Ethical Considerations Essay

1808 words - 8 pages

Upton Sinclair where art thou? The job of the muckraker responsible for the bane of high school literature students everywhere, The Jungle, has created more vegetarians than famous vegetarians from Gandhi to Pamela Anderson combined apparently is not yet finished. After the 1906 publication of The Jungle, a disgusted public offended at the thought of eating a line worker as part of their potted meat began to clamor for safer food and safer working conditions.
Many years and many pieces of legislation later, if the statistics can be trusted, it would seem like the more things change in the meat packing industry the more they stay the same. During the 1970 creation of the Occupational ...view middle of the document...

These recommendations include: new federal and state laws to reduce production line speeds; stronger state regulations to halt underreporting of injuries; stronger worker compensation laws; stricter enforcement of anti-retaliation laws; U.S. labor law compliance with international standards on workers' freedom of association; and new laws ensuring workers' safety regardless of their immigration status.
The existence of existing laws and regulations that address the same areas as the Human Rights Watch report begs the question if these recommendations are worthy of support.
Denial of Problem and Recommendations
As can be expected, the meat packers deny the Human Rights Watch claims and see no need for further regulation. The American Meat Institute’s J. Patrick Boyle said it would take as many pages to dispute the falsehoods in the report as the report itself. Boyle goes on to cite statistics showing a consistent decline in the number rate of injuries and illnesses in the industry. However, for all of Boyle’s protestations, Horowitz (2008) points to reasons other than safety improvements for the decline in the injury rates. He notes that beginning in the 1990’s packers began keeping injured workers on the job there by reducing the reported injury rates and the accompanying worker’s compensations claims. Horowitz (2008) also cites a change in the Bureau of Labor Statistics record keeping methods that no longer track the most common meatpacking line injuries as causing the government data to drastically under-report meatpacking work related injuries.
The meatpackers try to claim that the Human Rights Watch report is inaccurate and should be discounted because the writer’s implied having first had knowledge of the conditions in plants they had not visited. While this may be a somewhat good point, it loses its validity in light of other similar reports. A 2008 report as cited by the Lincoln Journal Star noted that “production line speed remains brutally high and might even be increasing”; “455 workers in five communities a story of hazardous workplaces and unrelenting line speed”; Sixty-two percent of workers who responded to the survey reported they had been injured in the previous year…” (Walton, 2009).
Meatpacking companies like to point to existing regulations and standards as proof that the Human Watch Rights recommendations are not needed. Yet the 1999 Sparks reports tells us that meatpacking injuries from repeated trauma were 75 times that of industry as a whole. Settlement agreements with the meatpacking companies called for programs to use an ergonomic approach to redesign job, workstations and tooling, to limit workers’ exposure to cumulative trauma disorders. About this same time, the state of Nebraska, home to some of the plants mentioned in the Human Rights Watch report, passed a bill of rights for meatpacking workers (Walton, 2009). This bill delineated workers’ rights, including the right to organize through union...

Other Papers Like Ethical Considerations

Legal and Ethical Considerations in Employment Selection

1126 words - 5 pages Legal and Ethical Considerations in Employment Selection Cardinal Stritch University Cathy Carew Instructor John Koehler MGT-445 Human Resource Management II July 25, 2013 Legal and Ethical Considerations in Employment Selection Organizations use screening tools such as assessment tests, medical tests and drug testing to effectively find applicants or current employees that are best qualified for a particular job. There are legal

Ethical Considerations for Counselling in Rural Conditions

2324 words - 10 pages not available, an experienced counsellor. (b) Any disclosure of confidential information should be restricted to relevant information, conveyed only to appropriate people and for appropriate reasons likely to alleviate the exceptional circumstances. The ethical considerations include achieving a balance between acting in the best interests of the client and the counsellor’s responsibilities under the law and to the wider community. (c) While

Designer Babies Or Superheroes?: Ethical Considerations

1197 words - 5 pages family. Works Cited Agar, Nicholas. "Designer Babies: Ethical Considerations." Action Bioscience. N.p., Apr. 2006. Web. 5 Mar. 2014. Bellis, Mary. "Genetic Engineering." Inventors., 05 Mar. 2014. Web. 05 Apr. 2014. Cohen, David. "What Does It Mean to Be Posthuman?" New Scientist. N.p., 13 May 2013. Web. 5 Apr. 2014. "Genetic Engineering." HowStuffWorks., 29 Oct. 2008. Web. 11 Mar. 2014

Ethical Considerations

3375 words - 14 pages Ethics and Corporate Responsibility in the Workplace and the World Patricia Ingram Professor Renee Berry Legal 500- Law, Ethics, and Corporate Governance March 1, 2015 Introduction "PharmaCARE is one of the world’s most successful pharmaceutical companies, enjoying a reputation as a caring, ethical and well-run company that produces high-quality products that save millions of lives and enhance the quality of life for millions of

