This website uses cookies to ensure you have the best experience. Learn more

High Involvement Management Comparison Essay

2543 words - 11 pages

Comparative study of high-involvement and non-involvement management
Michael Triplett
Grantham University







Abstract
A comparative study between the positive and negative aspects of both high-involvement and non-involvement management styles. Pointing out how one strategy may be used over the other based on a company’s management needs. Determining which management style plans works in the short term and which works best in the long term. Non-involvement management primarily works best in the short term. This management style does not spend money on extensive training of employees which increases capital in the short term on the company’s balance ...view middle of the document...

This frees up middle and upper management to work on innovative strategies to keep ahead of competitors. This management strategy is achieved in a five step process; selective hiring, extensive training, decision power, information sharing and incentive compensation.
In a non-involvement structure the decision making authority is handled by upper management and implemented by middle management. Lower management and associates are not empowered to make decisions on daily operations. Upper management has to ask questions for example, whether workers want to participate in management decision making or if management wants to allow lower level managers to carry out daily management level decisions like approving vacation time, in order to decide the level of non-involvement strategy to use.
Determining which management style to use is based on how management plans their short term or long term strategies. Costs can be reduced in the short term by using non-involvement management which does not invest in their people capital. Success for a company can be achieved in the long term by using high-involvement management which invests in the employees from management to associates. It is a matter of purpose and goals.
High-involvement management is effective when the following combinations are used; selective hiring, extensive training, decision power, information sharing and incentive compensation. Selective hiring is a product of taking samples of large amounts of applications and reviewing them with specific selective requirements. “Large pools of applicants are built through advertising, word of mouth, and internal recommendations. Applicants are evaluated rigorously using multiple interviews, tests, and other selection tools. Applications are selected of skills and fit with culture and mission.” (Hitt, Miller, & Colella, 2011, p. 27). “In 1993, for example, Southwest Airlines received about 98,000 job applications, interviewed 16,000 job applications, and hired 2,700.” (Pfeeffer & Veiga, 1999, p. 40) Any company that plans on success will want to put forth the effort to hire the right people for the right positions.
Extensive training for new hires is required or they cannot be expected to perform jobs to the expected levels. Asking a new hire to perform without a scope or direction could lead to issues, so in a high-involvement structure proper training is expected. “New associates and managers are thoroughly trained for job skills through dedicated training exercises as well as on-the-job training. They also participate in structured discussions of culture and mission. Existing associates and managers are expected or required to enhance their skills each year through in-house or outside training and development. Often, existing associates and managers are rotated into different jobs for the purpose of acquiring additional skills.” (Hitt, Miller, & Colella, 2011, p. 27). Socialization into the culture of...

Other Papers Like High Involvement Management Comparison

Strategic Change Management Essay

679 words - 3 pages type of stakeholder in the planning of the change is best explained by referring to the following graph. Figure 1 Stages of stakeholder involvement in change processes Source: Change Management Toolbook (2010)  On the basis of graph above, employees and managers as the main internal stakeholders at Company need to be involved in change planning process

Organizational Performance Management System: Exploring the Manufacturing Sectors

3721 words - 15 pages time which accelerates the continuous organisational learning process. Emphasis on people: organizational initiatives The rapidly changing business environment engenders difficult challenges in designing and implementing effective performance management systems in organisation, for the management. The performance management system needs be integrated with the strategies of the organisation to enable high degree of success. Therefore, several

Extracurricular Activites

2457 words - 10 pages gathered from a multitude of sources and previous research. The data and research has shown that there is a positive relationship between the two factors; as a student’s involvement increases, so does his or her grade point average. To look at this relationship more closely and exact, the relationship between a student’s involvement in high school athletics and their grade point average was examined. Once again, the research said that there is a

Human Resorces Practices

1747 words - 7 pages – necessary to achieve a high level of performance • Four types of key processes – Design processes – Production/delivery processes – Support processes – Supplier processes AT&T Process Management Principles • Focus on end-to-end process • Mindset of prevention and continuous improvement • Everyone manages a process at some level and is a customer and a supplier • Customer needs drive the process • Corrective action focuses on root

