Law Case Study

2098 words - 9 pages

PHC6420
Spring 2013
Dated:

Summary of Planned Parenthood of Southeastern Pennsylvania v. Casey (1992).

In 1973 Roe v. Wade created a political and legal uproar on issue of abortion. Under due process clause of the 14th Amendment, which declares that “no State shall deprive any person of life, liberty or property without due process of law”. This due process of law has not been completely understood though court has spent years of defining redefining each component of due process clause. Women’s decision to have abortion before viability of fetus and to obtain it without interference from State .Interest of State to protect prenatal life and create hurdles for Women’s right to choose ...view middle of the document...

If a minor is seeking abortion Parents’ consent must be taken. A married woman seeking abortion must sign a statement saying that she has informed her spouse about her intent of having an abortion. The act also imposed reporting requirements on the facilities that provide abortions.
These Provisions were challenged by abortion clinics and physicians. They brought suit against the Respondent: Robert P. Casey, Governor of Pennsylvania, and others seek relief from these provisions of Pennsylvania Abortion Control Act. The district court held these provisions unconstitutional. The United States court of Appeals for the third Circuit reversed in part saying only the husband notification provision was unconstitutional. The court applied the doctrine of stare decisis and reaffirmed the essential holdings in Roe v. Wade.
The US court for eastern district of Pennsylvania held all provisions were unconstitutional. The United States Court of Appeals for the third circuit affirmed in part and reversed in part the provisions holding spousal requirement unconstitutional and so did the US Supreme Court. The supreme court further acknowledged the woman has right to choose abortions before the fetus is viable and the state has power to restrict abortion after fetus is viable provided it does not endanger the life of the woman.
The constitutionality of several Pennsylvania state regulations regarding abortion was challenged in this case. A Pennsylvania law that required spousal awareness prior to obtaining an abortion was invalid under the Fourteenth Amendment because it created an undue burden on married women seeking an abortion. Requirements for parental consent, informed consent, and 24-hour waiting period were constitutionally valid regulations. Third Circuit Court of Appeals affirmed in part and reversed in part. Five provisions of the Pennsylvania Abortion Control Act of 1982 were being challenged as unconstitutional under Roe v. Wade, which first recognized a constitutional right to have an abortion in the liberty protected by the Due Process Clause of the Fourteenth Amendment. The plurality, an opinion from a group of judges, reiterated what the Court had said in Eisenstadt v. Baird: "If the right of privacy means anything, it is the right of the individual, married or single, to be free from unwarranted governmental intrusion into matters and so fundamentally affecting a person as the decision whether to bear or beget a child."
One of the main issues being challenged in this case was that spousal notification imposed undue burden. In a serious matter such as abortion, it seems obvious that the mother and father of the fetus should discuss the issue. They will either agree or disagree on abortion. However, the Court decided that ultimately, the view of only one of the marital partners could prevail. The Court thought since it is the woman who physically bears the child and is the one directly and immediately affected by the pregnancy, the balance...

Other Papers Like Law Case Study

Business Law Case Study

1190 words - 5 pages want to sell the business, the price it will be sold at will be high due to the good performance of the business. By the use of the advisors recommended, the running of the business shall be simple and without a lot of input from the owners. These are the things that will assure the business’ continuity. The strategy given will work and the success of the business is assured. References Hoffman, Scott L. The Law and

Business Law Case Study

1565 words - 7 pages . 0313801 To advice Mrs Smith Again, this is the case of negligence statement causing loss from insurance claiming. However, it satisfied all three criteria given by Lord Reid, shown in the case above. It also conducts the CAPARO test. 1.Proximity: Jim works in the Law Faculty; he agreed to give free legal advice to Mrs Smith in his office. The advice is given professionally. There was proximity here, because the advice is given for

Business Law I Case Study

519 words - 3 pages consequences would be an oppressive and unfair scenario. Therefore, the motion for preliminary injunction was denied in favor of the defendants. Facts: The defendants, upon being hired by Russell, entered into contracts which contained three relevant covenants in this case; not to compete with the plaintiffs, not to solicit the plaintiff’ customers, and not to disclose the plaintiffs’ confidential information. The defendants, for many

Law For Management Case Study

1560 words - 7 pages : Sweet &Maxwell Ltd, 2003. Laurence, Kffman and Elizabeth Macdonald, The Law of Contract, 7th Edition, New York: Oxford University Press, 2010 Case Adams V. Lindsell (1818) 1 B & Ald 681 Brinkibon Ltd V. Stahag Stahl and Stahlwarenhandelsgesellschaft Gmbh [1983] 2 AC 34 Bromley V. Ryan (1956) 99 CLR 362 Byrne & Co V. Leon Van Tienhoven & Co (1880) 5 CPD 344 Carlill V. Carbolic Smoke Ball Co. Ltd. [1893] 1 QB 256 Coward V

