This website uses cookies to ensure you have the best experience. Learn more

How Persuasive Is Nozick's Account Of How A Minimal State Could Emerge From A Suitably Specified State Of Nature Without Violating Anyone's Rights?

1055 words - 5 pages

How persuasive is Nozick's account of how a minimal state could emerge from a suitably specified state of nature without violating anyone's rights?
In Anarchy, State, and Utopia Nozick gives extreme importance to self-ownership. It is from here that the rights and then the minimal state originate from. As individuals own themselves, they cannot be treated as means and must be seen as ends, in Kantian fashion (Chia, 2010). Individuals are inviolable like Kant describes them and self-owners therefore; Nozick states that we have absolute rights to life, liberty and rights to property. These rights function as side constraints on the action of others in the sense they set limits on how others ...view middle of the document...

According to Nozick, the minimal state emerges from the state of nature through series of steps. John Locke considers a nature of state where everyone is their own judge. However, Nozick establishes few problems with the nature of state. He states that men who judge their own case in the state of nature “will always give themselves the benefit of the doubts and assume they are in the right…punish others more than proportionately and to exact excessive compensation….Also, in the state of nature a person may lack the power to enforce his rights; he may be unable to punish or exact compensation from a stronger adversary who has violated them” (Nozick, 1974, pg.11-12) Nozick argues that because of the reasons outlined above individuals in the state of nature will endeavour to improve their position and therefore will perform actions which will bring about a minimal state. It is worth noting that a minimal state will arise unconsciously where no one intended this, this is also known as the invisible hand process (Wollf, pg.42). Nozick points out several stages between the state of nature and minimal state. The first stage is the formation of protective agencies or association. ''In a state of nature an individual may himself enforce his rights, defend himself, exact compensation, and punish" (Nozick, 1974, pg.12). So therefore, even in well behaved state, some violations of rights will occur so men will find it more efficient to hire these protective agencies that can protect them (Althan, 1977). However, this protective association “has no rights of action other than the sum of the rights delegated to it by its subscribers” (Barnett, 1977, pg.15)
In time, one agency in a geographical territory will become dominant and come to be the only association within a territory. But it is not yet a state because it does not ‘‘announce that, to the best of its ability… it will punish everyone whom it discovers to have used force without its permission,’’ and second, ‘‘under it… only those paying for protection get protected’’ (Nozick, 1974, p. 24). This basically deals with the question that how will DPA deal with those who...

Other Papers Like How Persuasive Is Nozick's Account of How a Minimal State Could Emerge from a Suitably Specified State of Nature Without Violating Anyone's Rights?

Parental Rights Versus State Needs Essay

3205 words - 13 pages any State shall infringe upon this right without demonstrating that its governmental interest as applied to the person is of the highest order and not otherwise served. Section 3: No treaty may be adopted nor shall any source of international law be employed to supersede, modify, interpret, or apply to the rights guaranteed by this article ( One could strongly argue that such a Constitutional Amendment would

The View of Human Nature and the Role of the State

757 words - 4 pages ideologies, their beliefs on human nature and how this affects their view on the role of the state. The state is a sovereign entity within a clearly defined region which has monopoly of violence, thus holding the ability to create peace or war. Views on the state, in terms of its function and involvement in society, stems largely from ones ideas on human nature. The conservative view on human nature is quite pessimistic. Conservatism is largely

The Ownership Over Commomn Proeprty Resources : State Versis Community Rights

4120 words - 17 pages development (Mullick 2007: 22) .Indigenous people struggle for autonomy and identity throughout the colonial and post- colonial period demanded state recognition of integrity of their culture and nature. As far as tribals are concerned, forest is inseparable from their existence, the tribal and forest policies of state could not be framed on incompatible premises. However, this demand was never honoured by the state (ibid 24). The government of

Poverty Is a State of Mind

1303 words - 6 pages . (934) This essay is, in some way, an evidence that it is possible to let go of the poverty by soul. Bernard Hare made it, and on a journey marked by injustice, poverty and damaging surroundings, he tough us that it is possible to break out of the poverty. From his point of view, poverty is a state of mind

Poverty Is a State of Mind

1252 words - 6 pages There is a big gap between wealthy and poor people and it has grown a lot over the years. One part of England is doing well, while the other part is struggling and facing bigger challenges. It causes a lot of difficulties for the poor, but is it just materialistic or is it also psychological? In the essay “Poverty is a state of mind” by Bernard Hare from 2012, originally broadcasted on BBC radio 3, he reflects on his life growing up poor and

