John Stuart Mill: On Liberty The Nature And Limits Of The Power Which Can Be Legitimately Exercised By Society Over The Individual

1553 words - 7 pages

Liberty for John Stuart Mill is defined as "the nature and limits of the power of which can be legitimately exercised by society over the individual". Mill argues that society can only use authority over behaviour that harms others; anything else is an end of human freedom. He links liberty to the ability to progress and to avoid social inactivity. Free discourse is a necessary condition for intellectual and social progress. The only time humans or society as a whole can interfere with individual liberty is for self-protection. Mill also notes that the right of liberty does not apply to children, or to what he calls "backward" societies. Liberty holds only when people are capable of learning ...view middle of the document...

They also wanted them to reflect their interests and will. Although, limiting the ruler's power seemed efficient, it was not necessary, since the ruler was accountable to the people and there was no fear of the people tyrannizing himself.Mill then talks about an actual democratic republic which developed in the United States and was accountable to determine that the people do not rule themselves. Rather, powerful people take advantage of this power and exercise it over others. Always the majority will oppress the minority. This is so called the "Tyranny of the majority". However, Mill argues that the power of public opinion has more effect than any new law being implemented. Thus, there must be protection for the public opinion. People must express their ideas for future change in the system. However, Mill argues that society should have control over only those actions that directly affect it and those actions that harm some of its members.Mill also talks about rejecting social interference with individual thought and activity. He is also arguing here about the "Moral Reprobation". Any group could not then punish an individual and treat him/her as an enemy if his actions only affect the sole subject. They could only punish the individual if his actions affect the public. People can express their disapproval with actions they dislike but not alter its behaviour. Individuals could improve themselves if they cooperate with each other instead of just focusing in the wrong actions done by others.Mill ends up his discussion in the justification of liberty by calling it utilitarian. This means the greatest good for the greatest number of people. His defence of liberty is not based on natural right as Locke argues, but based on what is best for the people and what could help them advance and benefit from human liberty. If humans are capable of achieving total cooperation and full human liberty, this process will guide individuals to a better state of moral development in which people will become more rational.In Mill's view of "The Liberty of Though and Discussion" he argues about the issue of whether individuals should be allowed to limit people's opinions. He says that when limiting anyone's expressions of opinions, one's actions are being illegitimate. Even if only one individual has a particular opinion, society will not be justified by silencing him. He says that silencing anyone is wrong since it robs those who disagree with these quiet opinions. Humanity then gets hurt by these silenced opinions and could not gain any knowledge or debate when not commented to others. People should then come up with their own judgements for the benefit of the nation.Mill then points out some arguments about silencing opinions and tries to address the issue by incurring individuals to express their ideas. The first arguments highlights that moral values in fact exist. Some opinions may or may not be valid but they have to be heard in order to be dismissed. Second,...

Other Papers Like John Stuart Mill: On Liberty The Nature And Limits Of The Power Which Can Be Legitimately Exercised By Society Over The Individual

The Nature And The Power Of The Learner

2123 words - 9 pages circumstances. Believes that problems can be resolved if enough input and attention is given by people who are affected. Sense of Humor - Knows how to take the tension out of tight situations. Uses humor, spontaneously, in a tasteful manner. Builds togetherness in the classroom, through the use of humor. Learning Environment Conducive to Learning Learning environments are typically constructivist in nature, engaging learners in "sense

Explain in Detail How Teaching and Learning Plans Can Be Adapted to Meet the Individual Needs of Learners

663 words - 3 pages learner stay engaged, was the session of the correct length of time and what learning objectives have been achieved. What could have been done differently. This can be achieved by individual questioning or Q&A evaluation sheet given to all learners.

Hope and the Limits of Research

680 words - 3 pages The case "Hope and Limits of Research" portraits a very common scenario in current fast-evolving medical field and a possible ethical dilemma : an almost foreseeable future for the end-stage tumor patients and the hope (may actually be an hype) for cutting edge research. Both Susanne and Margaret are end-stage breast cancer patients. Dr.Tetler, their oncologist, treated Susanne and Margaret with current established medical procedures but no

The Influence Of Advertising On Society And The Power Of Effective Commercial

2367 words - 10 pages it makes us aware that there are claimed differences between brands. Much of the advertisement creates only marginal differences, but small differences can build into larger differences. At the same time, consumers have opportunities to evaluate the product or services promoted by a company and make a decision based on which of the companies presents its product better. Thus, it comes down to focusing on image in advertisement which seems like

