Management Employee Resistance Essay

2696 words - 11 pages

Conflict at work stems from employees’ petty, childlike behaviour and their inability to understand the necessary decisions that manager’s make for the good of the whole organization. Critically discuss this statement, drawing upon course readings that engage with the issue of employee resistance.

Introduction

In the following essay I am going to argue that conflict at work stems from managers decisions to control and dominate the lives of its employees, as it misuses the power relationship in an attempt to enhance its control. I will discuss the article by (Prasad and Prasad 2000), (Clegg, Kornberger and Pitsis 2008) and (Knights and Roberts 1982) to demonstrate this point. I also ...view middle of the document...

Finally I argue that managers decision to control and dominate is not done for the good of the organisation as its misuse of power and denial of the interdependence between employer and employee, limits the organisations overall success. I will use text by (Clegg, Kornberger and Pitsis 2008), (Knights and Roberts 1982), (Adams and Balfour 1998) and (Knights 2009) to demonstrate this point.

Conflict caused by control and domination

Conflict at work stems from “persistent efforts (by employees) to oppose forms of control and domination” as argued by (Prasad and Prasad 2000, pg 388). Forms of control and domination have manifest through managers misunderstanding of the power relationship. They view power as an individual possession and thus use it in an attempt to control and dominate their employees. From this I argue that conflict at work does not stem from employees petty, childlike behaviour but rather from managers attempts to dominate and control. This is argued by (Prasad and Prasad 2000, pg 389) who state “resistance has implications for the extent and effectiveness of organisational control.” Clegg, Kornberger and Pitsis (2008) argue that these attempts to dominate and control leads to a disconnection from the organisation by its employees. I argue that this is not done for the good of the organisation as the misuse of power inhibits them in reaching their full potential as employees find ways to work against the organization. As well as a disconnection, Knights and Roberts (1982) argue that employees feel alienated due to the misuse of power. These feelings of alienation further affect organisations as (Knights and Roberts 1982, pg 51) argue “employees may engage in ‘dramaturgical’ behaviour, giving the appearance of personal commitment to the aims and rules of management, but in reality being committed only to the protection and pursuit of their own self-interest.” Through organisations attempts to dominate and control its employees it leads to a breakdown of relationships and interdependence, which is fundamental to the success of organisations. From this I argue that conflict at work does not stem from the petty, childlike behaviour of employees but from managers attempts to control and dominate.

Many employees are faced with “oppressive routine” (Cohen and Taylor 1992, page 63) as if “to commit oneself to the task now constitutes an abandonment of self expression, a surrendering of oneself to the motions and pace of the factory and the office” (Cohen and Taylor, pg 62). Under this, I argue that conflict does not stem from petty, childlike behaviour but rather in an attempt to retain some control over our actions. In doing so employees attempt to counteract the domination of basic human qualities such as feelings and emotions, as organisations see them as ‘tools’ to reach objectives. (Prasad and Prasad 2000, page 389) state that some conflict by employees is done in an “attempt to restore worker pride and autonomy into an...

Other Papers Like Management- Employee Resistance

Implementing Change Hcs 475 Essay

1107 words - 5 pages . Project management is the key to implementing change. Managers oversee all concepts of change implementation consisting of preparation, training, coordination, production release, and protecting stake holder investment. How should a manager successfully handle staff resistance to change? Any kind of change will initiate resistance to occur. The fear of change creates panic and anxiety because of possibilities of failure and fear of the

Drum Case Essay

667 words - 3 pages undercover to expose employees’ wrong doings? -Is this process a breach of one’s personal privacy? -The personal difficulty facing management as well as career implications?- Ethical Dilemma -Could management discriminate between the sellers of hard drugs and the occasional marijuana and alcohol user? -Once an employee has recovered should the company reinstate them and if so, should they be allowed to the same production line as others

Organizational Structure Simulation

923 words - 4 pages production standards. At the same time improving organizational effectiveness and employee wellbeing. The first stem would involve identifying and investing in key technologies like project management and workflow automation software. Communication can be done in manner of an employee forum for technology and network design innovation. The implementation of industry benchmarks and network design will also be necessary. Part of the

Teamwork and Motivation

876 words - 4 pages Perrier (Gotsil, Natchez, 2007). References Centers for Disease Control and Prevention (2015): Retrieved from http://www.bt.cdc.gov.agent/benzene/ Foote, N. (2001). The fertility of resistance (to change). Computerworld, 35(3), 36 Gotsill, G., Natchez, M. (2007). From resistance to acceptance: How to implement change management. T & D, 61(11), 24-27 Kotter, J. (2012). Leading change. Boston: Harvard Business School Press Palmer, I., Dunford, R., & Akin, G. (2009). Managing organizational change: A multiple perspectives approach (2nd ed.). New York: McGraw-Hill.

