Macbeth And Macbeth Retold Comparison Essay

1006 words - 5 pages

Analyse how the central values portrayed in Macbeth are creatively reshaped in Macbeth Retold
Through the exploration of connections between a pair of texts, the central values portrayed in the original are ultimately reshaped to reflect the modern context. As a result by enhancing the accessibility to a modern audience, the core values are able to be transpired through a change in medium and context, inevitably leading to a greater understanding of the underlying values of both texts. In Shakespeare’s play “Macbeth” and in Mark Brozel’s modern appropriation “Retold”, the implicit and explicit relationships initiate the fundamental values of an individual’s overarching ambition, the ...view middle of the document...

Adding to this is Macbeth’s line ‘If good, why do I yield that suggestion whose horrid image doth unfix my hair’ which is reshaped in Retold through the use of close ups which show Jo’s psychological battle that fatally leads to his destruction. As a result of these visual elements which have been cleverly implemented, Retold is able to allow the modern audience to gain a greater grasp of the essence of the value of and individual’s downfall caused by the desire for control.
The disintegration of one’s identity as a direct consequence of their descent from humanity is another key value which connects the two texts together and has been reshaped to conform to the current ideologies of society. In both texts, this is made notably evident through the way Macbeth’s character changes and through the changes in the way people perceive him. At the start of the play Macbeth is presented as a respectable and notable character as seen in the line ‘Like valor’s minion carved out his passage’ which is similarly replicated in Retold where the cheerful atmosphere in his kitchen signifies his nobility. Additionally, the scene where Jo carefully carves the pigs head whilst emphasising the importance of respect only further amplifies his fatal flaw and disintegration of his identity as it is a complete contrast to the character he evolves into. Furthermore, the line in Macbeth ‘Things bad begun make strong themselves by ill’ echoes the divine right of kings which is manipulated in the adaptation by exemplifying the string of terrible events that occur through the juxtaposition of the scenes of both the murder of Macduff’s family and Ella’s suicide. As a result, by changing the medium, the transposition of Macbeth into a modern context is able to still retain and emphasise the core values thus enhancing the viewer’s understanding of the values in the original text.
The significance of external forces in initiating an...

Other Papers Like Macbeth and Macbeth Retold Comparison

Macbeth: Trust and Betrayal Essay

1366 words - 6 pages Comparative Essay on Trust of Macbeth and The Social Network While many may argue that trusting others is easier to get by and freeing, the movie The Social Network and the Shakespearean play Macbeth seems to disagree. Trust should be earned and should be not given carelessly. Many would take advantage of the trust because of their greed. The relationship between Macbeth and Banquo; Macbeth and Duncan can be compared to Mark and

Comparing Macbeth And Othello Essay

1424 words - 6 pages Comparing Macbeth and Othello A masterful playwright and poet named William Shakespeare in the Seventeenth century wrote both the tragedies Macbeth and Othello. In William Shakespeare’s Macbeth, the idea of one character becoming both victim and villain is introduced. Macbeth falls prey to others’ deception, and is supplanted with greed and hate when three witches trick him. When told that he is going to be King of Scotland, Macbeth

Macbeth - Evil And Darkness

706 words - 3 pages The play "Macbeth" by Shakespeare is jam-packed with malfeasance and darkness. All actions taken by Macbeth, his wife, Lady Macbeth, the witches and Hecate have immoral intentions and/or evil outcomes. An example of such is Lady Macbeth’s dark intentions to quicken Macbeth’s crowning, fuelled Macbeth’s "vaulting ambition[s]" (Act 1 scene 7 line 27) to murder anyone or anything that stood in his path of a long reign

Lady Macbeth And Curley's Wife

1357 words - 6 pages submissive in comparison. Lady Macbeth surprisingly, however, warns Macbeth of his bizarre behaviour showing she cares deeply for her husband when informing him “Your face, my Thane, is as a book, where men may read strange matters”. Warning him of potential discovery demonstrates the bond the couple have and how she would hate to see it broken should either one of them be caught. The mention of ‘book’ infers his face expresses strange feelings

Macbeth and Lady Macbeth's relationship

723 words - 3 pages “Macbeth” by William Shakespeare shows the effect of greed/power on a relationship. Is gaining power more important than a relationship? When Macbeth usurps the throne as King of Scotland, he puts aside his relationships to carry out as king and his relationship with Lady Macbeth is impacted. Macbeth and Lady Macbeth’s relationship takes a shift as well as partly remains the same when Macbeth is given the title of king of Scotland. Macbeth’s

