In Comparing The Two Texts You Will Have Become Aware Of How The Contexts Of Texts Shaped Their Form And Meaning. Of More Interest, Perhaps, Is A Comparison Of The Values Associated With Each Text

1212 words - 5 pages

Contexts in which texts are created shape the meaning and interpretation of individual writings and can often portray parallel concepts. Jane Austen’s Elizabethan novel Emma (1815) and Amy Heckerling’s cinematic adaptation, Clueless, (1990) both exemplify the thematic concerns of the complexity of relationships, self-realisation and the roles of women. Heckerling transforms a 200 year old story to suit current audiences through a recreation of the characters, language and context; despite this, presents parallel ideas. Heckerling has elegantly restructured these features from the original text, in order to be suitable for the teenage genre and create a teen comedy film. Austen’s classic ...view middle of the document...

This stems from her higher standing social class and her redundancy for the use of money from other males as she has wealth provided from her father. Whereas, other women such as Harriet and Jane, saw marriage as an important part of life as this would mean they were able to live off their husband’s income. Correspondingly, in Clueless, during a passage where the car is depicted, Cher’s unappeased facial expression, presented in an over-the-shoulder shot, in response to Elton’s dialogue “Me and you, well, makes sense”, depicts that she does not believe in the fact that the Elton’s and the Horowitz’s were in similar standings, Cher strongly disagrees and debates that she must find a more socially suitable partner for such relationship. Thus, both texts highlight worlds in which relationships and marriage are characterised by the necessity for social compatibility and how over time the values in relationships have reformed and modified but carry the equivalent message.

Emma and Clueless both examine female protagonists in contemporary and classic contexts, and therefore expose the power and control of women in patriarchal societies. Emma Woodhouse is part of the upper class society in 19th century England, while Cher Horowitz also belongs to the upper class and lives in Beverly Hills. Emma and Cher's similarities have been exemplified in the texts as both are described as being ‘handsome, clever, and rich, with a comfortable home and happy disposition’; Austen’s authorial voiceover displays the stability and the social circumstances that Emma and Cher were in. Similarly, in Clueless, the opening scene of the film presents a montage, depicting Cher as a popular girl, establishing the lavish life she lives: attending parties, shopping, and the freedom she has. Each writer shows their own understanding of differing aspects of a women’s role in society. In Austen's novel, Emma has a lifestyle limited to leisure, fine arts and social gatherings. Through the use of repetition in Emma’s dialogue “If I draw less, I shall read more: if I give up music, I shall take up to carpet-work” (Chapter 10), Austen exhibits that even upper class females were restricted in their aspirations and desires to participate in activities that were seen to be for the masculine. In the same way, in Clueless, Cher’s voiceover “when a boy comes over, you always need something baking” gives an insight into how regency female domesticity has been changed into postmodern female thinking despite Cher having more access to the outside world than Emma. Hence, though the domesticity of females has been preserved in both texts and has reshaped over the time...

Other Papers Like In Comparing the Two Texts You Will Have Become Aware of How the Contexts of Texts Shaped Their Form and Meaning. of More Interest, Perhaps, Is a Comparison of the Values Associated with Each Text

Writing Matters - Text Binder: Texts: “ the Luckiest Time of All”

989 words - 4 pages , © 2009, Teaching Matters, Inc. Page 168 Writing Matters - Text Binder: Texts: “ The Luckiest Time of All” and when we walked back to the dancin dog’s place in the show he let the dog loose and helped me to find my stone. I told him how shiny black it was and how it had the letter A scratched on one side. We searched and searched and at last he spied it! “Ovella and me lost interest in shows then and we walked on

How Does a Comparative Study of the Great Gatsby and the Sonnets from the Portuguese Bring to the Fore Ideas About the Unchanging Nature of Social Values? in Your Answer Refer to the Language Forms...

796 words - 4 pages relationship to work, even if it is a love of money, ease, and material luxury rather than a love for a person, her relationship with Gatsby as he could not offer these. Therefore love is valued as a need, just as it was in the Victorian era with Barrett Browning, representing unchanging values of society. Both texts also show values that do change during time and with different contexts. During the Victoria Era women were dominated by a

Analysis Of Semantics And Pragmatics In Two Texts

1518 words - 7 pages pairs "healthy and disabled" in comment 3 have an antonymous sense relationship because their oppositeness is a question of degree. The lexical items abortion and termination have a synonymous sense relationship because both terms have the "same" meaning; however the term abortion is the more specialised term for such process. The denotative meaning of the expression "so coldly" used in comment 2, is usually associated with temperature degree

A Study of an Individual’S Choice, How It Can Be Corrupted and What the Outcome Will Be, with Reference to the Texts 'Brave New World', 'the Screwtape Letters' and 'the Devil and Miss Prym'

4532 words - 19 pages individual and therefore limiting the choices that a singular person has. Singular people are not allowed to make their own choices in life as said choices have already been made for them. Human beings are grown, or rather produced, in laboratories in what is known as Bokanovsky’s process – no one is born normally. In fact the idea of family is considered “smutty”(BNW Pg 18) – even at one point the words ‘mother’ and ‘father’ are referred to as

A Paper Encompassing How "Knights" In The Midieval Times Grow To What They Are. Through Chivalric Values And Hard Work They Become Defenders Of Their Society

