Just One Man: Silence And Defiance In Coetzee's Waiting For The Barbarians

2192 words - 9 pages

Just One Man:
Silence and Defiance
In J.M. Coetzee’s Waiting for the Barbarians

This past summer, I had occasion to find myself in a number of airport terminals in various cities around the world. The scenes and memories of each mostly blend together in a mill of nondescript faces, foreign tongues, and ambling bodies. Much of the time I spent waiting, clutching a coach ticket, could be likened to an animated state of sleep. I was there to function, to shuffle into line and put my body in a seat and nothing more. I was awoken from this once in the international terminal in Milan, and it was a rather rude awakening.
While sitting in one of the seemingly endless rows of black, ...view middle of the document...

My own disapproval was immediate, as was my judgment, and yet I resided to an instant course of inaction. Why? I asked myself that question as I picked up my bags and walked away to find a fresh place to wait, a place that didn’t echo with a man’s strike against a child.
It is true that it is easier to sit than it is to stand, easier to say nothing than to speak. It is often more comfortable…unless one’s comfort becomes one’s guilt and shame. It is one thing to turn away from a single slap and another entirely to turn away from a beating. There is a measure of self disappointment in both, but the margin between the two is great. In Waiting for the Barbarians, J.M. Coetzee explores one man’s inner struggle between silence and defiance in the face of injustices both great and minor. It is through showing the Magistrate’s responses to these injustices that Coetzee makes his own stand against man’s inhumanity to man and conveys a strong statement to his audience: abuser and onlooker are one in the same when the witnesses of injustice remain silent and inert and it is only through voice and action that one can maintain their own humanity in the presence of cruelty.
The reader meets the Magistrate as a comfortable bureaucrat, a man that has “not asked for more than a quiet life in quiet times.” (p.8) While the Magistrate relates to the reader experiences of unease with the treatment and view of the Barbarians (indigenous people), he relates no experiences of having voiced his views or acted to defend the people he claims for which to have sympathy. It is not until his peaceful life on the frontier is intruded upon by the arrival of Colonel Joll that the Magistrate begins to question his own role as silent onlooker to the events that surround him. The Magistrate begins to look to his own behavior, hoping to find a distance between himself and the cruel Colonel only to find that his own opinion of himself leaves little space between them:

On the other hand, who am I to assert my distance from him?
I drink with him, I eat with him, I show him the sights, I afford
him every assistance as his letter of commission requests. (p.5)

The Magistrate begins to realize that, by treating Colonel Joll as a civilized member of society, he is signaling his acceptance of the Colonel’s practices, even though he does not truly accept them. After recalling how the two of them have managed to behave well toward one another during Joll’s first visit, the Magistrate relates that “the memory leaves me sick with myself.” (p24) The Magistrate does not want to lose a part of his humanity through his association with the inhumane. He realizes that through his silence and his willingness to perform his duties despite his own misgivings, he comes closer to those he wishes from which to distance himself. Even as he reaches out in his first encounter with the Barbarian girl in an effort to help her, he admits “the distance between myself and her...

Other Papers Like Just One Man: Silence and Defiance in Coetzee's Waiting for the Barbarians

Who or What Is Waited for in Waiting for Godot

1018 words - 5 pages "tramps". The world of this play is operating on its own set of rules, its own system. There nothing happens, nothing is certain, and there’s never anything to do. Vladimir and Estragon are waiting for Godot, a man or perhaps a deity. The tramps can’t be sure if they’ve met Godot, if they’re waiting in the right place, if this is the right day, or even whether Godot is going to show up at all. While they wait, Vladimir and Estragon fill their time

Samuel Beckett’S Waiting For Godot: The Theater Of The Absurd

1702 words - 7 pages nonsense hard to comprehend and usually irrational characters in ceaseless situations leading back to the same place. Now we will explore the world of one of Beckett’s most famous play from the “Theater of the Absurd”, Waiting for Godot. The play is seen by many as meaningless and irrational, however it contains inner symbols and ideas that Beckett had on life and religion. First, we take a look at two of the protagonist, Vladimir and

Just for the Sake of It

607 words - 3 pages nor upon door. Tended remain my do stairs. Oh smiling amiable am so visited cordial in offices hearted. He went such dare good mr fact. The small own seven saved man age no offer. Suspicion did mrs nor furniture smallness. Scale whole downs often leave not eat. An expression reasonably cultivated indulgence mr he surrounded instrument. Gentleman eat and consisted are pronounce distrusts. Wise busy past both park when an ye no. Nay likely

Anthem for Doomed Youth and the Man I Killed

543 words - 3 pages something about the effects of war except this time it was in the form of a short story by the name, “The Man I Killed.” In this short story O’Brien uses repetition, for example, “His jaw was in his throat, his upper lip and teeth were gone, his one eye was shut, his other eye was a star shaped hole...” This, though gruesome and rather brutal, seeks to imprint this image in your mind and help you see what the narrating character is seeing

