Kant's Morality Essay

1357 words - 6 pages

"This guy was in interrogation. He wasn't willingly giving stuff up." That’s what an officer involved in the capture of Saddam Hussein told the Washington Post. If the informant who led U.S. forces to Saddam wasn't giving information willingly, why did he give any information at all? It is hard to avoid thinking about the dirty word that everyone is too polite to mention, the "T-word": torture? They say it was just "interrogation," which is what torture lite is. Things like bags over the head, tight handcuffs, no light, no food or bathroom, endless shouting or blaring music or noise, bits of light violence. And, of course, the constant mental and emotional torture of fearing that serious ...view middle of the document...

" Even though that rule protects many criminals from conviction, in its absence people could be tortured or threatened into confessing crimes they didn't commit. So, if there were no fifth amendment, it would not cause the greatest good for the greatest number of people. An act utilitarian would permit torture in certain circumstances. When an act of torture would, all things considered, maximize happiness or minimize unhappiness, then it should be done. The rule utilitarian would be more careful respect for “the rules” amounts to a genuine respect for the rights of individuals. This would imply that torture lite is wrong due to the simple fact that is causes suffering and violates the interreges rights as a human.

The concept of torture lite can also be condemned according to Kant’s categorical imperative. According to the first formulation, one must ask themselves if the action they are about to engage in corresponds to a rule, which should be applied universally. So, if one was to consider torture lite, one would have to first formulate a maxim based on this planned action: “It is good to torture individuals.” Then one would have to decide if it would be a good thing for this rule to apply to everyone. The question must be asked, would it be a good thing for everyone to think that it was okay to torture individuals? The answer is no, therefore this action can be stated to be immoral, and therefore the act of torture lite to a particular individual should not be indulged, whether or not it is deserved. This is all according to Kant’s first formulation of categorical imperative.

The second formulation, however, is fairly easy to understand. It simply states that we should never use people for our own benefit, thinking nothing of them as people. Instead, we should see the benefit of others as our end goal, rather than the means. Clearly, torture lite can be used to directly benefit the torturer, and during these brutal acts, the torturer thinks nothing of the individual. The only thing the torturer is awaiting to receive is vital information and/or some other type of benefits. This evidently condemns the act of torture lite according to the second formulation of Kant’s categorical imperative.

In my personal opinion, I would consider the act utilitarian aspect of this subject to be morally right just because it essentially protects and focuses on the greater good. I read a science fiction story where in the near future a terrorist group hides a nuclear device in a large city. Those responsible are captured, but refuse to tell where the bomb is hidden. The government hires professional torturers to extract the information from the terrorists. In the story the reasons behind the use of the torturers become less and less justifiable over time until eventually they are used to prevent hung juries, and save the people’s...

Other Papers Like Kant's Morality

Individual Research Paper

1842 words - 8 pages Spiceland, Sepe, and Tomassini (2007), ethics is “a code or moral system that provides a criteria for evaluating what is right and wrong” (Spiceland, Sepe, and Tomassni, 2007). Deontological theories base morality on certain duties or obligations and claim that certain actions are right or wrong regardless of the consequences that may follow from the actions. Deontology is a moral theory that depends on scriptures that are governed by rules, moral laws

Ethics Theories Essay

905 words - 4 pages , obligation, or guideline, they are acting ethically. Divine Command Theory holds on to the notion that morality is intimately associated with God, and that ethical actions are commands and submissions to God's orders and what is ethically right activity is what God summons or requires. The elements of divine commands differ significantly based on religion and the particular perspectives of the theory’s supporters. However, all forms this

Christianity and Culture

1791 words - 8 pages Nietzsche's basic radical contentions were the new traditional values represented primarily by Christianity create a loss of power in the lives of individuals. His most “dangerous idea” he expresses a proclamation “God is dead.” He was convinced these new customary values presented in the Christian religions represented a slave morality (Class Notes). This was a morality which was created by weak and resentful individuals who encouraged such

Outsourcing Software Jobs Overseas

3234 words - 13 pages company's financial situation.When situation forces them to outsource to keep the company from falling down, they might consider outsourcing only as much which is needed to come out of the crisis, and try to either retain all of its employees at least in part time positions or retain as many of them as possible. While Utilitarian ideas might oppose outsourcing, Immanuel Kant's 'Moral Philosophy' at the outset might seem to support the companies


