This website uses cookies to ensure you have the best experience. Learn more

Ethical Language Has No Meaning Essay

1153 words - 5 pages

Ethical language has no meaning. Discuss (35 Marks)

The meaning and function of ethical language is the focus of meta-ethics. It can be discussed whether ethical language has any meaning at all by looking at different perspectives.

An ethical naturalist would say that all ethical statements are the same as non-ethical ones; they’re factual and can, therefore, be true or false. So ‘Thomas More was executed for his beliefs in 1535’ and ‘Thomas More was a good man’ can be proved true or false by looking at the evidence. If we can find evidence, we can conclude that Thomas More was good and if not, we can conclude he was not. The same holds for any moral issue for example if one wants to ...view middle of the document...

He also states that although the world may be in a particular state it doesn’t mean we can draw ethical terms from the natural world. As ethical language is sometimes used to discuss supernatural concepts such as God and therefore ethical naturalism’s argument as to why ethical language is meaningful is absurd.
Moore states that we can stall ask ‘what is good?’ this would lead to an open question argument which displays the ethical naturalist argument as to why ethical language is meaningful may not be fully sufficient.
However intuitionists do argue that ethical language is meaningful but only because of the fact that intuition is used to conduct ethical statements. Moore uses the Simple Notion to suggest although we cannot fully describe what good is, ‘we just know good is good and that’s the end of the fact.’ He uses the analogy of yellow, stating that just as we cannot describe yellow without giving examples, we can’t describe good without referring to good with examples. It is therefore an indescribable truth, this is called; ‘Naturalistic Fallacy’.
On the other hand H.A. Prichard (1871-1947) developed these ideas further and said it wasn’t only goodness that was indefinable, but also the idea of obligation. In the same way that goodness is unrecognisable by example, so are our obligations. We will always know when we ought to act in a certain way. For Prichard, Intuitionism helps people decide how to act, he believed that everyone has a different moral intuition – some more developed than others. Where there is conflict between our moral obligations, we simply examine the situation and choose the greater obligation. Therefore ethical language has no meaning because something ethical such as good is unrecognisable by example, so are obligations you cannot define it or recognise it by using an example however by using only your intuition.
However, it could be argued that; how can people be sure that their intuitions are correct? Since people may come to different conclusions, whether using intuition or reason to reach their decision. It could also be argued that ethical language sets a reliable guide to ethical truths such as trying to use ethical language to understand what is good, or what your obligation is also to understand ethical concepts.
A.J Ayer claimed that ethical statements are really only statements of opinion; they’re not statements of fact. He is a logical positivist; his theory is...

Other Papers Like Ethical Language Has No Meaning

Using Gay Lingo Essay

1538 words - 7 pages convention. Each generation transmits this convention on to the next. Like all human institutions languages also change and die, grow and expand. Every language then is a convention in a community. It is non-instinctive because it is acquired by human beings. No body gets a language in heritage; he acquires it because he an innate ability. Language is Productive and Creative: Language has creativity and productivity. The structural elements of human

Figurative Language And Literative Language Essay

651 words - 3 pages language basically has concerns with that words that do not vary from their specific, fixed, specified meaning, determined and you can also covered literal language, just like word to the meaning of word and thus saying is called literal meaning. Now, we are talking about the figurative language that this concerns and deviates to that type of couple of words who exaggerate, amplify or enlarge the common and usual meanings of those same words. Now

Love Isin Theair

1308 words - 6 pages 1814 letter to Thomas Law: Self-interest, or rather self-love, or egoism, has been more plausibly substituted as the basis of morality. But I consider our relations with others as constituting the boundaries of morality. With ourselves, we stand on the ground of identity, not of relation, which last, requiring two subjects, excludes self-love confined to a single one. To ourselves, in strict language, we can owe no duties, obligation requiring

Meta-Ethics

1245 words - 5 pages The branch of ethics that discusses the meaning and indeed the validity of the word good is called Meta-ethics, meaning ‘beyond' ethics lies ethical language. From here there are two separate branches, cognitive; where "goodness" can be known as an analytic (Moore) or synthetic (naturalists like Mill) property of the world and non-cognitive; where "goodness" cannot be know as a property of the world. Within the non-cognitivists are another group

