This website uses cookies to ensure you have the best experience. Learn more

Law Review

2946 words - 12 pages

251 F.3d 1210 (8th Cir. 2001)
MARILYN SIMMONS, PLAINTIFF-APPELLANT,
v.
NEW PUBLIC SCHOOL DISTRICT NO. EIGHT, DEFENDANT-APPELLEE.
No. 00-2623
UNITED STATES COURT OF APPEALS FOR THE EIGHTH CIRCUIT
Submitted: March 16, 2001
Filed: May 30, 2001
Appeal from the United States District Court for the District of North Dakota.[Copyrighted Material Omitted][Copyrighted Material Omitted]
Before Murphy, Lay, and Bye, Circuit Judges.
Lay, Circuit Judge
1
Marilyn Simmons worked as an administrator for the New Public School District No. Eight (the District). She brought suit against the District alleging gender discrimination for (1) unequal pay, and (2) the non-renewal of her contract. The ...view middle of the document...

" Second, Simmons alleged she was paid less then men in similar positions. She relied on evidence that a male contemporary received larger percentage raises than she received, and evidence that the males hired to replace her a year after she left made significantly more money.2
4
The district court dismissed Simmons' claim in its entirety. The court first ruled that her claims were barred by the doctrine of res judicata by reason of the settlement in the state case. The court went further and dismissed Simmons' gender discrimination claims on the merits, holding that there was not sufficient evidence to support her claims. We reverse.
II. Discussion
A. Res Judicata
5
Res judicata precludes the re-litigation of a claim on grounds that were raised or might have been raised in a prior action. See Klipsch, Inc. v. WWR Technology, Inc., 127 F.3d 729, 733 (8th Cir. 1997). While normally Simmons' EEOC complaint would be barred by the settlement in her first lawsuit, it is clear that the explicit reservation of her right to bring her EEOC claims allows this suit. See Rugby Milling Co. v. Logosz, 261 N.W.2d 662, 664 (N.D. 1977); RESTATEMENT (SECOND) OF JUDGMENTS 26(1)(a) (allowing a second action when the parties to the first action "have agreed in terms or in effect that the plaintiff may split his claim, or the defendant has acquiesced therein."). We therefore hold that the issues raised by Simmons in her EEOC complaint survive the preclusive effect of the prior settlement.
B. Gender Discrimination
1. Non-Renewal
6
We next turn to the question of whether there was sufficient evidence to allow a trial on Simmons' gender discrimination claims. We review a district court's grant of summary judgment de novo, viewing the facts in the light most favorable to Simmons. See Moore v. Payless Shoe Source, Inc., 139 F.3d 1210, 1211 (8th Cir. 1998). To make a prima facie case of discrimination under Title VII, Simmons must show (1) she is a member of a protected class; (2) she is qualified to receive the benefit in question; (3) she was denied that benefit; and (4) there exists some evidence that gives rise to an inference of gender discrimination. See Kindred v. Northome/Industrial School Dist. No. 363, 154 F.3d 801, 803 (8th Cir. 1998). On appeal, the defendant argues that no evidence giving rise to an inference of gender discrimination exists. Simmons argues that Harstad's comments provide sufficient evidence of gender discrimination to allow the case to go to trial. We agree. It appears to us that Harstad's statements provide direct evidence3 of gender discrimination, which "meet[s] the fourth prong's minimal requirements of some evidence allowing for an inference of improper motivation." Landon v. Northwest Airlines, Inc., 72 F.3d 620, 624 (8th Cir. 1995).
7
The District relies upon a line of cases that hold that an inference of gender discrimination is not supported by "stray remarks in the workplace," "statements by nondecisionmakers," or...

Other Papers Like Law Review

Article Critique: Judging Judges - Critique Based Upon The Conceptual Article By Geoffrey P. Miller Titled; ‘Bad Judges’ (2004), Texas Law Review, 83(2), 431-487

1061 words - 5 pages Article critique: Judging PAGE \* MERGEFORMAT 1 Running head: ARTICLE CRITIQUE: JUDGING JUDGESArticle critique: Judging JudgesOctober 11, 2011Judging JudgesThis critique is based upon the conceptual article by Geoffrey P. Miller titled; 'Bad Judges' (2004), Texas Law Review, 83(2), 431-487, in which addresses the problem of bad judges who are abusive, corrupt, and incompetent. These judges undermine public confidence in the judicial system

A Book Review Of 'The Prince' By Niccolo` Machiavelli, Explaining, In Particular, What The Book Reveals About Rule Of Law

1065 words - 5 pages altered. And here Machiavelli pointed out the example of Sparta, which was able to maintain its self for eight hundred years without changing any law. He argues that if the Prince can commit himself to these laws, and therefore not taking people's wives and property, then he will not be assassinated, can remain powerful, and will have the support of his citizens in times of war. Therefore, Rule of Law is the 'magic-wand'.Rule of Law is the

Devry Business Law - Week 1 Assignment

618 words - 3 pages law or court decisions. Secondary sources of law would include things such as legal encyclopedias, legal treatise, or articles in law review. Statutory law is a body of law, which was enacted, by legislative bodies. Administrative law is created by administrative agencies in an effort to be able to complete their responsibilities and tasks. 3. What is the importance of precedent to the judicial decision-making process? When you consider the

