This website uses cookies to ensure you have the best experience. Learn more

In What Sense, If Any, Should Mental Illness Be Considered A Cause Of Crime?

1485 words - 6 pages

Frequent surveys of the subject of mental illness and crime appear to show a strong link between mental illness/abnormality and criminality. However, crime is neither a mental disorder nor is it necessarily evidence of such a disorder. The concept of crime and of mental illness should be kept separate and distinct. Crime is a violation of the criminal law, whereas mental illness refers to behaviour that is often marked by some defect of reason that interferes with an individual’s ability to test reality, and which is usually associtaed with stress, disability and an increased risk of suffering. While it is true that some crime can undoubtedly be explained by mental illness, to consider all ...view middle of the document...

Therefore it is important to remember that it might not have been the mental illness that triggered the crime at all. When considered together, these three observations greatly complicate the question of what connection exists between mental illness and crime in relation to causation and make it very difficult for a precise answer to be found.

The criminal behaviour of persons suffering from a mental illness is difficult to estimate with precision due to the difficulty in obtaining reliable data with which to examine the link. Many studies have been carried out to attempt to discover the extent of any link which might exist between criminality and mental illness. Many of these studies involved surveying a prison population and calculating the proportion of prisoners who were suffering from a mental illness. Teplin (1990) has observed that recent surveys of prison populations have concluded that the rate of mental illness in prison populations is, at its most conservative estimate, two to three times higher than the comparable rates in the normal population. However, one cannot conclude that this finding proves a causal link between mental illness and criminality because it is impossible to determine whether the mental illness existed at the time that the crime was committed. Imprisonment itself might cause the mental illness and in such a case there would be no causal link between mental illness and crime but rather the mental illness would be a consequence of imprisonment. On the basis of these observations it is easy to see that in order to prove a causative link much more evidence would be required. An alternative, and possibly better, approach might be to study the behaviour of psychiatric patients and thus attempt to understand the affect that psychiatric disorders have on behaviour. One such study was conducted by Rollin (1969) and concluded that the results pointed to some correlation between criminality and mental illness. However, whilst the figures in the study show that crime and mental illness often occur together, they do not prove a causative link between the two. The fact that a mentally ill person commits a crime does not mean that the act was caused by the illness as the illness might affect a part of the individual’s personality that has nothing to do with the specific crime in the case. It cannot be said with any certainty that crime is caused by mental disorders as even where an offender suffers from a mental disorder it might not be the illness that triggers the crime.

As can be seen the precise relationship between mental illness and criminality is uncertain but it certainly cannot be said that there is any form of simple link between them. In some very severe cases the mental illness may directly cause the crime but such instances are extremely rare and Julien (2001) has claimed that less than 5% of individuals convicted of a crime are suffering from a mental illness. In other cases there may also be an indirect link...

Other Papers Like In What Sense, If Any, Should Mental Illness Be Considered A Cause Of Crime?

Should Competitive Horseback Riding Be More Widely Considered a Sport?

1677 words - 7 pages you are announced the world champions of 2012. Who is to say that this moment is different than competing in any other sport? By definition, a sport is an activity involving physical effort and skill where one competes against others. Competitive horseback riding should be more widely considered a sport because of the dedication involved, the strenuous work exerted, and the competition with others in events. I have been riding horses since the

What Are the Positive Aspects of the Stereotypes, If Any?

1282 words - 6 pages this does not happen all the time but imagine if we are right 50% of the time. Ok, now take those odds into consideration and allow the police force to use your odds. There will be a small possibility that crime will be down in your city or state. • What are the negative aspects of stereotypes? Negative aspects of stereotyping go deeper than just on the surface of the problem. For example in the military for a long period of time

Can Anorexia Nervosa and Bulimia Nervosa Be Considered as Biological and Mental Predispositions or Rather as Consequences of Factors in Society?

4952 words - 20 pages Bulimia Nervosa be considered as biological and mental predispositions or rather as consequences of factors in society? Anorexia Nervosa is an eating disorder that causes those suffering from it to drop more weight than is considered healthy for their age and height. Persons with this disorder may have a concentrated fear of weight increase, even when they are underweight. They may diet or exercise extremely, or use other methods to lose

Individual and Community Perceptions of Mental Illness

533 words - 3 pages , groups that have higher levels of education and financial security are more likely to have more accepting attitudes concerning mental illness and treatment compared to groups with limited education and that fall within lower socioeconomic levels. “Treatment” is viewed as a natural course of action among individuals and their families resulting in the destigmatization of the “illness”. This compared to individuals who live in lower socioeconomic

The Cause of Aggressive Crime

778 words - 4 pages that everyone was telling him he was a punk if he didn’t take care of his business. In this case I would say that his environment (selling drugs) and his friends assisted in his decision to shoot this guy (peer pressure). He stated that he did not want to be a The Cause of Aggressive Crime 3 punk in the streets and that is why he did it

Common-Sense Model of Self-Regulation of Health and Illness

1573 words - 7 pages et al, 2007). For ease of communication it will be referred to as the Common Sense Model (CSM). It’s primary goal and function is to explain how a person processes an illness threat. The CSM is centered on the individual and his or her idea of health and illness. It works under the premise that the individual is “an active problem solver.” CSM also theories an individual’s representation of the illness will be the primary cause of their

To what extent should governments be involved in providing a child care program?

