Illegal Immigration, American/Mexican Border Essay

1831 words - 8 pages

Illegal Immigration and Border Policy
In recent years, Illegal immigration has been a contemporary political and social debate. It has been the platform of many politicians, especially in the southwest, and it is often a popular subject in news media. People in favor of strict immigration policy often claim that illegal immigrants are costly to the American economy and that they take American jobs. The border control policy is ineffective, it is often too costly for its effectiveness. Border policies have increased the number of immigrant deaths in the deserts of border states. Not only that but the US/Mexico border is harmful to the environment. The anti-immigration policy that's ...view middle of the document...

Instead of completely stopping migrants from crossing the border, the border wall is designed to increase the possibility that crossers will be seen on cameras or by drones. Increased spending on Border Security in 2006 failed to decrease the numbers of illegal entries into the United States. In fact, the number of illegal crossings during the Bush administration actually increased. The Department of Homeland Security offers a public report on illegal immigrant populations living in the US. The report shows that Between 2000 and 2007, the unauthorized population grew by 3.3 million from 8.5 million to 11.8 million and that of the 10.8 million unauthorized immigrants in 2009, 4.0 million (37 percent) had entered the United States on January 1, 2000 or later. The billion dollar expenditures to increase militarization and infrastructure along the US/Mexico border failed to completely stop illegal immigration into the United States. Because of this, it would appear that strict immigration policy might be fiscally irresponsible.
Aside from acting as a small deterrent for incoming migrants, border policies have led to the deaths of hundreds of immigrants along the border. Because of this, stricter border patrol policies can potentially lead to moral problems. Policies such as Operation Hold the Line and Operation Gatekeeper were attempts at redirecting Mexican immigrants to different routes along the border. These prevention policies were aimed at reducing the number of immigrants into America each year by making immigration more dangerous for border crossers. The rationale behind these measures was to funnel Mexican migrants to move through the Arizona desert. Julie Whitaker's paper called Mexican Deaths in the Arizona explains the consequences these policies had on migrants from Mexico. She explains that the policy forced Mexican migrants "to cross in the inhospitable remote environment of south western U.S. where the seemingly boundless terrain is treacherous and the temperatures can be extreme" (Whitaker 336). She then explains "Between 1998 and 2005, approximately 300 people died on average each year" (Whitaker 336). Humanitarian organizations like No More Deaths and Humane Borders have responded to the situation. Volunteers have placed water jugs along the border to prevent dehydration of migrants in the Arizona desert. These organizations have been highly criticized. Whitaker explains "for their assistance, many volunteers have been accused of, and charged with, criminal activities - mostly transporting migrants and littering" (Whitaker 367). The increase in the number of deaths along the border combined with the restriction of humanitarian aid in the dangerous desert terrain is a reason why strict immigration policy might be more than just a fiscal problem, but also a moral problem.
Aside from its moral consequences on human beings, the physical border has also had negative effects on desert wildlife. Because the wall is a physical...

Other Papers Like Illegal Immigration, American/Mexican Border

Immigration Essay

2187 words - 9 pages culturally live in the U.S. due to having the risk of become an underclass and face a social conflict with U.S. citizens (Zedillo, 2007). By having social conflicts with others, illegal immigrants will hurt government services by not actively participates in contributing taxes however they will benefit the overall economy in which "immigration is essential to the dynamism of the American economy and for sustaining its pace in job creation" (Zedillo

Illegal Immigration Essay

2136 words - 9 pages desperate migrants sneaking across the Mexican border. There is another side to America’s immigration problem, however, that most know very little about; those who come with valid, temporary visas and do not return home. Most of the visa over stays are for work, and some are for school purposes. According to a 2006 Pew Hispanic Center study, (, 2006), nearly half of the 12 million-plus illegal aliens in America arrived legally

Illegal Immigration and Its Impact on the Economy

1023 words - 5 pages close down or go bankrupt. Many states have spent a lot of money for emergency Medicaid for unauthorized immigrants. Madeline Codman states in the journal of American physicians and surgeons that 80 percent of cost associated with unauthorized immigrants is with childbirth. While there is no easy fix to illegal immigration, many alternatives can be adopted to slow or completely halt the illegal immigration. The alternatives outlined below can be

Illegal Immigration

2151 words - 9 pages generally considered to have been controlled in the United States are readily evident along the United States-Mexican border” (Illegal Immigration and Public Health, 2009). He tells of many outbreaks of tuberculosis, dysentery, leprosy, polio and the pork tapeworm which have ravaged many people who live near the border. With illegal immigrants rapidly spreading across the county, the problem of these diseases is not confined to the border

