How Does The Nature Of Friendship Affect Our Moral Obligations

1326 words - 6 pages

With reference to Aristotle and/or Kant, explain the nature of friendship. How does the nature of friendship affect our moral obligations?

Friendship involves a relationship between two beings pertaining to the elements of freedom, choice and love; “an association of two persons through equal and mutual love and respect” (Kant 1965, p. 469). Friendships offer support, affection, companionship and a sense of connection with another being. Aristotle and Kant hold similar views on friendship and recognise that the notion plays a central role in a meaningful and happy life, and also has a profound effect on our moral obligations. As individuals, we experience three main types of ...view middle of the document...

The reasoning behind Aristotle’s conclusion is that the individuals involved are only party to the relation due to the pleasure they receive from it. “One does things intended to advance the wellbeing of the other, but only because he judges this to be a way of promoting his own interests. Such a relationship is not a friendship” (Alpern 1983, p.306). Thus there are no qualities present that are indicative of true friendship. Being absorbed by these superficial types of relationships can be harmful to one’s emotional and mental state as we are not nourished by the establishment of true connection with another being, rather we are overtaken by a hierarchical and superficial sense of connection (LaBreche 2010). We therefore begin not to concern ourselves with the wellbeing of the other party, and become somewhat incapable of forming meaningful connections which cement our personal morals (La Caze 2005).

Secondly the friendship of pleasure or taste references a reciprocal connection whereby one being supplements what the other is lacking and vice versa (Lynch 2005).
“These friendships are defective, and have a smaller claim to be called ‘friendships,’ because the individuals involved have little trust in each other, quarrel frequently, and are ready to break off their association abruptly” (Lynch 2005, p.78)
Aristotle does not mean to suggest that unequal relations based on the mutual recognition of good character are defective in these same ways. This type of friendship is exhibited mainly by people that are young as they are frequently concerned with their feelings in these developmental stages, and have a simple focus on the present moment (Aristotle 1997). In friendships of utility and pleasure the requisite affection will be insufficient to survive the demise of a friend’s usefulness or his pleasant qualities (LaBreche 2010). Friendship of pleasure is closely linked with that of utility as this type of friendship is based on gaining and feeling pleasure from the other person. As mentioned earlier, there are no real qualities present that represent a valued connection. This can only suggest that being involved in this friendship is only harmful for yourself and your moral obligations to yourself. Tastes, attitudes and feelings change, so people that are involved in this friendship are quick to make and break the friendship. Once they find no use for the other person, they can be disregarded.

The pinnacle of friendship for Kant is then the friendship of disposition; the most actualised form of connection with another individual which nourishes our sense of being and cements our morals and value systems.
“This friendship is the absolute sense in which we achieve complete communion with our friend and in which we are in agreement with regard to intellectual and moral principles. It is a disposition of feeling, rather than a disposition to actual service, and is typified by the confidence such friends have to reveal themselves...

Other Papers Like How Does The Nature Of Friendship Affect Our Moral Obligations

How Does Manipulation Of Language In The Media (Print, Online, Television, Etc.) Affect The Way People Behave?

1720 words - 7 pages How does manipulation of language in the media (print, online, television, etc.) affect the way people behave?Instruments of mass media play a very significant role in the lives of people; they get us information we have no means of acquiring otherwise. Through the use of print and electronic media, one can quite literally get in touch with the entire world. Marshall McLuhan, a well known entity in the world of media theory, termed media as the

"Winter" By John Marsden. Discuss The Theme Of Personal Growth In The Story. How Does This Affect Winter?

1060 words - 5 pages others. She starts to explore and build new friendships, though she still holds an air of caution around her. Winter meets Jessica while over at her house for dinner one night, and strikes up a rather strong friendship with her. They talk for ages and Winter finds that she may be able to trust Jessica. Winter shows just how much she had grown from feeling helpless and alone, when she accepts the position at the music college Jessica attends. The

The Importance of Moral Values in Our Life Essay

557 words - 3 pages Positive moral values are important because they allow you to have an overall feeling of peace and joy. Moral values can give meaning and purpose to your life. You are able to direct your behavior towards beneficial and fulfilling activities. When you live your life according to moral values that are based on honesty, compassion, courage, modesty, and forgiveness, then you can also form positive bonds with other people. Incorporating the moral

How Does Frost and Wordsworth Convey the Contrast of Innocence and Experience of Life Through Nature in Birches and Nutting?

822 words - 4 pages How does Frost and Wordsworth convey the contrast of innocence and experience of life through nature in Birches and Nutting? The contrast between innocence and experience is conveyed by Frost and Wordsworth in their poems Birches and Nutting. In Nutting, William Wordsworth uses the memories of him as a young boy going 'Nutting' as a metaphor for the journeys experienced in life which can withdraw our innocence as we mature. Birches, written

How Does the Mise En Scene in the Opening of Moulin Rouge Affect How We Respond to the Characters and Setting?

