Employment Relations Essay

2599 words - 11 pages

Most ethnic Chinese share a common Confucian legacy with the Japanese and Koreans, but the way the Asian Chinese run their organizations, differs from them. The unique way that the Chinese business system operates is known as ‘overseas Chinese management’ (Petzall, Abbott & Timo 2007). Although both the Japanese and Koreans and the Asian Chinese are collectivist, community is more important to the former, while family ties and ‘guanxi’ are more significant to the latter (Petzall, Abbott & Timo 2007). ‘Guanxi’ is a special relationship between two individuals due to the existence of particularistic ties who are obliged to maintain a long-term relationship with mutual commitment and loyalty ...view middle of the document...

As high technological industries operate under such environments that require decentralized, participative organizational structures with extensive sharing of skills and knowledge, Chinese family firms are restricted to low and simple technologies and small-scaled organizations because of their management style (Babcock & Babcock 1998).

Petzall, Abbott and Timo (2007) highlight another reason why Chinese family firm are unable to expand is because of the lack of trust and willingness to open up to one another between employers and employees; supervisors and subordinates. Being small and family-focused, Chinese managers find the need for human resource management (HRM) redundant. Controversially, this generates distant relationships between the employers and employees which make it difficult for employees to be loyal and committed. The inability to trust outsiders dampens the opportunity for the business to grow as the bigger a firm is, the more the need for capable people to be in senior positions to help support the growth.

One problem would thus be getting the right people to fill managerial positions. In overseas Chinese management, traditional owners want members of the family to be in charge. The question arises: are there enough family members to take on such roles? In the olden days, the answer would be ‘yes’, where a man who could have as many wives as he wants, would have many sons as well. This in turn leads to another question: are the descendants competent? Yet, the high-ranking senior positions would still be given to family members, whether they are competent or not. This favoritism of allowing weak family members to hold managerial positions adversely affects effective ownership control.

However, if the management leaders are able to demonstrate attributes of the Chinese gentleman, i.e. humanness '' ‘jen’ and politeness '' ‘li’, and if the employees share similar cultural heritage of Confucianism, employees will still respect and be loyal to the managers and the business and will be more committed (Babcock & Babcock 1998).

Although Petzall, Abbott and Timo (2007) mentioned nothing about how overseas Chinese firms financed their businesses, it is inferred from Ahlstrom et al. (2004) that they relied on internal financing which also constraints growth due to heavy dependence on family members and distrust of outsiders, which were points stated by Petzall, Abbott and Timo (2007).

Another characteristic of the overseas Chinese management is the resentment of managers for their workers to join or support trade unions. Trade unions act as a voice of employees to negotiate with employers for improvements in key areas like wages, working hours and working conditions via collective bargaining. Employers view the formation of trade unions as a threat and use ‘divide and rule’ tactics prevent employees from linking up and becoming more powerful. Thus, it is not surprising that many discontented workers, upon gaining...

Other Papers Like Employment Relations

Australian Business Employment Relations Law : Directed At Business Migrants (Report Style Format) Appendices And Bib. Included

5326 words - 22 pages Business Migrant Employment Relations ReportWelcome to Australia! This package has been prepared for you to familiarise yourself with Australia's Employment Relations Legislation because Australia's business legislation may differ from the one you are accustomed to. This package covers the key areas of the Employment Relations Legislation which are:Occupational Health and SafetyWorkers CompensationAnti DiscriminationEqual Employment

Supporting Good Practise in Managing Employment Relations: 3mer

1674 words - 7 pages partake in to support an organisation. Below are three that I have decided to focus on Recruitment and selection: When it comes to recruiting for an organisation, an HR employee has a lot to get involved in. They are the ones that arrange, or provide assistance in posting vacancies, developing and implementing recruitment strategies, identifying and selecting candidates, assuring all pre-employment requirements are met, and confirming job

Unit 5 - 3mer - Supporting Good Practice in Managing Employment Relations

2737 words - 11 pages Unit 5 – Certificate of Human Resource Practice 1.1 - Describe the internal and external factors that impact on the employment relationship There are many factors that can impact on the employment relationship, both internal and external. External Factors - The availability of alternative jobs is a external factor of the labour market and can impact the employment relationship due to staff being head hunted by other companies, they

