This website uses cookies to ensure you have the best experience. Learn more

Essay About Essays

4572 words - 19 pages

The most obvious difference between real essays and the things one has to write in school is that real essays are not exclusively about English literature. Certainly schools should teach students how to write. But due to a series of historical accidents the teaching of writing has gotten mixed together with the study of literature. And so all over the country students are writing not about how a baseball team with a small budget might compete with the Yankees, or the role of color in fashion, or what constitutes a good dessert, but about symbolism in Dickens.

With the result that writing is made to seem boring and pointless. Who cares about symbolism in Dickens? Dickens himself would be ...view middle of the document...

But for obvious reasons no one wanted to give that answer. The archaeological work being mostly done, it implied that those studying the classics were, if not wasting their time, at least working on problems of minor importance.

And so began the study of modern literature. There was a good deal of resistance at first. The first courses in English literature seem to have been offered by the newer colleges, particularly American ones. Dartmouth, the University of Vermont, Amherst, and University College, London taught English literature in the 1820s. But Harvard didn't have a professor of English literature until 1876, and Oxford not till 1885. (Oxford had a chair of Chinese before it had one of English.) [2]

What tipped the scales, at least in the US, seems to have been the idea that professors should do research as well as teach. This idea (along with the PhD, the department, and indeed the whole concept of the modern university) was imported from Germany in the late 19th century. Beginning at Johns Hopkins in 1876, the new model spread rapidly.

Writing was one of the casualties. Colleges had long taught English composition. But how do you do research on composition? The professors who taught math could be required to do original math, the professors who taught history could be required to write scholarly articles about history, but what about the professors who taught rhetoric or composition? What should they do research on? The closest thing seemed to be English literature. [3]

And so in the late 19th century the teaching of writing was inherited by English professors. This had two drawbacks: (a) an expert on literature need not himself be a good writer, any more than an art historian has to be a good painter, and (b) the subject of writing now tends to be literature, since that's what the professor is interested in.

High schools imitate universities. The seeds of our miserable high school experiences were sown in 1892, when the National Education Association "formally recommended that literature and composition be unified in the high school course." [4] The 'riting component of the 3 Rs then morphed into English, with the bizarre consequence that high school students now had to write about English literature-- to write, without even realizing it, imitations of whatever English professors had been publishing in their journals a few decades before.

It's no wonder if this seems to the student a pointless exercise, because we're now three steps removed from real work: the students are imitating English professors, who are imitating classical scholars, who are merely the inheritors of a tradition growing out of what was, 700 years ago, fascinating and urgently needed work.

No Defense

The other big difference between a real essay and the things they make you write in school is that a real essay doesn't take a position and then defend it. That principle, like the idea that we ought to be writing about literature, turns out to...

Other Papers Like Essay About Essays

Virginia Woolf Personal Essays

2128 words - 9 pages Emily Sun Mr. Bursiek IB LA 11 22 October 2012 Limited Transcendence in the Human Condition An analysis of contradicting elements in selected personal essays of Virginia Woolf An author fascinated with boundaries, Virginia Woolf blurs the line between black and white in her essays The Death of the Moth and Street Haunting. In both essays she highlights opposing extremes: Street Haunting articulates the innate conflict of impulse and


2536 words - 11 pages Prince. The damage to Blackwater's reputation after the Nisoor Square shooting in Baghdad was bad for business. The company lost its most lucrative contract with the State Department and today only brings in about a third of the revenue it once did. While Prince was the sole owner of Blackwater and answered to no one, the new company has formed a board of directors, headed by businessman Red McCombs. He was joined earlier this year by former


2176 words - 9 pages . Alexander, J.Neil. The Liturgical Meaning of Advent, Christmas, Epiphany: Waiting for the Coming. The Pastoral Press, 1993. Asendorf, Ulrich. "Luther's Sermons on Advent as a Summary of His Theology" in A Lively Legacy: Essays in Honor of Robert Preus Edited by Kurt Marquart et al. CTS Press, 1985. Babin, David. Week In-Week Out: A New Look at Liturgical Preaching. Seabury, 1976. Bainton, Roland. Martin Luther's Christmas Book. Augsburg


713 words - 3 pages Do you have any idea about quantum vision system? Well, if not here is the right place for you; this is a vision therapy program that was created by Dr.Kemp, actually this program is a step by guide that contains information on how to improve your vision permanently, this program provides some necessary information that are common with people with eye issues, there are a number of issues that are addressed by this program that will help you to

Short Essays

623 words - 3 pages 1.) The Articles of Confederation was created by the Continental Congress which declared independence, raised an army, issued currency, borrowed money from abroad, and negotiated an alliance with France. In 1777, this plan was presented for ratification. The Articles declared “The United States of America” to be a “firm league of friendship” between the thirteen colonies. Congress would not be able to collect taxes or regulate trade. They

Essays Said!?

