Liability For Doctors Essay

658 words - 3 pages

A physician should not be totally immune from liability in cases in which the patient's contribution to the harm suffered was as great as the person whom contributed to it. In this case, I feel that there were factors that both sides neglected to handle so that the procedure that was done would be a success. There were testing (vascular testing) that could have been done to determine if the patient was in a good enough condition to be able to go through the surgery that was used to remove the diseased toenail that was infected. The jury found Dr. Azzara acted negligently by removing Ms. Ostrowski's toenail without adequate consideration of her vascular condition (Ostrowski v. Azzara 545 A.2d 148 (1988) Summary). I also feel that Dr. Azzara should have made sure that there was a review of the patients’ internal medicine records from her internist for her diabetes and blood pressure problems.
The patient was at fault by not ...view middle of the document...

realself.com/question/cosmetic-plastic-surgery-how-does-smoking-affect-healing-scarring). The patient was given adequate pre-surgery risk and complication disclosures before she signed her consent form for surgery. Another option for the patient was to get a second opinion on what was going on with her toe. Getting a second opinion on the toe could have reassured the dignosis by Dr. Azzara or shed new light on other problems the Ms. Ostrowski may have had.
Even though this case was reversed later and remanded for a new trial( health law) by The Supreme Court of New Jersey, Judge O'Hern, J., held that: (1) post treatment conduct of patient may be submitted to jury on question of whether mitigation or apportionment of damages can be expressed in terms of patient's fault, but patient's fault will not be a bar to recovery except to the extent that her fault caused damages; (2) trial court's instructions failed to distinguish between preoperative and postoperative conduct which could serve only to mitigate her damages as opposed to conduct which could serve to avoid any recovery; and (3) trial court's instruction improperly permitted jury to bar patient entirely from recovery of damages that were attributable to physician. (http://www.rongolini.com/casesumm.htm#Ostrowski).
Doctors like patients are human and they make mistakes. The comparative negligence on both sides caused the mishaps that happened in this case. Dr. Azzara knew of the complications that this patient may go through after the surgery, and by the book did not recommend any stop smoking treatments and did not get a hold of internist office that was treating Ms. Ostrowski. This could have helped the doctor to control or treat the blood sugar and blood pressure problems. The patient’s lack of compliance with her pre-treatment and post-treatment contributed to some of the issues which resulted in the decision by Dr. Azzara had to remove of the toenail. Second guessing of treatment is easy to do after a mishap happens. In my opinion, not a single physician in the world would think that they will have patient who is totally compliant with all instructions given. As patient, we have to responsiblty for our health to and follow up with problems that we have.

Other Papers Like Liability for Doctors

Performance Pay for Mgoa Physicians Essay

552 words - 3 pages there are advantages to this form of compensation, pay-for-performance also has some downsides. Employee may become goal oriented to fulfill a requirement and develop single-mindedness. Doctors would be come caught up with the financial incentives that they begin taking shortcuts and try to speed up their procedure to meet their quota. This presents a great liability; doctors who overwork themselves tend to make more mistakes. Which could

Business Entities, Laws and Regulations Paper

1112 words - 5 pages Employment Opportunity Commission for discrimination based on a violation of Title I of the ADA, Mei-Lin can justify her decision based on Michelle’s prior work experience. Conclusion When deciding on the best way to organize a business, factors such as control, taxation and liability are important considerations. Professionals such as doctors, lawyers and accountants are best served by limited liability partnerships that protect members from

Financialanalysis Report for Cango

623 words - 3 pages basis for professional liability remains exactly the same, litigation with the use of robotic surgery may be complex. In case of an undesirable outcome, in addition to physician and hospital, the manufacturer of the robotic system may be sued. In respect to ethical issues in robotic surgery, equipment safety and reliability, provision of adequate information, and maintenance of confidentiality are all of paramount importance. Also, the cost of

Business Torts Issue Spotter Essay

1274 words - 6 pages Business Torts Issue Spotter Essay Emmy V. MedK Corp. MedK Corp. faces potential liability for the tort of Contractual Interference/Tortious Interference with Contractual Relations. Contractual Interference occurs when parties are not allowed the freedom to contract without interference from third party. Tortious Interference is that someone intentionally persuades another to break a contract already in existence. Here, MedK Corp. may be