Change Management Theory

1767 words - 8 pages organization had to leave their positions and embrace the new system. The ability to accommodate this including the resistance would greatly influence on the success of the change. Another strategy is to come up with a new human resource policy (UOP, 2005). To merit the efficiency of this strategy as a leader one should be able to gauge the future success of the new policies and programs. The final strategy is the improvement in employee skills and

Being Average Is Not a Bad Thing

595 words - 3 pages , weaknesses and personal goals. This gave the interviewing manager insight to what the employee thinks of their own performance. It enables the managers to prepare for a more productive feedback interview. Therefore, the strategic and developmental purposes of performance management will change depending on the self-evaluation and reaction of the employee to the “average” feedback. It is without doubt that some employees are perfectly happy meeting

Change Process In Nhs

2442 words - 10 pages . Initially, the reasons that triggered the implementation of change process will be discussed. The types of changes happened in the organization will be focused. Differentiation will be done between strategic and operational changes. Focus will be given on change management theories and models. In addition to this the resistance to change among employees and methods to overcome the resistance will also be discussed. In the end of the paper, the

Roles of Managers and Individuals

839 words - 4 pages the change can create a void in progress. Resistance to change is not productive for the organization as a whole. The preoccupation with technical aspects of the change itself can be one of the issues an employee has with the specific change. During the process of a major change, a manager needs to address the change, and the progress, multiple times on multiple platforms. During a minor change, a manager may not even realize there is an

Organisational Change

975 words - 4 pages Cambio consultants The most common obstacle to successful change is human resistance. Often people’s first reaction to the prospect of using a new business application, reporting to a new manager, or doing their work in a new way is to resist it. Anticipating potential resistance, assessing its threat to your change, and figuring out how to reduce the resistance is what change management is all about.  The problem for business management is

Change Management And Communication Plan

745 words - 3 pages employee behavior. Communication amongst several levels of management entails employees to leverage their power and political influence within the organization so that the desired goals and outcomes are reached. Riordan Manufacturing is no small town plastics manufacturer, with over $1 billion in sales and well over 550 employees, this organization is here to stay. Because Riordan would like to standardize its process across all levels of

Essay on Human Resource Management

1509 words - 7 pages It can be said that the term ‘human resources management’ became popular in the UK at the latter half of the eighties and at the beginning of the nineties. It has been applied to a diverse range of management strategies and has sometimes been used simply as a more modern term for personnel, employee or industrial relations. It’s importance lies in its association with a strategic, integrated and highly distinctive managerial approach to the

Related Essays

Resistance To Change Essay

4010 words - 17 pages This literature review examines organizational change and offers an in-depth study of "resistance to change". It aims to deepen this field by a theoretical exposition of the concept of "resistance to change". It is a key topic in change management and has been seriously considered for helping the organizations to achieve the advantages of this transformation. This review hints at where an organization should give special attention while

Managing Resistance To Change Essay

4116 words - 17 pages employee resistance. The ADKAR change model (see exhibit 3.0) developed by Prosci is a goal-oriented change management model that allows change management teams to focus their activities on specific business results. This model is based on two basic principles 1) it is people who change, not organizations and 2) successful changes occur when individual change matches the stages of organizational change (Warrilow, 2010). It describes five

Implementing Change Essay

1346 words - 6 pages . These steps outline the various aspects managers are responsible for during changes within a department. Preparing for the implementation, the manager’s responsibility is to analyze the environment in which the change will occur. This includes analyzing employee morale, employee engagement, and potential resistance to the change. Step two is to expose details of the change and answer all questions the employees may have. Allowing employees to

Resistance To Change Essay

1918 words - 8 pages Resistance to Change Cha Xiong MGT/426 June 03, 2014 Resistance to Change Resistance to change is considered the act of opposing or struggling with changes and has a common problem for the management teams. When organizations are seeking to improve an aspect of their business, some of their employees will naturally show resistance. It is not important how the resistance manifests itself, but it is important that resistance still