A State of Trance

854 words - 4 pages September 12, 2012 G. Grunow English 131 A State of Trance “Hanady! Hanady! Hey where’s Hanady, she isn’t responding.” “She must be upstairs listening to music.” Music to me is almost like a third language. It not only provides insight but it allows me to feel as if I’m in another world. Music comes in many forms from rap, r&b, rock, pop, and many more but nothing speaks to me more than the power of trance. Trance is a genre of music

How Successful Were the Reforms of Post War Labour Government 1945-1951 in Creating a Welfare State?

1574 words - 7 pages Children’s Charter was passed. The Charter protected children in all aspects of life, making sure they were protected from abuse and neglect by making these punishable offenses and ensuring that they children were not living on the streets without food or education. It also banned under-16s from smoking, drinking alcohol or begging. Furthermore, children now had a separate legal system in which they weren’t tried as adults if they committed crimes

Could Poverty Be a Violation of Human Rights?

5200 words - 21 pages don’t assume what the nature of that justification is, or what being a right precisely involves. 2. An easy question? Depending on how one interprets ‘violation’, our starting question could be easily answered. Let’s distinguish three notable types of causes of poverty that are contenders for being human rights violations. Let’s call the first type-1 impoverishment: where an agent A deliberately acts such that she causes a person S to be in

Modern Russia is in Search of a Secular Model of Relationships Between Religions and the State

962 words - 4 pages , racial, national, religious or language superiority is forbidden”. Apart from the Constitution, a number of other laws regulate relationships between religions and the state in Russia. Drafting and adoption of the laws, regulating religious practices, involve challenges because such laws are extremely significant from the political and social viewpoints. The law “On Freedom of Conscience and Religious Associations” (1997) was adopted in difficult

Fear: Not a Mindset a State of Being

1159 words - 5 pages belief that fear is a state of mind. Poe plays with the idea that fear is not a mindset; it is a state of being. This statement reflects Poe’s short stories and the characters he creates. “The Tell-Tale Heart” exposes in copious amounts the side effects of a man whose state of being in fear and horror. The nameless main character recounts the story of how he killed an old man because his eye bothered him. He begins his story by defending his

How to Prepare a Persuasive Speech

951 words - 4 pages How to Prepare a Persuasive Speech Public Speaking Tips for College Students Aug 19, 2009 Carol Rzadkiewicz When it comes time for students to deliver a persuasive speech, if they follow certain guidelines, they can deliver a speech that is both powerful and effective. Students are required to take public speaking in college as part of any undergraduate program of study; and of all the speeches students will be called upon to

Related Essays

Why Does Hobbes Describe The State Of Nature As A State Of War?

605 words - 3 pages , even the weakest man will have a chance to succeed over the strongest – for instance by cooperating with others or by using tools. Neither will the smartest always win against the dumbest. This equality is also mirrored in men’s hopes to have a chance of succeeding in a battle. Thus, men usually consider battle as a means for their ends, instead of just surrendering to the stronger. Finally, in the state of nature, nobody hinders men from

Nba Persuasive Speech Wa State

1581 words - 7 pages cutting the budget for neighborhood health clinics. One is already closed and the others are cutting back services. How could Columbus justify spending millions for a stadium when it can’t keep all of its health clinics open? We need to prioritize and used our public funds much wiser. B. So in the end if we can make an impact on these franchises maybe professional sporting events will once again become an affordable event instead of a luxury

Alabama Justice Moore's Rights Were Inhibited With The Removal Of The 10 Commandments From The State Judicial Building

569 words - 3 pages separation of church and state. The concept originated from President Thomas Jefferson who suggested that there is a "wall of separation between Church and State." However, The Constitution sets out no absolute divide between God and government.The Ten Commandments contain both religious and secular directives, such as prohibition of stealing, killing, adultery, and lying. If one were to take the concepts contained in the Ten Commandments by themselves

With And Without The State In

1931 words - 8 pages . There is no hope for these people as they see the world expanding and competition for power and superiority remains.Struggle embodies the individual and the casted civilization they live in as the outside world continues to prosper, reigning above them. Christ Stopped at Eboli, by Carlo Levi, exemplifies an age-old repression of a people without hope because of an outside world that suppresses them.This eyewitness account demonstrates how the outside