This website uses cookies to ensure you have the best experience. Learn more

« For Machiavelli, The Art Of War Is The Supreme Test Of Any Polity, Whether Principality Or Republic ». Discuss

3173 words - 13 pages

IR 3034: The Political theory of Peace and War.


FIRST ESSAY: « For Machiavelli, the art of war is the supreme test of any polity, whether principality or republic ». Discuss


Quentin Skinner once argued that even if “Machiavelli died nearly 500 years ago, (…) his name lives on as a byword for cunning, duplicity, and the exercise of bad faith in political affairs”1. Indeed, there is no denying that Machiavelli stands probably as one of the most controversial thinker in the history of political theory. In fact, Skinner even argued that “the charge of being a Machiavellian remains a serious accusation in the political debate”2.
As his ...view middle of the document...

Yet, saying that military power counts does not imply that politics found a supreme expression in war and violence. Eventually indeed, we will point out that, contrary to what is usually believed, Machiavelli stands today as one of the main republican thinkers in political theory and consequently, his contribution cannot be reduced to a fascination for military valour and expansion (II). We will try to understand particularly that, the key to Machiavelli’s thought relies on the idea that “powers have to be replaced by ordinary justice and reason, (…) but before the rule of law is in place, politics in the conventional sense of the art of ruling according to reason and justice needs the help of the ambivalent but powerful art of the state”4. This is basically the best way to understand that, according to Machiavelli, war is indeed extremely important for any kind of polity but not necessarily the supreme test or above all an ultimate target.

1° A clear role is given to war, conflict and political violence in Machiavelli’s thought

A) Virtue, violence and the art of war as the supreme knowledge for a ruler:

It is worth mentioning that, according to Maurizio Viroli, “most scholars have considered Machiavelli as the intellectual father of the theory that politics is essentially a matter of political power”5. Since reputation can be misleading, we should look at Machiavelli’s writings to see whether or not, for him, skills in the art of war were more important to the state and his rulers than anything else, and whether or not warfare can be understood really as a form of supreme test for “any polity”. Yet, first and foremost, it will be most useful to explain a central concept that can be found in his different works, i.e. virtù. We may notice first that Machiavelli, in the prince especially, had associated this particular quality almost exclusively with great political leaders and military commanders, in other words men of action, and not theorists. According to J. Hannaford, “these men are warriors, soldiers ad generals, virtuosi in the art of war”6. Indeed, Machiavelli tries to demonstrate the fundamental importance of the art of war, which is “the only art which is of concern to one who commands”7. According to him, “A prince should have no other object, (…), nor take anything else as his art but the art of war and its discipline”8.
From all these statements, we can infer that Machiavelli gave a major part to war and military in politics, as they are both identified as the most important things a ruler has to learn. According to Harvey C. Mansfield, we can even deduce from reading Machiavelli that “a prince who has the art but no state will often gain a state, while a prince who has a state but not the art will lose his state”9. Similarly, Mansfield reminds us that Machiavelli recommended the reading of Cyropaedia, a Greek classical text, where Xenophon suggests that the art of war is all a prince needs to know. Meanwhile, Isaiah Berlin...

Other Papers Like « for Machiavelli, the Art of War Is the Supreme Test of Any Polity, Whether Principality or Republic ». Discuss

Using Examples, Discuss the Ways in Which Any of the Following Can Be Analysed Either in Ideological Terms of the Construction of Gender or Race

1724 words - 7 pages bravery for putting other people’s safety and needs first. However his lack of commitment to his family shows him as somewhat of an emotional coward. This is shown when he volunteers himself without hesitation, for a suicide mission, even though they were looking for someone without any family or commitments. 24 is dominated by men, every woman represented in the series is made to feel unwelcome in his world. His wife for instance, gets

An Analysis Of "The Jerilderie Letter", To Determine Whether Ned Kelly Is A Hero Or A Villain. Liam Butler

796 words - 4 pages The Jerilderie letter would be almost completely obsolete for an historian attempting to assess whether Ned Kelly was a hero or a villain. An historian should look at society's response to Ned Kelly when searching for such information as the belief that someone is a hero or a villain is completely subjective, and the closest anyone can come to an answer is to reach a consensus. The Jerilderie letter can at most, give us information about Ned

Fall of the Republic

804 words - 4 pages decisions there is no need for the Democrats or the Republicans, everyone should just come together as one. The people of American need to wake up. If no one does anything now or soon our future as a country will get even worse. Hopefully when people watch Alex Jones’ documentary, The Fall of the Republic, people will realize that Obama and the government leader’s do not care about the citizen’s or the country, but only about the power. More

The Art of War and Oic

4520 words - 19 pages discrimination against the Muslims in all forms and manifestations. The Art of War is of vital importance to the state. It is a matter of life and death, a road either to safety or to ruin. Here under no circumstances can it be neglected. The book is not only standard reading for military theorists and many great generals throughout history but has also become increasingly popular among political leaders and those in business management

