This website uses cookies to ensure you have the best experience. Learn more

Jones V Star Credit Corp Essay

667 words - 3 pages

Case Brief Ashleigh Diehl
MANGT 525 Commercial Law and Project Procurement
Professor William H Volz

Case Name: Jones v Star Credit Corp
Court Delivering Opinion: Supreme Court, Special Term, Nassau County
Citation No. 59 Misc 2d 189 (1969)

Facts: On August 31st, 1965, the Jones’ (welfare recipients) purchased a home freezer unit from a Shop at Home Services, Inc representative for the price of $900. After taxes and time credit charges, credit life insurance, and credit property insurance were added to the price, the total came to $1234.80. At the time of the trial, the Jones’ had paid $619.88 and still owed $819.81. The retail price of the freezer was also determined at trial to be $300.

The defendant argues that the contract on June 15th, 1966 is a financing contract and not a sales contract. The finance agreement states” Refinance of Freezer A/x #6766 and Food A/c #56788”. This agreement requests for refinancing and signed by the ...view middle of the document...

In addition, the credit charges exceeded the retail value of the freezer by more that $100. The seller knew this and still took advantage of the purchaser knowing their financial limitations.

* The law is fighting back in favor of the poor and illiterate to help protect against those that prey on this population
* Protecting the uneducated and often illiterate is important because they can fall victim to gross inequality of bargaining power.
* A court can find a contract “unconscionable at the time it was made” and may refuse to enforce the contract, excise the objectionable clause or limit the application of the clause. Section 2-302 Uniform Commercial Code
* Credit charges exceeded the retail value of the freezer by $100.
* Many previous court decisions supported decision. American Home Improvement v Maciver, Matter of State of NY v ITM, Frostifresh Corp v Renoso
* Known limited resources of the purchaser at the time of sale by Shop at Home Services rep, entitles weight in the balance.

Comments: I agree with the courts decision that the Jones’ had already paid enough ($600) to compensate and allow for a profit on the $300 freezer. Having seen my grandmother fall victim to a similar scam, I knew that these laws are in place to protect the elderly, poor, and illiterate. All too often, these populations fall victim because they’re presented with payment plans that at first seem affordable but in the end, they end up paying way more than the product is worth. The line of credit that these companies offer are in some ways necessary to allow the purchase of products for those that can’t out-right pay but they most definitely need to be kept in check. I used to see commercials for Western Sky loans that offer money quick but their interest rate was 139-200%. You would end up paying $7,000 for a $1,500 loan. Blew my mind but I know that someone out there would see the commercial and think it’s a good idea because they needed the money and would have it in days.

Other Papers Like Jones V Star Credit Corp

George Lucas Essay

2486 words - 10 pages George Walton Lucas, Jr. (born May 14, 1944) is an American film producer, screenwriter, director, and entrepreneur. He founded Lucasfilm Limited and led the company as chairman and chief executive before selling it to The Walt Disney Company on October 30, 2012. He is best known as the creator of the space opera franchise Star Wars and the archaeologist adventurer character Indiana Jones. Lucas is one of the American film industry's most

Partnership Act Essay

1208 words - 5 pages . | | | |- United Dominions Corp Ltd v Brian Pty Ltd | | | |Partnership Act itself provides for partnership for single undertaking (s.32b) in relation to

Employment Laws Chart

710 words - 3 pages Title VII of the Civil Rights |McDonnell Douglas Corp. v. Green |This law prohibits employment |Applies to employers with 15 or more | |Equal Employment Opportunity Act |Act of 1964 granting enforcement power|(1973) |discrimination which could result in |employees and the local or state | | |to the Equal Employment Opportunity

Earning Management Study-Oil and Gas Industry

3951 words - 16 pages reserve write-offs, Shell paid $151.5 million in U.S. and U.K. fines, dismissed three executives and lost its top-tier credit rating. 2. El Paso Corp Business Overview El Paso Corporation was a provider of natural gas and related energy products and was one of North America's largest natural gas producers until its acquisition by Kinder Morgan in 2012. It was headquartered in Houston, Texas

Employment Laws Chart

1240 words - 5 pages than 40 with the same opportunity as younger individuals. | Employers cannot favor younger employee over an older employee in the workplace. | Americans with Disabilities Act of 1990 | This law is to protect against discrimination based on disability | In National Federation of the Blind v. Target Corporation, Target Corp was sued because the company website failed to design for persons with vision issues. | This law is to protect people with

