This website uses cookies to ensure you have the best experience. Learn more

It As A Competitive Advantage Essay

1855 words - 8 pages

IT as a Competitive Advantage
Marcus Liubakka
The College of Saint Scholastica

In 2003, Nicholas Carr, published a controversial article titled “IT Doesn’t Matter”. The premise of his article defines IT as a digital data infrastructure, and compares its build-out to previous impactful infrastructure build-outs like electricity and the railroad. Carr claims that IT has become a commodity, and businesses can no longer use their IT as a competitive advantage. This paper will further analyze Carr’s article, and make recommendations as to how businesses can leverage IT as a competitive advantage for the future.
To fully understand how a business can leverage IT ...view middle of the document...

“IT is, first of all, a transport mechanism-it carries digital information just as railroads carry goods and power grids carry electricity” (Carr, 2003, p. 44).
During the turn of the 20th century, when electricity was new and scarce, manufacturing businesses gained an efficiency competitive advantage over its competition by building its plant close to a power plant (Carr, 2003). They could do-away with their cumbersome water wheel power generators with complex pulley systems, and convert their equipment to use electric motors, which were far more efficient (Carr, 2003). Electricity, in its early stages was scarce, and technology was proprietary; similar to IT in the 1960s. Pearlson and Saunders (2013) categorize the history of IT usage in organizations in eras. Era I took place in the 1960s, as the primary role of IT was to increase efficiency by automating existing paper-based processes (Pearlson & Saunders, 2013).
At the end of the build-out, electricity became widely available, rendering proprietary systems obsolete due to technical regulations, and standardization of best practices (Carr, 2003). The end of the build-out is similar to Era V, which occurred during the 2000s (Pearlson & Saunders, 2013). The primary role of IT was to create value through collaborative partnerships, and the internet was the dominant, ubiquitous technology (Pearlson & Saunders, 2013).
Carr’s argument that IT cannot be used as a sustained competitive advantage is logical, as it has followed similar life cycles as electricity, railroad, and telegraph technologies. A decade after Carr’s article was published, there are still companies contradicting Carr’s theory by using IT as a sustained competitive advantage. Walmart, for instance, “effectively blocked competition with their inventory control system, which helped the drive down expenses and ultimately offer low costs to customers” (Pearlson & Saunders, 2013, p. 51). A company looking to penetrate Walmart’s marketshare, would need to spend millions of dollars to replicate an inventory control system to rival Walmart.
Google, as another example, has an extremely valuable search algorithm which is extremely difficult for a competitor to duplicate (Pearlson & Saunders, 2013). The complexity of the algorithm in itself is a barrier, but even if a competitor was able to equally duplicate Google’s algorithm, the probability of replacing the search giant is next to impossible. Google has leveraged IT not only to create one of the most valuable algorithms in modern society, but IT played a large part in entrenching itself with its users. The ease of use, has created a habit with its users that is very hard to break.
The super-giants that are Google and Walmart, are examples of extreme success, and could be considered exceptions to the rule. However, this proves that using IT to create a competitive advantage is possible.
Strategies for establishing sustained competitive advantage
To fully understand...

Other Papers Like It As A Competitive Advantage

New Belgium Brewing (a): Social Responsibility as a Competitive Advantage Brief

1165 words - 5 pages Marketing Strategic Name: Ching Jui Liao Due date: 10/16/2012 New Belgium Brewing (A): Social Responsibility as a Competitive advantage Brief Strengths 1. Strong brand name 2. Definite company core values and beliefs 3. NBB offers a variety of permanent and seasonal ales and pilsners. 4. Strong and stable sales force. 5. Employees enjoy their job because the company treats them

Operation Strategies to Achieve a Competitive Advantage. Essay

1062 words - 5 pages its operation production at lower costs it will benefit as a result of economies of scale. Thus, leading to the emergence of sustaining a competitive advantage. However economies of scale is one strategy that can only be embraced by multinational businesses that have the capability to produce in large volume and have the potential in being financially stable in order to approach the global market. Inventory Management Inventory management is a

Corporate Social Responsibilities Activities: a Competitive Advantage in the Perception of Consumers of Tacloban City

1020 words - 5 pages requirements, government concerns, stakeholder management and satisfaction, and addressing of community concerns. Although a few researchers have tried to link CSR with competitive advantage from a strategic management perspective, only minimal of those have studied CSR activities as a source of competitive advantage and have explained its impact in yielding above average returns based on a more advantageous consumer behavior resulting from the

Quantifying The Contributions Of Human Resources Management To Overall Organizational Effectiveness. (How Human Resources Can Contribute In Creating A Competitive Advantage For The Company.)

