Innocence Lost Researched Argument Essay

2945 words - 12 pages

N.Boothe
WR 121
5 Dec 2015

“When we try children in adult courts, we do so as a result of flawed reasoning, penalizing them for not exercising that degree of judgment that we expect of adults” (Corriero 3).

In the age of legal and judicial reform, several laws are being changed (and some have already been changed) for the purpose of bettering our society and lowering the excessive rates of mass incarceration. There is still a long road ahead of us but I believe – and this paper will show – that changing the way juveniles are adjudicated in America is an important step in the right direction. The juvenile justice system was designed and implemented for juvenile offenders, ...view middle of the document...

S. Department of Justice, Trying Juveniles as Adults: An Analysis of State Transfer Laws and Reporting – henceforth, will be referred to as “Dept. Justice, Trying Juveniles”).
In 1978, Willie Bosket was 15 years old when he shot and killed two men and wounded another on a subway in New York City; he was subsequently sentenced to five years detention in a juvenile facility (Hager). The news media and much of the public were outraged and felt that the sentence was inadequate in proportion to the crime (Hager). Many news publications publicized the case and criticized the New York Juvenile Justice Department for being ineffective and lenient on Bosket (Hager). In an immediate and public response to Bosket’s sentence and the negative publicity towards the juvenile justice system, Carey and his legislative team put the Juvenile Offender Act of 1978 into effect (Hager). The act effectively legalized and generalized transferring entire groups of juvenile cases to adult courts, and soon many other states followed suit in quick succession. By the late 1990's, every state in the U.S. had passed similar laws, with the most legislative changes being made between the 1980’s and 1990’s, during the “super predator scare” (Hager).
Current Laws. In Oregon, the judicial waiver laws allow for discretionary transfer. A discretionary transfer happens when a juvenile court waives jurisdiction over a juvenile (Dept. Justice, Trying Juveniles). There is a process to the discretionary transfer; a formal hearing is held and then at the presiding judge’s discretion, the juvenile may be transferred to criminal court (Dept. Justice, Trying Juveniles). There are also laws regarding statutory exclusion; statutory exclusion dictates that certain crimes committed by juveniles are excluded from jurisdiction within the juvenile court system (Dept. Justice, Trying Juveniles). Like most states, Oregon has the “Once adult/always adult” law that requires any juvenile previously prosecuted in criminal court to be ineligible for juvenile court jurisdiction for any offense (Dept. Justice, Trying Juveniles). There are a considerable number of people that believe anyone that commits a serious crime should be adjudicated in criminal court. People within this group oppose giving any “leniency” towards these offenders, regardless of age. “Adult time for adult crimes” is one well-known argument that comes from this line of thinking.
Reform. There are many arguments in support as well as in opposition of juvenile transfer laws and adjudication in adult courts, as well as the treatment and sentencing of juveniles within the criminal justice system. One serious argument relating to juveniles adjudicated within the adult system is the constitutionality of sentencing a juvenile to the death penalty or even to life without the possibility of parole. For example, the American Psychological Association (APA), among a growing number of other medical and...

Other Papers Like Innocence Lost - Researched Argument

The Mind-Body Problem Essay

1268 words - 6 pages example of the violinist; if the violin is not tuned correctly, the violinist will not perform well; but has the violinist lost their talent? Materialists, on the other hand, could respond to this claim by using Occam’s razor argument; the simplest answer is often the correct answer. However if neuroscience has proven many of the Cartesian dualists claims wrong, does this mean that materialism is the correct theory? A part from Cartesian

Obesity Essay

1031 words - 5 pages eating the proper foods like fruits and vegetables. Everyday more Americans are getting diagnosed with major health issues that are due to lack of exercise and not eating right www.cdc.gov/obesity.date/trends.html. Team C asked- Are these causes reversible? It could be if they lost weight the correct way which is physical activity and diet. Many medical professionals recommend that each American should exercise at least 30 minutes. We believe

Case Study

681 words - 3 pages for certain things, but as long as they were aware of the contract being made, it would not be voidable (Beatty and Samuelson, 2008, p.164). Therefore, the argument that Son was in fact intoxicated would not hold up in a court of law. Looking more deeply into the case, I researched what the initial investment entailed. Kim invested money into the two companies; MJ. Inc. and Netouch International Inc. The investment money, as far as could be

