Herman Melville's Billy Budd The Tragedy Of Billy Budd

579 words - 3 pages

The Tragedy of Justice in Billy Budd


      Charles Reich's assessment of the conflict in Billy Budd focuses on the

distinction between the laws of society and the laws of nature. Human law says

that men are "the sum total of their actions, and no more." Reich uses this as a

basis for his assertion that Billy is innocent in what he is, not what he does.

The point of the novel is therefore not to analyze the good and evil in Billy or

Claggart, but to put the reader in the position of Captain Vere, who must

interpret the laws of both man and nature.


      Reich supports Vere's decision to hang Billy. In defense of this he

alludes to a famous English court case, in which three men were accused of

murder. However, ...view middle of the document...

I agree with Reich's notion that Vere was

correct in  hanging Billy, and that it is society, not Vere, who should be

criticized for this judgement; for Vere is forced to reject the urgings of his

own heart and his values to comply with the binding laws of man.


      First, the moral issue aside, Captain Vere had no choice but to convict

Billy. As captain of a ship under pressure of war and the constant threat of

mutiny, Vere had to act swiftly. Also, as captain, Vere had the responsibility

of making sure the laws were strictly enforced, including the Mutiny Act.

Although Vere knew in his heart Billy was innocent, Billy's actions had to be



      For Vere to have acquitted Billy would mean that he had placed the

divine law of nature above the laws he was bound to enforce as captain of a

British ship. Although this would have been morally right, who is to say where

to draw the line? This rhetorical question is what Melville wants his readers to

think about. Melville could have easily written in the plot that Vere went along

with the captain's suggestion to call witnesses. With the testimonies of Dansker,

the afterguardsman, and Squeak, Billy could have been cleared of the mutiny

charge. But I agree with Reich that Melville wanted to use Billy as an example

of the flaws in the laws of society; that they do not take into account the laws

of nature. However, until we reform our laws in such a way that we cannot be

punished for something out of our control, we cannot expect the laws to be

interpreted that way.




Charles A. Reich, "The Tragedy of Justice in Billy Budd," Critical Essays on

Melville's Billy Budd, Sailor, pp. 127-143



Other Papers Like Herman Melville's Billy Budd - The Tragedy Of Billy Budd

Billy the Kid Summary&Presentation Essay

1176 words - 5 pages ? Billy the Kid has been described as a vicious and ruthless killer, an outlaw who died at the age of 21, not before raising widespread destruction in the New Mexico Territory. It was said he took the lives of 21 men, one for each year of his life, the first one when he was just 12 years old. He was a rebel without a cause who killed without reason, but a young man who lived in a violent world where knowing how to use a gun was the difference

The Billy Beane Case Study

931 words - 4 pages The Billy Beane Case Study 1. Based on the “Billy Beane: Changing the Game” case, explain how and why the Oakland A’s economic situation after 1995 shaped its: a) Compensation strategies In the world of major league baseball, the Oakland A’s defied the laws of baseball economics. The team spent only $34 million (the 2nd lowest payroll) had won 102 games and lost only 60 in 2001. On top of this, they finished first in their division and

Comparison Of Billy Elliot And Grease

2122 words - 9 pages The musicals Billy Elliot and Grease present both conventional and unconventional representations of gender throughout. Both musicals also seem to obscure the message of the underlying gender stereotyping issues by overshadowing them with elements such as music, dance and costume. Men have been stereotyped as dominant, strong, brave and aggressive. Also there is an image of men being portrayed as harder workers than women and supposedly the

Characterisation of Billy in E. Annie Proulx's 'Postcards'

560 words - 3 pages Characterisation of Billy in E. Annie Proulx’s Postcards Although Billy, as the first victim of the changing face of America in the opening of the novel, is a character who appears just momentarily, her impact on the course of the narrative is profound. Much of our reading of Billy comes from the scenes in which she is already dead, which highlights the sense of loss of a character so crucial to the story. On one level of course she is

Movie Reviews Of The Legend Of Baggervance(By Robert Redford), I Am Sam(By Jessie Nelson), And Some Like It Hot By (Billy Wilder)

894 words - 4 pages Some Like It Hot is a 1959 comedy film directed by Billy Wilder and starring Marilyn Monroe, Tony Curtis and Jack Lemmon. The supporting cast includes George Raft, Joe E. Brown, Pat O'Brien and Nehemiah Persoff. In 1981 it was re-release and in 2000, the American Film Institute listed Some Like It Hot as the greatest American comedy film of all time.When Chicago down and out musicians Joe and Jerry witness a mob shooting, they escape to

