This website uses cookies to ensure you have the best experience. Learn more

Evil And Good Essay

1365 words - 6 pages

In Horrendous Evils and the Goodness of God , Marilyn McCord Adams uses another kind of defense for theism. In this reading Adams argues that the problem of evil has been directed at theism in general, which in this case has caused readers on either side of the debate to miss how important and how unique Christianity is to the problem of horrendous evils on this view. She argues that Christianity has a variety of unique tools that can meet the problem of evil more effectively when not abstracted into simply classical theism.
Adams’ account has the kind of honest, penetrating discussion of real evil in our world about which philosophy would do well to take notice. The little child kidnapped ...view middle of the document...

This act of Christ means that our defilement from sin, evils, and even horrendous evils has the possibility of becoming holiness. Thus, through Christ, and the power of the Holy Spirit’s redefining rebirth of baptism, God offers the greatest good to every individual
Through this self-defilement which leads to holiness, God invests meaning by “…being good to all created persons–that is, in seeing to it that each gets a life that is a great good to him/her on the whole, one in which any participation in horrors is not merely balanced off but defeated Adams’ thesis, then, is that in Christ, God provides the defeater for horrendous evils by ensuring that each person’s life is a great good. Here Adams rides a fine line of universalism it seems as though she may be saying every person is indeed saved through Christ, eventually, but her account can be easily modified by those who reject universalism–for one can argue that God provides the defeater simply by offering the possibility of such goods to each person. And God is good to each person by providing such an opportunity.
Adams uses the rest of her work to argue further how God’s participation in suffering demonstrates that God has been immeasurably good to each individual. I find Adams’ argument particularly enlightening. Her emphasis on the individual evils of the world is a breath of fresh air as well as a new challenge to Christian philosophers. We do need to address individual atrocities. This doesn’t mean we need to go through, case-by-case, and provide theodicies for each event. Rather, as Adams urges, we can address this by arguing that God is good to every individual through his redemptive act by Jesus Christ.
My main critique of Adams in this work is that while I find her issues with abstracting the problem of evil to hit the mark some of the time, I think she underestimates the value of some of the analytic responses to the problem of evil. Certainly, taking evil as a sum total and arguing that God could have some reason for permitting this much evil to occur downplays the importance of the evil actions towards individuals, but there is a place for such defenses within philosophy. Rather than jettisoning these types of answers, then, I think we would be best suited adding Adams’ defense to the many-faceted response to the problem of evil from Christian philosophers of religion.
My first objection is that she looks at the problem of evil as residing fundamentally in the finitude of creatures. She says that the main hurdle to atonement lies not in what we as people do but what and who we are. In the face of the holy, to use Otto's key term, `we have no more rightful place in God's household than worms and maggots do in ours nothing we could naturally be or do would make us suitable for divine company. There's just a `size gap'...

Other Papers Like Evil and Good

Good, Evil, or Otherwise? Essay

593 words - 3 pages What makes a person good? What makes a person evil? There are probably a number of movies and documentaries one could watch that would display the inherent nature of mankind. When you watch “Shake Hands with the Devil” mankind’s true nature is revealed. Not only are the Interahamwe evil for committing such an atrocity in Rwanda, but also the surrounding countries and nations that sat behind fancy desks, hid behind secure doors, and watched as a

Grendel Good Vs.S Evil Essay

631 words - 3 pages change one’s ways, improve one’s character? I must have been an interesting sight, that instant, big shaggy monster intense and earnest, bent like a priest at his prayers. (Page 61) this illustrates his compassion and remorse for what he has done. It gives the reader insight on how Grendel sees himself and shows that he wants to change and be good.In conclusion although Grendel is predominately seen as evil he shows humanistic and good

Macbeth from Good to Evil

832 words - 4 pages From Good to Evil The line between good and evil is permeable and almost anyone can be induced to cross it when pressured by situational forces. Macbeth is first introduced as a war hero, and the thane of Glamis, a nobleman who Duncan, the King of Scotland, speaks very highly of. Macbeth is a courageous Scottish general who is not naturally disposed to commit evil deeds, yet he deeply desires power. In Shakespeare’s play Macbeth, it is evident

Sonny's Blues; Good Vs. Evil

1117 words - 5 pages English 101LaToya PeoplesSonny's Blues: Recurring theme of Good vs. EvilThroughout James Baldwin's story Sonny's Blues, the neighborhood of Harlem is in a constant battle between good and evil. The narrator describes Sonny's encounters with evil, manifested in drugs and crime, as well as his assertive attempts at distancing himself from the darker side. The streets of Harlem are described as a harsh environment which claims the lives of many who

How Is The Theme "Good Vs Evil" Explored By Isobelle Carmody In The Book "The Gathering"?

