Explain The Main Impacts Of Any Two Electoral Systems Other Than First Past The Post

537 words - 3 pages

Explain the main impacts of any two electoral systems other than First Past the Post (10 marks)
Proportional systems such as closed party list are distinctly more in favour of smaller parties than most other systems. This is attributed to the fact that the percentage of votes cast in favour of a party directly corresponds to the percentage of seats they gain; this leads to an exceptionally more accurate result than majoritarian systems. Because of this, parties which are marginalised in a majoritarian or plurality system are not discounted from seats if they fail to win a constituency vote. As such, under a proportional system, in 2010 parties other than the Lib Dems, Tories, and Labour would have over double the seats they did; 77 compared to the actual 35. This highly ...view middle of the document...

This has led many to state that a proportional system will usually lead to a coalition government. The potential for intense political diversity in this coalition can be seen to be a sign of a weak government due to the difficulty of passing motions without complete partisan support.
Majoritarian systems usually favour a two-party system due to the systems’ necessity for majority rule; as such, the two largest parties are always most likely to gain this majority. However, this does not eliminate the presence of a third party such as the Liberal Democrats; because the Liberal Democrats are seen as a more middle ground alternative to Labour or the Tories, they are often not a voters’ first choice. Under a preferential system such as AV, this marginalisation of the third party would not happen, as they would likely hold the balance of power in their hands depending on the distribution of second choice votes after the first round. Not only would this help Lib Dem voters be more satisfied with a non-Liberal government, but they would gain more MPs by redistribution in constituencies; in 2010 under AV, the Liberal Democrats would have had 79 seats compared to 57 before. Labour conversely would have won the election due to voters for more radical left-wing parties not considering Labour as their first choice in their constituency.
Majoritarian elections produce, by definition, a majority government; in AV, the aim is to gain over 50% of the seats through redistribution of people’s second choices, in order to satisfy the largest amount of people and thereby gain a strong mandate for government. The government itself would be strong also, as there is no opportunity for bipartisanship or coalition government to undermine the efficiency of the legislative process.

Other Papers Like Explain the Main Impacts of Any Two Electoral Systems Other Than First Past the Post

Assess the Advantages of the Various Electoral Systems

978 words - 4 pages Assess the advantages of the various electoral systems One of the many electoral systems is the First-Past-The-Post system (FPTP), the current system for electing MPs to the House of Commons. There are 659 separate constituencies across the UK each electing one single Member of Parliament. In order to vote you simply put an ‘X’ next to the name of the candidate you support. The candidate who gets the most votes wins, regardless of whether he or

Explain the main themes of theodicies in the augustinian tradition

1193 words - 5 pages Explain the main themes of theodicies in the Augustinian tradition. • God made the world perfect as God can only make perfect things / evil does not exist, it is only a lack of perfection. • Only God himself is perfect. Created things are open to change and therefore open to going wrong. • God gave humans and angels free will and these rejected God and created evil. Their evil actions made all things imperfect. Evil is either

Explain the Roles and Responsibilities of Two Overarching Health Organisations

593 words - 3 pages P3: explain the roles and responsibilities of two overarching health organisations By Mercy Tiwo DEPARTMENT OF HEALTH The Department of Health (DH) is a ministerial department, supported by 23 agencies and public bodies. The department employs 2,160 staff who work in locations across the country. DH helps people to live better for longer. They lead, shape and fund health and care in England, making sure people have the support, care and

In Any Field Of Inquiry, The Beginner Is More Likely Than The Expert To Make Important Discoveries

520 words - 3 pages The speaker asserts the important discoveries in any field of inquiry are more likely made by the beginners, but not the experts. I strongly disagree with this view because it is an extreme one. Though I concede that some important discoveries may be attributed to the work of novices, but this situation is not a prevail phenomenon in all fields. Most of achievements people acquire are dependent on the research of experts.Admittedly, beginners

Electoral Systems Of Germany And Finland

1184 words - 5 pages Two Countries and governments that have electoral system similarities are those of Germany and Finland. They both use systems of the proportional representation model. Proportional representation, also called "full representation" is the voting system used in most Western democracies and is widely considered to be fairer and more democratic than the current U.S. system.THE FINNISH SYSTEMHistoryThe Finnish system came into being in 1906

