This website uses cookies to ensure you have the best experience. Learn more

Leadership Essay

3344 words - 14 pages

PSE 402 Leadership and Ethics

By Craig Tomlinson

2 C.F.F.T.S, Dept of National Defense
25 March, 2011

Assignment # 2

When we try to define ethical decision, we usually associate it with one’s perspective or type of decision-making that affects the situation at hand. We usually associate ethical or moral decision based on how it influences the emotional or personal well being of individual(s). Rarely do we associate ethical and moral decisions that affect the physical well being of the individual(s) or potentially the ending of ones life. This example of a C.O.B. authorizing the closing the hatch on 3 individuals challenges our type of ethical and moral decision ...view middle of the document...

Magnitude of Consequences, Probability of Effect, and Proximity are the three components that I feel would affect my moral decision ability the most.
The Magnitude of Consequences component that is demonstrated here is that I have the decision to lose 3 lives, or the potential to lose everybody on the entire ship including myself. The decision to lose of all lives including my own would versus three lives seems like an obvious one, but what distorts this is the Proximity component. Jones states in the Proximity component “ Intuitively, people care more about other people who are close to them (socially, culturally, psychologically, or physically) than they do for people who are distant”.[ii] Since Jones’ also states that “Moral intensity is generally expected to increase if there is a an increase in any one (or more) of its components, and it is expected to decrease if there is a decrease in any one (or more) of its components, assuming the remaining components remain constant.” [iii] This statement alone shows that my ability to make a moral decision will be heightened or influenced because the personal relationship I have with the three men. The fact that I am on submarine also indicates that I probably will be familiar with a majority of the crew including the three unfortunate sailors. If I am familiar with the crew on the boat, I could also conclude that the majority of the crew also knows these three sailors. Knowing this, would also further increase the Moral intensity of my decision, as my decision won’t just affect me personally, but also affect those around personally.
Concentration of Effect may be the one component that would allow me to keep the hatch open for a little while longer to save the lives of these three men. As this component states, the survival of these 3 men’s fate has greater affect on the ship than if the entire ship was affected as whole to keep these men alive. To make this type of decision, there are several variables that would have to be considered. The first would be how I’m getting my information? Am I seeing it first hand or am I relying on a crew
that are inexperienced or experienced? As the C.O., I would want to know that the three individuals have been notified to return back towards the hatch. If this has been confirmed, I would consider delaying my decision on closing the hatch. This may add stress to the rest of the crew in the ship and require more manpower to close the hatch, but obviously the results could motivational to an already difficult situation. If the men were not notified and their whereabouts unknown, this maybe the one factor that would solidify my decision to close the hatch.
Lawrence Kohlberg wrote Moral Stages and Moralization: The cognitive –developmental approach. We will try and use his theory to explain why a person can close the hatch on the ship costing the lives of the individuals. Kohlberg’s theory is divided up into 3 Levels,...

Other Papers Like Leadership

Leadership Essay

786 words - 4 pages Task You need complete the following workplace project on leadership and submit a 3000 word assignment. The Workplace Project on Leadership This project focuses on a critical analysis of a leader’s style and provides recommendations on how to sustain or improve leadership effectiveness. The intent of this assignment is to give you the opportunity to interview someone you genuinely admire for their leadership skills and results. You

Leadership Essay

581 words - 3 pages | Leadership Self Assessment Paper Embry-Riddle Aeronautical University 5 May, 2012 Background This section should be half a page to one page in length. The background should briefly describe what you do for a living and how leadership impacts your job or life in general. You also may want to briefly discuss the predominant style of leadership you are currently exposed to in your job. Personal Assessment Subjective Assessment This


529 words - 3 pages Leadership is ever changing. As our society changes and grows so does the endless aspects of leadership in what seems to be an endless array of applications as well. One thing, however, seems to remain the same as leadership is assessed and evaluated. At the root, leadership is the interaction or relationship between people. We may organize, develop, invent, create, or even grow things but people are lead. Leadership is the capacity within

Leadership - 752 words

752 words - 4 pages LEADERSHIP UNCUT | Brian Evje Jan 30, 2013 Quick: Define Leadership If you don't know what your leadership is, how are you going to make it persuasive to others? Only a few people have a solid answer. When first working with a client, I ask, “What is your definition of your leadership?”   Invariably, a pause follows. The eventual response is sometimes tentative, confused, or incomplete.  This happens with new and experienced leaders, in