1367 words - 6 pages HOW DOES THE MISE EN SCENE IN THE OPENING SEQUENCE OF MOULIN ROUGE AFFECT HOW WE RESPOND TO THE CHARACTERS AND THE SETTING? The director conveys the personalities of the men and women through Costume. This technique is very effective because it really gives us a sense of society and the men and women’s positions within that. The women in Moulin Rouge wear very frilly dresses that are very revealing, colourful and bright. The can-can dresses

D1: Evaluate How Nature and Nurture May Affect the Physical, Intellectual, Emotional and Social Development of Two Stages of the Development of an Individual

1201 words - 5 pages The nature and nurture debate has been greatest debate in psychology over the centuries. Biologists will support the nature side of the debate while the environmentalist/behaviourists will support the nurture side of the debate. The two stages of development of an individual that will be discussed in this spread are adults and children. At the very beginning of development, infants are believed to inherit the capacity to learn how to walk

Hows Does Changing The Length Of Wire Affect Resistance?

1632 words - 7 pages OBJECTIVEFor this piece of coursework I have been asked to investigate into the resistance of wires when the length is changed.INTRODUCTIONThe objective for my coursework (as already stated above) is to investigate how changing the length of wire can affect the resistance.There are factors which can affect how accurate our expriment is come on four levels.As in any scientific experiment, there are always variables ( "likely to change or vary

How Does Social Networking Affect You Privacy

1516 words - 7 pages How does Social Networking Affect Your Privacy? Gerald Briceño Prof. Blanco English Group 90 Academic Reading April 16, 2013 Abstract This essay discusses the overall issues and changes that social networks have created in the current society. How the society has change because of technology is something that cannot be omitted. The social networks have many benefits that humans need to know how to make the most of them instead of

How Does Divorce Really Affect Children?

959 words - 4 pages How Does Divorce Really Affect Children? Divorce rates have risen in recent years. Right now 50% of American marriages end in divorce. While the causes are varied, the effects on children can all be categorized into four major groups including stress, maladjustment, long-term psychological and behavioral problems, and relocation with a stepparent and step siblings. Divorce is pretty much always stressful for children. Most children don’t

How Does Change Affect People at Work?

2219 words - 9 pages How does change affect people at work? What are some of the current forces for change in the workplace? What are the implications for HR managers? Introduction Organizational changes do not appear from themselves. For any process of performing something, there is a reason, and the process is the result of that reasons. Increasing globalization, rapid technological advancement, changing economic conditions and organization’s

How Does the Herbal Bed Explore the Conflict Between What Society Expects of Us and Our Inner Devices?

1233 words - 5 pages human desires and passions and what society believes to be morally correct. Weare confronted with a main moral dilemma that splits the audience between societies views and modern perspectives of Susanna. Our consideration of the main thematic concerns of truth, love and duty are vested in Susanna as she is the dominant character in the play and through her knowledge and her actions, she is able to reconcile truth in love, passion and desire. The

Related Essays

Does Censorship In Technology Affect Our Youngsters?

705 words - 3 pages increasing. Sadly, our direct society is affected by this as the youngster try to display what they see or hear through imitation. Studies further show that young children are most affected by what they see on television (Dritz, Russel 1996) as well as in video games. The Academy of Pediatrics says “More than one thousand scientific studies and reviews conclude that significant exposure to (technology) media violence increases the risk of aggressive

How Does Wealth Affect The Relationship Between The Characters In The Merchant Of Venice?

1303 words - 6 pages How does wealth affect the relationship between the characters in the play? “Money is like water. It flows in and out of our lives” The theme of wealth plays a very important role in The Merchant of Venice. Though it may not be surprising because Venice is an exciting, cosmopolitan setting for the play as well as a heart of european business in the Renaissance. Most character relationships in the play reflect on the theme of love and

How Does Nihilism Affect Hedonism? Essay

1628 words - 7 pages How does Nihilism affect Hedonism? Farid Guzman BKvt.3 Hedonism and Nihilism are two incredibly interesting philosophies, especially when studied in contrast to each other. Although by the simplest definitions they are opposites, they actually have a lot in common. In fact, it s entirely possible for one to occur as a result of the other. Both are very common in modern Western society, although for the most part extreme hedonists or

How Does Change Affect The People At Work?

908 words - 4 pages Q.1 How does change affect people at work? Managing Change : Change is Charming Embrace it ! A change means any process involving a difference in some feature of an organization at two points in time. Change is a fact of life for any organization. It is unavoidable that all organizations need to change their practice time to time as per requirement to remain in competitive market. In current scenario the organization who have made the changes