a random walk model and any variations were found to be statistically insignificant. Although considerable evidence supports the concept of market efficiency, a growing body of academic evidence has begun to cast doubt on the validity of this notion. Researchers repeatedly challenge EH studies raising questions such as: Can price movements