This website uses cookies to ensure you have the best experience. Learn more

Jomini To Clausewitz: Tactics And Strategy

1717 words - 7 pages

From Jomini to Clausewitz: Tactics and Strategy
HIST 202 SEC 6380
Christopher P. McCuiston
22 September 2013

In times of war there always the unknown and even known factors that are unpredictable. Many seasoned war veterans from generals to seargent majors have contemplated the strategies and theories of how to win a war. Throughout history wars have been fought for a multitude of reasons; religion, politics, economic, land disputes, and to defeat tyrannical leaders who have committed atrocities against mankind. War has been waged for other than the aforementioned reasons, but are usually related to political or economic causes. Historically there are many strategist and tacticians ...view middle of the document...

From time in which they lived and fought they both pulled from three main sources: they studied the historical references of Frederick the Great, their experiences in the Napoleonic Wars, and the fact that they read each other’s books [1]. I think that the shared interest in Frederick the Great who was the King of Prussia from 1740 to 1786 encouraged both study and write about the complexities of war.
Major General Carl von Clausewitz (1780-1831) wrote the treatise “On War” which is widely taught in military schools around the globe. Clausewitz established premise that war belongs more to realm of philosophy than to the realm of art or science [2]. With this theory he developed his “concept of “critical analysis” or Kritik, which forms the basis for his approach to the study of war” [3]. To separate the idea of war being more in tune with philosophy you have to understand that war is ever evolving and proves to go beyond the proof of fact. In science we have the scientific theory which one poses a hypotheses and then looks to prove it false or to find the “truth” through the use of the scientific method. The Kritik involves three distinct steps; uncover or discover the facts, trace those effects to the causes, and investigate and evaluate the means [3]. I can draw parallels to the scientific theory and scientific method, but Clausewitz uses his own philosophical method to extract tactics and strategy from historical battles and wars in which he has participated.
Not only did Clausewitz see war being in a separate realm, he focused on calling the defense stronger than that of the offense. He did state “that the defender must usually go over to the offensive to bring war to a satisfactory conclusion” [3], meaning at some point you must abandon your defensive stance in order to win the war. There is always unpredictability in battle and this is where it plays into the hands of the side that takes the defensive posture. Clausewitz also believed in friction, which was the cause of the unpredictability. He felt that there was a definable difference between war that was studied or plotted on paper as opposed to the war that took place on the battlefield [4]. As the enemy advances on the offensive friction is created and I think that he sees the defensive being able to adapt as the offensive surges forward, suffers losses, and attempts to recover and advance. Of the benefits of defense, Clausewitz noted they had the element of “surprise, the benefit of terrain, and concentric attack” [2]. This also leads into the area of friction allowing the defense to surprise the offensive when suffering losses, know the terrain as they wait for the advancing enemy, and fight for that center of attack.
The last aspect that I feel is an important learning tool from Clausewitz that is notably worthy of being utilized in all areas of war is the use of the flank. Using the terrain to conceal troops and attempt to hold an advantage is a usual benefit during a...

Other Papers Like Jomini to Clausewitz: Tactics and Strategy

General Role Of Operations At Mercedes-Benz Buses And Coaches Division, The Contribution To The Overall Organizational Strategy And The Impact Of Operations Upon The Competitive Performance

2849 words - 12 pages CourseworkGeneral role of Operations at Mercedes-Benz Turkey Buses and Coaches Division and its contribution to the overall organizational strategy and the impact of operations upon the competitive performanceTask:Strongly growing customer expectations in the last decade for the municipal buses and coaches sector, with the introduction of several foreign-capital production and assembly facilites in Turkey, increased competition on the market

"Why Is It Important For Marketing Strategists To Think In Terms Of Cultural Issues And Cultural Factors When Formulating A Marketing Strategy?"

2804 words - 12 pages "Why is it important for marketing strategists to think in terms of cultural issues and cultural factors when formulating a marketing strategy?" Introduction Marketing strategy, as summarised by Drummond & Ensor (1999) '...involves achieving a superior competitive position within a defined market...it involves segmentation, targeting and positioning.' However, those three aspects of the strategy to achieve a superior competitive position

Every Organisation Has To Prepare For The Abandonment Of Everything It Does"( Peter Drucker). Discuss This Statement In The Context Of Change Management And Strategy

2993 words - 12 pages INTRODUTIONWhat is change management and strategy & why has it become compulsory to be carried out in organisations?Management , in an organisation, is to make things happen within it in order to make it's goals and objectives achievable. Strategies should be implemented , decisions and actions should be taken from time on time so that the an organisation can remain competitive in today's globalized market & economy. Although , many

Clauswitz vs Jominis

2349 words - 10 pages MARITIME STRATEGIST 2006 Maritime Strategist I. Introduction The world of maritime strategist has been around for decades. It is shaped and colored by wars and conflicts between nations and groups. From these occurrences, numerous strategic experts appeared and gave their contribution to the science of maritime strategy. Within this paper, we are comparing the work of Carl Philip Gottfried Von Clausewitz and A.H Jomini and how

Which Theorist Best Characterizes the Nature of World War I-Jomini or Clausewitz?

