This website uses cookies to ensure you have the best experience. Learn more

Intellectual Law Project Essay

1825 words - 8 pages

Brief Fact Summary
Samara Brothers is a manufacturer of children's clothes. Wal-Mart sent pictures of Samara's line of children's clothing to a manufacturer, had a line nearly identical to Samara's line produced, and sold the clothing through Wal-Mart stores.
Rule of Law and Holding
"In a [Section 43(a) of the Lanham Act] action for infringement of unregistered trade dress, a product's design is distinctive, and therefore protectible, only upon a showing of secondary meaning." Product packaging trade dress MAY BE inherently distinctive, and thus protectable without a showing of secondary meaning. Plaintiffs claiming rights in product feature trade dress under Sec. 43(a) must ALWAYS ...view middle of the document...

JUSTICE SCALIA delivered the opinion of the Court.

In this case, we decide under what circumstances a product's design is distinctive, and therefore protectible, in an action for infringement of unregistered trade dress under § 43(a) of the Trademark Act of 1946 (Lanham Act).

IWal-Mart Stores, Inc. v. Samara Brothers, Inc.
U.S. Supreme Court
529 U.S. 205 (2000)
Justice Scalia:
Respondent Samara Brothers, Inc., designs and manufactures children’s clothing. Its
primary product is a line of spring/summer one-piece seersucker outfits decorated with
appliques of hearts, flowers, fruits, and the like. [C]hain stores, including JCPenney, sell this
line of clothing under contract with Samara.
…. [In 1995,] Wal-Mart sent Judy-Philippine photographs of a number of garments
from Samara’s line…; Judy-Philippine duly copied, with only minor modifications, 16 of
Samara’s garments, many of which contained copyrighted elements. In 1996, Wal-Mart
briskly sold the so-called knockoffs, generating more than $1.15 million in gross profits.
In June 1996, a buyer for JCPenney called a representative at Samara to complain
that… Wal-Mart [was charging less] than JCPenney was allowed to charge…. The Samara
representative told the buyer that Samara did not supply its clothing to Wal-Mart. Their
Limitations on Rights 4.25
suspicions aroused, however, Samara officials launched an investigation, which disclosed that
Wal-Mart and several other major retailers… were selling the knockoffs….
[Samara sued] for copyright infringement…, and — most relevant for our purposes —
infringement of unregistered trade dress under § 43(a) of the Lanham Act. ….
[Samara prevailed, and certiorari was granted.] ….
The text of § 43(a) provides little guidance as to the circumstances under which
unregistered trade dress may be protected. …. Nothing in § 43(a) explicitly requires a
producer to show that its trade dress is distinctive, but courts have universally imposed that
requirement, since without distinctiveness the trade dress would not “cause confusion… as to
the origin, sponsorship, or approval of [the] goods,” as the section requires. ….
[C]ourts have held that a mark can be distinctive in one of two ways. First, a mark is
inherently distinctive if “[its] intrinsic nature serves to identify a particular source.” In the
context of word marks, courts have applied the now-classic test originally formulated by
Judge Friendly, in which word marks that are “arbitrary” (“Camel” cigarettes), “fanciful”
(“Kodak” film), or “suggestive” (“Tide” laundry detergent) are held to be inherently
distinctive. See Abercrombie & Fitch Co. v. Hunting World, Inc., 537 F.2d 4, 10-11 (C.A.2
1976). Second, a mark has acquired distinctiveness, even if it is not inherently distinctive, if it
has developed secondary meaning, which occurs when, “in the minds of the public, the
primary significance of a...

Other Papers Like Intellectual Law Project

Ethical, Legal, Regulatory Issues in E-Business

1123 words - 5 pages concerns, site policies on conditions of use, liabilities concerns, and adherence to federal and state laws. References Claburn, T. 2001. Smart Business "Intellectual Property: Harder to Protect Than Ever. Turban, Efraim; King, David; Lee, Jae; Viehland, Dennis., 2004. Electronic Commerce: A Managerial Perspective. 2nd ed. Effy.Oz., 2002. Foundation of E-Commence. NewYork: Prentice Hall Laudon, Kenneth C.; Traver, Carol Guercio., 2002. E-commerce: Business, Technology, Society. Pedley, Paul., 2003. Essential Law for Information Professionals. London

Recognizing Contract Risk and Opportunities Essay

1442 words - 6 pages law gives a remedy or the performance of which the law in some way recognizes a duty” (Chpt 9, Para 2). The following Memo will identify the legal issues presented in the Contract Creation and Management Simulation as well as identify what a manager may do to avoid theses risks and minimize liabilities. Business Memo -- Confidential TO: Project Leadership Team Span Systems – Kevin Grant, Harold Smith FROM: Mike