Legal and Ethical Considerations in Marketing, Product Safety, and Intellectual Property

3424 words - 14 pages Legal and Ethical Considerations in Marketing, Product Safety, and Intellectual Property Ervin Coburn Dr. Redmon LEG 500 December 15, 2013 Research three to five (3-5) ethical issues relating to marketing and advertising, intellectual property, and regulation of product safety. Marketing and advertising are the main channels that all companies use to get access to the customers and present their products to the potential customers. These

Forbidden Knowledge: Ethical Considerations In Genetic Research

1354 words - 6 pages Researchers or Nurses who are involved in research studies can encounter numerous ethical issues when the research comprises human beings and animals in any discipline. Code of ethics was endorsed by the National Commission for the Protection of Human Subjects of Biomedical and Behavioral Research. “The commission, established by the National Research Act (Public Law 93-348), issued a report in 1978 that is referred to as the Belmont Report

The Ethical Considerations That Arise When Tobacco Companies Market Their Products In Developing Countries

986 words - 4 pages Michael Carlson and Chris Luhrs outline the ethical failings of Tobacco marketing in the US in “The Ethics of Tobacco Marketing.” In this research paper, the authors juxtapose the American Marketing Association’s ethical norms against the Kantian theory of ethics to expose that by marketing tobacco products and betraying their duty to “do no harm” tobacco marketers fail the Kantian standard of ethics to act only in a manner worthy of becoming a

GEN 480 Ethics Awareness Inventory

949 words - 4 pages Ethics, 1997). The purpose of LEAD is to educate teachers on ethical issues and train them to increase ethical awareness in students which is an excellent way to improve society. Personal and Professional Development My decision to leave Lithonia Lighting and seek employment at a smaller company was in part due to ethical considerations. I was surprised at the way Corporate America bases decisions on cost-benefit analysis without human

Consideration for Ethics and Diversity Proposal

573 words - 3 pages Individual Instructions & Assignment Consideration for Ethics and Diversity Proposal | Choose two ethical considerations and two diversity considerations that could potentially impact the division of the company selected for your team project.Write a 350-500 word proposal for your HR Director.Provide details about what the considerations are. Justify why they were important for your strategic HRM planning process. Provide recommendations for

Impaired Employee And Liability

267 words - 2 pages unfair. Ethics plays a very important role during the recruitment of new employees. Law and regulations dictate that we have to be ethical in hiring. It is importance that candidates are to be selected based on merits. Applicants are to be hired based purely on merits such as knowledge, skills, and ability in accordance to the needs of the organization. If a company provides any special considerations, for example affirmative action, where certain groups are given special considerations, these considerations should be well stated in the company's policy statement. In any case, any preferential treatment should be one that is legally allowed.

Social Responsibility

686 words - 3 pages include a focus on environmental considerations, sustainable business practices, ethical decision making on the part of the leadership who will implement your plan, and should also be in compliance with all government regulations that affect the industry. For this task, you will select your client from your actual place of employment, a local small business, or a well-known public company. Task: Develop a social responsibility strategy for

Related Essays

Ethical Considerations In Research Essay

672 words - 3 pages Specific ethical considerations and practical issues that I will need to consider in planning my research design. According to research (Gillespie, n.d.), there are three areas of risks involved in social research. First, my participants could be harmed as a result of their involvement in the study. The potential harm could include death or injury, stress, guilt, reduction in self-respect or self-esteem, unfair treatment, withheld benefits

Legal & Ethical Considerations Essay

593 words - 3 pages Legal & Ethical Considerations In an economy that is constantly changing, and demand continually rising, companies need to be aware of their legal and ethical obligations to their consumers. Companies are liable in making sure their products are as safe as possible and an obligation to report any dangers that might exist. Product liability, “Products liability refers to the liability of any or all parties along the chain of manufacture of

Research Summary And Ethical Considerations Essay

546 words - 3 pages Research Summary and Ethical Considerations Michelle Parker Grand Canyon University Introduction to Nursing Research NRS 433V Nora Bazydlo April 8, 2012 Research Summary and Ethical Considerations The relationship between nurses and families is incredibly intricate. The intricacy of this relationship is shown whether the development is for a few hours in the emergency room or for a longer period of time in an intensive care unit or

Research Summary And Ethical Considerations Essay

803 words - 4 pages -related issues. This paper will focus on the background of the study, method of study, results of the study, ethical considerations and how this study results applies to the nursing. A qualitative approach with the use of focus groups and discussion is how data was collected for this study. There were twenty two school nurses from three different school districts, ranging from suburban to rural areas for a total of seven focus groups. Each focus