Heroic Values Of Achilles Vs. Aeneas

690 words - 3 pages

Homer’s Iliad and Virgil’s Aeneid are two great classical epics of Greek and Roman mythology. Both poetries convey heroism, pride, love, fate and duty. However, Homer focuses on his hero Achilles at the end of the Trojan War and Virgil focuses on his hero Aeneas after the Trojan War; eventually becomes the founder of a new Roman civilization. Besides the fact that they fight on the opposite sides of the Trojan War, the major difference between these two heroes is their ideas of who they are. Achilles stands as a symbol of self-serving person, while Aeneas is a symbol of self-sacrificing.
Homer portrays Achilles as a selfish and revengeful warrior. Achilles decides not to fight for Greek when king Agamemnon takes his battle prize Briseis away. However, Achilles allows Patroclus to wear his armor. He also instructs Patroclus to drive Trojans back from Achaeans’ ship but not to take over the city as it is only Achilles to win. His selfishness and self pride ...view middle of the document...

But Achilles continues to spoil his body until King Priam comes with ransom and begs for Hector’s dead body. This behavior shows his merciless character. At the end of the Iliad, Greek wins the Trojan War, but Achilles dies. To die in a battle will raise one’s fame. Achilles’ character shows the typical Greek hero, who would die gloriously at a young age rather than no fame. He is more of a fierce warrior and a ruthless enemy. His merciless character leaves him with no respect for the other warriors he fights with.
Aeneas, on the other hand, is more civilized than Achilles. His is dutiful and wise. He is not selfish as Achilles; he concerns about the goodwill of all Trojans. When Troy loses the Trojan War, he turns his thoughts to his family and his people. He goes back to find his wife. Eventually, he returns to the hill without his wife, where more Trojan refugees are waiting for his lead to find a new home. He chooses his people over his wife. He thinks for the greater cause, not for his personal feelings. Not only that, he is a lot more pious than Achilles. When Mercury tells him that he has to leave Carthage and found the Roman race, he leaves Dido without hesitation. He puts his duty first before his own feelings. While traveling through the Underworld to locate his father, Anchises, he shows Aeneas that he is destined to become the founder of the new Roman Empire. Aeneas returns to the land to fulfill his destiny and sails for Laurentum, where he will build his great city Rome. Thus, he becomes the true leader for Roman race.
Achilles and Aeneas are both extremely good warriors throughout Iliad and Aeneid; however while Achilles is vicious, Aeneas isn’t. Where Achilles wants destruction, Aeneas yearns for peace. Even though, Achilles and Aeneas are both heroes to their own nation, they are extremely different. Achilles is a great warrior for the Greeks; meanwhile Aeneas is not only a great warrior but also a leader of Roman. Although they both live around the same time period, their different cultures influence them in different diversity. Achilles’ arrogance and selfishness let him die in Trojan War. On the other hand, Aeneas’ intelligence and piousness let him survive the Trojan War and made him the founder of Rome.

Other Papers Like Heroic Values of Achilles vs. Aeneas

Hector Vs. Achilles Essay

1661 words - 7 pages and Achilles fulfilled different aspects of the code based on their personal strengths and weaknesses, but Hector surpassed Achilles as the more heroic of the two characters. Although both men were strong leaders with similar values, their words and actions in everyday life and their own interpretations of heroism created enough of a gap that Hector was shown as the greater hero.Hector and Achilles were very similar in their actions on the

The Iliad - "Achilles' Rage" Essay

685 words - 3 pages Journal Essay #3 When the reader first opens Homer's epic poem The Iliad, the author's very first line states the poem's main premise: "Achilles' rage" (1); if that doesn't tell the reader anything, it's also the title of the first book. However, I've noticed that many people still find it difficult to determine who the heroic protagonist is in The Iliad. That's because the audience today doesn't believe that their view, of what constitutes a

The Iliad Is a Great War Text

2091 words - 9 pages receiving the insults of his comrades—first Glaucus and then Aeneas. At the end Hector stands up to the mighty warrior Achilles, even when he realizes that the gods have abandoned him, and finally gets killed. Does the fact that Hector run away from Achilles makes him less than a leader, just like some people believe that Achilles is not a real leader because he abandoned the battle at one point due to his anger against Agamemnon? In my opinion the

Aeneid

1362 words - 6 pages “furor” overwhelms her to the point where she takes her own life. Aeneas on the other hand, struggles with the conflict of public vs private duty, but eventually overcomes it. He realizes that his duty is to his own fate, and not to his selfish interests. Throughout The Aeneid, the main characters are all unknowingly instruments in a chess game of the gods. Venus and Juno’s private feud is battled over the expense of mortals. Aeneas, who

Who is more heroic, Odysseus or Achilles?