Mktg 3010 Final Exam Study Guide

666 words - 3 pages Break Even | = | Fixed Costs | | | (Unit Sales Price-Variable Costs) | | | | * Consumer Behavior: describe the 5 steps, high vs. low involvement 1. Need Recognition 2. Information Search 3. Evaluation of Alternatives 4. Purchase 5. Post-purchase behavior * Diffusion of innovation: describe each group on the adoption curve * Marketing Research: primary vs. secondary data, qualitative vs

Citibank Indonesia

599 words - 3 pages lower management levels within the bank, allowing for an effective planning process that is proactive. It allows for smaller divisions within the bank to communicate their opportunities, resource needs, constraints and risks; their involvement within the process from the bottom-up allows for the consideration of all perspectives. The process implemented at Citibank facilitates top management oversight, allowing for preactive reviews to be taken

Implementing A Program For Single & Working Parents

1254 words - 6 pages reported.” (Gould Fall 2011). The study examined the number of school age children having a supportive biological parent involved in their child’s education, and comparison of a child without parent involvement. The conclusion of the study resulted in statistics showing that the data wasn’t close. Children who have parental involvement simply do better in class and in future education beyond high school. The study also showed that one parent

Health Care Operations Management Roles and Goals

636 words - 3 pages this does not mean physician-dominated. Successful operations management promotes physician involvement and provides the tools necessary to deliver the high quality patient care needed to be a successful organization (Henderson, 1995). Thriving teams have members who share a vision created through open, honest, and sincere communication (Henderson, 1995). Exceptional operations management will continue the flexibility to meet the ever-changing

Mn3153B Six Sigma

3207 words - 13 pages SIX SIGMA REPORT QUALITY 2009/10 MN3153B 23 June 2010 Table of contents 1 INTRODUCTION 1 2 SCOPE 1 3 SIX SIGMA 1 3.1 Evolution of Six Sigma 1 3.2 Concept of Six Sigma 2 3.3 Implementation Roles 3 4 SIX SIGMA AND ISO 9000 4 4.1 ISO 9000 4 4.2 COMPARISON 5 5 SIX SIGMA AND TOTAL QUALITY MANAGEMENT (TQM) 5

The contemporary workplace: changes and challenges

3580 words - 15 pages employee involvement has taken various forms, transforming from traditional worker participation and involvement in organizational decision making processes into the modern empowerment approach. The approach of employee empowerment involves providing employees with a significant amount of flexibility and freedom to make decisions pertaining to work without direct involvement of the senior management. This new concept of leadership is in contrast

Brana Equity and Brand Extension

2638 words - 11 pages , nationally or in the international market. Use of Best Practice * The brand name itself should add value to the product. * The band management should be ready to provide high quality service seven days a week 24 hours to enable customers to fruitfully use the product continuously. * The product should match with international quality standards, even if it is for local sale, as it must be able to successfully face international

Related Essays

Parent Involvement In Schools Essay

1696 words - 7 pages Literature Review: Parental Involvement in Schools Parental involvement in schools has been an intense issue since many years. The results of this effort have been heavily addressed in educational research. According to research, high parental involvement is greatly beneficial to children as it leads to higher grades and standardized test scores, improved behaviour at home and school, and better social skills and adaptation to school. Parents

A Qualitative Research Report On Parental Involvement As A Protective Factor During The Transition To High School

690 words - 3 pages A Qualitative Research Report on Parental Involvement as a Protective Factor During the Transition to High School by Cozetta Walk EDD 9300 Methods of Inquiry Nova Southeastern University September 20, 2010 A Qualitative Research Report on Parental Involvement as a Protective Factor During the Transition to High School Introduction As adolescents move from the smaller middle school setting to the larger and more sundry

Resource Shortage: Clean Water Essay

1175 words - 5 pages construction of the infrastructure and its management.Institutional frameworkThe private sector, when involved in the management of public utilities, has shown its capacity to provide efficient water services. However, private sector involvement in the public sector may require institutional reforms that allow stakeholders to work together for more effective water management. Financial practices must be realigned to support the sustainable use of

Mexico Management Practices Essay

2364 words - 10 pages Shift? MUHAMMAD MIZANUR RAHAMAN & OLLI VARIS The Mexico’s issues with water have been well documented in comparison with globally accepted water management principles. *The key aim of this series of global water events is to enable multi-stakeholder participation and dialogue to influence water policy making at the global level, thus assuring better living standards for people all over the world and more responsible social behaviour towards water