This website uses cookies to ensure you have the best experience. Learn more

Free Billy Budd Essays: A Deconstructive Reading

1578 words - 7 pages

A Deconstructive Reading of Billy Budd


Billy, who cannot understand ambiguity, who takes pleasant words at face value and then obliterates Claggart for suggesting that one could do otherwise, whose sudden blow is a violent denial of any discrepancy between his being and his doing, ends up radically illustrating the very discrepancy he denies.

- Barbara Johnson, p. 86


With Barbara Johnson's splendid Critical Difference we are willy-nilly plunged into deconstruction. At the moment I shall not attempt to explain this radical and highly subversive critical mode, except to say that what you are about to see is an example of it. At the moment you may well ask (being, as ...view middle of the document...

Johnson's first item on the agenda is to put into question Billy's innocence. (Melville himself tells us that "innocence was [Billy's] blinder" 49.) She asks us to consider Billy a kind of "reader" (Johnson calls him a "literal reader" 85). Billy is a "literal reader" in that he seems to take things at face value. He seems to believe, in fact, that things are what they seem to be. If Claggart appears to be nice to Billy (and he does) then Claggart must be nice to Billy (he isn't, of course). Implied in Johnson's argument at this point is the notion that the innocence we all seem to value in Billy is perhaps less than valuable. First of all, though he appears almost prelapsarian, Billy is really postlapsarian all the same. Here is how Melville himself puts the case:


Though our Handsome Sailor had as much of masculine beauty as one can expect anywhere to see, nevertheless, like the beautiful woman in one of Hawthorne's minor tales ["The Birthmark"], there was just one thing amiss in him. No visible blemish indeed, as with the lady; no, but an occasional liability to a vocal defect. Though in the hour of elemental uproar or peril he was everything that a sailor should be, yet under sudden provocation of strong heart-feeling his voice, otherwise singularly musical, as if expressive of the harmony within, was apt to develop an organic hesitancy, in fact more or less of a stutter or even worse. In this particular Billy was a striking instance that the arch interferer, the envious marplot of Eden, still has more or less to do with every human consignment to this planet earth. (17; italics mine)


Johnson is quick to make much of that apparently innocent word "striking" in the quotation above. For that's exactly what Billy does when his "vocal defect" is most evidently operative in the story - that is, when Claggart repeats the false accusation to his face. At this point, to do as much justice to Johnson's argument as possible, we must turn to Claggart himself for a moment. You see, what Johnson claims Claggart questions in Billy is precisely the potential discrepancy between seeming and being. In other words, is Billy what he appears to be - that is, "innocent"? Interestingly enough when Billy apparently accidentally and innocently spills soup in Claggart's path at one point in the story, Claggart says "Handsomely done my lad! And handsome is as handsome did it too!" (34). Johnson is quick to point out that this invocation of the famous proverb is not an affirmation but a denial of its significance in this case. In other words, Claggart suspects that Billy is not what he seems to be. Claggart, of course, proves himself right (dead right, if you will) concerning Billy. But the matter is not as simple as it appears. Nevertheless, as Johnson points out, Claggart's view of Billy is perfectly reasonable. When Billy is impressed into the man-of-war, when he is taken from a merchant marine named "The Rights of Man," he says goodbye to the...

Other Papers Like Free Billy Budd Essays: A Deconstructive Reading

Sexual Orientation Essay

1613 words - 7 pages English 2131 5 December 2009 The Recurring Theme of Male Sexual Orientation: An Examination of Billy Budd, Sailor by Herman Melville During the late 1800s, homosexuality was not widely accepted. Men were identified as strong and worked hard for their families and if they identified themselves as homosexuals they “might risk falling into a camp of outsiders” (Phillips 2000). Women of that time were not considered “real citizens” and

Herman Melville's Billy Budd - The Tragedy Of Billy Budd

579 words - 3 pages Squeak, Billy could have been cleared of the mutiny charge. But I agree with Reich that Melville wanted to use Billy as an example of the flaws in the laws of society; that they do not take into account the laws of nature. However, until we reform our laws in such a way that we cannot be punished for something out of our control, we cannot expect the laws to be interpreted that way.   Bibliography   Charles A. Reich, "The Tragedy of Justice in Billy Budd," Critical Essays on Melville's Billy Budd, Sailor, pp. 127-143    


776 words - 4 pages The setting of a story often helps a reader to feel as if he were actually a part of the story. Franz Kafka and Herman Melville are two authors who chose specific settings for their stories. The settings they chose help to place their characters into perspective and to understand the problems they face. Franz Kafka’s Metamorphosis and Herman Melville’s Billy Budd take place at different points in time and in different settings; Metamorphosis

Meaning of Absolutes in Billy Budd

2791 words - 12 pages Novel. Ed. Abby H.P. Werlock. New York: Facts on File, Inc., 2006. Web. Melville, Herman. “Billy Budd.” Billy Budd and Other Tales. New York: New American Reference Library, 2009. 5-105. Print. Rollyson, Carl, Lisa Padock, and April Gentry. “Billy Budd, Sailor.” Critical Companion to Herman Melville: A Literary Reference to His Life and Work, Critical Companion. New York: Facts on File, Inc., 2007. Web. Sterling, Laurie A. “Billy Budd, Sailor.” Bloom’s How to Write About Herman Melville. New York: Chelsea House, 2008. Web. Yannella, Donald, Ed. New Essays on Billy Budd. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press. 2002. 4-121. Web.