520 words - 3 pages , Odysseus is much more heroic than Achilles. Throughout both the Iliad and the Odyssey, Odysseus showed more cunning and acts of bravery than Achilles. Both men did make an attempt to avoid fighting in the Trojan War, however, neither succeeded. After Odysseus was tricked into serving the Greeks, he was sent to recruit Achilles. Disguised as a peddler, he approached Achilles, who was dressed as a woman hiding among the maidens, and displayed

Imitations in Virgil's Aeneid

2002 words - 9 pages his crew in danger; he betrays his wife at home in Ithaca and eventually returns to his country without his men. On the other hand, Aeneas values duty and is on a homecoming journey not for himself, but for the people and the future of his country. Mercury has told him that he must travel to Italy to found the new empire of Rome and he is willing to sacrifice personal desires for this mission, “the tall rooftops of Priam would remain, my hand

The Trojan War

559 words - 3 pages The Greeks besieged Troy for ten years. It was said that the gods took great interest in the war. Hera and Athena still resented Paris for not giving them the Apple of Discord, so they helped the Greek side. Aphrodite assisted the Trojans. Zeus also favored the Trojans, but tried to remain neutral. Eris and her brother Ares helped both sides because they loved war.In the tenth year of the siege, Agamemnon took Achilles' female prisoner, Briseis

Death of Hector

2060 words - 9 pages structure of Homeric composition, exemplifies the themes, plot and character development. The Death of Hector typifies the attitudes of Mycenaean Greek culture as this book explores the heroic nature of this society, especially when the archetypal heroes are involved in one-on-one warfare, as demonstrated by Achilles killing Hector. Throughout the epic, Homer explored many themes, including the glory of war, military values over family and longevity

Achilles and Beowulf

537 words - 3 pages Alex Kane February 7, 2009 Honors English IV – 2nd period Ms. Kleckner Beowulf/Achilles: A Tale of Two Heroes The story of Beowulf and the story of Achilles are both epic stories that involve heroic narratives and have mythic potencies. They participate in supernatural battles which most of the time, determines the fate of their nation. They also share the common characteristics of having extraordinary powers, ways of confronting

Classics Paper

1207 words - 5 pages -887)he can go . This privilege is not given to all of the heroes even Hector is not able to see the eventual fall of Achilles during his own death. This is a gift given to Patroclus for fighting so bravely and proving to the Gods that he is indeed worthy of heroic status. The prophesy from Patrolclus comes after Hector mocks him for trying to take his city. Hector speaks like Patroclus is a child, laughing at him for even considering that he could

Iliad Review

1272 words - 6 pages The story of the Iliad begins towards the end of the Trojan War. Chryses, a Trojan priest, is trying to get his daughter (Chryseis) back from Agamemnon. Chryses prays to Apollo, who sends a plague on Achaeans army. After nine days of plaque, Agamemnon agrees to return Chryseis and take Briseis instead. Achilles becomes angry and he and the Myrmidons would no longer fight with Agamemnon. Achilles also prays to his mother, Thetis, to ask Zeus that

Related Essays

Homer, Virgil & Milton Essay

903 words - 4 pages Homer, Virgil and Milton Homer, Virgil and Milton’s use of allusion in their literature is apparent and most likely educational. They all have clear and recurring parallels between their works. Particularly complex are the allusions to Achilles, which appear in the portrayals of both Aeneas and Turnus. W. S. Anderson, in his influential article1 on Vergil's use of the Iliad, has argued that although Achilles is initially invoked as a model

It's About How One Handles Their Mistakes

1283 words - 6 pages Achilles. Seen in Book 18, this great Greek fighter acknowledges his arrogance for withdrawing himself from the war and sending his comrade Patroklos, to his death. Achilles and Patroklos shared a mentor-mentee relationship where Patroklos admires this great warrior, however by Achilles displaying such selfishness, his heroic status diminishes. After recognizing the disgrace of his actions, Achilles assures his fallen comrade, Patroklos that he will

Hero As A Reflection Essay

3633 words - 15 pages that created him. The ideals of every culture were shaped by the social conditions of the time and therefore different attributes became valued. To different degrees, the hero in a work is a result of not only the culture from which the hero comes, but also the culture of the author. Cultural values are reflected in both the actions of a hero and his motivations. As heroes, Achilles, Aeneas, Beowulf, and Roland reflect the values of the

The Aeneid Essay

1002 words - 5 pages ever had happen. Aeneas just got out of a war and saw that he could fall in love with the queen and rule this city with no challenges to be faced with. He’s just doing what every other heroic figure would do in all the other readings we had read. Although the relationship of Dido and Aeneas stretches only through one book, this is where Juno causes Dido to commit suicide over the love of Aeneas. Aeneas arrives on the shore of Libyan and meets Dido