Making A New Deal Essay

568 words - 3 pages

HST 302
Journal: Cohen, Making a New Deal
Laura Mills

Lizabeth Cohen argues that the difference in workers lives between the 1920’s and 1930’s can be attributed to outside factors and can be attributed to their own desire to implement change. Cohen uses the backdrop of Chicago as her study group and focuses on the steel mills, agricultural and meatpacking industries, as well as a few other localized industries. She chose Chicago because she feels that it represents other industrialized cities and was the cross roads of transportation and communications.
The first third of the book covers explanations of the various ethnic groups and their respective neighborhoods and jobs during post WWI. It explains how these things contributed to the failure of worker unification during this time period. The issues that contributed to the weakness of unification were; geographic ...view middle of the document...

This division allowed employers to exploit differences in order to combat unification. This was done by creating different pay scales for native Americans, immigrants, blacks and even woman. In the case of International Harvester only Native American citizens could hold office of a representative. Cohen also goes on to say that ethnic prejudice was rooted in job competition. Employers would go so far as to create propaganda that would lead to ethnic prejudice, for example the quote about Italian laborers on page 41.
By the end of the 1920’s a new culture for shopping, banking and entertainment emerged. Many immigrants and first generation Americans began moving away from local and ethnic based avenues and turned to chain stores, federal banks, movies and radios. These things began to close the gap between ethnic fragmentations.
Cohen also discusses “welfare capitalism” and how some factories were beginning to understand that job turnover and workplace contention were costing them and instituted a paternalistic movement. In these movement policies to keep employees happy included wage incentives, vacation plans, pensions, stock ownership, and benefit packages. They even provided social outings, musical performances and other forms of recreation in hopes of reducing dependency on ethnic organizations and decrease the power of those groups. The manufacturers viewed “welfare capitalism” as a means to avoid a welfare state and the threat of increased government intervention in their affairs. This employer benevolence is deemed as “moral capitalism” which would shape the union movements in the 1930’s.
In the final three chapters Cohen discusses the political angle which she refers to at the beginning. During the early 20’s immigrants and first generation Americans were not as interested in national politics, because many of their needs and interests were met at a local level. However, due to the onset of the depression many of these local organizations could no longer meet their needs, thus they began looking elsewhere for answers.

Other Papers Like Making a New Deal

Ethics: 4th Quarter Deal Essay

1372 words - 6 pages In everyday life, many situations challenge our ethical decision-making skills. One such dilemma is clearly identified in the video vignette “Ethics: Let’s Make a 4th Quarter Deal.” The company Smith and Blackwell punched in a poor financial year and, as a result, bonus cuts and possible layoffs would be looming. Jason Powell, Director of New Accounts has really been feeling pressure since his department is largely responsible for the less-than

Management Frameworks - Four Frame Analysis

2646 words - 11 pages ; maintaining a manageable size; shaping purpose in response to an opportunity identified by NCS; and translating purpose into clear, measurable goals (Bolman&Deal, 2008). PT fostered creativity and integration, but its success had the potential to “divert attraction from ongoing operational issues” (Bolman&Deal, 2008, p.59). PT grew due to its successes, risking maintaining its manageable size. The new structure divides labor according to

Selling My Business

4029 words - 17 pages —all prior to the sale. • Generating the most value from a transaction is not necessarily tied to finding the highest sale price. Often, the maximum benefit can be gained by making a few critical decisions in advance. These decisions include: ■ Weighing the safety of cash against the tax deferral and greater return potential of a stock transaction. A stock deal may seem more lucrative, but its additional risks need to be factored in

4th Quarter Deal

1268 words - 6 pages 1.0 Introduction of Issue Ethics dilemma will occur when two organizational goals are in conflict. In this issue, it is involved how to generating revenue and at the same time practices ethics procedure. In this issue, manager is facing with a risky in making decision. If she is ignoring about the ethical procedure, so she will try to generate a huge profit to the company. The company does not have to lay off workers, but also provides year-end

Web Tv Case Writeup

1315 words - 6 pages “exclusivity clause,” and with Philips that were inconclusive (page 9). Also, making a deal with a VC like Brentwood would result in a loss of company ownership in exchange for money with $30-$40 million valuation. What should their walk away position be? Since they were already valued at $30 million dollars, their next deal should value them at least at that point. They need to make a CE partnership because that will bring in revenue from both