Critically Evaluate the Relationship Between Applying the Law and Social Work Values in a Child Protection Case Study in Northern Ireland Case Study

1416 words - 6 pages Critically evaluate the relationship between applying the law and social work values in a child protection case study in Northern Ireland case study. Social work is a value-based profession, and one of the core capabilities, at all career levels, is recognising, and where appropriate addressing, personal and professional values and prejudices. It is not uncommon, for the law to be seen as a critical component in developing provision and

A Study Of Law

2832 words - 12 pages follow the chastity law or not. Also, I would also examine that weather the chastity law is the protection of widows or not. In case of poor widows, they might choose to remarry. Accordingly, this paper will have a study on the chastity law in Qing society by examining the problems that widows at the time might surely had faced in terms of chastity laws posed on them. My paper is elaborated mainly based on Matthew H. Sommer’s artcle. As I mentioned

Article Case Law Paper

1223 words - 5 pages Article / Case Law Paper Rhonda M. Godwin University of Phoenix HCS / 430 Legal Issues in Health Care: Regulation and Compliance Gina Robinson, RN, MSN October 26, 2008 Obesity is becoming a worldwide epidemic. Right now, the numbers of obese persons is rapidly rising, with about 17% of EU residents and 32% of Americans being considered obese. According to the Centers for Disease Control, by 2010, the forecast is that the

Business Law

1508 words - 7 pages risks in order to avoid this legal problem. NB: Before commencing to write an answer to a legal case study question it is recommended that students run through the following checklist: What? Read the question that usually will appear at the end of the case study. It will tell you what you are supposed to be doing. Often it will tell you the area of law, so you can immediately look up information on it in your prescribed text and other texts

Business Law

1304 words - 6 pages Case Study 1 In this case study, John is not legally bonded to sell his property to both Adam and Bill. Thus, the transaction between John and Charles is valid. Principle of Acceptance In this case study, John offered to sell his house at $2 million dollars. Adam offers to buy the house for $1.8 million dollars and John said nothing to this transaction. According to the principles of acceptance, an acceptance must be positive and not passive

Business Law

1666 words - 7 pages Question 1 This issue with this case concerns the offences committed by the three China bus drivers that went on strike, the required criminal laws to deal with the offences committed are Duress, Tort of Conspiracy, Employment law and Discharge of Contract. As part of the common law, Duress happens when one party refuses to agree into a contract and is forced to agree to the contract by violence or a threat, and also the threat must be of

Labour Law

694 words - 3 pages WARD’s 11days Training on Bangladesh Labor Law Application Course on Bangladesh Labor Law [ACBLL] Date: November 07-December 13, 2014 Day: Friday & Saturday of Every week Time: 6.00 pm to 9.00 pm Registration deadline: November 03, 2014 Venue: WINGS Centre, Dhanmondi, Dhaka. OUR UNIQUENESS Role Play & Activities Whole training will be conducted based on Role Play, Case Study, Self activity, hands on exercise

Related Essays

Commercial Law Case Study

2400 words - 10 pages Commercial Law: Case Study COMMERCIAL LAW: CASE STUDY Introduction A contract is usually made between the buyer and the seller during the buying and the selling of goods and services. This contract is made with regard to elements that exist such as agreement to buy or sell a product willingly, acceptance of the terms and conditions and transfer of responsibilities and risks from the buyer to the seller (Bradgate & Twigg-Flesner, 2003

Case Study Eu Competition Law

1703 words - 7 pages Assignment: Competition in the European Union: The legal framework Assignment: Competition in the European Union The legal framework Case Study Florian Madl BUS 573_Law for Business Executives, CLU 1 Assignment: Competition in the European Union: The legal framework Table of content 1.  The Case ........................................................................................ 3  1.1.  General

Ls311 – Business Law Unit 3 Case Study

307 words - 2 pages Running head: Double Jeopardy Unit 3: Case Study NAME LS311 – Business Law Prof. SNAME Case Armington, while robbing a drugstore, shot and seriously injured Jennings, a drugstore clerk. Armington was subsequently convicted in a criminal trial of armed robbery and assault and battery. Jennings later brought a civil tort suit against Armington for damages. Armington contended that he could not be tried again for the same crime, as

Law Contract Case Study

1007 words - 5 pages Case 1 Issue This problem addresses the issue of agreement, whether there is a valid contract or the offer may be terminated. In order to the contract being valid and enforceable, there is a need for the conduct of an offer and an acceptance. Rule For an offer to be valid, it contains some rules, including lapse of time. When an offer is made, it does not last forever. An offer stated to open for a specific period, lapse if the there is no