This website uses cookies to ensure you have the best experience. Learn more

Ethics Essay

1427 words - 6 pages

Table of Contents
What is Dumping1
The Case Analysis1-5

What is Dumping?
Dumping is the practice of firms of developed nations exporting goods which have been categorized as dangerous to the health of individuals or which have been barred altogether from domestic markets, The practice is typically undertaken by companies who are clearly motivated by profit (Dumping Made in the USA: Dumped in Brazil, Africa, Iraq...). It usually involves a manufacturer selling the exported goods in the foreign market at below the price of the same goods in the home market (provided they have not been banned in the domestic market) (Delener, 1998).
The case referred in here ...view middle of the document...

Was this behaviour ethical? If we were to question the organisations would they cite the principle of Egoism, which states “an act is morally right if and only if it best promotes an agent’s long term interests” (Shaw, Barry, Issa, & Catley, 2013)? Upon further questioning there is a danger of them classifying it as psychological egoism which contends that ‘people are, as a matter of fact, so constructed that they must behave selfishly’ (Shaw, Barry, Issa, & Catley, 2013), and in fact they would be right as egoism as per (Shaw, Barry, Issa, & Catley, 2013) ‘does not preach that we should never assist others but rather that we have no basic moral duty to do so’. But looking at these arguments would it not be wrong as we know that ethical egoism ignores blatant wrongs, to dump these products and let the children of other countries suffer. Where do I get this reasoning from? I can cite the theory of Utilitarianism which is a ‘moral doctrine that we should always act to produce the greatest possible balance of good over bad for everyone affected by our actions (Shaw, Barry, Issa, & Catley, 2013). It would work for organisations as well as it is clear and straightforward for formulating and testing policies (organisations love policies), it is also an attractive way of resolving conflicts of self-interest, flexible and result oriented. In the same vein I could be criticised as ethicist A.C. Ewig concluded that if the manufacturers were to follow utilitarianism principles it would result in far more cheating, lying and unfair action than any good man would tolerate (Ewig, 1965).
Thus citing the critiques of Utilitarianism manufacturers such as those involved in exporting Wheat and Barley to Iraq which were treated with a US-banned fungicide in 1972 and resulted in deaths of 400 and making 5,000 ill would be emboldened and in fact could gain a supporter in the form of their own governments as the manufacturers of Dalkon Shield did in case of the Office of Population within the US Agency for International Development (AID) which purchased the intrauterine device even after having documented proof that it was an unsafe product. Was the government acting morally within the context of the Utilitarianism principles? Was it right when it said that their motives are humanitarian, because the rate of dying in childbirth is high in developing nations (third world countries) and some device is preferred to having none (Dumping Made in the USA: Dumped in Brazil, Africa, Iraq...). Is it also ethical when countries like the US specifically The State Department which has been the implementing authority states in its policy “No country should establish itself as the arbiter of others’ health and safety standards. Individual governments are generally in the best position to establish standards of public health and safety” (Shaw, Barry, Issa, & Catley, 2013). So which ethically sound or morally justifiable principle is the importing country (its...

Other Papers Like Ethics Essay

Ethics Essay

571 words - 3 pages Ethics Essay Comparing and distinct ethical theories helps an individual to appreciate the regulation system, which helps or aides one throughout their decision-making process. Virtue, utilitarianism, and deontology theories try to set up a moral that an individuality person can survive, and perform on. These approaches to ethics have similarities and differences at the end of the day. Every theory has its individual thoughts as regard to

Ethics Essay

386 words - 2 pages Ethics Essay ETH/316 version 2 Ethics Essay Utilitarianism is doing what is good for the team, putting the teams’ needs above your own. It says it is morally right to put the needs of others above your own to create a greater good. DE ontologically theory is about doing your duty because it follows a set of rules, it is the right thing to do based on the laws and rules. Virtue theory focuses on a history of excellence or doing good

Ethics Essay

760 words - 4 pages Ethics Essay In this essay I will compare the similarities and differences between virtue theory, utilitarianism, and deontological ethics. I will also include the following in this essay a description of the differences in how each theory addresses ethics and morality, and a personal experience to explain the relationship between virtue, values, and moral concepts as they relate to one of the three theories Utilitarianism is a

Ethics Essay - 700 words

700 words - 3 pages Ethics Essay Lejon Starks ETH-316 April 28, 2013 Linda Emmele Ethics Essay The three theories of virtue, utilitarianism, and deontological are tied together by a few common threads. Humans are each of these in certain situations. Some people live their lives by one theory over the other two. Culture and upbringing are the cornerstones for how a person reacts to each of these theories. My father preferred the utilitarianism theory