Essay On The Art Of War

450 words - 2 pages think of war, the first ideas that would come into our mind are chaos, pandemonium, disorder, and other words that could be attributed to destruction. Also, wars occur often because parties are fighting over something. In a business setting, same goals can be indicated. That is, to gain profits and subsequently overthrow or defeat competitors. Although it appears to be a simple goal, such objective can be achieved in different ways. Sun Tzu’s Art

The End Of The Republic

1207 words - 5 pages . She hoped that each nation would weaken the other; Egypt could then absorb both. This move saved Herod’s kingdom, for Octavin crushed the forces of Anthony and Cleopatra at the Battle of Actium and ordered their deaths. Herod met with Octavin and bargained to keep his life and throne. Through the years, Herod had rid himself of any possible claimants to the throne. He had playfully drowned his young brother-in-law Aristobulus, executed his

Discuss Whether Cross Cultural Research Supports the View That Gender Roles Are Innate or Learnt?

624 words - 3 pages Discuss whether cross cultural research supports the view that gender roles are innate or learnt? Cross culture research has had a major effect on the view point to whether gender roles are innate or learnt. It allows us to look at a wider population of people from all around the world and get a more general idea that can apply to more than one culture. The research done involving cross cultures also helps increase our understanding of the

What Is the Purpose of Business? Discuss

2757 words - 12 pages a world without business, it is crucial to know its purpose. Therefore it is the objective of this paper to examine in greater detail the nature and purpose of business and to demonstrate its importance to the whole world. “A business is any enterprise which makes, distributes or provides any article or service which the other members of the community need and are able and willing to pay for. “ 3 This is one of an abundant number of

Fall of the Roman Republic

744 words - 3 pages time, the laws that gave patricians exclusive rights to Rome's highest offices were repealed or weakened, and a new aristocracy emerged from among the plebeian class. The leaders of the Republic developed a strong tradition and morality requiring public service and patronage in peace and war, making military and political success inextricably linked. During the first two centuries of its existence the Republic expanded through a combination of

Decline of the Roman Republic

2426 words - 10 pages of the generals of the roman army would continue to rise. Sulla did not make the drastic reforms considered necessary to save the Roman Republic from its downfall, and thus only postponed for short time of his rule. There is great debate over whether the Roman Republic was better off with or without the reforms made by Sulla. Before his reforms there were civil wars and wide spread violence, there were multiple Consulships with people like

Senate of the Roman Republic

1144 words - 5 pages began the official containment of the cult throughout Italy [6]. The senate’s decree prohibited every aspect of the Bacchanalia. The decree forbid anyone possessing a place where festivals are celebrated and forbid anyone from being a Bacchantian. In line 24 of the decree the senate wrote, “if there are any who have acted contrary to what was written above, they have decided that a proceeding for a capital offense should be instituted against

Related Essays

The Art Of War Essay

1074 words - 5 pages Book Report on The Art of War by Sun Tzu Military Science 2020 “Stimulated disorder postulates perfect discipline; stimulated fear postulates courage; stimulated weakness postulates strength” (Tzu, pg. 20) “The Art of War” by Sun Tzu is a book that contains leadership lessons for everyone. The book was first written in 490 BC in the Kingdom of Wu. In 512 BC, he became the general for the King of Wu. The book contains thirteen chapters

The Art Of War Essay

1043 words - 5 pages Yangyang (Leon) Li Professor Bagdan Hosp 4060 Feb.4 2013 I. Author’s Purpose The Art of War is an ancient Chinese military treatise by Sun Tzu. It focuses on the importance of positioning in military strategy and factors that may affect the decision. The purpose of Sun Tzu is to tell how to position in military strategy in order to win the battles. II. Reaction 1) Chapter 5 Energy Sun Tzu said: The control of a large force is the

Discuss Marx's Theory Of Alienation And Assess Whether It Is Still Relevant In The Contemporary Workplace

2188 words - 9 pages Option 1 Discuss Marx’s theory of alienation and assess whether it is still relevant in the contemporary workplace. In a capitalism society of those days, workers worked solely for the profit and rarely any focus will be spared on if the products were of the social need. On top of that, while the social classing was still heavily emphasized, most of the employees were not given sufficient protection and the fundamental benefits as a

Did The U.S. Media Cause The Loss Of The War, Explain Whether You Agree Or Disagree With This Statement

1212 words - 5 pages . The most famous report on the Tet offensive was by CBS News reporter Walter Cronkite. In a special report, Cronkite declared that the War appeared to be in a stalemate and that the time had come for negotiation. He concluded his report with the famous remark “For it seems now more certain than ever that the bloody experience of Vietnam is to end in a Stalemate.” Based on the media reports from Vietnam, much of the American public