Honest Othello Essay

4895 words - 20 pages

"Honest Othello: The Handkerchief Once More"
Critic: Michael C. Andrews
Source: Studies in English Literature 1500-1900 13, no. 2 (spring 1973): 273-84.
Criticism about: Othello

[(essay date spring 1973) In the following essay, Andrews examines the different accounts that Othello gives of the handkerchief's origins in Othello, maintaining that the first account is true and that the second account is false. The critic contends that Othello changes his story in order to downplay his superstitious beliefs, which would have been viewed negatively by the Venetians.]
The fact that Othello gives two different versions of the history of the fatal handkerchief has, predictably, not passed ...view middle of the document...

ii.215-218).4
Although critics have offered ingenious interpretations whereby the substitution of Othello's father for the "Egyptian" and the omission of any mention of the magical properties of the handkerchief become fraught with significance, it seems to me that all attempts to explain Othello's words to Desdemona as prevarication are liable to the same criticism Nevill Coghill so devastingly levels at T. S. Eliot's reading of Othello's suicide speech. To Eliot, of course, Othello's final speech is an "exposure of human weakness" rather than an expression of "the greatness in defeat of a noble but erring nature." After quoting the speech (V.ii.339-357), Eliot offers his influential analysis:
What Othello seems to be doing in making this speech is cheering himself up. He is endeavouring to escape reality, he has ceased to think about Desdemona, and is thinking about himself ... Othello succeeds in turning himself into a pathetic figure, by adopting an aesthetic rather than a moral attitude, dramatizing himself against his enrivonment. He takes in the spectator, but the human motive is primarily to take in himself.
"I do not believe," Eliot concludes, "that any writer has ever exposed this bovarysme, the human will to see things as they are not, more clearly than Shakespeare."5 To this Professor Coghill replies, with I think unassailable logic, that Eliot's interpretation is unworkable in the theater: "What tones of voice, what move or gesture, can an actor use to suggest a Bovarist cheering himself up?" And how is the audience supposed to determine "whether Othello is cheering himself up for being so gross a fool and a failure, or whether he is cheering his audience up by showing once again, and at the last moment, a true flash of that nobility for which they had first honoured him?" Moreover, as Professor Coghill points out, Eliot's Shakespeare would have to be considered a remarkably clumsy dramatist:
For if Shakespeare had wished to convey the "terrible exposure of human weakness" that Eliot sees in Othello's speech, he could very easily have made this single purpose plain, unless he was a bungler, or quite indifferent to the effect he was creating. For if Mr. Eliot is right, the better this speech is spoken and acted, the more it must deceive the audience; and this is, in effect, conceded by Mr. Eliot, who says Othello "takes in the spectator."6
The handkerchief speech seems to me an analogous instance. How are we to know that Othello is fictionalizing?7 For whether one says that Othello is speaking symbolically and is really "asking Desdemona to restore to him the sacredness of love,"8 or simply trying "to cover up the real reason for his disproportionate passion over such a trifle,"9 the lines are designed, in Eliot's phrase, to take us in. To adopt Professor Coghill's argument, "the better this speech is spoken and acted, the more it must deceive the audience";10 the more, in short, we are willing to accept the handkerchief as an...

Other Papers Like Honest Othello

Shakepeare - Discuss how Iago is able to manipulate Othello's opinion of Desdemona and move him to jealousy so quickly. By Kala Harvey UK spellings

641 words - 3 pages him. Othello, as a soldier, is used to trusting his officers. Othello feels he has no reason to doubt 'honest Iago.' Iago plays upon this role that he created for himself.'I humbly do beseech you of your pardon / for too much loving you.'As a solider, Othello must make judgements and act quickly, this may explain why Othello is moved to jealousy so rapidly. Othello is also a man with a temper.'My blood begins my safer guides to rule / And passion

Othello - Critical Analysis

1291 words - 6 pages 'Othello' William Shakespeare's 'Othello' demonstrates that an interpretation of 'Othello' can be affected by studies of critical theories. Critical theories in the play mainly explore gender differences and racial tensions, through particular themes and language techniques. Othello's, different ethnic background provides a stable platform for probing ideas of racial conflict and the construction of well-developed yet opposing female

Jesus Christ

2411 words - 10 pages ) Othello shows his calm and solider ability of not showing stress when Iago tells him the Desdemona is cheating on him. He just tells Iago to go away, and when Iago is gone is the time that Othello starts contemplating his situation with Desdemona. (Act 3, scene 3) Trusting: Even though Othello is a solider that has been in many dangerous encounters his is still trusting of people, and trusts Iago. He think Iago is a honest man that he can trust to

Othellos Downfall

1446 words - 6 pages thinks him honest and has placed great trust in him and therefore he becomes more easily manipulated by him, the more Othello trusts Iago the more lies he can tell in his favour. Iago ingratiates himself to Othello and appears to be the good guy Othello is a foreigner and is culturally naïve, he is not from Venice and so doesn’t have much knowledge of Venetian culture. Iago uses this to his advantage by telling Othello he knows of Venetian woman

