How Democratic Is The American Constitution

945 words - 4 pages

Nathaniel Sellis
American & Wyo Government
Dudley
November 12, 2011

How Democratic is the American Constitution Summary
Robert Dahl explains in the beginning of the book that he is not proposing changes in the American Constitution, but suggests changes in the way we think about our constitution. In this essay, I will explain the history of this American constitution, what Dahl suggests about the American Constitution, and my opinion about this book.
In the history of the United States, there are two factors that mark its constitutional history. For one thing, the rights of citizens were organized through limits to power, linked to a libertarian conception of liberal viewpoint. ...view middle of the document...

An instance is the majority electoral system where "the winner takes all". The difference between the votes and voices representing the people are the three majorities who are in the political system and the failure to assign clear responsibilities for each of the powers by failure. The point to fall back on is that because of the image, the ordinary people are actors within the institutional structure.
The breakdown of the political operation allows us to formulate through two working lines: the historical and comparative. Both have been studied under an idea that suggests a close relationship between design and performance. If current performance is not acceptable or if there are flaws in the design, reformulating the design would help achieve better performance in civil rights. The development of agreements and political decisions is consistently mentioned in Dahl’s goal for equality.
In the result going through the opinion of leaders trying to reach an agreement in writing, the principles contained anti-democratic articles involving both citizens and the separation of powers. The maintenance of slavery and the right to vote is not guaranteed, and the fear of a popular majority give responsibilities of government by another, induced into the body of electors as a method of presidential election, the second chamber is responsible for overrepresentation, either by unequal representation of small states as mechanisms of choice of the charges and weak limits established between the legislative and judicial branch. These issues were unacceptable to say that the original constitution was democratic.
After this historical overview, we compare four pillars of the current design structure: federalism (strong bicameralism and unequal representation in the Senate) (pg.98), the electoral system, the method of presidential election and the limits of judicial power in relation to the countries that have functioned without interruption. The overall conclusion is that the American system...

Other Papers Like How Democratic Is the American Constitution

How Was the Greatest Constitution and Government Formed

1883 words - 8 pages of being cherished and utilized. U.S. citizens have rights thanks to the original Bill of Rights, for example the right to free speech and the right to bear arms. The framers of the U.S. Constitution which is the basic structure of the American system of government. The U.S. Constitution is a written constitution, "it is the world's oldest written constitution still in force, drawn up in 1787, ratified in 1788 and inaugurated in 1789" (Powell

The Uk Government Is Constrained by the Constitution

855 words - 4 pages The UK government is constrained by the British Constitution Constitutions are fundamental rules that regulate how a state or any other type of organisation is supposed to be governed. A quote by the UCL Constitution Unit “Constitutions organise, distribute and regulate state power. They set out the structure of the state, the major state institutions, and the principles governing their relations with each other and with the state’s citizens

The Us Constitution Is No Longer Fit for Purpose

1642 words - 7 pages 'The US constitution is no longer fit for purpose'. Discuss (45marks)     Arguments  to  suggest  it’s  no  longer  fit  for   purpose:       Imperial  Judiciary.  When  drafting  the  Constitution  the  Founding  Fathers  intended   that  neither  branch  would  become  too  powerful,  however,  this  has  failed  and  the

American Dream and How It Is Presented

596 words - 3 pages her" (90). He remarks, because Lennie "[...] usta like to hear about it so much I got to thinking maybe we would" (90). Their very act of striving for the impossible is Steinbeck's way of showing how unattainable the American Dream had become for many Americans, especially during the time period of the Great Depression. While a century prior it seemed anyone could come to America, work hard, and see a tangible gain, the story of Lennie and

What Is The American Dream?

