This website uses cookies to ensure you have the best experience. Learn more

Federal Regulation Of Marriage: A Study In Contradictions

3045 words - 13 pages

Federal Regulation of Marriage: A Study in Contradictions
With laws for and against same-sex marriage becoming so prevalent on the national scene in recent years, there has been much confusion, and on the part of congress, dictation on morals as to what constitutes “marriage” for purposes of federal law. Many state and federal regulations rely on a State definition of marriage for purposes of conferring rights and benefits to citizens. As promulgated, these regulations have a long-standing constitutional and jurisprudential basis. Such regulations were enacted to protect the spouses of accident victims, veterans, employees, and retirees. Congress, however, in enacting a federal ...view middle of the document...

In contradiction to these current regulations and past practices, Congress enacted the Defense of Marriage Act (“DOMA”), which added the following definition to the United States Code: “… [T]he word “marriage” means only a legal union between one man and one woman as husband and wife, and the word “spouse” refers only to a person of the opposite sex who is a husband or a wife.” (Defense of Marriage Act, U.S. Statutes at Large 2419 (1996): sec. 3; U.S. Code, Title 1, sec. 7).
Since the enactment of DOMA, however, five states (Iowa, New Hampshire, Connecticut, Vermont and Massachusetts) and the District of Columbia have come in direct conflict with the law by conferring full legal status to same-sex marriages (Urbina, 2010). Thus, a same-sex couple may be legally married in their state of residence but would not be recognized as such under federal law, or in any state that chose not recognize the marriage.
The sections of the Code of Federal Regulations that rely on the state law definitions of marriage are backed by a long history of constitutional jurisprudence founded on states’ rights, full faith and credit, equal protection and privacy laws. The constitutional underpinnings of such regulations are solid. DOMA’s contradictory attempt to undermine the long-standing legal bases for the way marriage is defined in the Code of Federal regulations should be resolved against DOMA and in favor of the regulations.
The Tenth Amendment expressly limits Congress's authority to enact legislation in areas traditionally reserved to the States: “The powers not delegated to the United States by the Constitution, nor prohibited by it to the States, are reserved to the States respectively, or to the people” (U.S. Constitution, 10th Amendment). Accordingly, “the States unquestionably do retain a significant measure of sovereign authority... to the extent that the Constitution has not divested them of their original powers and transferred those powers to the Federal Government” (New York v. United States, 1992, p. 156); The Tenth Amendment thus operates to confine Congress to its constitutionally-conferred powers. “Whether Congress has invaded the province reserved to the States by the Tenth Amendment is ... a question that must be answered by inquiring whether Congress has exceeded the limits of authority bestowed upon it by Article I of the Constitution” (Gillespie v. City of Indianapolis, 1999, p. 704).
The Supreme Court has recognized for more than one hundred years that domestic relations are the paradigmatic area of State, not federal, concern, and that marital status lies at the core of domestic relations law. “No one denies that the States, at the time of the adoption of the Constitution, possessed full power over the subject of marriage and divorce [and that] the Constitution delegated no authority to the Government of the United States on [that subject]” (Haddock v. Haddock, 1906, p. 575). Regulation of marriage is derived from...

Other Papers Like Federal Regulation of Marriage: a Study in Contradictions

A Christian's View Of Marriage Essay

1767 words - 8 pages A Christian's View of Marriage Some Christians believe that marriage should be the ultimate relationship. When two people get married they make a vow to stay in a life long committed relationship. . It is a Christian promise made before God and is significant and of great importance amongst all Christian denominations despite certain differences in opinions. However, sometimes a variety of different circumstances can

A Case Study Of Banks In Fiji

4467 words - 18 pages A CASE STUDY ON BANKS IN FIJI COMPILED BY: SHINAL PRIYANKA CHAND 1 INTRODUCTION Fiji has a well developed financial system that not only is secure and sound but has remained flexible despite the recent global financial crisis. The strong involvement of the banking industry to the Fiji Financial System has been a major factor in this regard. Over the years the Banks have invested heavily in

The Neccessity of a Marriage License

1294 words - 6 pages The Necessity of a Marriage License Jenna Haedike Professor Webster English 121 November 7, 2013 In the United States, when a couple decides to marry, there are many different ways a couple can choose to pursue their union. While some may choose to unite through holy matrimony and others may choose the secular route of marriage by a justice of the peace, documentation of said marriage, while elective, is an important legal step in

The Role of Federal Regulations in Corporate America

2823 words - 12 pages provide investors with ongoing information about the public companies (Beatty et al., 2008) and maintain a fair and honest market in securities transactions on the organized exchanges and in the over-the counter markets. The Act is designed to “prevent fraudulent, deceptive and manipulative acts and practices on the exchanges and in the over-the-counter market and authorizes the Board of Governors of the Federal Reserve System to regulate the use of