Deconstructing Dracula

1512 words - 7 pages reading of a literary text, in this case Bram Stokers Dracula, and how this way of reading can enhance our understanding of the text. Deconstruction aims to unravel the text itself in search of no one universal meaning, but a multitude of possible interpretations. Dracula reigns in uncertainty, with deconstruction thriving on the texts every contradiction. This essay will sample a few of the points in the text that characterise a deconstructive

Capitalist Posttextual Theory

652 words - 3 pages Capitalist Posttextual Theory 1. Eco and deconstructive narrative If one examines capitalist posttextual theory, one is faced with a choice: either reject deconstructive narrative or conclude that context is created by communication, given that narrativity is equal to art. Therefore, the subject is interpolated into a subcultural patriarchialism that includes language as a reality. Bataille’s essay on capitalist posttextual theory


1881 words - 8 pages In his Best Selling work Slaughterhouse-Five, Kurt Vonnegut attempts to elucidate the power of free will by using the protagonist, Billy Pilgrim's life as an exemplar to illustrate how free will is questionably nonexistent. Vonnegut exploits Billy's abduction of the Tralfamadorians. Through his abduction Billy discovers the Tralfamadorian's view on life. The Tralfamadorians see in a fourth dimension, time. Because of this they are capable of

The Blurb For A Kestrel For A Knave By Barry Hines

1097 words - 5 pages The Blurb for A Kestrel for a Knave by Barry Hines Works Cited Missing I don't think the blurb for the novel "A Kestrel for a Knave" by Barry Hines gives you an accurate idea of what the book is about. The blurb is over-simplified and makes it seem like there is no hope for Billy. In this essay I will show the writer's

Herman Melville

536 words - 3 pages Billy Budd. He also wrote about things that he knew about. He wrote about his own experiences. The one thing that he loved, and knew the most about was whaling. During Herman’s childhood he lived in the good neighborhoods of New York City. In 1832 he suffered tragedy when his father died after trying to cope with the stress of debts and misfortunes. After a short time in a business house in New York City, Herman determined he needed to go to

Short Story

738 words - 3 pages you go off playing.” “Don’t worry about me younger brother,” smiled Billy. Hermie headed for school, while Billy dawdled along. Picking up a stick and running along a fence, making a rat-at-ty-tat sound. “I think I need a little sea air,” Billy said aloud to himself, as he headed for the beach. Scruff, the town’s care-free stray dog, walked alongside of Billy. “Hey, what do you want Scruff? You’re not coming with me you

Characterisation of Billy in E. Annie Proulx's 'Postcards'

560 words - 3 pages Characterisation of Billy in E. Annie Proulx’s Postcards Although Billy, as the first victim of the changing face of America in the opening of the novel, is a character who appears just momentarily, her impact on the course of the narrative is profound. Much of our reading of Billy comes from the scenes in which she is already dead, which highlights the sense of loss of a character so crucial to the story. On one level of course she is

Related Essays

Free Essays Ode To A Nightingale

642 words - 3 pages Ode to a Nightingale   One must be armed with a little knowledge of Greek mythology before taking on Keats; Hyperion, for example, is filled with allusions to Milton's Paradise Lost.  After reading and re-reading Ode on a Grecian Urn I decided that it would be best to only comment on Ode to a Nightingale (because I'm baffled with Keats).  I found him very hard to understand.  You can't just sit down and read Keats

Free Essays Escape From Reality In A Farewell To Arms

818 words - 4 pages Escape from Reality in A Farewell to Arms   In Ernest Hemingway's A Farewell to Arms, Fredric Henry gets involved with Catherine Barkley to escape the insanity of war. Frederic loves Catherine. Catherine loves Frederic. The extreme situation of war and fate allowed both of them to be thrown together and fall in love. This love for one another was an escape into another world for Frederic. It provided him emotionally with a private

Free Essays Characterization In A Farewell To Arms

1215 words - 5 pages perfectly a single emotion: they begin with it and end with it, and any scenes, characters, thoughts, or stylistic elements that might tend to weaken the dominant emotion are ruthlessly rejected" (Schneider 283). At first you tend to believe that Frederic is only talking about stopping his journey and getting off the train, but after reading the rest of the novel, it gives a new meaning to the passage. Catherine's death could be related to this

Free College Essays Anse As A Vulture In As I Lay Dying

774 words - 4 pages doorstep of the house waiting for her to die. He has no fear or sorrow about the death of Addie. Anse's restlessness comes from the anxiety of having to wait for Addie to die. He lingers there, like a buzzard, awaiting the moment when he will be set free (15). Anse already has plans for the future, that Addie is not a part of. He constantly reassures everybody that she has her mind set on going. Anse wants her to die. He has obtained everything