This website uses cookies to ensure you have the best experience. Learn more

Employment Relation Essay

2099 words - 9 pages

Introduction
This paper will talk about the employment relations from two perspectives, a unitatist perspective and a pluralist perspective, and then make an analysis of the Australian Waterfront Dispute 1997-1998 from these two perspectives. In order to make clear the changes of the stevedoring industry in Australia, one has to understand the disputes occurred between 1997 and 1998. These disputes were not simple because they demonstrated the employment relations in the industry or even the whole economy (Trinca and Davies, 2000).
Thus, what is the Australian Waterfront Dispute 1997-1998? And how it happens and changes? About these two questions, the paper will give a clear outline on ...view middle of the document...

The appearance of these two organizations leaked out the defects of the industry. The reason of disputes is the impartiality of power and the unequal employment relations. MAU is a kind of collective cooperation which always makes reactions to the low pay, poor conditions and dangerous (Wiseman, 1998). It is a system focusing on daily work of employees and taking the control of the whole waterfront business. But such kind of organization can still achieve a fairly equal competitive position for workers. However, the organization has not escaped from the hands of the Communist Party of Australia which resists changes with a rigid attitude. As a result, this economic organization was elapsed into the political conflicts. After that, some want to save the whole industry by monopoly. Indeed, this kind of idea has some effects on the industrial development. Two dominate stevedoring companies achieved a reward to control the waterfront and the MAU became the sole representative of the workers in Australia.
However, it is not lasting because the so-called secret contract with a foreign country was leaked out and the public and related departments began to voice and oppose to the organization. As the disputes between MAU and Patrick continue, there comes a strategy holding that the behaviors of the MAU has worked against the Workplace Relations Act 1996, a law against monopoly( (Sheridan, 1998). As the voice of the public prompts, the strategy begins to show its advantages.
According to the Briefing Paper of the Australian Cabinet, the key to the success of the strategy is to take overall control of the national ports as fast as possible and then set up a pattern for the national growing movements (Australian Cabinet Briefing Paper, 1997). It is until the collapses of the workers’ strike that the strategy becomes low-lighted and the Australian government begins to be aware that there must be changes in the employment relations of the stevedoring industry. Therefore, it comes up with several supportive actions which include: (1) providing strategic advices; (2) providing legal assistance and medical care services; (3) employing capable worker and accommodating them; (4) be responsible for the public expenditures. These actions have played certain role in improving the employment relations of the industry, but it has not changed the nature of the contemporary formation of the employment relations.
The MAU and Patrick are elapsed into the court affairs. They make great efforts to benefit themselves and the courts spend a long time to process the affair. The reason why the two parties have become contrary parties from partners is that they want to safeguard their own benefits without complying with each other. But unfortunately, the Patrick company lost in the affair, as a result, the MUA controls the whole industry and wins the representative right of the stevedoring industry (Wiseman, 1998). The verdict of the High Court is to reach an agreement...

Other Papers Like Employment Relation

Casual Employment Essay

1951 words - 8 pages lower hourly rates of wage, do not believe that there is unfair. Studies found that 60 per cent of casuals reported that in their own opinion they believed their pay was fair in relation to what they performed (Wooden, 2001). In turn, that is 16 per cent higher as compared to the reported 44 per cent of fulltime permanent employees who believed they were also paid fairly for their employment (Wooden, 2001). In conclusion, there are two different

Just Some Tomatoes Essay

1335 words - 6 pages are not allocated tasks where their health and safety or the health and safety of others might be put at risk, we need to ensure that you are capable of performing the tasks associated with any assignments for which you would normally be considered should your employment application be successful. This information is confidential and will not be used other than in relation to your employment except with written permission. 1. Do you

Background Checks & Pre-Employment Testing

790 words - 4 pages to hire this applicant, but not without first conducting a pre-employment test with the written consent of the applicant. Pre-employment Tests At this point in time with consideration to the possibility of negligent hiring charges. I cannot offer the position until a drug test is administered. Of course any type of testing requires an explanation as to why the test is being conducted in relation to the job position. Written consent must be

Public Employment Services Office

2027 words - 9 pages Basic Understanding About PESO 1. What is PESO The Public Employment Service Office or PESO is a non-free charging multi-employment service or entity established or accredited persuant to Republic Act No. 8759 otherwise known as the PESO Act of 1999. To carryout full-employment and equality of employment opportunities for all, and for this purpose, to strengthen and expand the existing employment facilitation service machinery of the

What Is the Role of the Reserve Army of Labor Marx? How Would You Gauge Marx's Approach in Relation to the Theories of Effective Demand Developed by Kalecki and Keynes?

