This website uses cookies to ensure you have the best experience. Learn more

Justify A Lie? Essay

859 words - 4 pages

Justify a Lie?
In the one-act play Trifles by Susan Glaspell, John Wright, a citizen of Dixon County, Nebraska is killed in his home and his wife, Minnie Wright is the suspected murderer. The following morning, the County Attorney, the Sheriff Peters and his wife, and The Wright’s neighbor, Lewis Hale and his wife visit the house to look for evidence. The men tell the women to stay in the kitchen to keep out of the way. Little to the men know the answer to their questions is in the kitchen and Mrs. Peters and Mrs. Hale discover the clues and solve the crime. However, the two women decide not to tell the men in order to protect Minnie. The question that comes to mind is: “Was the ...view middle of the document...

Especially when that person is working for the government.
One may argue that Mrs. Peters and Mrs. Hale are defending their fellow woman. I do agree that the men were not treating the women fairly. I am a supporter of women’s rights, myself. But if you imagine what would happen in the story after Glaspell finished writing, are they really helping out the female gender? Suppose someone were to find out about what the two women had done. Not only would Minnie Wright be convicted of the murder, but Mrs. Peters and Mrs. Hale would be convicted of crimes as well. In the end, three women would be suffering. They would have done nothing but give an example of women not being loyal to their government.
I agree that we need to defend and stand up for what we believe in. But I do not think we need to go as far as endangering ourselves.
Others may say that the women lied to get back at the men for the way they are treated. During this time, circa 1916, men were still the superior gender. For example, Mr. Hale says, “Well, women are used to worrying over trifles.” A few lines later, the County Attorney finds dirty towels and Mrs. Hale defends Minnie saying, “Those towels get dirty awful quick. Men’s hands aren’t always as clean as they might be.” The County Attorney then shoots back with, “Ah, loyal to...

Other Papers Like Justify a Lie?

Critical Thinking Essay

1138 words - 5 pages from love and consider it as an activity for pleasure. She argues that during the time of marriage, many couples find new lovers and fall out of love in their marriages with their spouses. The author doesn’t find any moral value in staying faithful to somebody you no longer love. The weakest premise of the author is when she justify adultery to be just for pleasure and claims that it should be separated from love. The author’s claim implies a

Ls312 Unit 5 Assign Essay

1015 words - 5 pages of Greg’s. This At-Will law is not lawful because it violates a public policy exception. This means social norms or values are compromised. If an employer orders an employee to lie under oath and the employee refuses, the employer cannot terminate the employee. In this case Eddie is not telling Jane to lie under oath, but still is threatening her with firing her is she says anything (Kaplan EGuide, Chp. 3). The law being violated here is

Does the End Justify the Means?

1284 words - 6 pages warning to others that if they murder, then they will also be put to death. The end results (a safer society) justify the harsh means (putting someone to death) used to get them. What consequences may arise from following, or not following, this political axiom? There are consequences for a government following, and not following, the philosophy of "the end justifies the means." Each will be talked about respectively. A consequence of a

Formal Essay

623 words - 3 pages authority as a father doesn’t justify his actions and thoughts toward his son. He makes up for his actions by asking for forgiveness and changing his ways. He closes his story by telling how much he wanted his family to watch the baseball game. At the baseball game is when he made his first action to a drastic change in his life. Salvation is something Jack attained as he so writes, “I remembered my long walk across the outfield as a dignified, silent

Job Recruitment

553 words - 3 pages employees that are tailored to their specific needs without any hassle. These employees can be then be utilized in the workplace to see if they fit the job prior to being given the choice of a permanent position. This can greatly benefit the employer to ensure that the right individual is hired for the job. Another benefit of this type of external recruitment is that if a company can not justify hiring a full time employee they can then use a