Robotic Surgery

560 words - 3 pages being performed on the equipment the hospital will be fined. This sources also talks about the different types of maintenance that has to performed on the equipment and also who has to perform the maintenance, there is certain maintenance items that can be performed by the hospital and all other maintenance activity has to be done by a third party vendor for safety reasons. My last sources talks about liability that doctors have when they use

The Negative Impact of Healthcare Politics

1749 words - 7 pages perfection. However, doctor’s poor penmanship when writing orders and follow-up communication is often flawed; making it difficult for nurses to continue treating patients properly. “Charting errors and omissions are a significant source of liability risks for both doctors and nurses. In the often frantic world of medicine charting is never to perfection, making it easy to accuse a good healthcare provider of a menial mistake” (Wood 2009). The good

Organizational Business Forms

2543 words - 11 pages company to be an LLC. In many states, professionals such as doctors and attorneys cannot operate under and LLC. An LLC must have a registered office in the state of incorporation but it does not have to be the actual place of business itself. • Convenience or burden: One of the benefits of a limited liability company is there are far less paperwork and record keeping requirements. For example, unlike corporations, minutes of the company meetings do not need to be taken or maintained. An LLC that does not elect S or C corporation status must pay self-employment tax. There is no employee stock option plan with an LLC. PART B

Assignment

2254 words - 10 pages for him to work again, but his doctors are not able to say which car caused those injuries. Adeel’s laptop computer was also damaged, causing information to be destroyed which led to loss of business for his employers, FatCat Ltd. Advise Adeel and FatCat Ltd whether they have any remedy against Betrice and/ or Cassandra. Case Study 7 ( Employer’s Liability- Vicarious liability) • Eric and Roland are employed to clean the windows in a

School Sport Injuries and Negligence

1211 words - 5 pages a school or a coach liable for a student's injury during a sporting event. Recovering compensation for school sport team injuries are usually limited because the school has the athletes sign a release clause waiver. By signing the wavier, the athlete agrees to relieve the school of any liability and assumes the risk related to that sport Although schools are normally protected from liability, a student injured while playing school sports

Leg 500 Part 2

1025 words - 5 pages | Correct Answer: |   To extend the life of copyrights | | | | | * Question 23 4 out of 4 points | | | Parodies occur in what type of intellectual property?Answer | | | | | Selected Answer: |   Copyrights | Correct Answer: |   Copyrights | | | | | * Question 24 4 out of 4 points | | | In a lawsuit for copyright infringement, a defendant can avoid liability by successfully arguing _________, based on the

Law and Healthcare

2065 words - 9 pages 1. Identify and explain the four elements of proof necessary for a plaintiff to prove a negligence case. To begin with, when people think of professional liability in healthcare, they usually think of medical practice, a form of negligence. Negligence by definition is known as one of the most common type of malpractice that exists in the healthcare industry. However, in order for a negligence case to be proven, four elements are necessary

Related Essays

Law 531 Week 1 Knowledge Checks

1015 words - 5 pages 1. Identify an accurate statement about a sole proprietorship. A. It is a form of business that is seldom found in the United States. B. It is a form of business that has only one owner. C. It is a separate legal entity, distinct from an owner. D. It is a business form in which the owner enjoys limited liability. 2. Sara and Cilia run a café together. They share ownership of and liability for the café and have come to an

Fin 419 Week 1 Paper

1114 words - 5 pages that can form an LLP. LLPs are mostly preferred by lawyers, doctors, architects, and accountants. One important detail about an LLP is that it is strong as long as its partners’ commitment continues. That means, when one or more partners withdraw from the partnership, the partnership is terminated. As for the limited liability provided to a limited partner, it is safe only if the limited partner does not participate in the management of the

Organizational Ethics Essay

432 words - 2 pages Organizational Ethics Name Subject Instructor Date The doctrine of Respondeat Superior is one that directly translated from Latin means “let the master answer”. This is the doctrine that seeks to have the eventuality of any cases of organizational ethics being answered for by the organizational heads as opposed to the employee show may have performed them. The doctrine underscores the fact that the employer is

Partnership Form Of Organization Essay

2374 words - 10 pages Partnership Form of Organization Partnership Form of Organization A partnership is an association of two or more persons to carry on as co-owners of a business for profit. Partnerships are sometimes used in small retail, service, or manufacturing companies. Also accountants, lawyers, and doctors find it desirable to form partnerships with other professionals in the field. Characteristics of Partnerships STUDY OBJECTIVE 1 Identify the