This website uses cookies to ensure you have the best experience. Learn more

Hate Crime Laws: Are They Constitutional?

1681 words - 7 pages

Are hate crime penalty enforcement laws constitutional?

“That’s Gay.” If you are around teenagers today, that is a phrase you will most likely hear very often. It is not necessarily meant as a homophobic or hate-filled remark, and most of the time it is referring to an object, an idea, or a conversation; things that obviously have no sexual orientation. But now, according to a bill passed by the senate, it could almost be considered a hate crime. Many people support the widening of hate crime laws, assuming that with stricter penalties, the crimes will lessen. In June, 2004, Senate passed a bill that received a record number of votes, passing 65-33, including 18 Republicans voting yes. The ...view middle of the document...

However, most hate crimes are carried out by otherwise law-abiding citizens who see little wrong with their actions. Alcohol and drugs sometimes help fuel these crimes, but the main determinant appears to be personal prejudice. New FBI data shows that the number of hate crimes reported in 2003 increased slightly, from 7,462 in 2002 to 7,489 in 2003. The 7,489 hate crime incidents reported to the FBI in 2003 involved 8,715 separate offenses affecting 9,100 victims (Kelotra). By far the largest determinant of hate crimes is racial bias, with 51.3 percent of all hate crimes falling under this category, followed by Religion bias (17.9 percent), Sexual Orientation bias (16.5 percent), Ethnicity bias (13.7 percent) and Disability bias (0.4 percent) (Kelotra).
According to FBI Uniform Crime reports, there were 30,606,332 crimes reported in 2003. So is it fair that 7,489 of them were treated with top-priority because of the person’s race, religion, or sexual orientation? The Southern Baptist Convention’s ethic agency doesn’t think so, and they’re doing their best to try to reverse the bill that widens hate crime laws. “Existing laws in every state cover real crimes of violence, vandalism and property destruction, which should be punished to the full extent of the law” they argue (Toalston). Others argue that the bill is simply redundant. "What is really being punished, as [critics] see it, is a criminal's thoughts, however objectionable they may be. The actions - incitement, vandalism, assault, murder - are already against the law" (Haberman).
For every group against the defining of hate crimes, there are twice as many groups who feel it is more than necessary. "Hate crimes are message crimes. They are different from other crimes in that the offender is sending a message to members of a certain group that they are unwelcome" (McDevitt). While the constitution promises us free speech, it doesn’t allow us to use that as a weapon to put certain groups in fear. As much as everybody has a right to voice their opinion, everyone also has a right to live their life in peace without discrimination.
     Another critical issue in hate crime is that studies indicate that hate crimes appear to have more serious psychological effects on the victims and the communities they represent than other crimes. Research shows that victims of hate crimes many times link their vulnerability to their personal, cultural, or spiritual identity. The result of this is that victims of hate crimes often suffer greater and more permanent emotional trauma than other crime victims. So while a victim of assault could potentially get over the act, a person who was assaulted because of their race can never just “get over” their skin color and the trauma it brought.
A very important effect this bill may have, some fear, is that it may prohibit some preaching against homosexuality from a scriptural standpoint. "Religious liberty would be...

Other Papers Like Hate Crime Laws: Are They Constitutional?

Hate Crimes Essay

567 words - 3 pages , which is a plan on how they will tackle hate crime and offer better support for the victims of the hate crime. The government is working to increase the number of victims and witnesses who steps forward to report the crime, often victims of hate crimes never contact local authorities because they are in fear. The government will like to bring more hate crime offenders obtain legit justice leading to successful outcomes when a hate crime is

A World of Hate Essay

1222 words - 5 pages establish dialogue across racial, ethnic, cultural, and religious boundaries. Education, awareness, and acceptance of group differences are the cornerstones of a long-term solution to prejudice, discrimination, and bigotry. Hate crime laws and effective responses to hate violence by public officials and authorities can play an essential role in deterring and preventing these crimes in which it will create a better society for all Americans

The Many Forms Of Hate Crimes

879 words - 4 pages The Many Forms of Hate Crimes The issue of hate crimes has greatly affected the way in which people interact. A hate crime is defined as any act of violence or verbal slashing of a person based upon race, religious belief, or one's sexuality. There are several other grounds for determining a hate crime depending upon guidelines in written laws. Hate crimes are said to have originally derived from the unjust treatment of Jewish cultures

Hate Crimes in the United States

1266 words - 6 pages replaced the Hate Crime Statistics Act to include both physical and mental disabilities. When the developed of the guidelines for hate crimes data that is collected recognized that hate crimes are not separated. Profile of Hate Crimes: The types of persons that are committing these types of hate crimes are those of their perceived biases. They are committing crimes of murder, forcible rape, aggravated assault, simple assault, robbery, burglary