Schadenfreude

617 words - 3 pages lengths to attain what they want. A couple was envious of another couple’s home and tried everything they could to get them to sell their home. As a last resort, they convinced the couple that a highway was going to be built right through the home, which was a lie. This was enough for the homeowners to move out and sell their home. Once the envious couple attained what they wanted, they saw that construction machinery was actually rolling up to the

The Mandrake

671 words - 3 pages charming wife. Through the play, Machiavelli has wittingly portrayed the perception that knowledge is power through capturing the simplicity that shows Messer’s gullibility. The other characters in the play continuously trick him despite his affluence. In an illustration, Calimaco conjures up a lie about being a physician by way of pretending to be an expert in the medical field with a few utterances in Latin (Maloney and Machiavelli, 2008). Through

The Integrity of Memory and the Process of Reasoning

572 words - 3 pages consider. All of this has me asking myself a bigger question. How do I know what is real and how would I justify if it is or not? What if all that I know isn't true and I've been living a lie that I created? Through family and friends, I know some basic things, such as my age and the year and similar things which we all seem to agree on, but what about the personal experiences I have had which affected my memory and caused me to perceive

Space Shuttle Disaster

635 words - 3 pages On the 1st February 2003, a critical systems failure on the space shuttle Columbia on its re-entry to the earth’s atmosphere. This caused the disintegration of the shuttle leading to the death of all seven crew members. 1.  Describe NASA's apparent approach to risk management after Challenger but before Columbia. On January 28, 1986, the space shuttle Challenger broke apart in 76 seconds after launch, killing all of its 7 crew members

The Mass Media And Social Construction

936 words - 4 pages of Seeing." (Berger) It turns out that what we see is not necessarily what we are seeing.Berger makes an important point when he says that publicity falsely proposes that purchases of things will change the consumer. Yet we know that this is a lie. Nonetheless, people but into the lie of advertising. People are simply led to believe that they are making a choice, when in fact all that is happening is the negation of choice.This is where Berger's

Hero By Siegfried Sassoon Analysis

1395 words - 6 pages between the truth in the trenches and the truth at home. His poem leaves it perfectly in the middle where the blame could possibly lie. While Jack lied about getting injured, and the Brother Officer lied to the mother, the newspapers are also lying to the people back in Britain. Propaganda was used back home to try and keep morale up and justify the war. Sassoon was a big critic of the way propaganda was falsely influencing the people, and the rest

Related Essays

Lying Essay

777 words - 4 pages In an article I read by Ericsson called "The Ways We Lie" she talks about five different types of lies. The different types of lies are white lies, facades, ignoring the plain facts, stereotypes and clichés, and bald face lies. The lie I believe is justify is a white lie, and the lies that are not justify are facades, ignoring the plain facts, stereotypes and clichés, and bald face lies. White lies are acceptable because they're

Rhetorical Analysis

1002 words - 5 pages all do. We exaggerate, we minimize, we avoid confrontation, we spare people’s feelings, we conveniently forget, we keep secrets, we justify lying to the big-guy institutions.” The author believes that lying is an essential component of life, however “There is a world of difference between telling functional lies and living a lie.”(167), and individually people need to decide how much they want to lie and how much they want to be lied

How Does Lying Help You? Essay

518 words - 3 pages eventually causes their cruel death, but soon people figure out that it is a huge sham. In addition, at the end of the whole fiasco her one true desire John Proctor is killed, making the whole lie a waste of human life. In conclusion, both movies Easy A and “The Crucible” have one theme in common and that is, that no matter how big or how small a lie is, it can always have a negative outcome. However, the reasoning behind a lie can also justify its

Rebuttal Stan Your Ground Law

525 words - 3 pages Stand your Ground Law The Stand Your Ground Law is a type of self-defense law that gives individuals the right to use deadly force to defend themselves without any requirement to evade or retreat from a dangerous situation. It is the law in certain jurisdiction within the United Sates. This may lie within either statutory law or common law. Under these laws a person can justify using deadly force in certain situations and the stand your