829 words - 4 pages DISTENDING A PARAGRAPH / METHODS OF PARAGRAPH DEVELOPMENT 1. Enumeration - the easiest method of paragraph development; ideas are enumerated to produce a point EXAMPLE: More and more people are learning that the most vital feature in a feasibility study is the market. The first question asked is: Is there a market for the product? If the finding shows a slender or unstable market, the study stops there. The next factor to take into

Jasmine's Essays

1053 words - 5 pages '' Are these areacceptable grades to you? because C's are like F's in my eyes, what college do you plan on attending?." I glared at him and was upset , who this man think we wa telling me about myself? he didnt know me! I responded USC this was my dream school he chuckled and look at me and said "Your not going to anyone's USC with grades like these." The semester went on and the class began to learn many things about Mr.Clay, how he group up in

Scholarship essays

742 words - 3 pages thought he had no way out except to kill himself. Towards the end of the movie Neil’s parents blamed Neil’s death on the teachings of Mr. Keating and ordered the school to fire him. His friends were asked to give up information about why Neil would kill himself. Most of them told them what Mr. Keating has done. So when Neil began school at Welton Academy, he was doing fine, making friends, and doing outside activities out of

Sanket's Essays

547 words - 3 pages Reflection on ‘Do People Resist Change’ Change is a necessity in a business. But often forcing a change can lead to severe problems in a business. Whether a change should occur is affected by people’s attitude towards a change. Resistance of change occurs at time when people do not find any positive improvement being caused due to a particular change. Along with the positives of changing such as better health conditions along with good foster

History Essays

1156 words - 5 pages Essay 1 It has been said that liberalism has a “hollow core,” that when individuals are given unlimited freedom, there is no way to assure that they will also be moral and orderly. How did liberal societies in the 19th and 20th centuries attempt to deal with that problem? Liberalism was an idea that took away class restrictions and the only restriction was how hard the individual is willing to work. The people are given unlimited

Essays, Story

1984 words - 8 pages thought of this when Father Christiano told us after catechism that we were absolutely hopeless, and that even the blacks were better than us, and he went back to this thing about their hands being lighter, and said it was like that because they always went about with their hands folded together, praying in secret. I thought this was so funny, this thing of the black’s hands being lighter, that you should just see me now – I don’t let go of anyone

Related Essays

Essays 322 Words

322 words - 2 pages details that will support this perspective. ➢ a reflective essay deals with a topic/issue of importance to you. Your aim is to present the reader with a glimpse inside your mind as you consider that subject. ❖ The difference: narrative essays tell “what happened” to the writer; reflective essays tell what the writer thinks/feels about a subject Take note: 1. Use the English Essentials for both assignment formatting

Essays Australia

496 words - 2 pages study your paper is about. They will also be of Australian descent. We don’t use freelancers or copywriters at our company. You can see the difference when you compare an essay example from a copywriter with our professionally developed work. The difference in quality will be obvious. The art of writing essays requires more than creativity, academic essays a base of knowledge and extensive research skills. This places our company above all the

Essays Benefit Our Education

562 words - 3 pages would be relieved of a lot of stress and pressure which could be the difference between a mental health issue and sanity. Essays are used all throughout life and do indeed help in life situations. When applying for a job an essay structure is almost a necessity for a successful application. Employers want people who can write properly and have well structured sentences and large pieces of writing. Essay writing also helps with spelling, grammar

Types Of Essays

2182 words - 9 pages ." The second sentence gives vivid details to make the reader feel like he is there. Exposition Expository essays can compare, explore and discuss problems, or tell a story. An exposition essay gives information about various topics to the reader. It: * Informs * Describes * Explains In writing an exposition, the text needs to: * Be concise and easy to understand * Give different views on a subject or report on a situation or