Hate Groups in America

1634 words - 7 pages Hate Groups in America Abstract This essay will be exploring hate groups that exist in America, and some of the victims that have been a target from these groups. Hate groups commit violent crimes against people because of their demographics or the organizations that they represent. A hate crime is a violent criminal act that is not justified; it is committed to inflict pain and suffering. While hate groups exist in America, the crimes

Persuasive Speech: We Must Take A Stand Against Hate Crimes

1770 words - 8 pages current laws in effect regarding hate crimes are limited. Additionally, victims who experience a hate crime suffer much more traumatically than victims of other crimes do. Hate Crimes not only affect the individual, but their entire community as well. According to, last updated November 2, 2014, "The current law does not protect three groups that are particularly vulnerable to physical attack: women, the disabled, and

Hate Crimes

794 words - 4 pages tolerance values instilled by said hate crime laws. Intolerance is not an issue to be dealt with by the United States government. It is an issue to be addressed by the surroundings of individuals whether it is parents, organizations, or churches.      As immoral as it may seem, people can be racist or intolerant if they want to be. It is their choice for what ever reason to be so and the government should not be involved in

Shake Me Down

1541 words - 7 pages hate in pure loathe and rage. Perhaps it because love and hate is ultimately a feeling that evolves through experience of society In Andrew Sullivan’s New York Times Article “ What’s So Bad About Hate?” The question of whether making laws of morality should limit the personal rights and feelings of an individual are discussed and analyzed. In another New York Times Article Steven Pinker, “ The Moral Instinct”, the idea of how to measure ideas

Hate Crimes

1444 words - 6 pages (Uniform Crime Report) from the FBI databases in 2008 there were 7,783 hate crimes reported. Of the reported crimes religious, racism, and sexualism are a few that cause so many communities to be divided against each other. Religious discrimination is defined as treating a person or a group differently because of what they do or don’t believe. Freedom of religion is an individual’s constitutional right. We should be free to express our religion

Cause of Terrorism Against Israel

956 words - 4 pages skin. Woman could not speak unless spoken to or even obtain groceries without a written pass from their husband. Woman who have rebelled, have sadly been killed. The new laws are demolishing the Terrorists belief system, threatening them, eating away at them every day that the law is upheld. This breeds hate, hate for the Israelis, hate for what they stand for, hate for what they have done. To them, revenge is all they can accomplish, Terrorists

Diversity Research Paper

4285 words - 18 pages of wanted to be considered equal. While most groups that have high statistics for hate crimes want to prove the stereotypes wrong and stay away from the bad connotation, the black community as a whole seems to think that violence and extreme behavior is the way to get people to pay attention. In order to decrease the crime against black people simply because they are black, we have to stop treating them like they are different. Black people can’t

Related Essays

Hate Crime Laws Essay

2348 words - 10 pages States Code (28 USC.Sec. 534. 31 Oct 2011). The Hate crime laws are too general it’s hard for prosecutors to decide if they have enough evidence to pursue a hate crime charge. Deputy Dist. Atty. Tom Glazer stated, “There are many obstacles to prosecution. Suspects are not always identified, many incidents are not actual crimes, and it is often difficult to prove the bias motivated an illegal act” (Lynch). In one incident, a group of young people

Brainstorm Essay

385 words - 2 pages nonminority. The Institute of Medicine reported an unequal treatment, which concluded racial and ethnic disparities in healthcare exist. 2. Should hate be considered a crime? What arguments support the use of sentencing- enhancement penalties for hate crimes? What arguments oppose such statues? Are hate crime laws likely to deter offenders and reduce crime? Hate should be a crime to a certain extent. If the statue of the hate turn violent then

The Objectivity Of Law Essay

1031 words - 5 pages and hate crimes have broke out everywhere. I feel as far as the attacks relating to the concept of the living body, it shows how laws can change and be manipulated into breaking our constitutional rights, yet in a way where it does not really seem like we are being violated, but rather “protected.” The purpose of a person that is being accused having rights is to protect them from being punished for a crime they did not commit. Our

Hate Crimes Essay 567 Words

567 words - 3 pages violent hate crimes may suffer from more psychological distress, depression, stress, anxiety, anger than victims of other comparable violent crimes 2. Survivors of violent crimes, including hate crimes, are also at risk for developing a variety of mental health problems including depression, anxiety and posttraumatic stress disorder B. What effects can a hate crime have on communities 1. They affect community cohesion and social