This website uses cookies to ensure you have the best experience. Learn more

Ethical Dilemma In International Business Essay

1397 words - 6 pages

Business Ethics Case Study
Peter Paulson's offer to provide the previous case documents to Steven Craig is professionally unethical but morally permissible. In addition, I believe that the offer was not theft but possession by entitlement and permission. His actions are a great example of how professional ethics and morals don't always align in the analysis of a case.
Part (1)
Peter Paulson's offer although helpful commits the Texas Board of Professional Engineers code. As an expert witness for a previous case against PPC, Peter Paulson was exposed to certain documents which would help with the current case against the same company. The code states in 137.63.c.4 that "The engineer ...view middle of the document...

By omission the PPC company gave Peter permission to have the documents.
(2a) Peter's offer is morally permissible due the self-defeating test. If the process of paying off people for documents was universally accepted, it would not affect the efficiency of Peter's offer. In other words, if it became common practice to make offers like Peter's, it would not be self defeating because he Steven and Peter would both still benefit. The reason why they both benefit is because the offer has no negative affect on any collateral group or person. Ultimately no one gets abused in the deal and so the transaction allows everyone to make the same possible deal without being self-defeating. Therefore Peter actions were validated by failing the self-defeating test and ultimately morally permissible.
(2b)An act utilitarian perspective of the offer shows that Peter's fee was morally permissible. The greatest good of all the people involved in the lawsuit would be to pay Peter's fee and expedite the process of getting money for the families. Accepting the offer creates the most happiness because: (1) from the perspective of Peter, he gains $25,000, (2) from the lawyer's and families' perspective the documents are received two weeks early, (3) the case ends earlier and the families receive their money faster, (4) the PPC company loses money from the settlement and potentially some employees. The most important feature of the offer is the chance for the families to end the case early. A quick settlement would end anxiety for the family and resolve financial issues. The fee would be a small price to pay compared to the waste of two weeks enduring the gruelingly slow pace of the court system. Although Peter's offer is professionally unethical it does not mean that it is morally wrong. The utility that is created through accepting the offer and gaining the documents would compensate for the unprofessional exploit. Because act utilitarianism is focused on creating the greatest good for the majority then Peter's actions are morally permissible.
Part (III)
Table 2. Line drawling of "The Offer" showing theft (Peter's perspective)
Feature Theft The Offer Not Theft
Possession vs. Ownership Possess/ Not own ---X--------------------------------- Not Possess/ own
Intention Sell ---X-------------------------------- Share

(1) Peter's ownership of the documents was theft based on the features of possession vs. ownership and intention. Peter possessed the documents from the previous case yet did not own them. When property is possessed and not owned it constitutes theft. Peter's intentions with the documents were to sell them to make money. His greedy actions show that documents were stolen and verify theft.
(2a) Peter's offer can be shown to be morally impermissible by the rule utilitarian approach. Suppose that a rule was placed into effect that stated: expert witnesses never can sell or receive payment for securing admissible documents. The rule would...

Other Papers Like Ethical Dilemma in International Business

Ethical Behavior in Business Essay

896 words - 4 pages Russell Bettinger BUS-340 – Ethical and Legal Issues in Business 26 October 2014 Esther Lahargoue Analyzing Ethical Behavior Bernard Madoff was a renowned stockbroker, financial adviser, and served as the chairman of NASDAQ. Bernie Madoff is also solely responsible for the largest accounting fraud in all of American history. In December 2008, Madoff admitted to the federal authorities that the wealth management branch of his business

Ethics In International Business Essay

3474 words - 14 pages Chapter 4 - Ethics in International Business Introduction • Business ethics are the accepted principles of right or wrong governing the conduct of business people • An ethical strategy is a strategy or course of action that does not violate these accepted principles Ethical Issues in International Business • Many of the ethical issues and dilemmas in international business are rooted in the fact that political systems, law

Ethical Dilemma in Current Events - Family Presence During Resuscitation

1232 words - 5 pages Ethical Dilemma from Current Events Family Presence During Resuscitation Tracy Sitek Grand Canyon University Ethical Decision Making in Healthcare NRS 437V Barbara Trabelsi April 17, 2011 Ethical Dilemma from Current Events Over the last decade, controversy over family presence during resuscitation (FPDR) and invasive procedures has markedly increased. Historically, it has always been thought that having a family member that was