Human Trafficking

1313 words - 6 pages . Federation for American Immigration Reform conducted a study which demonstrates that illegal migrants cost to the country about $113 billion a year (Barnes). At the same time, the opponents of the Federation for American Immigration Reform argue that illegal migrants contribute $245 billion to Gross Domestic Product (Barnes). This dispute shows that, in fact, it is very difficult to estimate the impact of illegal migration on the US economy. On the

Illegal Immigration

1481 words - 6 pages directly affect all Americans in this economic crisis. Illegal immigrants also cause other problems like crime, overcrowding, and language disputes. The United States of America needs to stand by laws that are in place for illegal immigration. The United States of America border is about 7,515 miles. “Each year, more than 500 million people cross the borders into the United States, some 330 million of whom are non-citizens. There are 118,129

The Arizona Immigration Law

1134 words - 5 pages that the police must check people solely on the basis of their skin color, many perceive this as racism. And in the end, this can help to increase the disparity between the different races in the country. Some positives thing could be that many believe that the rules in Arizona are the first step towards the immigration laws of the United States becoming stricter. To intensifying border controls, throw more illegal immigrants out of the country

Ex Mexico’s Exodus

2178 words - 9 pages . (Reuters, Mexico Protests) In rebuttal a Mexican activist has offered a $10,000 bounty on anyone that succeeds in killing a U.S. Border agent. This politico heads a group called “Citizen Defense Committee” and has stirred anti-American feelings in his country. The Justice Department is investigating. Meanwhile the violence continues. An agent shot dead an illegal immigrant trying to flee near Brownsville, Tx. in May this year

Hiring Illegal Workers

3239 words - 13 pages increased funding for the Border Patrol. Over 3 million individuals, including 2.3 million Mexicans, were granted legal permanent resident status under IRCA. Opponents of the law claimed that it would encourage future illegal immigration, notwithstanding tougher border enforcement, because it set a precedent for granting amnesty. One such concerns arose again recently as, fifteen years after Ronald Regan provided amnesty, another amnesty was under

Mexican American

761 words - 4 pages Running head: MEXICAN AMERICAN Mexican American ETH/125 Cultural Diversity Sonia Rivera August 23, 2009 Mexican American The Mexican Americans have been living in the Americas for many years. Immigrants have been in the United States since the Mexican American war in 1847. After the treaty of Guadalupe was signed Mexican immigrants were brought to

Bordercoastal Security

2957 words - 12 pages immigration laws. But Mexico would not do what it could to secure and maintain control of its southern border against illegal immigrants. Both countries feel that most of the financing for the Mexican traffickers comes from the American drug consumers (Mauldin, 2010). United States Secretary Hillary Clinton stated that “Our insatiable demand for illegal drug fuels the drug trade, and that “the United States bears shared responsibility for the

Related Essays

Mexican American Immigration Essay

755 words - 4 pages Krystal Flores Soc 3413 6-27-13 Dr. Mercado- López Mexican American immigration act There are lots of current policies/events going around in the world and it affects the Mexican Americans community, but there is one that affects mostly all Mexican Americans is the immigration which is the most issue in the United States and Mexico. Mexican and Mexican American immigrants seem to share a common culture identity because

The Cost Of Illegal Immigration Essay

1171 words - 5 pages people, especially those who live in the border states of California, Arizona, and Texas. Finally, there is the subject of fairness. Illegal immigrants have been allowed access to in-state college tuition rates, while American citizens have been denied the privilege. These facts can no longer be ignored and the sovereignty of the United States is at stake.ResourcesBarnes, E. (2010, July 06). Illegal immigration costs u.s. $113 billion a year, study

America Essay

1115 words - 5 pages already here (DiConsiglio 3). NAFTA, officially, hasn’t reduced as much illegal immigration as had been hoped, but, it helped Mexico recover faster from it’s economic crisis in ‘94-’95, which has stopped a larger flood of people, since most immigrants tend to come to the U.S. in times of Mexican economic depression ("Mexico" 2). The major reason Mexicans tend to illegally immigrate is to find jobs. Therefore, elimination of the chance of them getting

Is The Mexico Us Border Fence Justified

1312 words - 6 pages Is The Mexico-US border fence justified? The United States Congress approved the "Secure Fence Act of 2006" which sanctioned the construction of numerous separation barricades at the Mexican-American border and the installation of a virtual fence entailing surveillance cameras, sensors, and other equipment to cover those parts of the border that do not have a physical wall. The debate is related to the American debate on immigration, and