This website uses cookies to ensure you have the best experience. Learn more

How Fair Is The Judgment That Bentham’s Utilitarianism Is A ‘Pig Philosophy’ Or ‘Swine Ethic.’ (10 Marks)

611 words - 3 pages

How fair is the judgment that Bentham’s Utilitarianism is a ‘pig philosophy’ or ‘swine ethic.’ (10 marks)

Thomas Carlyle was a critic of Bentham’s approach of Utilitarianism. He reflects on Bentham’s approach as a ‘pig philosophy’. This is because he saw it more as a morality based on the ‘swinish pleasure of the masses.’

Bentham’s philosophy was referred as a swinish or the pig’s philosophy as it endorsed on the greatest amount of pleasure for the greatest number of people. This is degrading humans viewing them as animals that focus mainly on the needs of the majority whether even if the minority is morally approved. An example of this will be abortion. Bentham’s theory will support the act of abortion. According to his theory the majority will receive pleasure through the abortion of an unborn. The pregnant women ...view middle of the document...

Majority will benefit from this abortion. However, utilitarianism advocates injustice as the innocent is unjustly framed. Minority is not considered although they are still humans. They have to go through pain even though they are innocent.

Moreover, it ignores the importance of duty. An act maybe right or wrong for reasons other than the amount of good or evil it produces. A millionaire asks his friend to swear that on his death he will give all of his assets to his local football club. The millionaire dies and his friend sets to fulfill his last wish. However, he sees an advertisement to save 1 million people who are dying of starvation. The question of should he keep the promise or save 1 million people will raise. Some promises can be bad and should not be kept. The role of duty of each individual is important.

On the other hand, the theory is fair to an extent as it promotes the well being of the greatest number of people. His is the basis of the health care system: care is provided to improve the health of the population. If more money is spent on health services, a greater amount of people are healthier therefore happier. If a person has been severely ill and the doctors have decided that he will die in the next 2 years. For the period in-between he is going to be bed ridden unable to do anything else. This theory can be used to take a decision that euthanasia is a correct act. For the reason that the amount of pain his family, friends and himself have to suffer will be reduced. This will also allow saving money for the medicine meaning it will be useful for another person has a higher chance of recovering form the illness.

Lastly, I support the statement that Utilitarianism is a ‘pig philosophy’. This is because it focuses on the majority portrays human beings as animals that are emotionless. It does not focus on the motive and intentions and so rejects the principle of treating people with intrinsic value.

Other Papers Like How Fair Is the Judgment That Bentham’s Utilitarianism Is a ‘Pig Philosophy’ or ‘Swine Ethic.’ (10 Marks)

Access the Claim That ‘the Main Function of Education Is to Maintain a Value Consensus in Society’ (20 Marks)

619 words - 3 pages experience, and the more responsibility they have for the outcomes. Also Bowels and Gintis point out that success is not entirely related to intellectual ability e.g. the pupils who fit in and conform will do better then whose whom express attitudes or display behaviour which challenges the system. In conclusion we can see that the main function of education is to not to maintain value consensus but that it is to teach the norms and values that enables people to get a job however tis is not equal for everyone as the education system does not have equal opportunity for everyone due to a variety of reasons.

Is the Death Penalty Is a Fair Punishment

2100 words - 9 pages possibility of parole, or the death sentence? Do you think a person should be killed for killing one person, if killing is wrong how can execution be right? Do you think it is cheaper to keep a man in prison for forty years or to be executed? Do you think the death penalty is a fair punishment, is capital punishment justifiable killing? What would you do if you a got a phone call on the night before Thanksgiving: (You) Hello, (Caller) I need you

Assess the View That, in Today’s Society, the Family Is Losing Its Functions (24 Marks)

1082 words - 5 pages ‘Assess’ Essay Planning Sheet Name: Essay Title: Assess the view that, in today’s society, the family is losing its functions (24 marks) | Underline or highlight the key concepts, terms and instructions, by identifying these key elements it will allow you to focus on answering the question. It is important to use relevant sociological terminology within the context of you essay. List

Using Material from Item a and Elsewhere Assess the Postmodernist View That the Nature of Religion in Society Today Is Becoming a Matter of Consumer Choice. (18 Marks)

784 words - 4 pages Postmodernists argue that in recent years, western societies have undergone major economic and cultural changes. We have changed from a modern to a postmodern society, and this has had a big impact on the religious beliefs that we hold. For example, in a traditional society, a person is born into a religion, they will learn about that religion from a young age and it will shape their personality and lives. However, in modern society, people have

Using Material from Item a and Elsewhere, Assess the View That Science Is the Dominant Metanarrative in Society Today. (18 Marks)

1021 words - 5 pages Many sociologists see science as a product of the process of rationalism, which is the view that knowledge must be based on reason or evidence. With this, some sociologists such as secularisation theorists claim that science has undermined religion by the way we think and see the world. Therefore due to these reason it has overtaken other metanarratives including political philosophies (such as socialism or conservatism), or nationalities

Is There Still A Role For Judgment In Decision-Making?

