This website uses cookies to ensure you have the best experience. Learn more

Legalizing Assisted Suicide Essay

1751 words - 8 pages

Legalizing Assisted Suicide
M. Garcia
PHI 103: Informal Logic
Instructor: Webster
April 4, 2011

Legalizing Assisted Suicide

Part I: Thesis

Jack Kevorkian did not invent assisted suicide, he just happened to be responsible for bringing it out into the open. The practice of assisted suicide is not a modern experience. Lester Zygmaniak, 23, shot and killed his brother George who was paralyzed from the neck down in a motorcycle accident in Freehold, N.J. Lester was found not guilty by reason of temporary insanity after only 2 ½ hours of deliberation. He walked out of court a free man. In the United States, the practice of assisted suicide is also nothing new. As of today, ...view middle of the document...

Withdrawing or withholding medical treatment such as disconnecting a respirator or removing a feeding tube, signing a form that is commonly referred to as a DOR (do not resuscitate order) is commonly known as passive euthanasia and has become the accepted resolution to this predicament. Active euthanasia, the practice of actively participating in the act of ending ones life possibly by poison, an overdose of sleeping pills, or a deadly injection of pain-killers such as morphine remains controversial. Assisted suicide is most widely defined as a type of active euthanasia in which a doctor or a loved one provides the means of death, usually by prescribing or obtaining a lethal dose of drugs, but the patient is responsible for performing the final act.
The constitution does not guarantee a person rights over their individual bodies,

however, it does offer the following:

“We hold these truths to be self-evident, that all men are created equal, that they

are endowed by their Creator with certain unalienable Rights, that among these

are Life, Liberty and the pursuit of Happiness.”

If the pursuit of happiness means that, a loved one wants to end their suffering how the government can deny them that basic right and if they have the right to life, how can the government deny them the death that they seek to end their suffering. There are thirty-five states, the U.S. Government and the U.S. Military that have the death penalty, within those states, laws have been put into place to protect murders from inhumanely being put to death, but if you are a law-abiding citizen, you must suffer unspeakable pain in some cases before you die. Criminals have more rights when it comes to their death then the average person.
Part II: Anti-thesis

America’s courts and legislatures have not changed significantly over the past several decades when it comes to assisted suicide. In June 1997, the U.S. Supreme Court ruled that people do not have a constitutional right to assisted suicide. "The state's assisted suicide ban reflects and reinforces its policy that the lives of terminally ill, disabled, and elderly people must be no less valued than the lives of the young and healthy," Chief Justice William H. Rehnquist wrote as the court took up the question of assisted suicide for the first time. (Biskupic, 1997) 1990 to present Michigan pathologist Jack Kevorkian, known as "Dr. Death," has admitted to assisting in 45 suicides. He has been charged with murder and other crimes but has never been convicted. 1997, Supreme Court upholds New York and Washington state laws that criminalize doctor-assisted suicide. 1990, U.S. Supreme Court rules in a case involving Nancy Beth Cruzan that a person has a "right to die" grounded in the Fourteenth Amendment's guarantee of personal liberty. But the court also called attention to living wills by holding that states can require clear and convincing evidence of a patient's previously expressed wish to die. 1976,...

Other Papers Like Legalizing Assisted Suicide

The Right to Die Essay

1886 words - 8 pages legalizing assisted suicide is based on the idea that "it is a human impulse of kindness," and one that we afford to our pets but not human beings. He also argues that it robs a person of their autonomy. He expresses disgust at the idea that people are forced to travel to places where assisted suicide is legal, such as Switzerland, instead of being allowed to die with dignity in their own home surrounded by family and friends. He also states that

The Morality Of Assisted Suicides Essay

2403 words - 10 pages -assisted suicide continue to ask how many people will die unnecessarily if doctors can legally help a patient end their own life? Americans recognize there are many valid reasons a doctor should not facilitate suicide. Some of the reasons include doctors will no longer pursue alternatives to heal the patient but rather default to suicide quicker when someone is terminal. Another reason is legalizing assisted-suicide may pressure those who would never

Phyician Assisted Suicide. Religious, Moral, Economic, And Historical Aspects Concerning Physician Assisted Suicide

2811 words - 12 pages solutions. The physician may also ignore or misunderstand patient ambivalence, and even put to death patients who have not requested it What is the historical background of assisted suicide? Should physician assisted suicide be legalized? Would legalizing physician assisted suicide help the financial concerns of the family and our nation? How does religion play a part? These, among many others, are the controversial questions surrounding physician

Heaven or Hell

2529 words - 11 pages -State Guide to Physician-Assisted Suicide, n.d.). The rest it is illegal or they have no clear laws about physician-assisted suicide currently. Presently there is also an ethics debate on physician-assisted suicide. As with non-assisted suicide people feel that it is just a cry for help or those who seek it out are depressed. Some say that if physician-assisted suicide is legal that would be legalizing murder, or giving doctors the right to kill