Ethics Essay - 903 words

903 words - 4 pages dilemma. Ethics Essay Even though people usually base their individual choice of ethical theory upon their life experiences (1,2). Each of these theories is seen every day through in our actions and decisions. One of the virtue theories that I can relate to is virtue, which encourages me to be the best that I can be, and put forth the effort necessary to be successful in my endeavors. I believe that by being the best person I can be, I not only

Eth/316 Ethics Essay

646 words - 3 pages Ethics Essay Ethics is something that we as people deal with on a daily bases. People view ethics in their own way and have their own way of approaching everyday conflicts, which ethical and moral decisions need to be made. In this paper I will discuss the similarities and differences between virtue theory, utilitarianism, and deontological ethics. I will describe the differences on how each theory addresses ethics and morality. I will also

Ethics Essay - 554 words

554 words - 3 pages Hospitals implement programs to secure patient satisfaction, when a patient is seeking care. However the programs implemented cause other problems that have not been successfully address to secure that the proper actions are being taken when a patient shows a concern or problem with their care. In some cases patients that are not in a state, that would allow them to make an ample analysis of their situation cause harm to the caregivers

Ethics Essay - 1403 words

1403 words - 6 pages Famous Thinkers Paper Bill Gates Bill Gates, formally known as William Henry Gates III, was the co-founder of the Microsoft Corporation in 1975. It was not until the 19080s when this company really became a known corporation. Bill Gates was known for being an aggressive person that went after his ideas and did think twice about what his peers opinions were of him. Bill Gates found himself in the middle of a lawsuit and parted from the company

Ethics Essay - 592 words

592 words - 3 pages Virtue ethics, which are also called virtue theory, utilitarianism, and deontological ethics are principles that individuals use to guide their actions. These principles can be moral decisions. Moral decisions are those made by what an individual perceives as right or wrong. The decisions can also be non-moral in nature, which pertains to an individual’s desire to improve themselves or a group/team affiliation for the greater good. The

Ethics Essay - 572 words

572 words - 3 pages or a form of character as virtuous or a vice. Deontological ethics follow moral obligation. The goal is to make sure an action or a characters way of being is followed under a moral rule or even a command. For example, as a child lying was never acceptable. Every time someone told, a lie there would be a punishment and the child guilty conscious, which followed suit. Morally, lying is an immoral deed to do. Ethically, it goes against the

Ethics Case Study Essay

732 words - 3 pages Ethics Case Study Does Jerry’s medical training qualify him to issue this refill order? Why or Why not If Jerry was solely a medical assistant he would not be able to refill any prescription for they have absolute no authority to do so. Medical assistants’ may take the call and write the messages and send it to the nurse but that is about where it ends because they are not permitted to authorize or even inform patients about a prescription

Related Essays

Ethics Essay 608 Words

608 words - 3 pages Ethics Essay ETH/316 July 2, 2012 Ted Haas Theories will usually be used to help understand different beliefs; people are more likely to believe bits and pieces of different beliefs instead of the whole idea behind the theory. Theories are mostly used to help a person understand better about certain characters and to assist in figuring out exactly who they are and where they are going in life. There are

Ethics Essay 523 Words

523 words - 3 pages Ethics Essay Devon Okafor ETH/316 October 18, 2013 Christopher Canter Ethics Essay Introduction We are attempting to compare and contrast of the virtue theory, utilitarianism, and deontological ethics. Each theory will reveal a common thread; however all possess distinct differences in explaining morality. To wrap things up a personal experience that displays related virtue, values, and moral concepts ties in to one of the theories

Ethics Essay 680 Words

680 words - 3 pages Ethics Essay Marlina Ralstin ETH/316 December 3, 2012 Denise Antoon Ethics Essay The subject of ethics can be quite controversial, especially when the three major theories are vying for front-line attention. Understanding why people react to specific situations the way they do is beneficial from any stand point in life whether profession or personal. In the following paragraphs ethics will be defined, as will the three theories

Ethics Essay 599 Words

599 words - 3 pages Ethics Essay Michael McPhetrige ETH316 09/19/2013 Mr. David Trammell Ethics Essay In our world, there are many different ways to approach ethics. We all have our different opinions on what ethics are, or as I like to say, our own ethical codes. However, we can relate to other peoples theories. Some theories that can be related to, but are different from each other, are virtue theory, utilitarianism, and deontological ethics