The Generation Gap Is Which Can Be Bridged

610 words - 3 pages it can be bridged; however, it’s still a question mark. 2. Body * For: + Para 2: Some people argue that it can be bridged by building positive relationships between children and elders, especially in a family. + Para 3: Spending much time accessing to traditional and modern things in life helps two different generations scratch out these distances. * Against: + Para 4: Many others do not consider that the case as generation gap is

Restoration of the Stuart Monarchy

1490 words - 6 pages decision on mercy (Durant 245). There were eighty-four men involved in the murder and dethroning of Charles I, only thirteen were sentenced to death by Charles II (Durant 245). On January 30, 1661, in a morbid celebration of the anniversary of Charles I's murder, the body of Oliver Cromwell was exhumed and hung, in the manner of an execution (Durant 245). He was then beheaded, thereafter; his head was displayed for the duration of Charles

Critically Explore the Way in Which Violence Can Be a Source of Popular Entertainment

637 words - 3 pages Critically Explore the Way in Which Violence Can Be A Source of Popular Entertainment. The presumption of Violence is in are faces more than every before. Whether it is something that appears on television, something you have read or something that has affected you directly or someone you know. The latest type of violence that is notes by parents, police and the community is mobile violence, know as happy slapping, another type of violence

The Limits of Bureaucratic Efficiency

1228 words - 5 pages gone wrong” (Wilson 1989, p. 175). Perhaps the ubiquitous signal that focuses attention on a case is a consumer complaint, which is used because consumers have legitimate information on the correct allocation of goods, and raising flags helps superiors to intervene. This is the stuff of bureaucracies, where the best that managers can hope to do is to “step in when complaints are heard or crises erupt” (Wilson 1989, p. 175). Complaints are

The Statue of Liberty

1632 words - 7 pages United States, where, upon entering New York harbor by ship, he knew immediately that the Statue of Liberty must be located on Bedloe’s Island. It was during Bartholdi’s trips to America that he tried to gain support for the statue financially and ideologically. As mentioned, the jobs for the statue were split, with the American people working on the pedestal and the French people working on the actual statue and assembly itself. When Bartholdi

The Statue of Liberty

2234 words - 9 pages between the French and American people in 1865. On October 28, 1886, President Grover Cleveland allowed the statue to be seen by thousands of people. The observers would gather around the torch of the statue in the 1880s for a breathtaking sight of the harbor. The statue was two hundred and fifty-one feet above water and fifty feet taller than the "Colossus of Rhodes" which was two hundred and one inches tall. The Statue of Liberty was a "landmark of

The Damaging Influence of Advertising on Children Can Be Reduced

1553 words - 7 pages the market or through cooperatives (Story,, 2006). Fourthly, kids are given health education. They are taught which products have damaging effect on organism and which can help to be healthy. By explaining the significance of both nutrition and physical activity education can help children to accept healthful lifestyle (Story,, 2006). Furthermore, with health educational programs, schools promote nutritional products, which can

Related Essays

Stuart Mill And John Locke Conception Of Freedom

2373 words - 10 pages sense, but “civil or social Liberty: the nature and limits of the power, which can legitimately exercised by society over the indivdual.” He defends the argument that society can interfere with the liberty of individuals only to prevents harm to others. Eventhough Mill believes that freedom can be limited by the society, he also believes that this option should be considered carefully because it can be ended to the Tyranny of Majority: Like

The Nature Of Justice In Society And The Individual According To Plato

2358 words - 10 pages Plato’s account of the nature of justice for the individual, how does Plato build his account, why does Plato take it that the claim made by Thracymachus is altogether mistaken – if indeed he does? Plato finds that justice is the harmonious balance of the three elements of the soul. He explains the elements as the desire that is that which drives or motivates you, the appetites that are that which causes you to be spirited or to

Examine The Extent To Which Religion Can Still Be Said To Be Functional For Individuals And Society

1300 words - 6 pages Examine the extent to which religion can still be said to be functional for individuals and for society (18 marks) Functionalists define religion as promoting social solidarity and integration. This can be described using the biological analogy- each segment of society performs a function, this maintains an equilibrium, without which society would disintegrate. Functionalists see religion as contributing positively to society, as it performs

What Are The Arguments For And Against, Greater Control Being Exercised Over Business By Government?

793 words - 4 pages What are the arguments for and against, greater control being exercised over business by government? How do these arguments differ between the countries of the group members?We would like to start the answer by an example of USA when they were heavily involved in the industrialization and expansion. People of all different occupations were involved in some part of the industrial revolution. However there was a debate over the government