Ivf Treatment Is It Right?

1716 words - 7 pages

Bioethics Essay:
The Relevance of An Embryo's Status as Concerns IVF and Genetic Testing
Modern reproductive strategies such as in-vitro fertilization and prenatal genetic testing are
intimately connected with how policies are generated, from state to state, due to the perception of
the embryo's 'moral status'. Interestingly, although most policies take into account how embryos
are perceived and treated, and how parents of the embryos fit into the process, as some feminist
bioethicists have opined, less emphasis seems to be placed on the overall status of women, which
such strategies annually chisel in our society.
Some right-winged scientists, theologians, and politicians might ...view middle of the document...

latter manmade manipulation, involving IVF, would violate the moral rights of the embryo to a
unique existence. In the collective vision of such opponents, only 'natural' twinnings, decided by
'God' can be deemed acceptable, worthy, and morally just. Never mind the fact that 'God'
allowed medicine to achieve the knowledge and accomplishments it already has in now
preventing what was once merely treatable disease forms.
Stemming from the opposite pole of the ethical spectrum are the leftists, who assume the stance
that embryos are entities like any other human tissue. Therefore, manipulations on such 'tissues'
should remain equivocal to those of other parts of the human body, as long as consent over
ownership issues are adequately appeased. Such a viewpoint disregards the fact that within such
a 'tissue' lays the genetic potential of a new, unique human life form. Such leftist thinkers would
also agree to further manipulations of prenatal genetic testing, even for the purposes of research,
alone. Within the contexts of such a 'same as any other human tissue' view, it would be
considered acceptable to embrace methods of genetic engineering. By doing the latter, one could
bring the growing tissue to a more 'superior' level of physical existence. Also, it would be okay
to readily eradicate/terminate the pregnancy, due to perceived genetic deficits, that would render
the growing tissue 'inferior' and compromised at a later date.
I tend to agree with the overwhelmingly popular position that an embryo, while not an actual
'person', should nonetheless be accorded a special moral status, which respects its rights to
potentially become a person. Ethical and legal committees derived from both capitalistic and
socialistic countries (e.g. USA, Canada, Great Britain) have agreed upon the latter stance.
However, while such a vantage may have its advantages, disagreements between the realms of
reproductive strategies and state practices still ensue. For instance, in order to increase the
success rates of the incredibly expensive IVF methods for infertile couples, multiple eggs must
be generated during each cycle. After fertilization, multiple embryos that have achieved
blastocyst statuses are inserted into either the fallopian tubes or onto the uterine linings of their
mothers/hosts. The reasoning behind this is that it will increase the chances of a successful
implantation of a singular embryo. The problem with this technique is that if too many embryos
are successfully implanted, the health of the mother (not biologically constructed to bear a litter)
will be compromised. IVF clinics in Canada apparently have chosen to ignore the status of the
mother in lieu of that of the embryo. In other words, every in-vitro fertilized embryo that has
successfully achieved the blastocyst stage is implanted into its mother/host. Within this country,
the three states of Minnesota, Louisiana, and Illinois have banned the intentional...

Other Papers Like Ivf Treatment - Is It Right?

How Far Do You Accept The Belief That If Crime Is Rising, It Is Because People Today Lack A Clear Understanding Of Right And Wrong?

579 words - 3 pages benign - like dropping litter, when backed up by police action, can also increase these figures.However, those who belief that crime is rising as a result of people today lacking a clear understanding of right and wrong, do state some clear points that are worth taking into account. Indeed, upon consideration with more and more dysfunctional and broken down families becoming commonplace, it could be considered a harder task for today's parents to

Financial Crisis Problem: IS The Government Bailout Right? It Is An Essay About The Financial Crisis In 2008, In My Economy Class

1630 words - 7 pages Somebody says that the "American Dream" is built on the bases of Credit. It might be right, however, now a new problem has occurred. A credit crunch is flipping the whole U.S, and has become a credit crisis.Credit crisis has happened many times during human history. Credit crisis usually comes with cyclical purging of excesses. When the whole industry is booming, prices are growing fast and profits are huge. Thus the investments are growing

Ivf Critical Analysis

2592 words - 11 pages womb, but even they can not make it stay put. It is still the miracle of a loving God that allows even this, man made process, to work. Again, I do believe that as Christians we need to be lead by God into the process. IVF isn’t for everyone; God has a purposeful plan for each Christian couple and what is right for one, may not be for another. As Christians, it is our responsibility to seek God’s guidance and listen to his direction in our

The Right to a Child Is an Absolute Right. Discuss

554 words - 3 pages . However, it could be argued that the doctrine of double effect could counter the argument seeing the destruction of embryos as an unintended consequence of IVF. Overall, however, Natural Law would reject any means of a right to a child disagreeing with the idea that it is an absolute right. However, followers of utilitarianism would weigh up the pleasures and pain of those involved and decide based on the situation and the consequences. They