Leadership - 5617 words

5617 words - 23 pages Chapter 18 Managers as Leaders Leaders in organizations make things happen. But what makes leaders different from nonleaders? What’s the most appropriate style of leadership? What can you do to be seen as a leader? Those are just a few of the questions we’ll try to answer in this chapter. Focus on the following learning outcomes as you read and study this chapter. LEARNING OUTCOMES 18.1 Define leader and leadership. 18.2

Leadership - 3289 words

3289 words - 14 pages I. Introduction Leadership has gained more attention of researchers from the whole world. Leadership is needed to corporations because it could bring extra assets to organizations and increase the line of bottom ultimately. There is a wide variety of theoretical approaches to analysis the complexities process of leadership. The essay will introduce three main leadership approaches: Trait approach, Situational & Contingency approach and

Leadership - 576 words

576 words - 3 pages MGMT20125
Leadership and Governance Term 1 - 2013 Profile information current as at 22-Mar-2013 16:04 Assessment Tasks WRITTEN ASSESSMENT Assessment Title Assessment item 1— Essay
This assignment requires you to write an essay on why the leader’s role is critical to effective governance of organisations. Your essay topic should be informed by the extant literature on leadership and governance, especially literature which points to

Leadership - 1345 words

1345 words - 6 pages The Nature of Leadership LEADERSHIP - the ability to influence people toward the attainment of organizational goals -a “people” activity and is dynamic and involves the use of power LEADERSHIP vs. MANAGEMENT COMPARISON |LEADERSHIP |MANAGEMENT | |Create a vision

Leadership - 284 words

284 words - 2 pages My Personal Leadership Experience The following paper will include a brief explanation of my occupational background, as well as a discussion of the circumstances, experiences, and people who I believe have helped my leadership ability. It will go on to explore my own experience and abilities in leadership roles, described by my viewpoints, and future ambitions related to leadership. Further detail will be examined of my leadership

Leadership - 1963 words

1963 words - 8 pages Modern Leadership University of Maryland University College AMBA 600 9045 10/28/14 Susan Malone Abstract The following paper examines two different leadership styles. Daniel Goleman introduces emotional intelligence and he explains the fundamental elements that define emotional intelligence and make a good leader. Mitch McCrimmon examines thought leadership in the workplace and compares it to shared or positional leadership. Both styles

Leadership - 1281 words

1281 words - 6 pages Servant Leadership This type of leadership emphasizes increased service to others, a holistic approach to work promoting a sense of community and the sharing of power in decision making. The term servant leadership was first shared in a 1970 essay by Robert Greenleaf (1904-1990) entitled “The Servant as Leader” Greenleaf spent most of his organizational life in the field of management research, development, and education at AT&T. He also

Related Essays

Leadership Essay

522 words - 3 pages packages was ?on-time, on-target.? I was a young lieutenant and at times I experienced frustration and ?growing pains.? In those trying times, I would often turn to my boss for help on leadership issues. He would give me the necessary advice and always close his comments with the phrase ?Leadership is leadership is leadership.? It was his signature phrase that he used quite frequently. To be quite honest, it meant nothing to me at that time. It

Leadership Essay 2706 Words

2706 words - 11 pages Table of contents 1.0 Executive Summary 3 2.0 Introduction 3 3.0 Discussion 3 3.1 Strategic leadership 4 3.2 Transformational leadership 4 3.3 Transactional leadership 5 4.0 Issues 5 4.0.1 Corporate vision and mission 5 4.0.2 Cultural diversity 6 4.0.3 Nurturing and delegation 6 4.0.4 Teamwork 6 5.0 Impacts 7 5.0.1 Unity of working teams 7 5.0.2 Setting organizational tone, strategy and right culture 8 5.0.3 Improved individual

Leadership Essay 1782 Words

1782 words - 8 pages Leadership Concepts of Leadership Good leaders are made not born. If you have the desire and willpower, you can become an effective leader. Good leaders develop through a never ending process of self-study, education, training, and experience. To inspire your workers into higher levels of teamwork, there are certain things you must be, know, and, do. These do not come naturally, but are acquired through continual work and study. Good leaders

Leadership Essay 571 Words

571 words - 3 pages 1. Ethical leadership Ethical leadership is leadership that is directed by respect for ethical beliefs and values and for the dignity and rights of others it is thus related to concepts such as trust, honesty, consideration, charisma and fairness. Ethical leadership as the process of influencing people through principles, values and beliefs that embrace what we have defined as right behavior. Example: tom is the director of an organization