Ethical Dilemma

1745 words - 7 pages Ethical Dilemma (Author’s name) (Institutional Affiliation) Abstract This research paper seeks to resolve a particular case of an ethical dilemma. This has been necessitated by the fact that ethical dilemmas are a recurrent part of life. Moreover, ethical dilemmas have become a key point of argument in the field of ethics and interestingly, philosophy as well (Garsten & Hernes, 2009). As an inividual

Ethical Issues in Accounting

740 words - 3 pages Hume was a Scottish philosopher. Hume introduced the moral philosophy known as metaethics. Metaethics refers to the study of moral language and its meaning. (Gaffikin, 2007.) Metaethics focuses on the following questions: * semantic questions such as the meaning of moral terms such as good, right and ought; * logical questions such as the (syllogistic) validity of moral arguments; * ontological questions such as the existence of

Language and Memory

1184 words - 5 pages connection with ideas and concepts stored in the semantic memory. Tomasello (2002) stated that, “Language production relies on the semantic memory as one needs to associate words with ideas and concepts” (p. 12). For example, a caution sign has a cultural universal meaning because of the shape, color, and the big black words have meaning. Each one, shape, color, and the words are associated with the caution sign. The concepts are kept within

Ethical Delimms

795 words - 4 pages becomes a position that can be a lot different from others. Society’s views are better than others in a transcultural way. A person can act, but to act for reason’s, intentionally, and with purpose, no matter what the culture or beliefs can be. Ethical relativism in one’s culture may think that it is okay when the elder become too old and become a burden, they may abandon their loved ones. Is this correct where is the love and respect for

Emotivism

1571 words - 7 pages no possible evidence that can be given either for or against that statement being true, then it is meaningless. This approach was summed up as: “The meaning of a statement is its method of verification”. I.e. to say ‘X exists’ means ‘if you go and look, you will see X’. This view of language is found in the early work of Wittgenstein. His Tractatus (1921) was an immensely influential book, which inspired a group of philosophers known as the

Ethical Decisions

611 words - 3 pages involve a system of organizing, securing and recommending ideas of right and wrong behavior. In my line of work ethical choices and decisions has to be made every day, every hour, every minute, and every second. Making an ethical decision not only reflects you as a worker, but also reflects your people skills, you as a team member, wife, husband, part of the organization working for, and I feel it just reflects us as a whole and not just one

Ethical Leadership

1353 words - 6 pages promotes equality between the workers. An ethical leader will make sure that all workers are treated fairly, that there are no separate canteens for administrators and for spot boys, and there are no separate parking places for executives and for clerks. An ethical leader will know how to schedule his projects keeping in mind the time frame and instructs the team to manage their work schedules accordingly. An ethical leader knows that he has to abide

Related Essays

How Personal Can Ethics Get Essay

1223 words - 5 pages what the company will or will not accept as ethical behavior. The development of ethical policies and procedures start by identifying what the organization stands for meaning its core values. These core values provide a guideline for supervisors and employees on how they should respond to different situations without compromising the integrity of the organization. It allows them to understand in no uncertain terms what the company or

Religious Ethics Essay

1514 words - 7 pages To what extent is ethical language meaningful (35 Marks) The analysis of ethical language is called meta-ethics and what Meta-ethics does is look at the meaning of the language that is used in ethical statements and it includes questions about whether those statements are true or false or whether those statements are just expressions of emotion and if it is the truth then is it the truth for everybody or just a select few depending on society

Religious And Ethical Language Are About Facts. Discuss

1534 words - 7 pages it paints a picture about the world it must relate to and derive meaning out of. As such the case religious and ethical truths are to be discovered. Ethical naturalists such as F.H. Bradley have argued that ethical language is about facts of the world. It is argued that moral statements which are subjective statements about values can be translated into facts or objective statements of fact. Thus it can be argued that ‘Hitler is evil’ is a

Religious Language Essay

580 words - 3 pages ruler of the Nazi’s decided to use it as a sign of conflict and genocide of the Jews. Religious language cannot be understood if points to something beyond its meaning and power of what it actually represents. On the other hand, some would disagree that symbols are losing its meaning. Tillick talked about how symbols allowed religious language to become symbolic. It does not mean that it has to necessarily change its meaning for example, the