Industrial Relations

2340 words - 10 pages HRM 603: Comparative Studies of Industrial or Employment Relations Assignment 1 Trimester 3 2013 HRM 603: Comparative Studies of Industrial or Employment Relations Assignment 1 Trimester 3 2013 Name: Cagi Merelita ID no.: 2011001230 Table of Contents Introduction 1 The development & evolution of IR/ER system 2 The development & evolution of IR/ER system in the Fiji Island 3 The IR/ER system of Australia

What Are the Four Legal Means That Affect Employment Practices in Canada? Identify and Briefly Describe Each One

599 words - 3 pages employers’ relations related laws and regulations. Besides, to investigate and examine any complain against unfair labour practices Canada Labour Code establishes a labour union board. A federal and provincial Employment standard law provides information about the rights and responsibilities of employees and employers. It covers employment standards such as hours of work, minimum wage levels, vacation and holiday pay, notice period for termination

Three Elements of a Good Employment Relationship

881 words - 4 pages Identify three elements of a good employment relations system Dunlop Model The Dunlop Model, created by John Dunlop, is a conceptual model that studies employment relations. |ENVIRONMENT |THREE ACTORS |OUTCOME | |Marketing/ Budgetary constraints |Union

Employee Releation

1295 words - 6 pages relations includes handling and dealing with harassment claims, discrimination's, disputes, & employee performances. It also involves making sure regulatory guidelines and employment laws followed and complied by the employers, supervisors, and employees within a company. I. Theoretical basis for Employee Relations as a HR discipline. I believe employees are the core of a company. They are the link that brings the company to the customers

Business Financial Systems

1232 words - 5 pages establish and build business relations. This paper will describe and analyze employment and labor laws in the domestic and international markets, and the impact those laws may have on the XYZ Construction Company. Employment and labor law initially arose out of the desire to protect the employee from unethical and immoral practices in the workplace and combat preferential and bias treatment towards specific groups of people. The

Functions Of Public Relations

1130 words - 5 pages . Employment is projected to increase through 2010" (Seitel, 2004). The need by organizations for good public relations will lead to specialists in the field and this will dictate a more specific public relations campaign. With designated functions, the organization will be more prepared to create a campaign that will be competitive and justify the organization's desire to be number one in their line of business. "Private and public organizations

Employee Relations

1000 words - 4 pages resolving workplace issues. Factors which affect employee relations According to Gennard & Judge, (2005:58) the following factors affect the development of a successful employee relations strategy or policy. • The organisations business strategy in relations to employee relations. • How management’s personal views and values can influence the organisations strategy. • Why some employment policies are strategic. • The type of management

Roles of State & Federal Governments in Employment Regulation

1724 words - 7 pages legal requirements. However, the state cannot require any state laws that conflict, are in conflict, or are against any federal laws. A case in point is a collection of cases which has caused difficulties and concerns the impact of federal labor laws on state power to preside over management-labor relations and created the National Labor Relations Board (NLRB) to carry out such policy. The labor and employment law define US workers’ rights

Related Essays

Employment Relations Essay

801 words - 4 pages employment contracts, Legal and psychological contracts (Gardner 1992) The legal employment contract mainly refers to things that an employer/employee must legally provide to each other - things that are covered in a typical employment contract such as a certain number of work hours per week, a certain salary in exchange for performing a defined job, safety at work, equal employment opportunity, etc. Anything covered by law. (Balnave 2009) They

Supporting Good Practice In Managing Employment Relations – 3mer

3600 words - 15 pages Supporting Good Practice in Managing Employment Relations – 3MER 1.1 Describe 4 factors, 2 internal and 2 external, which impact on the employment relationship There are several external and internal factors that might impact on the employment relationship such as the following examples: External Factors: 1. Given the state of the recession and how it might have affected an organisation’s finances, this has a large impact on the

Identify And Explain The Main Changes That Have Occured To The Employment Relations Environment

2326 words - 10 pages Identify and explain the main changes that have occured to the employment relations environment. A successful employment relationship is the fundamental element of any successful business or organisation, hence, it is essential and the reason of all the organizations continues seeking methods to improve and maintain these relationships. There are many philosophers and writers have studied and written lots of different theories and approaches

Report On Employment Relations Issues Relating To Aged Worker In Singapore

2017 words - 9 pages investors’ with incentives to boost foreign investment, revision of the Industrial Relations Act and introduction of the Employment Act had gradually rebuilt the confidence level of the investors. Hence, by 1980s the unemployment issue was resolved (Tan, 2007). Singapore, a small populated country was unable to provide the sufficient supply of manpower to meet the rapid demand. Therefore, overseas career opportunities were open to foreign