Investigation Of Reproduction And Development In Animals

862 words - 4 pages first used for infertility in humans in 1977,in England. To date, thousands of babies have been delivered as a result of IVF treatment. The IVF procedure has become simpler, safer and more successful over the years.What types of infertility can be helped by IVF?IVF is a good option for a couple in several instances. The most common reasons for this procedure is blocked or damaged fallopian tubes. Through IVF, the damaged fallopian tubes are

My Sister's Keeper

1477 words - 6 pages tension in the home and most likely will not ever dissipate. In the move My Sisters Keeper for example, Sarah – the mother in the film – is very much focused on the health of Kate – her cancer daughter – that it almost appears that she is neglecting her other two kids one of which she has created to help Kate which has created a separation within the household. So overall, another negative towards IVF is that it has the potential to create very

Medical Antropology

1089 words - 5 pages of IVF treatments in Egypt and how Egyptian society, culture and religion have influenced the way women discuss their infertility and their use of IVF treatments. The use of IVF treatment has remained quiet because of the prejudice and judgment those who use it feel. In Egyptian culture, having children is an important status symbol in a women’s life and for her husband and family. Women face the pressure to have children in order to gain the

Explain the Issues to the Claim to the Right of a Child. 25 Marks

1087 words - 5 pages these rights. Situation ethicists believe that the human right to a child is afforded by doing “the most loving thing”. This means that according to the situation anybody, potentially, has the right to fertility treatment. Whether an embryo is seen as a person or not, abortion depends on whether is is the loving thing to do. If it is, then it is always acceptable. However, it would be very difficult to predict the consequences. Utilitarians

Nervous System

706 words - 3 pages of stimuli. The occipital lobe has to do with visual processing. The temporal lobe is associated with perception and recognition of auditory stimuli, memory, and speech.A deep furrow divides the cerebrum into two halves, known as the left and right hemispheres. The two hemispheres look mostly symmetrical yet it has been shown that each side functions slightly different than the other. Sometimes the right hemisphere is associated with creativity

The Australian Legal System

816 words - 4 pages as IVF, have been very conflicting ones. *IVF helps infertile couples achieve their dream of having a child by an ovum fertilised by sperm in a laboratory. The allowance of IVF has been effective in achieving justice for infertile couples by allowing them to start a “family”. On the contrary, the case of Leesa Meldrum in the High Court resulted in the allowance of a single mother to have IVF treatment, which creates justice even more for those

Surrogacy: a Chance to Life or a Conspiracy

2829 words - 12 pages Surrogacy is when another woman carries and gives birth to a child for another individual. Though it can be an emotionally intense and legally complex arrangement, it is growing in popularity among parents as a way of having children.  Having another woman bear a child for a couple to raise, usually with the male half of the couple as the genetic father, is referred to in antiquity. Babylonian law and custom allowed this practice and infertile

Related Essays

Debate Topic – Couples Wishing To Undergo Ivf Treatment Should Be Awarded The Legal Right To Choose The Sex Of Their Child

5118 words - 21 pages ETHICS FOR HOLISTIC PRACTICE Debate topic – Couples wishing to undergo IVF treatment should be awarded the legal right to choose the sex of their child. Good afternoon everyone our debate topic today is whether or not couples wishing to undergo IVF treatment should be awarded the legal right to choose the sex of their child. I’m Melinda and along with Angelique and Melissa we will be presenting the affirmative argument and the negative

Is It A Right? Essay

1286 words - 6 pages . This is the perfect example of interference that cannot be justified. The Soviet Union attempted to control Yugoslavia and when it couldn’t, they withdrew economic aid as well as rejected the plans for the Balkan federation of states. Lesser states, like Yugoslavia, should not have to follow a greater nation’s rules when the greater nation is only looking out for it’s own self-interests. When greater nations attempt to exert influence on

Abortion Is It Right Or Wrong

672 words - 3 pages alcohol, drivers cannot pay attention to the road. The other factor is the sleepless drivers. They are like the others; cannot pay attention to the road and they even fall asleep while they are driving. It can be frustrating and even down right irritating to notice that the other driver who caused a crashes while talking on a cell phone. Unfortunately, all too many people think that they can handle the task of driving and talking to their boss

Is Dance Music A Subculture Or Has It Now Become A Culture In Its Own Right?

1191 words - 5 pages Is Dance Music a Subculture or Has it Now Become a Culture in its Own Right? Classically subcultures define themselves as 'other' and 'subordinate' to 'the dominant' culture. Many cultural theorists such as Stuart Hall and Dick Hebdige have been chiefly concerned with the ways in which subcultures subvert and pose a resistance to the 'established order' through their expressive dress codes and rituals. Dance music