Tragedy of the Commons

717 words - 3 pages DJ Diakite PLTC 171 Professor Richter Tragedy of the Commons Analysis The Tragedy of the Commons is an effective metaphor to understanding the exploitation of global property resources by private producers. Its flaws as a metaphor stems from the gross assumptions it makes on human behavior and motivations. When taken at face value, the metaphor can be used to explain broad resource issues that nations are still dealing with today, such

The Tragedy Of Macbeth

961 words - 4 pages to Macbeth is probably Malcolm. Malcolm is the rightful heir to the throne and leads the army that takes Scotland back. Macduff plays a small role until the end, but he is important because he defeats Macbeth in battle. The story is a tragedy of a Scottish nobleman and war hero named Macbeth. In the beginning, Scotland is at war with Norway, and the battle is won by Scotland against all odds because of the brave Macbeth. As Macbeth and his

The Tragedy Of Globalization

834 words - 4 pages The Tragedy of Globalization Globalization has been around for over a thousand years and is not a new development of western nations. Globalization is simply the transferring of ideas from one society to another. Amartya Sen the author of “How to Judge Globalism”, and Sen believes that the whole world benefits from global cooperation, and there is uneven distribution of benefits. He believes another downside of globalization is the

The Tragedy of the Commons

3320 words - 14 pages agree towards a solution. The main problem in this case -and in many others- is how best to limit the use of natural resources so as to ensure their long-term economic viability. Some people recommend that the state control most natural resources to prevent their destruction and overuse; others recommend that privatizing those resources will solve the problem. The reality is not that simple; the logic of the tragedy of the commons depends on a

Tragedy Of The American Indians

2039 words - 9 pages Tragedy of the American Indians Today there are more than half a million Indians in the United States. They are still trying to adapt to the white civilization, being in all stages of development. There are a few Indians who have made money from natural resources found on their lands, but there are still thousands who live at close starvation levels. Many live in almost complete isolation from Americans who are not Indian, but there are

Casy Study Of The Tragedy Of Common

5411 words - 22 pages Discussion on Tragedy of the Commons | This paper intends to discuss the basic theories within the scope of the tragedy of commons, especially from the ethics perspective. In addition, the paper also explicitly explores two possible ways to solve the tragedy of the commons, the free market solution and the socialism solution, and applies these ways to a real case of Euro’s Tragedy. In the end, referring to Elinor Ostrom’s theory in 2009, the

Related Essays

Meaning Of Absolutes In Billy Budd

2791 words - 12 pages Melville’s Meaning of Absolute At first glance, Herman Melville presents Billy Budd as an unambiguous story whose plot follows an innocent sailor striving to survive on a military vessel while being exposed to malicious characters and violent punishments. Melville portrays his protagonist as purely innocent and naïve, a child incapable of understanding, let alone imposing any harm. Melville pens his antagonist as the innately evil and

Free Billy Budd Essays: A Deconstructive Reading

1578 words - 7 pages same thing when I first noticed the chapter in Barbara Johnson's book on Billy Budd. But I began to read it anyway and I soon found myself in the throes of a critically different excitement! The first thing that truly grabbed my attention was a remark Johnson makes apropos of the following quotation from Melville's story: "innocence and guilt personified by Claggart and Budd in effect changed places" (62). The narrator says this apropos of Billy

The Case Of Billy Tushoes Essay

1072 words - 5 pages Reneging on a Promise Billy Tushoes recently received an offer to join the accounting firm of Tick and Check LLP. Billy would prefer to work for Foot and Balance LLP but has not received an offer from the firm the day before he must decide whether to accept the position at Tick and Check. Billy has a friend at Foot and Balance and decides to call her to find out whether an offer is forthcoming. His friend explains the delay is due to the

The Case Of Billy Tushoes Essay

740 words - 3 pages The case of Billy Tushoes is a common ethical dilemma that many people are faced with when considering the acceptance of a job. Billy has been put in a difficult situation to make a decision to keep the position he has already accepted with Tick and Check LLP, or to break his promise and commitment with Tick and Check and take a job with his preferred employer of choice, Foot and Balance LLP. Many times in life we are faced with a decision to