Nowadays It's Easier to Maintain Health Than the Past

907 words - 4 pages Nowadays it’s easier to maintain health than the past. – Teddy 13-5-17 下午6:22 Nowadays it’s easier to maintain health than the past. Per​son​al health has long been the cen​ter of pub​lic at​ten​tion. Some neo-Lud​dites ar​gue that com​pared with their coun​ter​parts in the past, they are now in a dif​fi​cult sit​u​a​tion to re​main healthy. From my per​spec​tive, al​though such en​vi​ron​men​tal headaches as the de​ple​tion of ozone lay

To What Extent Were Opposition Weaknesses the Main Reason for Conservative Electoral Victories Under Thatcher

1698 words - 7 pages council houses, rising from less than 2,000 in 1979 to an average of 100,000 a year, won over many working class voters to the Tory cause in her first term, and while the number of unemployed rocketed to more than 3m by 1983, most of the industrial workforce finding itself out of work as a result of her monetarist policies were unlikely to have been Conservative voters in any case. Meanwhile, her cutting of upper and basic rate income tax in the

With Reference to One or More River Basins, Describe and Explain the Different Impacts of Flooding. (25)

806 words - 4 pages River Environments. With reference to one or more river basins, describe and explain the different impacts of flooding. (25) Floods make a big impact on the environment and society. Floods can destroy drainage systems in cities. Also in cases of severe floods, buildings can be damaged and even destroyed. This can lead to catastrophic events on the environment and society. Floods also cause millions of pounds worth of damage. However

The Electoral College

1056 words - 5 pages argument in favour of retaining the present system is that there is too much uncertainty over whether any other method would be an improvement. Many of the weaknesses of the Electoral College apply just as well to the Senate and, in some ways the House of Representatives. The reform of the Electoral College system could lead to the dismantling of the federal system. Another democratic

The Electoral College System

550 words - 3 pages . 2009). The concerns raised by the American people about the system of the electoral college are not new and yet have not produced the change necessary. Any change to the process would need an amendment to the Constitution, which requires a two-thirds vote from Congress and then ratification by three-fourths of the states for it to become law (Dell, K. n.d.). Many people like the fact that the Electoral College reflects the federal nature of the United States and resist efforts to abolish it as an attack on federalism and the powers of the states (Lublin, D. 2008).

The Impacts of Metal Extraction

932 words - 4 pages expensive as magnesium is a highly reactive metal and therefore more expensive than others. First the magnesium has to be extracted using electrolysis resulting in more CO2 emissions making it a two-step process meaning it takes more money. During this process hydrogen is also produced which is flammable, making this potentially dangerous. However, this process does produce more metal and fewer impurities, so it can be more beneficial. Extracting

Related Essays

Outline The Main Ways By Which Offending By Children And Young People May Be Prevented. Explain Any Conflicts You Feel May Exist With The Principles Of Human Rights And Natural Justice

3383 words - 14 pages Outline The Main Ways By Which Offending By Children And Young People May Be Prevented. Explain Any Conflicts You Feel May Exist With The Principles Of Human Rights And Natural Justice. The aim of the question stated is to discuss how the New Labour Government has responded in terms of preventing children and young people from engaging in criminal behaviour and entering the youth justice system. In order to answer this statement the essay

Compare The Main Job Roles And Functions In Two Organisations And Explain How They May Differ In Different Organisational Structures

1997 words - 8 pages M1 Compare the main job roles and functions in two organisations and explain how they may differ in different organisational structures: Tesco: The main job role of the CEO is looking after shareholders interests and deciding strategy or policy this means what the business aims to do in the long term for example to expand and grow. The CEO also looks at the long-term plans of the business over the next five years. They also try to aim to be

Identity And Explain The Alternative Method Of Resolving Civil Disputes Other Than By Taking Action Through The Courts And Consider The Advantages And Disadvantages Of Each Of These Alternatives

975 words - 4 pages achieving similar or even better win-win situation as a result. Last but not the least, the final agreement reached are legal binding and will be kept in strict confidential without letting too much detail to disclose. On the other hand, there are also concern on the effectiveness of mediation and conciliations. Firstly, either side of the disputants may withdraw from the process at any time disregard how much time and efforts have contributed

This Is A Comparative Essay Between Two Writters' Views On "The Lord Of The Rings: Return Of The King." While Both Critics Were Happy With The Outcome, One Was Far More Pleased Than The Other

535 words - 3 pages the eye;...cause the heart to soar;...cause the adrenaline to surge; and images of spectacle that make the jaw drop" (Bernardinelli366). Although in Burr's synopsis, he bestows a run-down of the story in great detail with little room for admiration. He was less than passionate compared to James.The conclusion of the story left one appreciative with slight weariness and the other completely blown away. No surprise that James had written, "The