Outline The Fundamental Essentials Of An Action Based On Judicial Review

598 words - 3 pages Outline the fundamental essentials of an action based on judicial review Judicial review is a type of court proceeding in which a judge reviews the lawfulness of a decision or action made by a public body. It is a challenge to the way in which a decision has been made. It is not really concerned with the conclusions of that process, as long as the right procedures have been followed. The types of decision which may fall within the range of

Data Base Administrator

1342 words - 6 pages treatise, or an article in a law review. | statute of limitations | A federal or state statute setting the maximum time period during which a certain action can be brought or certain rights enforced. | statutory law | The body of law enacted by legislative bodies (as opposed to constitutional law, administrative law, or case law). | substantive law | Law that defines, describes, regulates, and creates legal rights and obligations

The Three Strike Law

833 words - 4 pages ), 264. Reed, S. (2004). Sentencing And Punishment--Cruel and Unusual Punishment: The United States Supreme Court Upholds California's Three Strikes Law, Ruling The Law Does Not Violate The Eighth Amendment's Prohibition On Cruel And Unusual Punishment. North Dakota Law Review, 80(3), 497-533. Romano, M. (2010). Striking Back: Using Death Penalty Cases to Fight Disproportionate Sentences Imposed Under California's Three Strikes Law. Stanford Law & Policy Review, 21(2), 311-348.

Business Law

629 words - 3 pages rules (legislative and interpretative), they investigate (example: subpoena) and they adjudicate (hearing before administrative law judge, ALJ). Limits on Agency Power Statutory Control The enabling legislation of an agency provides some limits. For example, formal rule making or investigating only certain issues. Political Control By President, By Congress who controls money Judicial Review Information Control and the Public Freedom of

Business Law

982 words - 4 pages common law. Common law is “ the body of law developed from custom or judicial decisions in English U.S. Court, not attributable to legislature” (Jentz-Miller, pg.7, 2012). Common law is the basis of varies cases will be given the same judicial review. Judges like to keep the same biases, when need be, they will make decisions bases on cases handled before. The common law helps to keep decisions to a minimal with the same stature, which

Business Law

908 words - 4 pages Business Law 315 - Chapter 1 Review Questions 1. In the common law system of the United States, a crime is defined as: a. a private wrong that necessitates litigation between the victim and the perpetrator b. any act prohibited by the government and made punishable through imprisonment or fines c. litigation where the injured party sues to recover compensation for the damages and injury sustained as a result of the defendant’s

‘the Law of Contract Confines Itself to the Enforcement of Voluntarily Created Civil Obligations’-Illustrate and Explain

2709 words - 11 pages Classical and Relational Contract Law, 72 Nw. U. L. Rev. 854 (1978) Michael Trebilcock, The Limits of Freedom of contract (1993) Penner J.E. (1996),Voluntary Obligations and Scope of Law of Contract, Legal Theory-2, pp325-57,Cambridge University Press. Raz, J, . Harvard Law Review, supra note 1 at 211, 933-38 Schwartz, Alan and Scott, Robert E., ”Contract Theory and the Limits of Contract Law” (2003). Faculty Scholarship Series. paper 308

Role and Functions of Law Paper

837 words - 4 pages Judicial reviews are where a higher level court can review cases involving laws and render those laws invalid if they are in conflict with other higher forms of law, such as the Constitution. It is an important part of the checks and balances to limit the authority of the legislative branch. The power of judicial review was established by the case of Marbury v. Madison, which the Court heard in 1803 under Chief Justice John Marshall, who is

Related Essays

Law Review

1213 words - 5 pages Law Review 1. Pendleton Act 1883: A United States federal law that required government jobs to be awarded based on merit. This act selected government employees by competitive exams. It also made it illegal to solicit campaign donations on Federal government property and use political reasons to fire or demote government employees. 2. Davis-Bacon Act 1931: A United States federal law that required public works projects for laborers

Book Review Business Law Battle Plan

2193 words - 9 pages PART I Business Law Battle Plan by Marjorie Jobe, J.D. provides strategies and steps necessary to protect entrepreneurs from the risk of litigation which has become commonplace in the United States legal system . The author claims that today’s American legal system is broken, abused by bad lawyers and corrupt prosecutors whereby no business owners are safe no matter how insignificant the business is or even if it is innocent. The author

Law And Management Review

3367 words - 14 pages .’ Common law has developed a series of tests to help determine the position of a worker and the role that they have in the company. These tests examine whether or not there is an employment contract visible, and therefore conclude whether or not the worker is actually an employee. The first test to be devised is known as ‘the Control test’ and it considers the amount of control that the employer has. Therefore if the employer controlled both

Special Education Law Review

746 words - 3 pages IDEA, the Individual with Disabilities Education Act, is our nation’s special education law. The IDEA guides how states, school districts, and public agencies provide early intervention, special education and related services to more than 6.5 million eligible infants, toddlers, children and youth with disabilities. The ADA protects the civil rights of people with disabilities in all aspects of employment, in accessing public services