732 words - 3 pages broader perspective (for example, by asking "What information am I missing?"). I didn't Google the texts of these books, but there is no mention of the word "judgment" in their tables of contents or indexes, and I don't recall the use of the word in the texts. In fact, if there is a sense that one gets from all of this work, it is that we are our own worst enemies when it comes to making and implementing good decisions. We need tools to

The Xyz Co. Is Hiring Salespersons. Due to the Existence of Asymmetric Information, the Firm Has Decided to Pay the Salespersons a Fixed Hourly Rate That Is Independent of How Much They Sell or Their...

2744 words - 11 pages Q2:The XYZ Co. is hiring salespersons. Due to the existence of asymmetric information, the firm has decided to pay the salespersons a fixed hourly rate that is independent of how much they sell or their ability to sell. Explain what type(s) of asymmetric information problem(s) may take place and how can they be addressed. You are expected to illustrate your answer using relevant diagrams and/ or equations. ECN256 ASYMMETRIC INFORMATION

To Gloss, or Not to Gloss, That is the Question –

1205 words - 5 pages speak out against the authority that is placed upon the men in fourteenth century England whether or not they accept the idea of being subservient to men both in the domestic sphere and the religious sphere. Chaucer, in one of his tales, slips a strong willed and powerful female villainess but is she really a villain or merely a fierce, independent woman willing to stand outside of the social standards that dictate what is feminine and what is not

To Entertain or to Learn? That Is the Question

1139 words - 5 pages To Entertain or to Learn? That is the Question. In her essay, “Thinking Outside the Idiot Box,” published in Slate on March 25,2005, Dana Stevens argues against what Johnson has to say about how television makes us smarter. Stevens explains how television is just a way for Americans to become overly obsessed with shows that have no value to the way our brains work. She wants her readers to know that television is just a form of

TO (blank) or not to (blank) that is the question

592 words - 3 pages To jump or not to jump that is the question,So what if it's a transgressionI would rather burn in hellAt least then it will be without choice that I sufferI could leave this treacherous place,Which makes me think of deathAnd continue to a place of tortureYet I don't know if there is such a placeSo it is when life turns to the worstThat I decide to place my bets that there will be no such placeOr should I wait this anger, pain and suffering outIs

Sales Ethic Is an Oxymoron

1816 words - 8 pages whether they should be given or marketed even though they are against the interest of the society. ’Right to abortion’, ’Right to distribute hate literature’, ‘Right to own weapons’ and ‘Right to use polluting and noise making automobiles’ fall under this category(Valentine and Fleischman 2008). It is quite evident from the above that there is a conflict between the accepted axiom of marketing and interests of the society and individuals (Lindsay

Related Essays

Reptilia: Testudines: Carettochelyidae Carettochelys Insculpta This Is A Species Account On The Carettochelys Insculpta Or Also Known As The Fly River Turtle Or The Pig Nosed Turtle

1663 words - 7 pages , leaves and roots off of the riverbank vegetations. The fruits of figs and pandanus that fall into the water are regularly eaten. The pig-nosed favorite food item is the ribbon weed (Valisneria spiralis) which grows in the water. Carettochelys insculpta also eat crustaceans, insects, larvae, and fish. A large range and amount of food is found throughout the rainy season, when vast majority of the habitats are flooded (Groombridge, 1982).FIGURE

Is It Fair To Say That By And Large The Internet Is Unregulated? Why Or Why Not?

1978 words - 8 pages Research Topic: Is it fair to say that by and large the internet is unregulated? Why or Why not? Internet is basically the world-wide network that connects computer worldwide via TCP/IP protocol for the purpose of exchange of information. At Global level, the Internet is highly unregulated. It lacks the common global authority that regulates the Internet at global level. Nations have law regarding what comes in and goes out through their

Considering The Consequences Is More Important Than Following The Rules (10 Marks)

694 words - 3 pages with the statement that considering consequences of our actions is more important than following rules because firstly, to consider consequences it means using our inner self conscience. Using our inner conscience is the most important thing to me when making a decision. I think this because conscience is greatly linked to morality, and it’s our inner voice, telling us what is right and what is wrong. Christians come to the conclusion that God

History Of The Utilitarianism Ethic Essay

3042 words - 13 pages visions on how the lands should be applied. Pinchot was for the democratic viewpoint for the use of nature to benefit as many people as possible, the utilitarian approach. Whereas Muir stood for nature and that nature is a place where we all go to understand the creation in its whole glory. Nonetheless, these theories began were on a collision course (Miller, 2013). These two viewpoints collided within the Yosemite National Park, within the Hetch