Contract Negotiation

1422 words - 6 pages Contract Negotiation Memorandum Greg White Law/531 April 25, 2011 Pamelya Herndon To: Kevin Grant Project Director CC: Harold Smith Legal Counsel From: Greg White Project manager Subject: Negotiation of contractual considerations with Citizen-Schwarz AG In consideration of the communication from Leon Ther and his request to rescind the current contract I am writing this memorandum. The intent of this memorandum is to identify

Tft2 Task 3 V1.Docx

2324 words - 10 pages global network. The information shared between all three parties shall be accessible only for the duration of the project and then the network should be shut down and moved into storage until the destroy date is reached. The destruction of the data shall take place six years after the final use date of the finalized and signed SLA. This methodology protects Finman’s data by storing the information only for the amount of time required by law under the

Search and Seizure

1695 words - 7 pages Project 2-Search and Seizure CCJS-321 6381 Digital Forensics in the Criminal Justice System [Type the author name] 6/21/2015   1. What permissions/authorities should you have before you search Mr. Yourprop’s former Company work area, and how would you document that authority? The mention of the word “former” leads me to believe that Mr. Yourprop has officially vacated his work area. At this time his work area is no

Information Technology

690 words - 3 pages may further impinge on the long tradition of intellectual freedom enjoyed in the United States” (Online Libraries & Microcomputers, 2001). People should have the right to research whatever is needed for their current project or situation, no matter if they are located at home, work, school, or public places. Information technology has an ethical impact on the American people because the government should not be allowed to say what we can

Recognizing Contract Risks and Opportunities

1481 words - 6 pages performance due to the fact that bugs were in the software delivered, along with Span working behind the timeline. Span heard a rumor that C-S was in negotiations with another company to complete the rest of the project and gave the other company all of the codes needed for the software. If Span’s intellectual property had been given to another company, this could have also been considered a material breach, meaning serious failure to follow the

Traveling To Thailand

444 words - 2 pages While traveling to Thailand on a vacation, you meet Ms. Jenny Chang, an Asian business executive, in the plane. She is happy to learn that you are the international business development consultant for a multinational company. She becomes interested in your expertise and asks you to work as her company's consultant for a project involving new business development in Pakistan. Her company has just invented a revolutionary new CAD system for

International Business

4164 words - 17 pages the project progression, democracy’s retreat has slowed because the rule of law is antithetical to totalitarianism. Now the more plausible scenario is one in which merging economies will arguably migrate from one basis of rule to another. Growing cries from expanding middle class for stronger property rights, will then lay the foundation for society to accept the legitimacy of the rule of law. * Implications for Managers: rule of law

Lawrence Lessig: Cyberlaw Superstar

2410 words - 10 pages Cyberlaw is a relatively new area of jurisprudence and telecommunications policy, where technology and law intersect. From the controversies over intellectual property rights, free speech, fair use and other issues has emerged a voice described in as the "Paul Revere of the Web" (Mullaney & Greene). Lawrence Lessig is both an intellectual and an activist, a constitutional scholar and an original thinker who has an enormous following not only

Research Paper

672 words - 3 pages , being talked about for the first time. With the internet changing the way that people can network over great distances, more people are speaking out and trying to be heard. Project Unbreakable is a blog on Tumblr that shows pictures of rape victims holding signs that saying what the victim was told by the attacker, family members, friends, and even law enforcement. The point of Project Unbreakable is to raise awareness for victim shaming and give

Related Essays

Contract Creation And Management Essay

963 words - 4 pages formal contract. A defense against the genuineness of assent would be difficult to win, since undue influence would be difficult to prove. Although the possibility to void the contract was possible, more than 50% of the contract has been tendered. The contract has a clause for internal dispute resolution, requirements change, communications and reporting, and an intellectual property clause, that provides alternatives to law suits to resolve issues

Challenges In The Publishing Industry Essay

1169 words - 5 pages Business Leaders - 30 Jan. 2012. . This website will help us better understand what SOPA and PIPA (piracy acts) bills are and what type of effect they will have on people all over the world. It also talks about the type of protest Google and Wikipedia performed in order to raise awareness of the effects those acts would have on the Internet. Fisher, William. "Theories of Intellectual Property." Harvard Law School.Web. 29 Jan. 2012

Search Of Status Essay

1279 words - 6 pages of the law of real property and personal property both tangible and intangible property, e.g. Intellectual property. • Demonstrate a basic understanding of contract formation. • Demonstrate an understanding of UCC-Sales and Negotiable Instruments. • Demonstrate a basic understanding of the law of agency. • Explain types of business organizations: sole proprietorship, partnership, corporation, limited

Contract Risk And Opportunities Memo Essay

1124 words - 5 pages the project management structure changes at C-S. This is the reason why they want to cancel their contract with us and we cannot allow this to happen. The cons are that there is no evidence of the delay due to the turnaround problems at C-S. The third clause is the “Intellectual Property Rights.” The pros of this clause is that all the work and afford that was put into this project still belongs to us until we are paid in full for all the