How Does Iago Attempt to Poison Othello Against Desdemona and Cassio and to What Extent Is Iago's Plan Working

1436 words - 6 pages can only assume that these words really hit home for Othello as for someone to say this about their own daughter it must have some truth within it. Iago says ‘men should be what they seem/or those that not to be would they seem none’ this is an important quote as in this piece of text Iago is once again try to provoke a negative response from Othello In a way in which he says that cassio may seem to be honest and loyal (reasons why Othello

Othello essay summary

1665 words - 7 pages him. I’ve done a great deal of thinking and I have a general idea of whom and what I will use against Othello in order to bring him down. I will be the God without mercy while I demonstrate myself as the honest, loving friend toward Othello and all of his associates. Othello has just been wed to the fair Desdemona. Roderigo, a fool who will play a role in Othello’s downfall, is deeply in love with Desdemona. I will use his love and

Othello

873 words - 4 pages You Are Who You Hang Out WithThey say what people don't know won't kill them yet in this case, it did. Throughout the play "Othello" there are two characters that consistently have a hold of the reader's attention, Othello himself and his right hand man, Iago. Iago is someone Othello has a high level of trust for, someone he calls a friend. Othello is a kind hearted, honest soldier and strategically intelligent with battles at that. Although

Theme Of Deception In "Othello"

894 words - 4 pages very important in the contribution to the story because Iago is able to use Desdemona's deception of her father as some base that she is being unfaithful to Othello.Deception is shown throughout "Othello" by many characters, most notably Iago. Desdemona also deceives her father. Through deception, Iago creates the appearance of good, which ultimately fools the people around him into thinking he is loyal and honest. The basis of Iago's success comes

Analysis Of Iago Character In Shakespeare's "Othello"

1328 words - 6 pages , manipulating people for his own pleasure. His character is quickly established as corrupt and sly as he pretends to be a supporter of Othello but in reality, is secretly scheming against him. Iago achieves this easily as his great ability to play the part of the "loyal ensign" renders his facade more than convincing. Othello believes "honest Iago's" every word and begins to rely on him for information. Iago's jealousy of Othello's position is more

Othello's Hidden and Obvious Illusions (Final Essay)

1443 words - 6 pages believes the illusion that "honest Iago" is his friend. Iago and Cassio's friendship is also illusionary. it is always part of Iago's plan to frame Cassio for having an affair with Desdemona, but he says, feigning friendship, "I had rather had my tongue cut from my mouth / Than do offence to Michael Cassio," and goes on to say, "Cassio's my worthy friend." In reality Iago hates Cassio as much as Othello, because he received the promotion that Iago

Othello Essay

1349 words - 6 pages he schemes to bring down and take revenge upon Othello, he hides behind the ironic guise of “honest Iago”. The reason why this guise is needed is because in order for Iago to be able to manipulate Othello and persuade him to do his bidding, Iago needs to earn Othello’s trust by being acting the role of someone who is honest and believeable, “The Moor is of free and open nature, That thinks men honest that but seem to be so, and will be tenderly

Related Essays

Write An Essay Accounting For The Difference In Othello's Responses To The Challenges Of Brabantio's And Iago's Attacks On His Person And Marriage To Desdemona

1300 words - 6 pages admits that he hates Othello ? "I hate the Moor" and reveals that he is going to destroy Othello by making use of Othello's trusting nature and blind faith in him.He holds me well:The better shall my purpose work on him (lines 383-384)The Moor is of a free and open nature,That thinks men honest that but seem to be so,And will as tenderly be led by th'noseAs asses are. (lines 392-395)Before Act Three Scene Three, Iago had prepared the background for

Reputation In Othello Essay

692 words - 3 pages Reputation plays a big role in the play Othello written by Shakespeare. Iago uses his reputation as an honest man to deceive Othello and everyone else. Othello's reputation also plays a big role throughout the play. Cassio's changing reputation has a big part in the outcome of the play as well. Iago's reputation played a key role in the play. Everyone thought of Iago as an honest man. "O, that's an honest fellow", "You

Literature Review For Dating Violence

628 words - 3 pages . "Make the Moor thank me, love me, and reward me; for making him egregiously an ass." (II.2 lines 302-303)Just as everyone views Iago as "honest Iago" everyone holds Othello in high regards. We see how wrong the characters can be as they do not see the true evil inside Iago, we are implored to think that Othello truly is evil as well.Early in the play Iago realizes that Othello's idea of honor is intertwined with his concept of justice. Othello, more

How Does Iago Plant The Idea Of Desdemona’s Infidelity In Othello’s Mind, And How Does He Make It Grow?

1067 words - 5 pages , “Why did I marry? This honest creature doubtless sees and knows more, much more, than he unfolds.” Upon leaving, Iago asks Othello to notice whether Desdemona insists on Othello giving Cassio his lieutenancy back. Of course, Desdemona’s innocence and willingness to help a friend becomes a sign of infidelity in Othello’s mind with Iago’s manipulation. Later in the play, when Iago sees that Othello is “eaten up with passion”, he grabs this