This website uses cookies to ensure you have the best experience. Learn more

Legal And Ethical Dimension Essay

1397 words - 6 pages

Virginia Pollard worked as a cashier and clerk for Teddy’s Supplies, a family-owned chain of film production equipment supply stores in Pennsylvania and New Jersey. During a routine performance evaluation, Virginia's supervisor at Teddy's complained that she made too many personal phone calls when she worked in the West Orange store. The supervisor noted this on Virginia's annual review, and warned her to keep personal calls to a bare minimum while at work. Soon thereafter, Teddy transferred Pollard to guard film equipment in the main warehouse behind the storefront; Virginia couldn't make personal calls there, and her work became exemplary. Her performance evaluation three months after ...view middle of the document...

In that case, the employee should report using the company website form which will submit the incident to Human Resources."

Pollard never filed a complaint with Steve King, her supervisor; she also did not file a complaint at the website, although she claimed she told King in July 2008 that she felt she was being "picked on" by the guys she worked with. She claims Steve King told her to "grow some balls" and to "get over herself." She testified during the NJ Human Rights Commission hearing that she tried to file an anonymous complaint but the website wasn't working the day she tried to do so.

In August of 2008, King and the other warehouse workers put a sign on a truck that read "HARDHAT REQUIRED/BRA OPTIONAL." King and another employee called Pollard over to look at the sign and encouraged her to do as it said. She refused and tried to walk away. King promised not to report her to management, whereupon she lifted one side of her shirt in the back and exposed part of her bra on her backside. Upper management learned of the incident that October by a co-worker who filed an anonymous complaint online. After a brief investigation, Pollard was fired for exposing her bra. None of the men were disciplined. A man replaced Pollard in the guard shack.

That November, Pollard filed a charge of sex discrimination with the New Jersey Commission on Human Rights. The Commission found that Pollard had been the victim of sex discrimination and that Teddy's reasons for firing her were pretext, and awarded her back wages and damages. Teddy's appealed to the circuit court, including in their case that Pollard had committed several infractions, including participating in the spanking incident. They reported that Pollard had failed to report any sexual harassment and included a copy of their sexual harassment policy as part of their defense case. The Circuit Court found that Teddy did have good reason to discipline Pollard but that firing her was in fact disparate treatment when compared with the utter lack of discipline given to King. The circuit court reversed the Commission's award of damages because it believed that Teddy had been right to discipline Pollard, but they ordered Teddy's to reinstate Pollard to her old position. Pollard appealed to the New Jersey Court of Appeals and refused to accept her job back.
You are the independent human resources consultant hired by Teddy's Supplies to help explain to the company what the case against them will entail. You have gleaned the facts from your investigations into the situation to date. You have never talked with Virginia Pollard. The case is currently in the appeals stage and the company executives have some questions for you. Answer them using the most recent legal information you can find.

1. Teddy's Supplies' CEO has asked you to advise him on the facts of the case and your opinion of their potential liability. He wants to settle the case. Write a memo to him that states your view of whether...

Other Papers Like Legal and Ethical Dimension

Social Legal and Ethical Issues Essay

5339 words - 22 pages Chapter 5 Social, Legal, and Ethical Issues in the Information Age Teaching Objectives Students should be able to answer the following questions: 1. What ethical, social, and political issues are raised by information systems? 2. Are there specific principles for conduct that can be used to guide decisions about ethical dilemmas? 3. Why does contemporary information technology pose challenges to the protection

International Legal And Ethical Issues Essay

701 words - 3 pages Role and Functions of Law Laws provide rules of conduct and ethical standards that people, businesses, and organizations must follow in order to keep matters and differences under control and regulate social behavior. There are several functions and roles of laws in business and society which plays an important stand in business operations. Without laws and standards, businesses in today's society will be unsuccessful and society itself will

Addressing International Legal And Ethical Issues

416 words - 2 pages Addressing International Legal and Ethical Issues LAW/421 Contemporary Business Law October 4, 2014 Addressing International Legal and Ethical Issues In the “Addressing International Legal and Ethical Issues” simulation; a company named CadMex was in discussions to do international business with a company from Candore named Gentura. The issues that were involved in resolving legal disputes in international transactions are that the

Ethical And Legal Issues In Nursing

1233 words - 5 pages Ethical and Legal Issues in Nursing University of Phoenix Nursing 391 Ethical and Legal Issues in Nursing Marianne, the 79-year old woman who presented with a hemorrhagic stroke in a recent case study, brings up thought for ethical debate. Her outlook is poor, with or without surgery, and she has no advanced directive. Her husband and children cannot come to an agreement on whether life support should end or if all resuscitative