1051 words - 5 pages Human Resource Management (HRM) is a vital part of creating and maintaining an effective organization that is able to meet its goals and gain a competitive advantage over the competition.. HRM includes myriad activities ranging from recruitment to training and even the development of compensation systems. HRM has evolved significantly since the early 1900s. The need to deal with labor unions, as well as global competition, technological advances

“Marketing Is the Management Process That Seeks to Maximise Returns to Shareholders by Developing Relationships with Valued Customers and Creating a Competitive Advantage.” Doyle, P., (2000),...

2242 words - 9 pages existing customers and attracting new ones. Business is about satisfying customers and thus increasing their activity with your business. As in most business sectors there is tough competition meaning that businesses can only gain competitive advantage when they are effective in marketing & good customer service, which includes creating good rapport via public relations. However, this is not as easy as it sounds and much work has to be done in order

Competitive Advantage

593 words - 3 pages competitive advantage is sustainable over the sequence of the 2011 NBA playoffs. Components of Competitive Advantage Sustainable competitive advantage should advance over time to uphold its advantage (Strategy Fundamental: Determining Sustainable Competitive Advantage, 2010). Some characteristics of a sustainable competitive advantage are it cannot be duplicated by competitors, competitive advantage continually adds values and it can be

Competitive Advantage

3479 words - 14 pages , finding and nurturing a competitive advantage can mean increased profit and a venture that is sustainable and successful over the long term. This fact sheet looks at what defines competitive advantage and discusses strategies to consider when building a competitive advantage, as well as ways to assess the competitive advantage of a venture. The Essence of Competitive Advantage To begin, it may be helpful to take a more in-depth look at what it

Competitive Advantage

1657 words - 7 pages Competitive Advantage: Question 1/2: A competitive advantage is a position that a firm occupies in its competitive landscape. Cost advantage Cost advantage A firm possesses a sustainable competitive advantage when it has value-creating processes and positions that cannot be duplicated or imitated by others, that lead to the production of above normal rents, in that it provides a long-term advantage that is not easily replicated. Sources of

Competitive Advantage - 1250 words

1250 words - 5 pages lessor provides the assets as well as the supporting services and maintenance. Lessee has the right to revoke the lease and in return the assets before expiry date of the agreement. 2. Financial Lease It is a non-cancellable agreement; where the lessee has to make periodic payment of rental over a specified period to lessor, and the lessee has to maintain the asset leased in good condition and to take out adequate insurance coverage

Vizio's Competitive Advantage

1195 words - 5 pages challenge LCD TV sales. In addition, LCD TV product quality may further increase driven by technological improvement. If OEM players cannot catch up with manufacturing technology, companies relying on OEMs may have a hard time competing with large TV companies. Lastly, the emergence of laptops and tablets may impact customers’ willing to buy LCD TVs. 2. Analyze Vizio’s strategy and assess if it has a competitive advantage. Vizio understands that

Lego's Competitive Advantage

949 words - 4 pages retailer. Lego’s competitive advantage is a combination of four factors: its brand equity, merchandise assortment, pricing, and visual merchandising. As a toymaker that has prominent brand equity, opening themed brand retail stores gives its consumers an engaging in-store experience with its unique product. TWINCITIESDAILYPHOTO·3 YEARS AGO Since Lego has been successful in the market for a long time, its brand equity allows the retail

Related Essays

Q&A: Competitive Advantage Essay

923 words - 4 pages Europe. The threat of new entrants is likely to be lower for book publishing than textiles. Bargaining power of suppliers and buyers: it is difficult to distinguish between two industries on these bases. Suppliers of basic textile commodities (such as wool and cotton) are unlikely to have a great deal of power; authors (unless already proven winners) certainly do not. In both industries large retail outlets dominate sales to consumers. However

Amazon It For Competitive Advantage

1660 words - 7 pages of service to its customers which is called "Market Place". The site proposes to the private persons and to the professionals to resell their own articles on the website. This model was launched a little so as to counteract Ebay. Nicholas Carr explains in his theory that IT can’t be used as a competitive advantage and doesn’t really matter anymore because nowadays barely everyone has access to softwares and IT in general. Even if a part

Cognitive Capacity As Competitive Advantage: Essay

399 words - 2 pages , possession of these scarce socio-cognitive capabilities is valuable because it allows members of the firm, and in particular senior managers, to make better quality decisions about the deployment of extant resources. This study focuses on cognitive capacity as one facet of cognition. Cognitive capacity is defined as the capacity to “...register, store, use and make sense of data” [18]. It is possible to identify a number of propositions in the

Communication And A Competitive Advantage Essay

592 words - 3 pages will improve quality, efficiency, and productivity. Companies and managers will benefit greatly from the open lines of communication and be closer to gaining, and sustaining a competitive advantage. As a member of today’s workforce, for a fortune five hundred company, I believe communication between management and non-management employees is one of the most important factors in employee satisfaction. If a company can keep their employees well