2629 words - 11 pages was because it was not fit for a knight to perform these skills and was not thought to be very manly. This type of attitude has some similarities even in today's world. Not necessarily with reading and writing but the fact of how people will perceive you if you do not comply with a certain structure or system. This was a time in a page's life when all they needed to do was get the "just" of what becoming a knight would be like. Taking part in

Texts in Time Comparison

1042 words - 5 pages Regardless of the times people live in some values will always be shared by humans. The values of love and hope are two of them though love can be expressed in many forms. Such forms are past love, idealised love, uncertain love and many others some of which shown in the novel The Great Gatsby, written by F Scott Fitzgerald. Is set in the 1920’s a time when the traditional values of Americans were changing as women were gaining more rights and

Comparing Texts-Letter to the Guardian

951 words - 4 pages someone or been bullied or have I been caked in makeup. I have never talked back to a teacher nor have I been involved in playground scraps. Why? Because I am a normal teenager and, like most other members of my age group, nothing in this abhorrent Daily Mail article can be used to describe me. The main issue I have is with the writers: lazy anglerfish just waiting to ambush an unsuspecting story, drag it down to their level, and rip it to shreds

"Gambling With The Future": A History With And Without Tradition. Comparison Of Two Short Stories And Their Themes. Shirley Jackson's "The Lottery" And Thomas King's "Totem."

1266 words - 6 pages , even harmful, leaving no room for innovative thought. In both stories, neither situation shows the characters to be keen on change or considering another viewpoint different from their own. Symbolic meanings behind each of the points stated works to further support this argument, for they share the same universal meaning. When analyzing both these stories one can interpret a second more concealed message, which is that using what you are told and what you learn, and drawing your own conclusions is the only way to break out of a possibly harmful cycle. Perhaps Hegel was right when he said, "We learn from history that man can never learn anything from history."

• in What Ways Have Various Forms of Entertainment Media Shaped American Culture and Its Values

925 words - 4 pages express ourselves in a way that no other form of entertainment can. The lyrics to a song are special to the writer/artist as they give connotative meanings to words (pg 103). Music can also act as a pain killer by releasing endorphins in the brain, encouraging relaxation. Music is a great way to get together with people who have a similar passion, which helps you meet new people, socialize, and help give you a sense of belonging. There are some

Choose Any Three Nail Conditions and Give a Referenced Account of Their Causes(S) and Management. Please Note Not All References Will Give You the Same Method of Management and Some Will Give More...

600 words - 3 pages CHOOSE ANY THREE NAIL CONDITIONS AND GIVE A REFERENCED ACCOUNT OF THEIR CAUSES(S) AND MANAGEMENT. PLEASE NOTE NOT ALL REFERENCES WILL GIVE YOU THE SAME METHOD OF MANAGEMENT AND SOME WILL GIVE MORE THAN ONE METHOD Nail fungi (onychomycosis) is caused by dermatophytes that invade the nail matrix. They possess the ability to thrive and grow on the protein keratin and favour damp and dark conditions, therefore the human toenail and nail bed

Our Interest in the Parallels Between Pride and Prejudice and Letters to Alice on First Reading Jane Austen Is Further Enhanced by Consideration of Their Marked Differences in Textual Form

1235 words - 5 pages within the bounds of individual contexts. The study of Fay Weldon’s Letters to Alice: On First Reading Jane Austen enhances the reader’s understanding and interest of Austen’s Pride and Prejudice and presents new perspectives on the original text. The changing values and attitudes towards education, the importance of literature, marriage and the position of women in society are explored through the marked differences in textual form. A reader’s

Related Essays

How Have The Texts You Have Studied This Year Effectively Shaped Your Understanding Of 'the Journey'?

1209 words - 5 pages Margaret Atwood, focuses on the journey of studying the intrinsic nature of ones self. The journey is a never-ending one, as the journey to the interior of ourselves will never be complete whilst we learn new things about ourselves each day. Because of the countless experiences dealt with in life, and how large an affect they have on ones life, we are always learning more about ourselves. Atwoods 'Journey to the Interior' have communicated this

Transformation: Emma And Clueless "When You Compared These Texts And Their Contexts, How Was Your Understanding Of Each Text Developed And Reshaped?"

1571 words - 7 pages these girls can do more than Emma, what they do is no more important: makeovers, shopping, parties etc. Despite how Emma and Cher subvert the expectations of their world through the assertion of free will, both finally capitulate to their man and his perceptions, and awarded by a secure marriage/relationship with him.Both protagonists live in insular, microcosmic societies defined by rigid stratifications. The "ropes of Bronson-Alcott high" parallel

A Comparison Of Macbeth With Other Texts

1871 words - 8 pages not only Macbeth who has killed the peace inside of him, Lady Macbeth has also become so deeply disturbed by the events that she is unable to sleep because of what she has done. Still, before this point in the play Lady Macbeth has shown to be a lot more focussed and determined than Macbeth, “Are you a man?” This type of behaviour breaks a lot of the stereotypes around women in that era. A Jacobean audience would have been shocked by this because

Comparison Of 2 Texts Essay

714 words - 3 pages Compare how information and attitudes about spiders are conveyed by the speakers in the two texts. Text A is an emotive piece; it is a conversation between Patsy and her friend about her fear of spiders. Text A’s agenda is to inform Phil about Patsy’s experience with spiders because of this Phil allows Patsy to go into a monologue as she speaks, the text involves a lot of personal anecdotes showing Patsy’s heightened emotional state. Text B