1576 words - 7 pages . However, euthanasia and assisted suicide is forbidden in the majority of countries and could be penalized by a fourteen years prison sentence. (“Euthanasia and assisted, intro”). Legalizing euthanasia is extremely controversial moral and legal issue throughout the world, but achieving that goal is extremely necessary. Although legalizing euthanasia could cause negative effects for society, the positive side of this controversy indicates that

Analysis of an Ethical Dilemma

1195 words - 5 pages of states in the United States rule that assisted euthanasia is illegal as well as in most countries. Under most state laws, assisting someone to commit suicide is a felony. There are three states that have passed laws legalizing assisted euthanasia under special circumstances. Oregon passed a Death With Dignity Act allowing doctors to prescribe doses of medication that are lethal to facilitate terminally ill patients to end their own lives. The

Physician Assisted Death

1102 words - 5 pages passing a similar Act legalizing physician-assisted death with similar strict conditions. However, firm rules applied. The patient should be mentally suitable to make such a judgment. Secondly, the patient must be diagnosed with a terminally ill condition and that such a patient has a life expectancy of six months or less.  Such a patient must also provide the request for terminating own life in writing for the physician. Finally, the patient should

Euthanasia: the Dignity of End of Life

2016 words - 9 pages . Physician assisted suicide can be defined as the suicide of a patient facilitated by the means of drug or lethal injection that is provided by a physician who is aware of the patient’s intent. Euthanasia can be defined as the act or practice of killing or permitting the death of hopelessly sick or injured individuals in a relatively painless way, for reasons of mercy. Although both definitions sound very similar, the debate of legalizing one or

Death with Dignity

2377 words - 10 pages . Paroled and released in 2007, he is still an advocate for physician-assisted suicide. Dr. Kevorkian cannot contribute or support this practice actively or face returning to prison. To date, at least 21 states have attempted to pass legislation legalizing physician-assisted suicide and failed. In 1997, Oregon became the only U.S. state with legal physician assisted suicide. The Death with Dignity Act became legal in 1994, and went into

A Request to Die

1466 words - 6 pages when he asked to halt the tube feedings in order to let him die and suffer no longer. This is a heart breaking situation when an individual has to see a loved one suffer. Knowing that she stands against legalizing physician assisted suicide – her father now asks her “Can we accelerate it?” (Wolf, 2008, p.24). Her personal experience with her dying father, now questions her moral ethics and she undoubtedly does not want him to suffer any more

Legalizing Euthanasia

813 words - 4 pages . Next, the reason to legalize Euthanasia is to reduce the financial problems. Emanuel and Battin (1998) revealed that, “ commentator observed: Managed care and managed death through physicians-assisted suicide are less expensive than fee-for-service care and extended survival. Less expensive is better.” (p. 167). A financial problem is something that everybody wants to limit or cut off. Obviously, Euthanasia is the only effective way

Related Essays

Legalizing Physician Assisted Suicide Essay

2185 words - 9 pages rejecting physician-assisted dying as being morally unjustified and socially harmful as it relates to the current proposal for legalization (Bresnahan, J., 1995). Even though opponents against legalizing physician-assisted suicide do pose good arguments, the argument for legalization is stronger because how a terminally ill patient spends their last days is really a God given, personal right. The right to live and die for terminally ill

Assisted Suicide Pros And Cons Essay

994 words - 4 pages . The arguments we hear in favor of legalizing assisted suicide generally run along these lines. People should have the to control their own lives. Some terminally ill patients are allowed to end their lives by refusing medical treatment and those who don't have that option should be allowed to choose death. Death is a compassionate way to relieve unbearable suffering. Legal or not, assisted suicides occur, and it would be better if they were

Death And Dying Essay

1766 words - 8 pages opinion i think that suicide assisted or none assisted in any form causes the people around you to suffer more than if you had just died naturally. Are you for or against assisted suicide? A number of arguments are offered in favour of and against legalizing assisted suicide in Canada. One of the biggest arguments for legalization in Canada is that everyone should be able to die a good death. (Shana Alexander) wrote “I want a good death; i think

Ethical And Legal Issues With Physician Assisted Suicide And Euthanasia

534 words - 3 pages controversial topics. The saga of Dr. Kevorkian exhibits the difference of opinion, lack of prudent legislature, and the ethical issues involved in assisted suicide. Supporters, like Kevorkian, argue that the choice to die is a fundamental right of all people. Legalizing assisted suicide in particular would allow appropriate patients to have a humane and comfortable death. Opponents to the issue say that if voluntary active euthanasia and/or