Business in the International Economy

717 words - 3 pages BUSINESS IN THE INTERNATIONAL ECONOMY ASSIGNMENT – 1 PART – A 1. If demand price elasticity measures 5,this implies that consumers would: Ans: 2. Economic profit is: Ans: 3. In the long run, a monopolistic competitive firm will operate at a price that: Ans: 4. Which of the following would NOT be considered an example of foreign direct investment (FDI)? Ans: 5. In terms of international business, market

International Business: Doing Business In Another Country

3065 words - 13 pages 1.0 IntroductionThis report will investigate the viability of "Aussie Boardies" expanding its business overseas. The potential country chosen is India. This country will be analysed with its business protocol, communication and cultural differences. The report will also investigate the strengths and weaknesses of setting up business in India and make comparisons to Australian business ethics. An informed recommendation will be made based upon

Ethical Dilemma in Reproduction

1505 words - 7 pages Summary * During the early 1970s, women of color were subjected to a sterilization abuse where social workers and the government would sterilize them without their consent. * Tubal ligation was formerly the most prevalent form of sterilization in the United States. * With technological advances, new forms of contraceptives have been developed and marketed by pharmaceutical companies. * Two temporary forms of sterilization were

Ethical and Moral Issues in Business

534 words - 3 pages Ethical and Moral Issues in Business By Lisa Battiato MGT/216 March 18, 2011 Professor Laura Brodkey-Scott Ethical and Moral Issues in Business When it comes to understanding the concepts of ethics and morality it can easily become confusing to many. It is perceived as personal values and systematic beliefs. We all struggle with the image of what is right and what is wrong however, when it comes to ethics imposes as to how one applies

Ethical And Moral Issues In Business

507 words - 3 pages Ethical and Moral Issues in Business In today’s business environment employees and manager feel pressure to compromise his or her ethical and moral beliefs. In industry, businesses are encountering issues that are wide spread throughout the industry. On the company side managers are dealing with company specific issues. What are some of the common ethical problems businesses are dealing with today? Knowing the difference between ethical and

Ethical and Moral Issues in Business

639 words - 3 pages Ethical and Moral Issues in Business Barbara Douglass MGT/216 February 5, 2011 Brigitte Culberson-Austin Ethical and Moral Issues in Business Ethical and moral issues have been an issue since the dawn of civilization. It has never been more important than how business deals with these issues. Ethics and moral behavior is essential to any successful business and its environment. Morals and ethics are two separate entities

Ethical and Moral Issues in Business

946 words - 4 pages Ethical and Moral Issues in Business University of Phoenix Organizational Ethics and Social Responsibility MGT/216 Ethical and Moral Issues in Business Organizations promoting ethical operations while allowing employees to retain their moral compass will proactively solve issues and maintain successful operations even in times of turmoil. Individual or company values motivate effort and influence performance. Employee motivation

Moral and Ethical Issues in Business

781 words - 4 pages Ethical and Moral Issues in Business Michelle Ayuso Wienke MGT 216 August 8, 2011 Ethical and Moral Issues in Business In business today ethical and moral issues are very common. These types of issues are frowned upon and in some cases have extreme consequences but, they are still happening in businesses everywhere. Morals and moral issues can be difficult. Everyone has different morals and values that influence the decisions they make

Related Essays

International Legal And Ethical Issues In Business

826 words - 4 pages Unit 1 Individual Project International Legal and Ethical Issues in Business American InterContinental University It is know that is anyone in the business world has legal obligations to keep their employees and

Ethical Dilemma In Healthcare Essay

1154 words - 5 pages maximum of $1.5 million | These were just a couple of the minor issues in the movie that I noticed that wouldn’t be tolerated nowadays. In an early scene there is a major ethical dilemma when the main character, who is an ER physician, has to decide who to send to surgery first; the police officer who got shot and has his family and fellow officers waiting right outside the trauma room or the criminal that shot him and is bleeding out

Ethical And Dilemma Iss In Professions

997 words - 4 pages stumble across your share of ethical dilemmas to face. For example, you will encounter numerous of people from all different walks of life with various views. With that being said it’s not always guaranteed that the designer will fully agree with the particular company or individual wishes or advertisement. That raises the question of right or wrong, an ethical dilemma, for the designer. In a situation that asks of you to help advertise a

Ethical Issues In Business Essay

1102 words - 5 pages Ethical Issues in Business: I and two business associates have decided to start a small consulting business. We will be providing management consulting expertise and service nonprofit organizations. Many of our clients will be paying for this management consultation using federal funds. We intend to have between fifteen and twenty employees in addition to ourselves. We bring with us the highest ethical credentials but we feel that it is