Hume And Religion Essay

1828 words - 8 pages

Religious Philosophers and Speculative Atheists
Interpretations of Hume's philosophy of religion are often made against the background of more general interpretations of his philosophical intentions. From this perspective, it is not unusual to view Hume's views on religion in terms of the skepticism and naturalism that features prominently in his Treatise of Human Nature (1739-40), his first and most ambitious philosophical work. According to the account that is now widely accepted in the scholarly literature, Hume removed almost all the material in the Treatise that was concerned with religion because he was anxious to avoid causing any “offence” among the orthodox. In his later works, ...view middle of the document...

Moreover, a view of this kind is liable to overlook the way in which 17th and 18th century theological controversies and debates structure and shape Hume's entire philosophy — not just his philosophy of religion. Put another way, Hume's philosophy of religion is integral to his entire philosophical system. It should not be viewed as an extraneous outgrowth or extension of earlier concerns and commitments that lack any specific irreligious motivation or orientation.

In the opening paragraph of the last section of the first Enquiry (XII) Hume makes the following observation:

There is not a greater number of philosophical reasonings, displayed upon any subject, than those, which prove the existence of a Deity, and refute the fallacies of Atheists; and yet the most religious philosophers still dispute whether any man can be so blinded as to be a speculative atheist. (EU.149/12.1 — Hume's emphasis)
These remarks bring to light an important point. The central debate that shapes Hume's views on the subject of religion is not the empiricist/rationalist controversy, nor its “British”/”continental” correlate, but a more fundamental dispute between philosophical defenders of Christian theology and their “atheistic” opponents. It is this divide over issues of religion that is especially important for understanding the positions and arguments that Hume presents throughout his philosophical writings.

During the 17th and early 18th centuries British philosophy gave rise to two powerful but conflicting philosophical outlooks. On one hand, this era has been described as “the golden period of English theology” because of the emerging alliance between philosophy and theology. It was, in particular, a major concern of a number of divines at this time to show that theology could be provided with a rational defence — one that would ward off all threat of scepticism and atheism. Among the leading representatives of this tradition were Henry More, Ralph Cudworth, John Locke, Samuel Clarke, George Berkeley and Joseph Butler. (More and Cudworth were both Cambridge Platonists.) On the other hand, in opposition to this Christian tradition, there existed a sceptical tradition of which the greatest representative was Thomas Hobbes. Almost all the defenders of the Christian religion during this period had their arguments targeted against the “atheistic” doctrines of Hobbes.

From the perspective of Hobbes's critics the doctrines that lay at the heart of his atheism were materialism, necessitarianism, moral relativism and egoism, and scepticism concerning natural and revealed religion. Any thinker who endorsed doctrines of this kind was liable to be read as a follower of Hobbes and branded an “atheist”. During this period Hobbes was not without his followers. The most important thinker to become closely associated with Hobbes, in the minds of his critics, was Benedict Spinoza. In the Theological-Political Treatise (1670) Spinoza pursued a number of Hobbesean...

Other Papers Like Hume and Religion

John Locke Essay

1511 words - 7 pages that all aspects of it can be grasped through mathematical and logical principles, and not simply through sensory experience. The most famous rationalists were Descartes and Spinoza. Empiricism is a philosophical perspective to counter the rationalism of the 17th century. Empiricists were philosophers who felt that everything in our mind comes from our experience through the senses. They heavily critiqued the rationalists. Locke, Berkeley and Hume

Com 200 Final Paper

1765 words - 8 pages pain and to live through painful experiences as well. Descartes was a rationalist with doubts his own sense perceptions to the point that he isolates himself from the world; by separating worldly thoughts from his philosophy, he assumes his ideas reflect innate ideas placed in him by a superior, ultimate force (God). Hume an empiricist doubts the existence of anything that cannot be proven without observable evidence. These contrasting

Classical Metaphisics

1183 words - 5 pages Name Professor Course Date Philosophy Free will can be termed as the ability of agents to make choices with no constrains of different dynamic factors. This principle of free will has implications on religion, legal and ethical factors among others. Philosophers since time immemorial have debated extensively on the existence or the nonexistence of free will in of this philosophical figure is David Hume, he maintains that humans are

Design Argument Revision Notes

1100 words - 5 pages analogy and likens the complexity of a watch to the complexity of the Universe. Since a watch is clearly designed, so is the Universe [qua regularity]. Also, the human eye is too complex to have arisen by chance so must be designed for some purpose [qua purpose] • Hume [1711-1776] in Dialogues Concerning Natural Religion and An Inquiry Concerning Human Understanding put forward a number of criticisms of the DA before Paley published his

