This website uses cookies to ensure you have the best experience. Learn more

Judiciary System In Ecuador Essay

2062 words - 9 pages


1. General Description and explanation of the Ecuadorian Judicial System

1. Corte nacional de justicia (The National Court of Justice)

It’s composed of 21 judges who are designed for a period of 9 years and they cannot be re-elected.


1) To know the appeals in the high court, revision and others resources established by law

2) To develop case law system based on triple reiteration failures.

3) To know the cases initiated against civil servants who enjoy immunity

4) To Introduce law projects related to the system of administration of justice.

2. Cortes provinciales de justicia (Provincial Courts ...view middle of the document...

It exercises national jurisdiction.

JURISDICTION: the right or power to administer justice and to apply law

2. Background

On May 7th 2011, there was a referendum in Ecuador in order to make in a democratic way the Judicial Function’s Reform proposed by Rafael Correa.

In this referendum 53.8% of Ecuadorians supported the reform in order to eliminate the excessive use of the remand, to avoid impunity, to guarantee the appearance to the penal judges and modify the Consejo de la Judicatura. It had more support in the structural change of the Judicial Function in order to have a social, impartial, democratic, transparent and independent justice.

REMAND: Remand (court procedure) when an appellate court sends a case back to the trial court or lower appellate court for further action

IMPUNITY: is the lack of punishment. When there’s impunity, the person that has committed a crime doesn’t receive the punishment that he/she deserves; there are no sanctions for this.

1. Origin and Structure of the International Oversight

1. What is Oversight?

It is the democratic mechanism of representation that allows citizens or different organizations to apply surveillance on a public management in relation to administrative, political and judicial authorities.

Once the reform was supported from Ecuadorians, President Correa invited the Consejo de la Judicatura Transitorio (CJT) and a group of international experts to constitute the International Oversight in order to make the reform in a democratic and transparent way. This group had 6 supervisors:

Baltasar Garzón Real (Spain) - Coordinator

Carolina Escobar Sarti (Guatemala)- Sub-coordinator

MarigenHornkohl Venegas (Chile)

Marco Aurelio García (Brazil)

Victor Hugo Foresi (Argentina)

Porfirio Muñoz Ledo (Mexico)

The International Oversight had a Technical Support team in Ecuador in order to have the required information to supervise the process given by the Consejo de Participación Ciudadana y Control Social, Ministerio de Justicia and Derechos Humanos y Cultos.

2. Method

They had to act in an autonomous, impartial and independent respecting the Ecuadorian Constitution, the Internal Law of Ecuador and the international rules that protect Human Rights. For this, they selected participants to make the interviews with the following criteria:

- Democratic context: actors from different ideological tendencies

- Pluralist Context: women groups, Consejo de Participación Ciudadana y Control Social.

- Academic Context: different universities’ academics

- Institutional Context: Corte Nacional de Justicia, Cortes Provinciales, Defensoría Pública, Fiscalía General del Estado and Consejo de Judicatura Transitorio, Asamblea Nacional.

- International Context: interviews to UN representatives

- Citizen Context: Members of Law School, Federación Nacional de Judiciales, victims of the Comisión de la Verdad.

Other Papers Like Judiciary System in Ecuador

Body of Government in Malaysia Essay

2143 words - 9 pages are elected based on state constituency election and led by Chief Minister. THE JUDICIARY The judiciary basically is a system of court that responsible to interpret the laws including the in FC, applies the law to the facts of each case, provides the function for the resolution of disputes and declares any law and action of federal or state illegal from the law perspective. The judiciary comprises the Federal Court, the Court of Appeal, two High

International Business Essay

1229 words - 5 pages . Question 4 I feel that Wal-Mart should not be doing business in those countries. Those companies cannot be trusted to adhere to rules and regulations established by Wal-Mart. I feel in the long run it will end up costing Wal-Mart more money because of unethical behavior. They would need to spend enormous amounts of money to set up a system where these companies can be monitored and policed. That would mean bringing in their own people instead of

The Role of Government in Policy Making

914 words - 4 pages Assignment: The Role of Government in Policy-Making HSM 240 Public Policy Development in Human Services Axia College Instructor: Amy Randle Student: Marlo Palmer July 23, 2010 Assignment: The Role of Government in Policy-Making Human service organizations are governed by a legislative and judiciary system. The judiciary system decides what policy is legal and illegal, and can require the executive or legislative branch to fix it

Court Systems

1211 words - 5 pages within governments. The dual court system is considered to be the product of the colonial period. The establishment of federal judiciary in 1789 by the constitution of United States refers to the independent court system based on the English model. Both the systems, the English and American, were developed simultaneously. Both systems are now able to practice jurisdiction exclusively in some areas and concurrently in others (Mauer, 1996). The