1046 words - 5 pages either side-troops, that is, which are not burned out like dead volcanoes. 3 (Clausewitz, On War, ed. Howard and Paret, book IV, chapter 2, 226.) World War I was a defensive war in tactics. Existing technology such as machine guns and artillery provided more firepower to the defense than the office in World War I. Clausewitz explained the strength of the defense in tactical warfare. Clausewitz emphasized that well-prepared, well-manned, and

Sun Tzu Versus Carl Von Clausewitz

2322 words - 10 pages . Tactics is virtually limited to material factors “to occupy some of the enemy’s districts” (Carl Von Clausewitz, On War, p. 171), whereas strategy is unlimited factors such as “to overthrow the enemy”(ibid). The difference is illustrated by the 1991 Gulf War and the 2003 Iraq War. In 1991, the US-led coalition tried to liberate Kuwait from Iraqi occupation, but in 2003 there ensued an unlimited aim to overturn Saddam Hussein’s regime (T.G, Mahnken

Support or refute the argument that the prolonged and bloody stalemate of the World War I

1124 words - 5 pages  Support or refute the argument that the prolonged and bloody stalemate of the World War I stemmed from a slavish adherence to the theories proposed by Clausewitz. By Major Billy Stubbs H100 Outline Argumentative Essay June 22, 2015 General Carl von Clausewitz is one of the best-known translators of Napoleon’s success during war and is considered to be a genius on military theory

Policy and War

4254 words - 18 pages and a “gamble”, both objectively and subjectively. A theory of war must be an analytical investigation that later might prove beneficial to reason and judgment. It must consider the ends and means of warfare, which consist of strategy and tactics. Tactics are the uses to which the army is put to achieve victory. Strategy has to do with the plan for achieving victory. The real activity of war lies in the tactical aspect of battle, since tactics

Strategic Management

650 words - 3 pages new global players • China, Hedge Funds Increasingly scarce resources • Commodity supercycles Volatile capital markets • Return of the State Impatient investors • CEO tenure 4-6 years! Black swans Why should we be concerned about strategy? • Need to find new sources of growth • Acceleration of market growth, uncertainties • New competitive threats Clausewitz Strategy requires • Creativity • Purpose • Leadership

Japan Was Better Prepared For World War II

2651 words - 11 pages Japanese also perfected their tactics in dive-bombing, torpedo attack profiles in shallow water and horizontal bombing. They took great effort to combine all of these methods into one fluid singular system of devastation. (Evans and Peattie, p 345-346) The training, planning and discipline to reach this pinnacle of complex and integrated warfare were monumental at the time. A Plausible, Limited Strategy In the 1920s, Japan turned away from

Miitary Genius

860 words - 4 pages . Ramses II showed good military leadership because demonstrated some of the characteristics of a military genius discussed by Carl Von Clausewitz such as courage, presence of mind, and strength of character when they were ambushed by the Hittites. However he is not a military genius because he lacked the high intelligence to suspect he received false information about the Hittites location in the first place. In the bulletin and poem for the

Related Essays

Absolut Chosen Differentiation And Positioning Strategy And Tactics

609 words - 3 pages ). Absolut sells the image of chic and luxury. And naturally their target market consists of people looking for such image in the things they buy. Absolut chosen differentiation and positioning strategy and tactics Positioning strategy refers to how the organization want its consumers to perceive their product. The positioning strategy includes the message the company wants to convey to consumers about its product (Ries, Trout, 1986). The

Integrating Human Resource Strategy And Strategic Planning To Achieve Business Excellence

5729 words - 23 pages strategy and strategic planning to achieve business excellence” the thesis statement states that developing a human resource (HR) strategy to support the business plan, requires human resource management (HRM) planning to be recognized as a fundamental part of the business planning process and integrating HR strategy and strategic planning is fundamental to achieving business. Both strategies are seen as imperative in achieving a company’s

Identify The Goal Of The Company And Describe The Strategy That Was Adopted To Achieve It. Explain With Full Reference To Available Information And Data How Successful, Or Otherwise, This Strategy...

1408 words - 6 pages Identify the goal of the company and describe the strategy that was adopted to achieve it. Explain with full reference to available information and data how successful, or otherwise, this strategy turned out to be in practice. Company overview Bunge Company was found in 1818 by a German merchant, Johann Peter Bunge in Amsterdam, Holland. It was to merchandise grains and imports from the Dutch colonies. The company has since grown to become one

A Close Alignment Of Organization Strategy With Human Resource Development (Hrd), As A Way To Improve Individual And Organizational Performance

3072 words - 13 pages A CLOSE ALIGNMENT OF ORGANIZATION STRATEGY WITH HUMAN RESOURCE DEVELOPMENT (HRD), AS A WAY TO IMPROVE INDIVIDUAL AND ORGANIZATIONAL PERFORMANCE There is increased need of human resources development to meet today’s organizations’ needs, which are ever changing due to globalization that has resulted into more competition in the global markets (Garavan, Heraty, & Barnicle, 2002). According to Hyland (2005), human resource