Labour Parties Reforms In 1997 Essay

1086 words - 5 pages

After the Labour party’s strong victory in the 1997 general election, winning 179 seats, they have made moves and provisions towards constitutional reform. Indeed, the two prime ministers; Tony Blair and Gordon Brown have done much for reform over the years, as illustrated by devolution and the human rights act. Indeed, they made provision for reform in 4 key areas, modernisation, and greater protection of rights, democratisation and decentralisation. However, it can be argued that their reform has been limited, and much more can be done for constitutional reform. 

Firstly, it is clear that the modernisation aspects of the reform have been severely limited. Indeed, this can be illustrated ...view middle of the document...

This once united the three branches of the state, yet it has now been separated. The Chancellor is now merely a member of the executive. Furthermore, there have been significant modernising reforms within the House of Commons in recent years. These have included the increase in use of Westminster hall for debates, the publication of bills two weeks in advance to increase scrutiny, and the change in prime ministers questions, from the once two 15 minute questions, to once half an hour slot. Therefore these reforms have strengthened the UK constitution. 

In addition, there has been weak reform with the protection of rights. Indeed, the human rights act (2000) is merely semi-entrenched. This means that its provisions can be put aside by Parliament, which has been done through the Declaration of incompatibility. The government can ask Parliament to pass legislation which infringes with the human rights act, under cases of national security. This was the case with the Terrorism act (2001)- emergency legislation passed in two days which suspended the Habeas Corpus Act and could have someone imprisoned indefinitely. In addition, the freedom of information act (2000), was to allow for the government to become more open and transparent by allowing for citizens to see documents which affect them. However, the Justice Secretary can veto requests if they believe that it hinders with national security. This was the case with Jack Straw and the cabinet meetings over the Iraq War and Devolution. Therefore it is clear that more can be done for the protection of our rights, possibly by creating a Bill of Rights, which would entrench citizen’s rights clearer. It is clear that reform of the constitution has not gone far enough. 

Furthermore, the democratisation aspects of the constitution can also be shown to be limited. Indeed, the Labour party promised to make provisions towards electoral reform. This has occurred in the devolved assemblies, which utilise proportional representation systems such as the additional member system- however, it has yet to occur in Parliament. This is because any governing party who is able to achieve a majority of the seats in the commons, do not want to change the system of first past the post of simple-plurality voting, as they do well under this. Also, aspects of...

Other Papers Like Labour Parties Reforms in 1997

Great Britain Notes Essay

955 words - 4 pages ) * Association of Conservative with economic and elite * “Long lasting alliance between upper-class and lower-class” * Electoral support from about one-third of manual working class * Internal division on the EU cost the party * Neoliberalism-more hands off for economy to succeed. The Liberal Democrats(Leader in Nick Clegg) -The only challenger to Labour and Conservative parties -2001 election they gained 50

Functionalism Essay

684 words - 3 pages How effectively do the UK's main political parties fuffil their key roles and functions? Introduction: In the UK we currently have a two party system the Labour party and the Conservative party, each party has main roles that they need to perform in order to provide an active government system. These key roles come in five different forms known as the following; * participation, this is where the parties allow members within the party


655 words - 3 pages have democracy as a central theme of their electoral manifesto. The 1997 Labour Party manifesto is a key example, as it explicitly expressed a commitment towards referendums. In Abraham Lincoln's definition of democracy, government 'by and with the people' was a core element. Referendums are viewed as a way of enforcing a government 'by and with the people', as it allows public opinion to inform party policy. A forth and somewhat modern

To What Extent Are the Ideas and Policies of the Labour and Conservative Parties Similar?

565 words - 3 pages In my opinion, I think that while the Labour and conservative parties started at different ends of the political spectrum, as time progresses and attitudes have become less radical, that both parties have become more moderate to appeal to the voting public, and in doing this, have become very similar as they both fight for the middle party. When concerning environmental issues, I believe that the ideas that the Labour and conservative

The New Labour

816 words - 4 pages The New Labour 1. Introduction 1.1 Content: The essay question asks about whether the reforms implemented in the 1990's by Labour are a new phenomenon or a revamp of past policies implemented by other governments in their time. 1.2 Key terms: The idea of New Labour is described by Philip Norton as "A summary label to describe the economic polices devised by the Labour Party in the 1990's to ensure a departure