The Study of Motivation Is a Study in Why People Behave in a Certain Way

2004 words - 9 pages Managing People and Change Motivation The study of motivation is a study in why people behave in a certain way. There are four main theories of motivation Maslow’s hierarchy of needs, Alderfen’s modified need hierarchy model, Herzberg’s two-factor theory and McClelland’s achievement motivation theory. Maslow’s hierarchy of needs theory arranges five main levels of needs. Physiological as the lowest need, then safety, love, esteem

The Federal Protectionism Of Minority Rights In The United States

2398 words - 10 pages minority rights began to take shape, alluding to the federal protectionist opinion that he later formed; he wrote of the incident in Democracy in America, “Since the majority has the greatest prejudice against Negros, the judges don’t feel strong enough to guarantee them the rights the legislature gave them (Wallace, 2001).” Later in the nineteenth century, John Stuart Mill, a prominent British political philosopher, published his 1859 work, On

A Framework for Prudential Regulation and Supervision of the Financial Sector

5339 words - 22 pages A FRAMEWORK FOR PRUDENTIAL REGULATION AND SUPERVISION OF THE FINANCIAL SECTOR BY DR. OWEN JEFFERSON Recent developments in the financial sector has catapulted the issue of the safety and soundness of the financial system into the forefront of discussions in Jamaica. While not necessarily providing any consolation for us, it is important to note that this issue has also been plaguing many other countries and

A Study Of Law

2832 words - 12 pages , in this paper, I would like to see the chastity law from the view point of women because I study that there is gender inequality and the consequence problems of chastity law in Qing society. I also think that the Qing law served the interest of the women of the rich household but not the poor women. For example, it is hard for a common widow to survive while keeping chastity since they are economically weak. In one study, it mentions that the

A Study Of Co-Morbidity In Mental Retardation

1433 words - 6 pages behavioral disorder (26 %)4, mostly not based on any scale but rather the examiners expertise and the ICD-10 & DSM-IV diagnostic guidelines. A Taiwan study using a structured questionnaire indicated that nearly half (47.7%) of the subjects with MR had an associated co-morbid medical or psychiatric illness. A population-based study using a Learning Disability Register in the UK reported that the prevalence of epilepsy was 26% in adults with

A Study of Neologisms

3875 words - 16 pages neologisms have been found. On the other hand, large numbers of neologisms also reflect new things, new concepts and show us how out culture is evolving. This paper presents a picture of the definitions, characteristics and classifications of neologisms, elaborates the significance and purpose of this study based upon a historical view of neologisms. In addition, the thesis also offers an exploration of sources of neologisms by demonstrating the major

A Study On Commercial Banks In Kenya, Case Study Cooperative Bank Of Kenya

1814 words - 8 pages History OF COOP BANK 2013: Coop Bank is recognized as the Most Green Bank at the 2013 Energy Management Awards for achieving the fastest turnaround time for renewable energy and energy efficiency financing for SMEs and Large Enterprises, actively promoting “Green Financing” among clients and for being the bank with the largest pipeline of projects seeking green energy financing. 2011:  For a second year in a row the bank wins Best Bank in

Related Essays

Roles Of State & Federal Governments In Employment Regulation

1724 words - 7 pages Roles of State & Federal Governments in Employment Regulation Angela McIntosh Sullivan University Employment Law HRL404 Abstract This paper will provide an overview of the State and Federal regulations in employment and discuss relevant employment regulations. The findings will explain on how in today work environments that the business climate of companies seem to subject to a wide

The Impact Of Computer In Our Modern Days Organization ( A Case Study Of Federal College Of Education Technical Asaba, Delta State)

5420 words - 22 pages organization with special relevance to Federal College of education (Technical), Asaba. 1.3 THE SCOPE OF THE STUDY This study is to identify the impact of computer in our Modern day organization with Federal College of Education (Technical), Asaba as a case study. 1.4 RESEARCH QUESTIONS The following research questions were formulated as a guide in analyzing the impact of computer in modern organization. 1. Does the use of computer

History Of Accounting Regulation In Fiji

1584 words - 7 pages : » Adverse business conditions often cause companies resort to unethical practices | | | | | | | | | | Corrupt corporate executives are no better than common thieves when they betray their employees and steal from their investors." - John Ashcroft (US Attorney General), in August 2002. "WorldCom put extraordinary pressure on itself to meet the expectations of securities analysts."1 - A report filed with the bankruptcy court

Will Kyoto Work In A Federal System?

2596 words - 11 pages government who will respect the provincial jurisdiction on the issue. The Federal government has said no individual province will carry a heavy burden by itself and is calling for new and innovative technology to aid in green house emissions. Investment in new infrastructure is crucial such as a carbon dioxide pipeline. The federal plan is to limit the costs and maximize the benefits by solving the uncertainties of emission regulation through