1515 words - 7 pages What is the American Dream, and who are the people most likely to pursue its often elusive fulfillment? Indeed, the American Dream has come to represent the attainment of a combination of goals that are specific to each individual. While one person might consider a purchased home with a white picket fence his or her version of the American Dream, another might regard it as the financial ability to start and operate his own business. Clearly

The Constitution In The Years Prior To The Civil War (DBQ From 1987 AP American History Exam)

741 words - 3 pages The Constitution: Unity or Disunity?The U.S. Constitution is looked upon as not only a legal bond, but as a unifying document that exemplifies the American desire for "life, liberty and the pursuit of happiness." From 1787, the year of its creation, until 1850, the Constitution helped to uphold these ideals, by ruling with the majority, but protecting the minority, as well as acting as a symbol of unity for the growing nation. In the decade

How the President Is Selected

688 words - 3 pages How the President is Elected Steven Turlington, Pamela Lemon POL/115 3/31/2015 How The President Is Selected In school, we’re often taught that anyone can grow up to become the President of the United States. This is true, but with certain exceptions. For instance, a qualified Presidential candidate must be at least 35 years old. He or she must have been born in the United States. Finally, he or she must have lived in the United States

An Exerpt From The Book "Down To Earth Sociology" It Explains How The Existence Of Poverty Is Benefical To The Affluent In American Society

807 words - 4 pages poverty in American society.1.)With the existence of poverty, society's "dirty-work" will be done. This is the physically dangerous or dirty, dead-end, menial jobs that exist in every society that nobody really would choose to have. The poor have no other choice than to take these jobs at low wages. Many businesses and companies actually depend on the poor to do so. Such places of business include restaurants, hospitals and factories. Many of

The American Dream This Essay Is About The American Dream Throughout The Years Of American History

1103 words - 5 pages 1.In general, the American Dream is John Winthrop's theory of "A City upon A Hill." John Winthrop was a Puritan and had a theory of building a perfect society. He wanted people to admire and take after his perfect community. To me, it means to have the idealistic country so people could admire and take after. To have every country envy us yet not despise us. The dream is that America has to be superior to the world and that our flag is a symbol

Problems With The Articles Of Confederation That Were Addressed By The Constitution And The Importance Of The Issue Of Power Centralization In American Politics Today

1643 words - 7 pages decentralization and those who support centralization still exist despite the fact that the tenets of federalism and the American Constitution call for compromise between the two opposing factions. Indeed, the Americans with Disabilities Act is just one of many issues that provoke feelings of hostility between states' rights activists and people who want the central government to be the dominant force in American politics. Although the Constitution is

How the American Mortgage Crisis Spread to Europe

1727 words - 7 pages spread to other countries, and the global financial crisis was a fact. In this paper I will start off by explaining the background for the mortgage crisis in the US. Afterwards I will try to elaborate how this could spread across the world and make the crisis global. Finally I will discuss why this crisis has been so slow in resolving itself since many countries still struggle in the aftermath of the crisis. My thesis is that: The decline in

Related Essays

How Politics Shaped The Constitution Essay

660 words - 3 pages How politics shaped the Constitution? Since the beginning of the colonial period, historians can easily see various political characteristics that became influential in the development of America. The original thirteen colonies acquired enough experience with self-governing and this led to the formation of autonomous states. At a failing attempt to unify, the Articles of Confederation were created for the young nation. Still, soon

The American Constitution{The Bill Of Rights}

980 words - 4 pages other countries around the world gotideas from this. I believe that this document till to this dayexpresses the ideas in the hearts and minds of the Americanpeople. Thomas Jefferson outlined four universal truths that thecolonists and American people have in common: equality, life,liberty and happiness.The next document to be discussed is The Bill ofRights. The Bill of Rights came about due to pressures to amendthe constitution in order to define

Why The United States Constitution Is Unique

854 words - 4 pages . Yet, somehow, our constitution turned out to be unique.The first difference between our inspiration and our reality is, our constitution is down on paper. As the Anti-federalist and the Federalist battled out the pros and cons of this document, and as people were making decisions, Thomas Jefferson placed these infinite words on paper. He did not allow the foundation of our new nation to be a weight bared by the minds and memories of the people

How Food Is Viewed In The American Culture

1886 words - 8 pages “means through which human beings construct reality” (Counihan, 1992, p. 55). Counihan advocates for the importance of studying food rules by explaining that knowledge about how food is viewed in our culture can do three things: improve understanding of other culture’s food rules, allow nutrition education programs to mesh with these rules, and reveal an aspect of society that helps maintain our current stratification system, which has not been