Film and Book Review: Macbeth

1089 words - 5 pages Macbeth, who is a protagonist in the play Macbeth by William Shakespeare and the film Macbeth by roman Polanski. He commits the same deed of murdering Duncan in both play and film to become the king of Scotland. However there are lots of differences in the theme, plot and characterization. Paragraph change Play and the film show a great different relationship between lady Macbeth and Macbeth. In the play, lady Macbeth is a central character

Darkness and Concealment in Macbeth

1060 words - 5 pages Despite Shakespeare’s ‘Macbeth’ being a pre-gothic text, a vast range of gothic notions remain present, including those of darkness and concealment. The role of darkness within ‘Macbeth’ forms a vital aspect of the entire nature of the plot, with characters such as Macbeth, Lady Macbeth and even the witches displaying the use of dark acts, such as murder, in order to achieve personal ambition “that wilt raven up life’s own means

Comparative Essay: Lotf and Macbeth

3739 words - 15 pages when they first meet on the island is also destroyed in the process. The group descends into chaos, with Simon and Piggy as casualties. In the end, Jack, the primary exponent of sin, burns down the island while hunting Ralph, which allows for the boys’ rescue. Despite being rescued, it was clear the boys were changed forever. Likewise, in William Shakespeare’s Macbeth (1606), the country of Scotland is portrayed to be organized under the order of

Memory Man And Macbeth Essay

1676 words - 7 pages risks and believe that risk taking is something they should not do merely because it could end with negative consequences; consequences that are almost always exaggerated a great deal. In Shakespeare’s Macbeth, the protagonist Macbeth made many decisions to achieve his deepest and darkest desire which was to become king. In order to take a hold of what he wanted he took many huge risks, and in taking those risks he achieved his goal. David

Favourite Character in Macbeth and Why?

663 words - 3 pages The play I have chosen is Macbeth by William Shakespeare. From reading act one; my favourite character is that of Macbeth himself. I chose this character as he is so complex and appears to have several facets to his personality. In some scenes he is shown as a brave warrior steeped in honour and many are in awe of him. Yet we also see that he has a desire to become king and at first gave the impression that he had no qualms about killing the

Betrayal and False Appearances in 'Macbeth'

656 words - 3 pages William Shakespeare’s, Macbeth widely explores the theme of betrayal, the fear of its occurrence and the effect paranoia has on an individual. The play harbors many mistrusting and deceitful characters, who prove that care should be taken when considering someone’s outward appearance. However, Shakespeare demonstrates that a life of mistrust and paranoia will lead to ones demise, just as much as a life of foolish trust will and that only those

Related Essays

Macbeth And Macbeth Retold Essay

879 words - 4 pages Macbeth vs. Macbeth Retold Most people believe that books are absolutely better than movies because movies have a tendency to be incomplete, either from lack of important details or from different interpretations and setting, but Macbeth retold has proven that it is one to watch, not only does it have great actors and a stupendous storyline, it has also stayed fateful to the context of tragedy that makes Macbeth a true literary work. The

Character Comparison: Macbeth And Lady Macbeth

519 words - 3 pages Shakespeare's Macbeth encompasses the Aristotelian definition of tragedy where the ending of a tragedy causes catharsis, which is an emotional cleansing that is caused by the spectator's sympathy for the tragic hero. The tragic hero, Macbeth, goes through a major character change as the play progresses where Duncan's murder is the first indication of the change. Macbeth murders Duncan because of Lady Macbeth's continual persuasion and the murder

A Comparison Of Macbeth With Other Texts

1871 words - 8 pages descendent of Banquo, therefore he was written to be a noble, wise and regal man whose good qualities tended to make some of the other characters, particularly Macbeth, envy him. King James 1 considered himself to be an expert on witchcraft, he wrote a book which stated that witches made a pact with the devil, so including the evil ways of the witches and showing them to be dark creatures that turn good loyal men into murderers would have pleased

Gender Roles And Macbeth Essay

2084 words - 9 pages What roles and actions should actors of a particular gender portray? Should men be aggressive and have a level of ambition high enough to meet their loftiest goals? Should women always be passive and frail, never using their energy to advance their lot? William Shakespeare’s Macbeth is a tragic tale of one man’s deadly and unchecked ambition to be king, and his wife’s lust for power and title. By the final act of the play, Macbeth has been