The Problem of Evil (~1100 Words)(Not Great Writing)

1186 words - 5 pages the Free Will debate, which states that; God created us as we are, therefore God created us with free will and free will has the capacity and potential for evil. If God had not created us with free will, then humanity would be a race of automata, which would basically be slaves or drones. Not even a halfway decent god would do this David Hume ttalks of the problem of evil in: Dialogues Concerning Natural Religion. Hume says: “Is he

Cognistic Theory of Learning

2266 words - 10 pages association of one state with its successor states. (Warren 1921) The theory was developed by Plato and Aristotle, and further developed by pioneers like John Locke, David Hume, and James Mill. In the evolution of development, Locke, Hume, Mill developed elaborate principles and its relation to neurophysiology. Their contributions have led to Psychologists tactics in describing and assessing behavior when conducting sessions. The easiest way for

John Locke

633 words - 3 pages and philosophies. Many of John’s views both political and religious were found to be famous though-out history in many countries. Locke was one of the first people who thought religion and state should be separated. Locke published anonymously the “Two Treaties of Government” and an essay “Concerning Human Understanding.” These writings were immediately successful and both influenced Rousseau and Voltaire along with many other scholars

How Successful Is the Design Argument?

1405 words - 6 pages God is an intelligent and personal agency that is outside the world. Therefore this agency must be God.   When examining the successfulness of the argument from design, we are also able to look at the problem of evil in conjunction as this also provides challenges to accepting the argument as being successful. John Stuart Mill, does this in "Nature and the utility of Religion. He does this by ascribing the designer to human characteristics

Newspaper Analysis

5917 words - 24 pages writings earned him fame and admiration among the French Enlightenment philosophers of the Paris salons -- including Diderot and Voltaire. Hume was admired for his systematic and intelligent critiques of religion -- important because these thinkers were the first high-profile intellectuals of their time to publicly suggest religion was an outdated institution best removed from the social sphere. Today, a quarter-millennium later, religion is alive

Northern Ireland Conflict

5438 words - 22 pages South of Ireland, and religiously between Protestants and Catholics. Theories that have emerged have pointed to causes such as land claims and a nationalist ideology, ethnicity and culture, and perhaps most frequently, religion when attempting to define the conflict. In fact, what is more likely is that elements of all of these issues lie at the root of what is commonly referred to as "The Troubles".The history of this contemporary conflict is

Francis Bacon

1033 words - 5 pages the theatre, which are the beliefs we hold in past philosophies that have either been disproved or changed, or are just philosophically dormant. Bacon believed highly in religion however. He believed that the more we search for god the less we rely on our faith and the more distant we grow from knowing god. He was quoted as saying that "the more discordant, therefore, and incredible, the divine mystery is, the more honor is shown to God in

Related Essays

Humes Ethics Essay

1054 words - 5 pages Hume’s Ethics Contents 1. Introduction 2. Hume’s ethics as an emotive theory of ethics 3. Conclusion 4. Bibliography David Hume is an outstanding Scottish philosopher of the 18th century whose views has a significant impact on the following generations of thinkers throughout the world. His sceptical arguments concerning induction, causation and especially religion, including his famous thesis that human knowledge arises only from sense

Philosophy And Religion Essay

2529 words - 11 pages of the most significant philosophers of the Enlightenment. Hume’s frequent recourse to man as the measure of all things, including God. R.C. Sproul states “Many believe that Hume destroyed once and for all the law of causality, and in doing so he opened the door to the idea that anything can produce anything (107). ”The big picture of Hume’s view of morality and religion is that they were social that is, manmade constructions that were subject to

Two Philosophies And Their Bel Essay

719 words - 3 pages , then it can be classified as a belief. Basically Hume classifies beliefs as ideas that are important to people's heart. This section of his theory is pleasing because the reader can place such important categories as religion and love into the belief category.Both Descartes' and Hume's theories are valuable to the philosophical community because they exhibit different viewpoints that can be considered by a reader. It is almost impossible to

Notes On Hume & Poppers Different Philosophies

885 words - 4 pages ; make mistakes. It is much more likely that a person in question has lied and/or made a mistake than the person overturned the laws of nature.?Arguments against Hume?s ?miracle thesis?s?:-Do unexplainable, extraordinary events happen in real life? This must be true, despite Hume?s above arguments-Can we be certain that science will explain all such ?miracles? (extraordinary events)? No, we can never be sure; despite advances, scientists will never