Interpreting The Un Interpretable Essay

697 words - 3 pages

Danny Ambalu 06/04/12
Interpreting the Un-Interpretable
In Poulet’s A Phenomenology of Reading, he asserts that in a sense the reader, by reading and thinking about a text, creates the text. When the reader reads a text, his consciousness unites with the consciousness of the author, and their ideas combine and transform the text from a “dead object”, or objective words on a page, into a living, dynamic work. In other words, Poulet gives the reader license to provide his own reasonable interpretation of a text, because the reader is the author’s partner in creating the text. This is especially true with regards to John Ashbery’s “Farm Implements and Rutabagas in a Landscape”, where a straightforward explanation of the poem is almost impossible. Therefore, in accordance with Poulet’s literary theory, I would like to unite my consciousness with Ashbery’s and provide my own interpretation of the poem: the poem is not meant to be understood.
Upon reading the ...view middle of the document...

Perhaps the poem is sending the reader the following message: certain things are not meant to be understood. (This is reminiscent of Oedipus Rex, where Oedipus searches for Total Knowledge against the warnings of the other characters, resulting in devastating consequences.) The poem hints at this through its consistent use of seemingly random, non-sequitor dialogue. In the first stanza, the poem begins by describing a coded message, but jumps to the Sea Hag reclining on a couch without mentioning who received the message or what it has to do with the Sea Hag sitting on a couch. In the following stanza, Wimpy says “no pleasant/Inspiration plunge us now to the stars (lines 11-12)”, which is his way of asking if this is all there is to life, but then, seemingly out of the blue, he says “For this is my country (ibid.)”. The note on Swee’pea’s bib also lacks a clear connection to the rest of the poem.
There are other hints to the poem’s conscious lack of intelligibility as well. The poem begins with a coded message, which can be interpreted to refer to the entire poem, not just the phrase in quotes. It also says that the phrase is the first of several coded messages without ever mentioning what the other ones are, leaving the reader in the dark and implying once more that the entire poem is an undecoded, or rather undecodable, message. The tangram mentioned in the first stanza may be symbolic of the poem as a whole being a puzzle, and the characters’ constant scratching, as if they were having difficulty understanding something, may be the poem’s way of hinting at the futility of attempting to decipher it. Even the Sea Hag’s use of Spanish in the first stanza is another throwaway hint saying “Don’t try to understand. It’s hopeless.”
To recap, my interpretation of Ashbery’s poem is the futility of interpretation. The moral of the poem is that some things are simply not meant to be understood. Whether my interpretation is that intended by the author is uncertain. However, even if it is not, it is a valid interpretation according to Poulet, because I am Ashbery’s partner in creating the poem. Accordingly, I have now united my consciousness with that of Ashbery, and I believe Poulet would be proud.

Other Papers Like Interpreting the Un-Interpretable

Pepsico Research Proposal Essay

3894 words - 16 pages interpretable multi dimensional space, for which Multi dimensional scaling is used. Today in different places like schools, restaurants, movie theatres etc, there is a constant battle between Pepsi, Coke and other competitors to place their product in that place. Another research technique that we would use is the conjoint analysis where we would administer this technique to a smaller sample size of 20 to 30 people.   4 EXPECTED RESULTS

Contabilidad Essay

5796 words - 24 pages en un momento dado su situación financiera. [Notas de contabilidad del primer curso, Carlos A. Corzo.] Accounting is the recording, classifying, summarizing, and interpreting of those business activities that can be expressed in monetary terms. [The language of accounting in english, Sandra Costinett.] Contabilidad es la rama de la contaduría que obtiene información financiera sobre las transacciones que celebran las entidades

Feminist Perceptive On The Scarlet Letter

930 words - 4 pages and their role in society despite the negativity. She uses Hester's role in society to formulate a strong argument against The Scarlet Letter. When view and re-analyzing Benstuck's analysis as a whole, once again the reader should automatically infer that this is a feminist approach to literary analysis and criticism. When interpreting the Scarlet Letter from Benstuck's perspective, she had many strengths and logical points than weaknesses in

Define the Distinctions Between Primary, Secondary, and Tertiary Sources in a Secondary Search

779 words - 4 pages 2 Define the distinctions between primary, secondary, and tertiary sources in a secondary search. The best way to distinct between the sources of secondary research is to define each. Primary sources are those that are direct and un-interpreted records of a subject that you are researching. A primary source can be just about anything such as books, artifacts, or even patents. Secondary sources are ones that build on primary sources