1483 words - 6 pages The book "The Gathering" by Isobelle Carmody explored the theme of "Good VS Evil" in such an intricate manner that every aspect of the text, the characters, themes and her own message portrayal, all become involved. This means that the reader can understand the plot of the book, and will be able to clearly read the message being revealed by the three main aspects of it. Other minor things, such as the title of the book itself, contribute to the

Response to Fallacious Solutions

1258 words - 6 pages all-knowing and all-powerful there would be no evil in the world (Robbins, 2012). Mackie presents several solutions to the problem of evil that he deems fallacious. I will argue that "Good cannot exist without evil" and "Evil is due to human free will" are in fact adequate solutions to the problem of evil. Mackie (1955), defines God as an omnipotent and omnibenevolent being, meaning God is all-knowing and all-good, and should be able to

Response to Fallacious Solutions

1258 words - 6 pages all-knowing and all-powerful there would be no evil in the world (Robbins, 2012). Mackie presents several solutions to the problem of evil that he deems fallacious. I will argue that "Good cannot exist without evil" and "Evil is due to human free will" are in fact adequate solutions to the problem of evil. Mackie (1955), defines God as an omnipotent and omnibenevolent being, meaning God is all-knowing and all-good, and should be able to

East of Eden Analysis

1340 words - 6 pages Daniel Barton October 27, 2014 Religious Literature Transient and Permanent Qualities in East of Eden: The Relationship Between Good and Evil Torben Grodal talked of art film as possessing two basic elements, transient and permanent, but they are also seen in the novel East of Eden. Steinbeck creates scenes that at first have a transient quality, and then purposefully connects to a permanent nature. These permanent qualities, grappled

God and Evil

1281 words - 6 pages   PHL 101 11 March 2012 A Summary of the problem of evil and a critical evaluation of how it is said to undermine the traditional characteristics of God. This paper will attempt to review the philosophical quandary of the existence of evil and if evil exists can God exist and if so can this God still be declared perfect? The epistemological issue that arises is One’s knowledge of God and the validity of God’s existence. What is good

Statement of Rationale

781 words - 4 pages can take a deeper look on the context and history of evil. As with many branches of evil, the topic of imagination and evil stem indirectly from religion. Just as each religion has its own unique identity and definition of evil so does each individual. How far someone is willing to cross the line between good and evil varies greatly depending on whom you talk with. This imaginary line separating the two is movable, and it is permeable. Good people

Critically Expose The Problem Of Evil

2413 words - 10 pages EMMANUEL SAGWETE (916)DPL 314 PHILOSOPHY OF RELIGIONFR. A. RUTSVIGA28 OCTOBER 2010Critically expose the problem of evil.Evil is a privation of the good. The problem of evil "arises from the paradox of an omnibenevolent, omnipotent deity's allowing the existence of evil" (Pojman 1987: 151). The Judeo-Christian tradition affirmed that God is omnipotent, omniscient and perfectly good. The same tradition also affirmed the existence of evil. The

Related Essays

Beyond Good And Evil Essay

1146 words - 5 pages Jessica Drummond Hirsh English 4140 – Shakespeare Later Works 30 September 2012 Beyond Good and Evil In the tragedy of Othello, the plot is driven by the relentless revenge of the antagonist Iago. His hatred of the main character Othello causes him to weave a tangled web of lies that ultimately leads to the demise of four characters and secures a fate worse than death for himself. Using his power of manipulation, Iago plants the seed of

Good And Evil In Othello Essay

734 words - 3 pages The idea that "there would be no good without evil" is a good place to start when thinking about Iago and Othello as rival characters in Shakespeare's Othello. The play shows us how good turns into evil in the complex character of Othello, who turns out to be more than a victim of Iago's wrongdoings but also a character who is both good and evil. In Shakespeare's play evil is not something absolute. Evil demonstrates itself as a different

Good And Evil In Chirstianity And Buddhism

603 words - 3 pages Good and Evil in Christianity and Buddhism Christianity and Buddhism are in many ways incompatible with each other. There is a clear contrast between the two types of religious teachings. According to Christianity, evil is neither created, natural, or a necessary element. It is a separate entity that sustains itself by misusing God’s resources and in following a wrong direction. The first noble truth, according to the Buddha, states that the

Good And Evil In Young Goodman Brown

1549 words - 7 pages Well-known Romanticist and Transcendentalist author Nathanial Hawthorne delves into an uncomfortable but very real thought of aspect of the clash between good and evil in his uncharacteristically dark short story, Young Goodman Brown. Hawthorne does this mainly through symbolism. There is an abundance of symbols throughout the tale. These range from hair ribbons to colors and names. Regardless of specifics, these symbols allow a plentiful amount