Employment at Will Doctrine

1203 words - 5 pages a union. This is permissible because she can use her lunch break how she sees fit as long as she is not violating any company rules. Due to the fact Jennifer is trying to organize a union, the U.S. Supreme Court announced in 1935 an employer could not use employment-at-will as a mean of intimidating or coercing its employees with respect to their self organization (NLRB v. Jones & Laughlin Steel Corp., 1937). In other words, employees cannot be

Lassiter Case

1001 words - 5 pages case of Estes v. Jack Eckerd Corp., the store had “reasonable cause” under Ga. Code Ann. § 51-7-61 to detain the plaintiff when the store employee failed to deactivate the special tag on a bottle of shampoo set the device off. The court held that the method and time of detention were reasonable within the statutory limitations, since the episode only lasted five to ten minutes, and the customer did not object for the store employee to search the

Enforceability of Pre-Dispute Clauses in Employment Agreements

2516 words - 11 pages Arbitration to Accommodate Title VII Protections, 47 UCLA L. Rev. 1885, 1893 (2000). [ 22 ]. Sherwyn, supra, at 1564. [ 23 ]. Siderman, supra, at 1892. [ 24 ]. Circuit City, 279 F.3d at 892 (internal quotations omitted) (quoting First Options of Chi., Inc. v. Kaplan, 514 U.S. 938, 944 (1995)). [ 25 ]. See, e.g., Reese v. Commercial Credit Corp., 995 F. Supp. 567 (D.S.C. 1997). [ 26 ]. See, e.g., Bailey v. Fed. Nat. Mortg. Ass’n, 209 F.3d 740

Stock Market News

1116 words - 5 pages improving credit-worthiness of the global consumer. 2) After two-week sprint that saw the Dow Jones industrial average jump 12% and return to positive territory for the year investors got a dose of reality. The Dow jones industrial average lost 2.1% Citi group and Wall Fargo, failed to impress investors with their quarterly earnings and so does some other big corporations. 3) The Dow jones and standard & Poor’s commodity index have said that in

Consumer Credit Scheme and Its Risk Management of Different Commercial Banks in Bangladesh: Implications for Ific Bank Limited Bangladesh

3244 words - 13 pages scheme loan reasonable or not. iv. To find out the consumer perception about the procedural obligations of bank for obtaining loan. v. To find out the contribution level of CCS on overall performance of banks through identify the profit generate from CCS. vi. To identify and suggest scopes of improvement in credit management of IFIC Bank Ltd. vii. To find out the preference of the segment of consumers of the society. viii. To have better

Strategic Case: T-Mobile

2277 words - 10 pages -catherine- zeta-jones SHARMA A. (2006, September 26). T-Mobile Readies New Web Phones -- And Hangs Up on a Star Pitchwoman. Retrieved August 2 from The Wall Street Journal website ( MhwUTXKGBvVjSs_kJoPkTnTXM3Q_20061026.html?mod=tff_main_tff_top T-Mobile USA. (n.d.). Retrieved August 1 from Wikipedia website Danger Hiptop. (n.d

Related Essays

Age Discrimination Lawsuit And Case Study

1048 words - 5 pages years.” CASES RESEARCHED A. Jones v. Dillard’s, Inc. Discrimination claim based on age from Gerda Byrd who alleged that Dillard’s took adverse action against them in their jobs. Alabama based case tried in 2003. In 1998 Gayferd’s Department Store was purchased by Dillard’s, Inc which she was an office and credit manager. There was no position at Dillard’s and she was placed as an assistant area sales manager to keep her at the same pay

Technologymanagement Essay

1313 words - 6 pages created products based on motion pictures such as Star wars and Indiana Jones. They designed product strategy for elderly and captivated the groups in the internet emphasizing Lego manifestations. Furthermore, they designed a line of Lego's for girls, since lion's share of their products had essentially focused on boys. 3) Are the changes implemented by Knudstorp an indication of hyper competition? Defend your position ? As per

James Earl Jones: A Voice In The Crowd

3096 words - 13 pages James Earl Jones:A Voice in the CrowdMarch 19, 1996 People all around the world know the voice of James Earl Jones. From Star Wars fans listening to the voice of Darth Vader to news junkies who hear a voice that dramatically intones "This is CNN" just before all the cable network's station breaks to children who hear the stately voice of the majestic Mufasa, the king of the jungle in Walt Disney Pictures" animated The Lion King - people

Business Ethics Case Essay

779 words - 4 pages Business Ethics Case Tina M. Drinka BUS/415 March 12, 2012 Rob Tischer, J.D., M.A. Business Ethics Case Discussed in this paper is the case of Calder v. Jones, 465 United States 783, 1984. Respondent Shirley Jones filed suit in California Superior Court against the National Enquirer claiming libel. Petitioners are South the reporter who wrote the article for the National Enquirer, and Calder who holds the position