727 words - 3 pages raised in substandard conditions. This can cause health complications such as malnutrition, or even mental problems. These issues might impact the child’s life as they get older, preventing them from being a fully contributing member of the society in the future. It should be a collective right that all children should have a standard quality of life. Kids can not advocated for themselves and are often neglected when governments make decisions

How Far Can the Rebellions of 1549 Be Considered a Key Turning Point in the Changing Nature of Rebellion Against Tudor Rule in England 1485 to 1587?

2064 words - 9 pages How far can the rebellions of 1549 be considered a key turning point in the changing nature of rebellion against Tudor rule in England 1485 to 1587? The period between 1485 and 1587 sprouted a large amount of rebellions during the reign of the Tudors. The 1549 rebellions can be seen as significant in the changing nature of rebellion based on numerous factors. Yet were there any other rebellions which contributed more to the changing nature

What Should Be Done About the Racial Disparities in the Sentencing of Criminals?

1394 words - 6 pages Desiree’ Smith World Literature, Heffernan Research Outline April 13, 2012 What should be done about racial disparities in the sentencing of criminals? I. Thesis Statement: Racial disparities in the sentencing of criminals is a problem in contemporary society and it must be solved II. Topic Sentence HB: It is necessary to examine the history and background of racial disparities in the sentencing of criminals before considering

Changes in Approach to Mental Health/Illness Within Australia

667 words - 3 pages for capital works, was damning of the ‘inadequate’ mental health system, highlighting low standards of care, abuse and overcrowding (Stoller, 1955). As a result of this, there was a wider general interest in mental health. In what could be the beginnings of deinstitutionalisation in Australia, as the report also called for an increase in community services. Funding provided by the government in the seventies was pivotal to the establishment of

The Stigma of Mental Illness and Its Effects

2567 words - 11 pages of stigma, causes, effects, impact of the programs all ready in place, and what can be done to change the perception of the general public . Individuals with mental illness are among the most stigmatized, disadvantaged, and vulnerable members of our society today (Johnstone, 2001). Overton & Medians Research addressed mental illness, and the barriers that are formulated as a result of stigma. Overton & Medina (2008) used current research and

Related Essays

In What Sense, If Any, Should An Environmental Ethic Attribute Value To Whole Ecosystems?

2983 words - 12 pages in fact goal-directed. Cahen cites Ernest Nagel in saying that a system may be considered to be goal-directed if its behaviour is persistent and plastic. Persistence is described as “the continued maintenance of the system in its goal-directed behaviour, by changes occurring in the system that compensate for any disturbances…which… would prevent the realization of the goal”13. That is to say, a system must be able to manage and adapt itself in

Should A Knower’s Personal Point Of View Be Considered An Asset In The Pursuit Of Knowledge, Or An Obstacle To Be Overcome?

1476 words - 6 pages Should a knower’s personal point of view be considered an asset in the pursuit of knowledge, or an obstacle to be overcome? Knowledge is the information of the world in which we acquire by our perceptions, interpretations, the different ways of knowing, points of view, and many other ways. Nevertheless, knowledge is more than that. We have to take into account how and when we apply our knowledge in our everyday lives. We can take into account

Should John Brown Be Considered A Murderer Or A Martyr?

578 words - 3 pages eliminate slavery from America. American's live today without slavery and live a happier life than countries that permit slavery. Looking back at John Brown he fought for slavery, something that most all of American's are against today and what is illegal today. He should be viewed upon as a martyr for fighting for what is moral and justified and killing those that got in his way is what he had to do.

In What Ways, If Any, Has Globalization Transformed The Phenomenon Of Terrorism?

2799 words - 12 pages In what ways, if any, has globalization transformed the phenomenon of terrorism? Introduction The idea of terrorism has not always been as it is today. The word “terror” originated after the French Revolution and the word “terrorism” was subsequently recorded by the Académie Française in 1798 (Roberts 2002). The regime of “la Terreur” was one of force and bloody repression against opponents to the newly born French Republic, but since