This website uses cookies to ensure you have the best experience. Learn more

Ethics Case Study

1061 words - 5 pages

Part A
In terms of utilitarianism theory, key stakeholders would include Tom, Tom’s parents, the company, co-workers in the company, charity. The below table would list the consequences (benefits and harms) by whether Tom exaggerate his work experience or not.
Stakeholders | Exaggerate-Benefits | Exaggerate-Harms | Not exaggerate -Benefits | Not exaggerate-Harms |
Tom | Retained by the company and provide the life-saving sponsorship for children. | He may lose job when the truth comes out and it would affect his future when he seeking a job. | He does not need to worry about any worse situations which may happen on him. | He would not obtain the job and cannot provide ...view middle of the document...

Firstly, he exaggerates his work experience on his curriculum vitae in order to get the job, so he cheats the company and telling lie. Tom would break universal law if he does so. Furthermore, Tom’s behaviour would not meet the consistently universal, because of the company must be in trouble if everyone do this. According Kantian’s ethics, everyone should tell the truth, that is the universal consistent law.
For the respect part, he would fail it. Tom’s behaviour is telling lie, which is not showing the respect to the company.
Overall, truth telling is a vital factor in Kantian’s theory. So Tom cannot meet both principles of universal acceptability and respect because of telling lie. He does not follow duties and against categorical imperative as well.

Virtue ethics
For virtue ethics, I am going to apply sincerity in expression (truthfulness) in Tom’s dilemma. Tom’s action is against the virtue in terms of truthfulness, he is not telling truth when he exaggerating. Moreover, Tom’s action turns him into means rather than ends, because he telling lie in order to get a job. Telling lie is actually against truthfulness and is not a virtuous person in this situation would do.
In brief, Tom’s action is not ethical under virtue ethics.

Ranking of ethical theories
In my opinion, the most useful for resolving my own ethical dilemmas is virtue ethics theory, and then is Kantian ethics theory and the least useful theory is utilitarianism. In comparison with Kantian ethics theory and utilitarianism, virtue ethics theory can address most ethical dilemmas, and also can meet other two theories in most situations. I think most of time I just need follow a virtue and take the consequence and be honest into account, and then most of situation can be addressed ethically. The disadvantage of Kantian’s ethics theory is some time we must telling lie when we meet some extreme situations. The principle in this theory is not flexible like virtue ethics theory, and truth telling is also being included in virtue. Utilitarianism may harmful some people in most situations in order to get a good consequence, which means in most of time some people might be harm by you decision. So...

Other Papers Like Ethics Case Study

Ethics Case Study

1060 words - 5 pages Ethics Case Study Ethics is the evaluation and study of the human behavior in regard to moral principles, especially those in a particular group, profession, or individual (The Free Dictionary, 2012). Individuals face many ethical dilemmas daily and how he or she responds could lead to major and legal ethical implications. In the health care industry, possessing methods for making ethical decisions is an essential part of the job. This paper

Ethics Case Study Essay

732 words - 3 pages Ethics Case Study Does Jerry’s medical training qualify him to issue this refill order? Why or Why not If Jerry was solely a medical assistant he would not be able to refill any prescription for they have absolute no authority to do so. Medical assistants’ may take the call and write the messages and send it to the nurse but that is about where it ends because they are not permitted to authorize or even inform patients about a prescription

Ethics Case Study

852 words - 4 pages Ethics Case Study Ethics are the moral principles that dictate a person’s or group’s behavior and decision making process. Ethics are needed on a daily basis for making proper decisions for a collective approval of group of people or business. I will discuss a situation that has happened in a doctor’s office and analyze what is ethical and legal for the worker to do in the situation that he is presented with. In the scenario

Ethics Case Study

1394 words - 6 pages Ethics Case Study Name HCS/335 Date Professor Ethics Case Study Today’s healthcare professionals are immersed in an ever-changing environment. The advent of managed care, a variety of medical practice arrangements, and a multitude of healthcare specialty areas have resulted in the continual need to understand healthcare law. Unfortunately, due to the rise of malpractice suits, many physicians are protecting themselves by ordering