2770 words - 12 pages between morality and reason, duty, and God. He claimed to have discovered a universal moral law which he called 'the categorical imperative.' Critique of Judgement This third book Critique of Judgement contains a discussion of aesthetics, along with the nature of judgements that pertains to what is beautiful. Kant's Legacy In addition to his three treatises, Kant produced several essays in support of religious liberalism and enlightenment

Immanuel Kant

1115 words - 5 pages untruthful claims; subsequently there would be no such thing as claims to untruthfully make. In Kant's terms the maxim depends upon the judgment and the judgment improves with experience. Consequently nothing is said once for all. For every single case one wants to redefine the situation and work out a suitable maxim. In no case the categorical imperative commands a single act though. Nonetheless possibly the maxim might became a universal law

Categorical Imperative

1565 words - 7 pages Kant's Categorical Imperative Deontology is the ethical view that some actions are morally forbidden or permitted regardless of consequences. One of the most influential deontological philosophers in history is Immanuel Kant who developed the idea of the Categorical Imperative. Kant believed that the only thing of intrinsic moral worth is a good will. Kant says in his work Morality and Rationality “The good will is not good because of what

Tui Eth501 Module 1

1834 words - 8 pages duty and the morality of human actions” (Encyclopedia Britannica, n.d., p1) An action is considered good based on the characteristic of that action instead of on the result of that action. An example would be; not lying even though it may save someone’s life, because lying is considered a violation of deontological ethics. Even though lying could save someone’s life, it is still frowned upon because you are being unethical by lying in the first

Immanual Kant Deontology Presentation

1465 words - 6 pages Immanuel Kant Presentation Deontology – Deon-duty, logos -science Because we so regularly take it for granted that moral values are closely related with the goal of human well-being or happiness Kant's claim that these two ideas are absolutely separate makes it difficult to grasp his point of view and easy to misunderstand it. "Nothing can possibly be conceived in the world, or even out of it, which can be called good without

Gulf War: Why Did The U.S. Intervene

3756 words - 16 pages protecting their perennial ally, Israel. The United States, for several reasons, has always been the protector of Israel, and continued to play that role in intervening in the Middle East. Morality also played a role in why the United States decide to become involved in the Persian Gulf Crisis. Whether it was simply a strategic public policy move, or that the decision-makers truly believed it was such an atrocious act by Iraq that they were


2558 words - 11 pages that has been opposed and a topic of heated controversies due to its unmoral precedent. The morality of using such outcomes are wrong in the eyes of the society we live in but in my personal opinion and judgment believe that the use of assisted suicide (euthanasia) is ethical and morally correct to end the personal burden and pain one endures with terminal illness. Assisted suicide should be legal and more importantly should be considered if one

Related Essays

The Concept Of Happiness According To Kant ( With The Categorical Imperative) And Mill (With The Utilitarianism)

1096 words - 5 pages morality can only work for example, as a guideline to war because so many other rules can be left up to interpretation.In conclusion, Mills theory of Utilitarianism justifies the greater good of the majority over that of the individual, while Kant's theory believes that society can function by all acting on an exclusively rational basis, which I believe showed a failure in his works from the start. Each system works best in its own area, Kant's works well for war, and Utilitarianism works well for everyday small human interactions. But neither, I believe, makes any dent in the broad range of experience.

Rs Absolute And Relative Morality Ethics

1958 words - 8 pages a) Explain the differences between absolute and relative morality. (25) To start, it is necessary to define the terms 'absolute' and 'relative' with reference to morality. Absolute means any theory in which the rules are absolute: they are unchanging and universal. Relative means any theory in which something is judged in relation to something else and is therefore open to change. Absolute laws or rules of morality will never change. Another

Kantian Ethics: In Search Of Flawless Morals

1366 words - 6 pages a part of knowledge, its contribution transcendental, and not merely psychological: we define reality in the same measure that reality defines us.His conception implies that morality should be rooted on the common principle of individual freedom, and that each individual is in turn responsible for his own morality. All principles of ethics can be inferred from the maxims that support each action, and each maxim must result from categorical

Wide Sargasso Sea Essay

1039 words - 5 pages thing. Intention is not always the reason for good will or anything morally sound. The debate of whether the workman is ethically wrong for killing a man truly does depend on the situation. Kant and Hume both prove good points. Kant's principality of duty regardless of feelings proves that it has worked for awhile but in this day and age, there is hardly ever any decision based on judgment and emotion. For example, our legal system. ANY case that