Country Analysis of Brazil

3878 words - 16 pages enterprise, and political pluralism. The classic tripartite branches of government (executive, legislative, and judicial under the checks and balances system), is formally established by the Constitution. The executive and legislative are organized independently in all three spheres of government, while the judiciary is organized only at the federal and state/Federal District spheres. Together with several smaller parties, four political parties

Caso Lan Expansion

3928 words - 16 pages expanded its operations to Lima; Miami in 1958 and in 1970 to Europe. After a privatization process is consolidated locally in Chile, then position in Latin America and assist its internationalization. In 1985 the government of the time transformed the company into a public limited company to start its privatization. In 1989 the sale of 51% to domestic investors and SAS (Scandinavian Airlines System) is specified, until in 1994 the Chilean

The Absence of a Separation of Powers in Britain Gives the Government Too Much Power

885 words - 4 pages ‘The absence of a separation of powers in Britain gives the government too much power.’ Discuss. 1c) Britain's govt. is too powerful due to its absence of a separation of powers. Britain’s executive, legislative and judiciary are fundamentally connected. Many are part of two or more these powers, such as the PM who is in both the executive and the legislature. Therefore a large majority can do as it pleases. The Govt. controls itself and can

Marketing Plan

536 words - 3 pages . Major reasons for insufficient quality of legislation include: a fragmented governance system with multiple veto points; deficient law drafting capacity in ministries and administrative bodies; inadequate consultation with regulated communities; poor translations of European laws and adoption of laws drafted by international consultants from alien contexts resulting in a system rich in written laws but poor in laws that effectively regulate

To What Extent Are Judges Politically Neutral?

593 words - 3 pages The Judiciary and Civil LibertiesAssignment 3:To what extent are judges politically neutral?In theory there should be no 'political' role for judges, but in practice there is. Ministers and their departments can break the law, MPs can be charged with breaking laws about election expenses and civil servants can be charged with handing over secrets about their political 'bosses'. A member of the judiciary has to decide whether they will be charged

Marbury vs. Madison

544 words - 3 pages October 30, 2011 Marbury vs. Madison It is not difficult to explain how important John Marshall's decision in the case Marbury vs. Madison was and how our entire Supreme Court and country's politics would be different if he had not made the decision. John Marshall's decision to declare that the Supreme Court could not give out writs of mandamus and thus the Judiciary Act of 1789 (that gave out this power) was unconstitutional set the

Judicial Reforms in India

4227 words - 17 pages Need for Judicial Reforms in India 1- Historical Overview: “Judicial Reforms” is a theme, which is so much of talked about but too little has been done. Indian judicial system has a long history right from the pre-British days. In the 18th century a uniform pattern of judiciary emerged and during the British regime High Courts were established in presidency towns. Thereafter, in 1937, the Federal Court was established to hear the appeals

Related Essays

Ecuadors Constitution Essay

1037 words - 5 pages of Ecuador. They have had to adapt their way of life around these two different terrains. The Lowland bases its economic system around agriculture and the highland bases it around pastoral farming. The land is usually owned by the local community, which is called “Ayllu” and is either cultivated jointly or redistributed annually within the community. A distinction is made between two primary types of joint work in the community. In the case of

Democracy In Ecuador Essay

1964 words - 8 pages clarify precisely how the term will be used. The best way to study democracy is to learn the other countries, so in this time I choose one of Latin American countries, Ecuador for well-understanding of the process of democracy.Ecuador is graphically one of the world's most varied countries despite its small size, which at 283520 sq. km is about the size of either New Zealand or Nevada State. Ecuador staddles the equator on the Pacific coast of

Role Of Judiciary Essay

545 words - 3 pages on a lower court. Basically, court hierarchy, binding precedent and accurate law reporting are important tools to the system of precedent. In order to assist with the interpretation of the statutes law, the judiciary have developed a number of approaches: the literal rule, the golden rule, the mischief rule, the purposive approach. All methods slightly differ and the judiciary do not always agree on methods to interpret the law, but once

Judicial Activism In Pakistan Essay

1877 words - 8 pages streamlining the system to cope with the imperative of speedy justice. The Supreme Court judgement has once and for all rejected the concept of summary trials, and dealt a blow to the executive-sponsored moves to create a parallel judicial system. Thankfully, the apex court has held in check the pronounced tendency for arbitrary functioning. It has reaffirmed the independence of judiciary, and thus safeguarded fundamental rights and civil