Group Decision Making

1317 words - 6 pages part of the decision-making process, one can also find that the closest a person is to a situation, the better information he has about it. For example, an employee working on the customer service hotline will have better information regarding the latest complains made by customers than the manager who hears it second hand. That fact will make such employee helpful in a group that tries to deal with customer needs. In addition, when

Ge Alstom

2562 words - 11 pages will buy back about $3.5 billion shares thanks to the new funds provided by the sell-off of its energy business to General Electric. Deal Rationale Why is this deal beneficial to General Electric? The Alstom businesses give GE a much stronger position in steam turbines used in coal-fired, gas-fired and nuclear power plants, and in power grid equipment, as well as a much larger installed base of power plants for its service operations

New Deal Under Attack

1560 words - 7 pages unemployed. His actions as president during these tough times are considered damning to several, but they did not increase the role of the federal government in citizen’s lives because he believed the people should fight their own battles. After being denied reelection by Roosevelt, Hoover returned four years later with his Anti-New Deal Campaign Speech in 1936. It is a fact that Roosevelt’s reforms did little for the people other than making them

Baker Adhesives

612 words - 3 pages Moreno was a sales manager and needed to meet with Doug to discuss the recent results. Going into the meeting Doug is excited at the prospects of finding new markets. As U.S. manufacturing continues to migrate overseas, he is under intense pressure to find new markets. This recent sale to Novo had been a financial boost to Baker Adhesives. The company was able to easily meet the order and in fact it freed up some raw material the company had

Nash Chapter 24

931 words - 4 pages Reconstruction Finance Corporation (RFC) Under Hoover, a federal agency which loaned money to big business in an effort to stimulate the depressed economy and save them from bankruptcy. Trickle down effect. Huey Long Louisiana Senator Long, critic of the New Deal. Said it did too little to help the poor. Advocated a program to transfer wealth from the rich to the poor. Assassinated in 1935. Civil Works Admninistration (CWA) During the winter of

To What Extent Does the Second New Deal Go Beyond the First?

1482 words - 6 pages Second New Deal were merely tweaks of the policies FDR began in 1933, however other went further. During the development of the Second New Deal, FDR had to chose his actions carefully as he didn’t want to jeopardize his Presidential election coming up the following year in 1936. FDR had a task of reviving the policies and agencies that had been previously opposed by names such as Long and Coughlin or declared unconstitutional by the Supreme Court

Related Essays

Comparative Summary Between Is Google Making Us Stupid And A New Dark Age

1476 words - 6 pages Nicholas Carr’s “Is Google making us stupid?”and Maggie Jackson’s “ A New Dark Age” have the similar subjects but different examining methods. In the article “Is Google making us stupid?” Nicholas Carr shares his experience that reading becomes more difficult than before as he spends more time online in the past few years. He then further explains that many of his writer friends have the similar feeling, as if their minds have

Results Of New Deal Essay

768 words - 4 pages have desperately used this food, I am almost positive that the U.S. Government could have devised a better plan that incorporated the acres of food and live-stock being put to better use than just destroyed. The Supreme Court also decided that this was wrong and unconstitutional in 1936, making this group a weakness of the New Deal. Then on March 13, 1933 Roosevelt put in motion a bill to repeal prohibition. This was on the most cultural diverse

Fdr And The Great Depression Essay

672 words - 3 pages how it affected the rural and urban communities both good and bad.               Roosevelt declared that the New Deal would bring relief, recovery, and reform. While it did help the economy a little it was not the grand save FDR imagined it to be. People living in urban areas benefited the most from the deal because many of the new jobs were in the city. Musicians, artists, dancers, and performers all benefited from the new theater project

Fdr's New Deal Essay

2275 words - 10 pages President Franklin Delano Roosevelt’s New Deal was an intensely politically active time, and in addition, American society was tremendously impacted by New Deal legislation. It can be justified to call the New Deal a revolutionary break with the past, rather than to say the New Deal was primarily conservative, pursuing to make only those new additions to legislation in order to prevent revolutionary changes. The New Deal increased the power of