Evolution and Theology

898 words - 4 pages universe that could give rise to the range, beauty, complexity, and diversity of creatures the Earth has produced.” (pg. 29) Southgate states that his argument is an un-provable assumption, but is an excellent framework for understanding creation. He contends that non-human suffering confirms the evolution of species and Darwinism. Southgate disputes that suffering, death, and extinction are byproducts of Gods evolutionary process, something that

Values and Study Practices of Nursing Students : an Indicators of Their Performance in the Nurses Licensure Examination

5959 words - 24 pages education at the Bulacan State University- College of Nursing. The Process load contains the performance in the nursing licensure examination of the College of Nursing of Bulacan State University. The Output load contains the desired result which is the improved delivery of nursing education at the College of Nursing of Bulacan State University after gaining and interpreting necessary information, the subsequent thread will be

Should a Knower’S Personal Point of View Be Considered an Asset in the Pursuit of Knowledge, or an Obstacle to Be Overcome?

1476 words - 6 pages every case, our views and beliefs must also play a role in determining and defining the knowledge of the world. In different areas of knowledge such as natural sciences and ethics, we can see how opinions can present many limitations. However, we also see the importance of opinions. Throughout this essay we will be able to see to what extent our points of view affect our acquiring and interpreting of knowledge in our everyday life. Natural

Weick's Analysis

1163 words - 5 pages frequent changes. The best response was to modulate and adapt to those changes. Despite the best efforts to deal with the unknowns, working on this project proved a continued challenge given the politics, scattered resources and un-justifiable demands on completing the deliverables How would you respond differently now? In retrospect, interpreting the actions that we've already taken, I would say that at that time we implemented the best we

Roles of Comparative Law to Legal Interpretation and Application

5252 words - 22 pages , when rightly understood, are in themselves of doubtful meaning, and we are forced to have recourse to like conjectures to find out in what sense he used them. Example: As we know that in common law, the competence in legal interpretation and application is of the court. In England, the judge can change every document to avoid those stupid things. This activity is one of the parts in interpreting law of the judge. The other activity is “Fill

The Continuing Role Of The Outside World In Afghanistan

3223 words - 13 pages the Taliban. The Taliban movement was formed in 1994 by Islamic students who took a radical approach to interpreting Islam. By February 1995, the Taliban successfully captured half of the southern provinces without any resistance and surrounded Kabul suburbs. The Taliban military campaign began after the announcement of the Pakistani government to open a trade route through Afghanistan to Central Asia. It actually created some stability after

Student

1558 words - 7 pages had arrested in the course of its battle over drugs in the last two years. A just released UN report says cannabis (opium) is widely consumed in Uganda, mainly by street and school youth, as well as by policemen, soldiers and night guards. It is estimated that 55% cent of sedatives users, 30% of synthetic narcotic analgesic users, and 20% of opiate users are women. The Permanent Secretary of the Ministry of Internal Affairs, Dr Steven Kagoda

Related Essays

Service Essay

701 words - 3 pages en ganar fácilmente interpretable y datos fiables sobre las actitudes de los huéspedes del hotel ' sobre la percepción la calidad del servicio. Los resultados de este estudio sugieren que la solución de los huéspedes problemas, el servicio realiza sin errores, la actitud de los empleados, ubicación adecuada , y la aparición de las instalaciones son la clave atributos para el éxito de un hotel en la Riviera de Opatija . Por lo tanto, los

Case Studies Essay

1096 words - 5 pages conflicted unconscious emotional experience for the dreamer on his or her own; rather, dreams are fully interpretable and understandable only by the analyst, who puts the repressed meaning of the dream into words for the patient” (Schneider, 2010, p. 533). As a result, Becky will be the sole person talking and working through her owns dreams, rather the therapist interpreting her dreams. Becky will respond well to this therapy she will start

Science Essay

3676 words - 15 pages , amounts to several hundred billion dollars per year. Another interesting item of information: There are more Hispanics in the US than Canadians in Canada! This aspect of reality cannot be ignored, but it is not yet properly dealt with. When we compare the status of translation-interpreting activities in the US to that of Europe, we cannot help but notice that we are far behind them. In Europe, for instance, there have always existed specialized

Simultanious Interpretation Essay

921 words - 4 pages Simultaneous Interpretation Most people think of a UN assembly when they hear the words“simultaneous interpretation”. It’s easy to think so, since such environment is the perfect example of what the world is: a group of people from various cultures and backgrounds, who speak different languages, trying to communicate with many others. Our university offers us an interpretation class and a wide range of interpretation and translation