Driving and Cell Phone Usage

1234 words - 5 pages several thousand accidents involving cell phones that turn out deadly. The worst case that I found, was Gina Richards. Who's car rolled under the back drop of a halted semi on the freeway, she was going over 55 mph. Gina, her two twin boys, and her unborn daughter were all killed in the wreck, completely crushed. Why? Gina was distracted by a argument she was having with her mom. Personally I'm against talking on cell phones while driving, after I

Corpus Linguistics: Comparing State and Claim

2595 words - 11 pages Introduction English is general considered to be the global language, a lingua franca, in terms of the population and wide-spread of its users. According to The World Factbook (2009), researched by Central Intelligence Agency (CIA) of USA, English is accepted as the official language in approximately 60 countries and regions. With the wide range of use in the world and its long history, English borrowed certain amount of vocabulary from other

Conflict and Decision Making

2160 words - 9 pages creative-decision making, (4) and environmental and strategic factors that affect the organizational design of a researched company. Negotiation Strategies used to Address Potential Conflicts in the Workplace Unity and teamwork are most essential for the continued growth and health of an organization. Unfortunately, the behavior and lifestyle of human beings in general often interfere or collide with a company’s primary mission. A

English Paper

1096 words - 5 pages of different families and their situations the readers become more interested in the reading because they start to feel for the families and what they have to go through. Everyone can relate to the economy being in a bad state right now, so telling stories of those who lost their jobs because of that can connect the readers to the article. Another style Foderaro uses effectively is logical appeals. She provides her readers with statistics and

Economic Equality

1176 words - 5 pages wants. My argument is that economic inequality affects company performance by lowering human development which can cause additional costs to the company (i.e. healthcare, training and lost productivity) and by lost productivity and negative attitudes in the workplace. Results: Human development Human development is ‘a process of enlarging people’s choices’ (Human Development Report [HDR], 1990: 9). There are many choices that are available in

Characterisation of Blanche Dubois

999 words - 4 pages stereotype the initial judgement will more than likely correspond to the persona of a character. The way in which she dresses makes her incongruous in the setting. ‘She is daintily dressed in a white suit with a fluffy bodice, necklace and earrings of pearl, white gloves and a hat.’ White traditionally represents innocence and youth, so this isn’t a true reflection of herself – she is trying to portray an image that used to be true when she was of a

Let's Talk About It

2409 words - 10 pages game or continue on? Communication can help us deal with other people individually and in groups, it can also help us to identify if our behavior remains the same or changes once we find our “self”,i.e., being judgmental, are we easily persuaded, when do we think that it is appropriate to submit, and do we want to belong or left alone? As I have researched the field of Communication and its value in our lives, I will seek to share some of my

Bloody Pixels

1627 words - 7 pages be caring and refrain from violence towards other people. I have not committed a violent crime or acted aggressively towards another in any way. A major argument that comes up is that children act based on what they see. With today's advanced technology video games have become so clear and graphic that one could get lost into the "gaming world". Albert Bandura, a famous psychologist, did a study on children and aggression. The study showed

Related Essays

Rhetorical Analysis On Child Abuse Psa

1038 words - 5 pages through a variety of elements such as images and speech. In this advertisement pathos and ethos are represented through the sounds and visual content while logos is presented through the statistics given at the end of the advertisement. With this advertisement it is also important to consider the point human services is making as a government program that deals with protection of children and families. A pathos argument is possibly one of the

Hiroshima Essay

1602 words - 7 pages a chance at losing something and that something being our innocence. Once such a thing is lost it can never be returned, once the mind is opened to such horrors its not as if they can just be forgotten or turned away from. Though the question can be is it that our innocence is a blessing or that of an ignorance to what is really happening in our world, is it better to not feel the closeness of these evils or rather see them for the purpose of

Language Analysis

1102 words - 5 pages closer scrutiny, this makes readers think that the argument has been researched thoroughly and that O'brien isn't just jumping to convlusions ”. O’Brien also bases her article on reason and logic, in order to make the reader feel as though they would be silly not to agree with her point of view as being radical. “if there’s room for overseas students at our most desirable state schools, then there’s room for more locals”. Thus, pressuring them to

The Justice System Has Lost Their Way

1683 words - 7 pages astonishing number -- now well over eighty and rising rapidly -- of prisoners who in the past quarter century were sentenced to death but were released from prison because of the likelihood of their innocence. A frequent rebuttal to this argument is that no innocent person has actually been executed. In this article we examine the weakness of that claim.” Here, however, we will explore some of what we believe to be at least a few dozen