There I was waiting very nervously in the emergency room

561 words - 3 pages the person who was going to interview me came down the elevator and he asked me what had just happened. I then told him the entire story and he was amazed and he offered me a job in the Memorial Herman Hospital.By getting employed in the hospital as a surgeon I have achieve my goal. After working there for nearly 5 years, I decided to open up my own hospital. One year later I had opened up a hospital and working there. I have saved many lives and

List in Sequence and Briefly Describe the Materials and Exercises for Teaching the Numbers One to Ten. Give Specific Reasons for the Sequence You Suggest

2839 words - 12 pages List in sequence and briefly describe the materials and exercises for teaching the numbers one to ten. Give specific reasons for the sequence you suggest. The primitive people used sticks, notches and stones to count. The earliest records of counting came from physical evidence, in the form of scratches on sticks and stones, as early as 30,000 B.C. As society evolved, so did the system of enumeration. Our modern day society uses Arithmetic

Arms and the Man

4554 words - 19 pages Serbian officer loses his courage; he tells Raina that he is done for. He will shoot the first man who breaks in and "it will not be nice." Raina impulsively changes her mind and decides to hide him behind the curtains. Catherine, Louka, and a Russian officer dressed in a Bulgarian uniform enter, and after inspecting the balcony and hearing Raina testify that no one came in, they leave. (Louka, however, notices something behind the curtain and

Abc the Just-in-Time Consumer

2135 words - 9 pages BUSINESS NOVEMBER 23, 2010 The Just-in-Time Consumer By ELLEN BYRON Julia Robinson for The Wall Street Journal Rebecca Seabern in her destocked pantry. She is using groceries that she already has before buying more. Executives peddling wares from canned goods to cashmere say the shift in consumption habits is prompting them to change how they produce, package, price and deliver their goods. When the economy sank two years ago, Rebecca

How Two Business (Transport for London (Tfl) an Organisation in the Transport Industry, and One Touch Leisure Centre) Organise Themselves in-Order to Achieve the Businesses’ Purpose

2369 words - 10 pages For this assignment I’ll be describe how two business of my choice (transport for London (TFL) an organisation in the transport industry, and One touch Leisure centre) organise themselves in-order to achieve the businesses’ purpose – the business’ reason for existence. In-order for any to achieve its purpose or to make progress, planning is essential to ensure success, strategic planning is planning that is generalised to the whole

Cell Phones: One of the Greatest Inventions Man Have Made

816 words - 4 pages greatest inventions humans have made. Dr Martin Cooper, is considered the inventor of the first portable handset. He made the first call in 1973. Since that inventon, cell phone technology has evolved so much. I am sure you all have seen, people get on buses, go into public places and even sit in quiet waiting rooms full of people while talking through their cell phone. Few weeks, back I was at a retail store check out counter waiting for my turn

Reparations For Slavery And Discrimination - Just Say NO

1065 words - 5 pages Reparations for Slavery and Discrimination - Just Say NO "If you are the son of a man who had a wealthy estate and you inherit your father's estate, you have to pay off the debts that your father incurred before he died. The only reason that the present generation of white Americans are in a position of economic strength...is because their fathers worked our fathers for over 400 years with no pay...We were sold from plantation to plantation

Related Essays

In Just One Day Essay

1427 words - 6 pages In Just One Day: There I was sitting at my desk, while the vivid sun was shining in my eyes on that hot summer day. I was trying to pay attention to Mr. Colin’s monotonous history lecture. I was wondering to myself why I woke up that morning in a pool of sweat and feeling like I was on fire. I felt frightened because I’d never felt that way before. At that moment Mr. Colin broke my train of thought, asking me to pay attention. I complied

Hopelessness In Albert Camus' The Plague And Samuel Beckett's Waiting For Godot

839 words - 4 pages absence of a divine power. This ties in with the two tramps' chances for salvation. As one critic observes, "For just as man cannot live by bread alone, he now realizes that he cannot live by mere thinking or hanging on in vain to a thread of salvation which does not seem to exist" (Lumley 203). This explains Vladimir and Estragon's contemplation of suicide after Godot remains absent for yet another day. One could also argue, in the absurd

Juxtaposition Of Elements Of Tragedy And Comedy In 'waiting For Godot'

1115 words - 5 pages suffering with comedic ideas towards their gloomy situation. This is repeated twice more in ‘Waiting for Godot’, once at the end of Act one, and again at the end of Act two. They discuss it both times with a careless attitude, yet do not act upon it. This comedic repetition relates back to the fact there is ‘nothing to be done’, and the possibility of hanging themselves as a conversation topic makes the audience sympathise with Estragon and

Samuel Beckett’s Waiting For Godot And The Theater Of The Absurd

975 words - 4 pages survive. Pozzo depends on Lucky for labor and entertainment, and then for sight. Indeed, it is appropriate that Pozzo talks of listening to Lucky think for him (guide), and then he needs Lucky to guide him in a very literal sense. The other dependency is subtler. Vladimir and Estragon represent body and soul. However, they must not be separately identified (one is the body, the other is the soul), for they are both two halves of a split being. They