Addressing International Legal and Ethical Issues

881 words - 4 pages Addressing International Legal and Ethical Issues simulation Eduardo Aguayo LAW 421 September 25, 2014 Richard Burgoon Addressing International Legal and Ethical Issues simulation International transactions and dispute resolutions require both an understanding of the law and a sensitivity to foreign culture, politics, formal and informal power structures and decision-making approaches. The International Transactions and Disputes Group

Legal and Ethical Considerations in Employment Selection

1126 words - 5 pages Legal and Ethical Considerations in Employment Selection Cardinal Stritch University Cathy Carew Instructor John Koehler MGT-445 Human Resource Management II July 25, 2013 Legal and Ethical Considerations in Employment Selection Organizations use screening tools such as assessment tests, medical tests and drug testing to effectively find applicants or current employees that are best qualified for a particular job. There are legal

International Legal and Ethical Issues in Business

826 words - 4 pages Unit 1 Individual Project International Legal and Ethical Issues in Business American InterContinental University It is know that is anyone in the business world has legal obligations to keep their employees and

Legal And Ethical Consideration In Marketing

2321 words - 10 pages condition that makes it “unreasonably dangerous to the user or consumer” (Halbert, 2012). This is referred to as strict liability according to the legal definition in Halbert. Rajan Chandran, Associated Professor of Marketing in the Graduate School of Business Administration at Temple University wrote an excellent article on product safety. (Chandran, 1979). According to Chandran, advertising fails to promote safety, and he gives some

Web Site Legal, Ethical, And Regulatory Issues

1399 words - 6 pages IntroductionThe three e-Business Web sites the team analyzed are Expedia.com, Orbitz.com, and Travelocity.com. The sites fall under the category of travel so it would seem that each company would encounter the same ethical, legal, and regulatory issues. An evaluation of each site will determine what, if any, of the above mentioned issues each e-business encounters and what resolutions are in place.ExpediaThe laws of the State of Washington

Ethical and Legal Issues with Physician Assisted Suicide and Euthanasia

534 words - 3 pages ABSTRACT: Medical professional have long prohibited physician involvement in assisting a patient's suicide. However, despite ethical and legal prohibitions, calls for the liberalization of this ban have grown in recent years. The medical profession should articulate its views on the arguments for and against changes in public policy and decide whether changes are prudent. In addressing such a contentious issue, physicians, policymakers, and

Legal and Ethical Issues Relating to Business Information

2215 words - 9 pages Legal and Ethical Issues Relating to Business Information Introduction I this task I’m going to explain the legal and ethical issues in relation to the use of businesses information and also I’m going to explain operational issues as well in the last park of the task i going to analyse the legal ethical and operational issues using appropriate examples . Most people do not feel safe in putting or giving their personal details on

Related Essays

Ethical And Legal Issues Essay

1267 words - 6 pages Nurses make legal and ethical decisions when caring for patients; decisions that need to be made carefully because the decisions could possibly change a patients' life. There are theories to explain how to problem solve ethically and the theories are not based on emotion (Guido, 2006). This paper will discuss the relationship between legal and ethical issues and ethical theories, examples will be provided.Ethics can be described as principles

Discussion Legal And Ethical Guidelines

601 words - 3 pages Grade Received - "A" Why doesn't the health care industry have a set of clearly stated legal and ethical guidelines? What are the implications for health care? How does this affect the thought that "every person is responsible for his/her own actions"? In this discussion I will attempt to explain why the healthcare industry does not have a set of clearly stated legal and ethical guidelines, what the implications for health care are and

International Legal And Ethical Issues Essay

658 words - 3 pages International Legal and Ethical Issues Simulation Analysis Businesses must ensure legal protection from other foreign country companies from adverse actions. There is high risk in international business transactions and CadMex need to protect against them. Steps to protect the business legally is crucial when selecting the choice-of-law, and selecting clause in the simulation. Establishing terms in a contract is important factor in a

Hiring Ethical And Legal Implications Essay

831 words - 4 pages Hiring Ethical and Legal Implications Hiring Ethical and Legal Implications Every business has the potential to succeed; however, many do not. The ability to hire and retain high-quality employees is one cornerstone to maintaining a successful business. The hiring process has many legal and ethical pitfalls that managers must avoid during their selection process. In addition to the moral quandaries managers face, their hiring