Constitutional Reform Since 1997 Has Not Gone Far Enough

1546 words - 7 pages Constitutional reform is the process whereby the fundamental nature of the system of government is changed, or change is proposed. Following their strong victory in the 1997 election, the Labour party have made moves and provisions towards constitutional reform. The two prime ministers; Tony Blair and Gordon Brown have made much progress in reform in the life span of the Labour government from 1997 to 2010, for example devolution to Scotland

Unemployment in Australia

1223 words - 5 pages productivity. Reforms to the industrial relations framework to encourage new workplace agreements will help, but even more important is the attitudes of the parties themselves and their willingness to think creatively about possible improvement in the organisation of their work. MORRIS RICHARD,2000, ECONOMICS DOWNUNDER, JOHN & WILEY SON LTD, AUSTRALIA

Post War Nz

1197 words - 5 pages diversity. “1945 - 1965 was marked by an emphasis on security, community and consensus” (Gustafson, 2006: 3) Gustafson also pointed out that much of the health, education and welfare systems remained virtually untouched (2006:4). The two party system prevailed with the National and Labour parties being the two main players and majority of the minor parties were left to be outsiders. The nation was also in agreement to have strategic alliances with

Comparing Electoral Processes in Uk

1038 words - 5 pages constituency level, where the winning candidate may have received only one third of the votes cast. Indeed, a government may be elected on a minority vote, as happened in February 1974 when Labour won the general election on the number of seats gained but the Conservatives had a larger share of the vote across the country. Smaller parties are not fairly treated under FPTP. Although they may have a sizeable national support across the country, they

Power: the Federal Government and the Union Movement

5751 words - 24 pages parties have only their interest group in mind, hence the reason for such power relations between the two. The reforms to the Industrial Relations Act (which was renamed the Workplace Relations Act) of 1996 saw significant additions, revisions and deletions to many sections of the Act. The Coalition purported them to be in the interest of ‘equity in the workplace’ and ‘providing a framework for cooperative workplace relations’ (Lee

Microeconomic Reform

2034 words - 9 pages weakest rate, Australia's productivity growth accelerated to new highs in the 1990s with labour productivity growth at an average of 3.0 per cent a year and multifactor productivity growth at 1.8 per cent a year (L. Taylor, The Rocky Road to Reform, 1993). For nine years, annual gross domestic product growth averaged just under 4 per cent, a performance not seen since the 1960s and early 1970s (Productivity Commission, Microeconomic Reforms and

Related Essays

How Successful Were The Reforms Of Post War Labour Government 1945 1951 In Creating A Welfare State?

1574 words - 7 pages strides when in reality a majority of those that needed help, still did not receive it. Moreover, reforms were aimed at tackling problems which sick workers faced. It was in 1911 that the National Insurance Act (Part 1) was passed. Said Act focused on creating unemployment insurance and the first labour exchange schemes where benefits would be collected. This way those who were out of work due to sickness were given funds to support them during

Were The Conservatives The Natural Party Of Government Between 1951 2007?

975 words - 4 pages ). Particularly with the growth of the affluent middle classes, Conservatives were seen more in tune with them. * Pre 1997 Labour was badly ravaged by internal divisions (Bevanites vs. Gaitskellites, Loony Left vs. Kinnock’s reforms), thus they were never effective in opposition. * Industrial discontent and rise of trade union militancy pre 1997 was frequently ascribed to the Labour party (who were committed to the needs of the trade unions as one

Has Constitutional Reform Since 1997 Gone Too Far?

1577 words - 7 pages Has constitutional reform in the UK gone too far since 1997? Due to the uncodified nature of the UK constitution it is organic and the lack of higher law enables constitutional reforms to occur far quicker and with greater ease than seen in other countries, such as the USA. A constitutional reform is a political change in the constitution. There are varying bodies of opinion on the extent of constitutional reforms that are currently required

Labour Relations Essay

1528 words - 7 pages , deliberately incorporate wage increase policies in the national budgeting process. These reforms would go a long way in minimizing the growing number of strikes in the country. II. Introduction and Background Martin Luther King, Jr. said that All labor that uplifts humanity has dignity and importance and should be undertaken with painstaking excellence. Labour relation or industrial relation is usually referred as the relationship between an