Ethics Case Study Hcs/335

1250 words - 5 pages Ethics Case Study XXXXXXXXXX HCS/335 May 2, 2011 Beryl Keegan, RN, BSN, MSN/HCE, CCRN, CLNC Ethics Case Study "Jerry McCall is Dr. William's office assistant. He has received professional training as both a medical assistant and a LPN. He is handling all the phone calls while the receptionist is at lunch. A patient calls and says he must have a prescription refill for Valium, an antidepressant medication, called in right away to

Case Study in Ethics: Human Resources

1239 words - 5 pages Case Study In Ethics: Human Resources In human resources, professionals face ethical decisions on an every day basis.   Many times, these involve issues that conflict with company policies and procedures or what they think is morally correct.   With this said, the board of directors or management may desire to change the way a company is ran and change employee benefits to achieve an organizational objective that may create an ethical issue

Individual Ethics Case Study (Jerry Mccall)

720 words - 3 pages Individual Ethics Case Study (Jerry McCall) Jerry McCall cannot legally or ethically justify refilling the patient’s last minute valium request and by doing so will set himself and his employer (Dr. Williams) up for possible legal and or civil ramifications. Jerry does have several suitable alternative courses of action he can pursue in an effort to solve the patient’s medical dilemma. These types of medicine refill issues occur

Ethics Case Study - 550 words


Business Ethics Case Study

1203 words - 5 pages Case 1 Raju knew he was smart. His classmates always turned to him for help on assignments and he always knew the answers to the questions his teachers asked in class. Raju just didn't study for tests so his grades were often mediocre. He knew he could do better in school, it was just that school was so... well, boring. School was coming to an end for the year and Raju needed to get a good job this summer, after all this was the end of his

Enron Ethics Case Study

1986 words - 8 pages - Another conflict of interest includes executives’ involvement to both manage and be equity holders of entities that conducted significant business transactions with Enron. Enron’s Code of Ethics and Business Affairs explicitly prohibits any transactions that involve related parties unless “the Chairman and CEO determined that his participation ‘does not adversely affect the best interests of the Company’” (Stanford University, 2003). For instance

Business Ethics 301 Case Study

934 words - 4 pages Module 1 Case Assignment: Should Justin Ellsworth's Parents have been given access to his email? By: Roger Waldo Ethics 301 Professor: Dr. Johnny M. Vanneste 21 July 12 Waldo 1 Should Justin Ellsworth's Parents have been given access to his email? As a service member, this article hits close to home. This is a tough situation for any family to endure. One can clearly see both sides of the argument and can draw

Related Essays

Ethics Case Study 889 Words

889 words - 4 pages Ethics Case Study Susan M. Brandt HCS/335 February 12, 2012 Professor Beryl Keegan University of Phoenix/Axia Ethics Case Study When we look at health care professionals they are immersed in ever-changing environments. In this case study it is important to know and understand how people face different situations within their everyday lives. Health care has been the main focus for individuals that have

Ethics Case Study 1153 Words

1153 words - 5 pages Ethics Case Study Heather Holcomb University of Phoenix Ethics: Health Care and Social Responsibility HCS 335 Deborah Laughon RN BSN MS DBA January 23, 2012 Ethics Case Study Case Study Jerry McCall is Dr. William’s office assistant. He has received professional training as both a medical assistant and a LPN. He is handling all the phone calls while the receptionist is at lunch. A patient calls and says he must have a prescription

Ethics Case Study 1135 Words

1135 words - 5 pages Ethics Case Study Ranacia Alford HCS/335 Ruby Wesley Shadow In order to make ethical decisions in the medical office setting, everyone should have a clear understanding of their role in the practice. Knowing the scope of their work allows employees to perform their jobs better and to keep from making mistakes that could reflect badly on the liable provider. In the case study that will be discussed, Jerry, the office assistant, is asked to

Ethics Case Study 757 Words

757 words - 4 pages Ethics Case Study HCS/335 Ethics Case Study There are many situations in which ethics come into play, especially concerning the healthcare industry. Day-to-say operations require employees to know how to handle certain situation in the most ethical way possible. The refill of a controlled substance such as Valium, an antidepressant medication, is just one example of how knowing what the responsible and ethical thing to do can be