1751 words - 8 pages What is the role of the reserve army of labor Marx? How would you gauge Marx's approach in relation to the theories of effective demand developed by Kalecki and Keynes? Throughout economic theory, there are various responses to the creation and subsequent role of unemployment and the wage rate. In Karl Marx’s theory, unemployment, or the ‘reserve army of labour’, is necessary for capitalism to regenerate itself, and is also what

Non-Agricultural Market Access

1661 words - 7 pages industries from a gender perspective. Global Perspective The literature reviewed by Joekes (1999) concludes that there is a positive relation between trade expansion and women’s participation in workforce. The positive gender effect is largest in lowest income countries. Ozer (2000) analyses the relation between exports and female employment in Turkey. It finds a strong positive relation between exports and female share of employment and gets that

Antinepotism Case Study

1168 words - 5 pages enforced its anti-nepotism policy that was incorporated in the company handbook in 1980. The policy clearly states that, “It prohibits simultaneous employment by “close relatives” and “immediate family.” The policy was readily available to each employee and Mr. Walton was clearly aware of said policy. Once Mr. Walton’s manager confirmed his knowledge of knowing his uncle worked at the company he took it to upper management. With this

Managing Diversity

2291 words - 10 pages EEO, AA and MD are in relation to each other. In order to make sure people can obtain equal opportunity in employment, it requires mix of affirmative action, anti-discrimination legislation and managing diversity approach. It needs all three approaches to get the equal employment opportunity, as each of them has different emphasis and usage. Anti-discrimination and AA/EEO legislation do not pursue changing work practices explicitly, just remove

Report on Employment Relations Issues Relating to Aged Worker in Singapore

2017 words - 9 pages , and able to earn enough to sustain themselves so their retirement saving could last longer as long as they are physically fit to work (Khalik, 2009) 5. Employment Issues in Singapore There were four main issues that Singapore encountered related to employment relation which includes foreign workers flooding in to take up the job for locals, the impact of investments and labour-intensive industries relocating to other countries, problems

Patrick Stevedores Dispute

654 words - 3 pages Fox (1996) stated that there are two major employment relation frames; unitarism and pluralism. The unitarist approach of conflict believes that management, staff and the workforce are integrated and share the same goals and interests; thus working together towards the same targets and for the benefit of the company. In other words, there is no evident division between employers and employees (Loudoun, McPhail, Wilkinson, Sappey, Burgess, Lyons

Human Resource Management in Spain

1377 words - 6 pages SPANISH HISTORY WITH RELATION TO HUMAN RESOURCE ISSUES The story of Spain's economy did not take off until 1975 where they eventually turned into a democracy when General Franco and his regime died. The Spaniards once again looked to their king to take them into the unknown territory of democracy and brought them closer to the European Union. Through out the 20th century just 1/3 of the population either had a job or was looking for one. In

Related Essays

Equal Remuneration Act Essay

984 words - 4 pages relation to any employment carried on by or under the authority of the Central Government or a railway administration, or in relation to a banking company, a mine, oilfield or major port or any corporation established by or under a Central Act, the Central Government, and o (ii) In relation to any other employment, the State Government; o (b) “Commencement of this Act” means, in relation to an establishment or employment, the date

Identify And Explain The Main Changes That Have Occured To The Employment Relations Environment

2326 words - 10 pages employment relations. The developments in managerial thinking are the second significant changed in the employment relation environment. According to Kalleberg (2009), “changes in employment relations reflect the transformations in managerial regimes and systems of control”. In addition, before industrialization, the common working environment in industries and organisations were principally ruled by employers. Employers imposed the rules and

Corporate Finance Management And Modeling Essay

1225 words - 5 pages Corporate Financial Management and Modeling Paper Data Analysis about 90-day U.S. Treasury Bill Rate and Civilian Employment-Population Ratio 1.1 Abstract This data set contains 132 monthly observations, from January 2002 to December, 2012, using three different rates: three-month Treasury bill rate from the secondary market, the implied three-month forward rate of interest computed by pure expectation, and civilian employment

Three Elements Of A Good Employment Relationship

881 words - 4 pages Technology: The advancement in technology affects the productivity. It aids in producing more in less time. Distribution of Power in Society: This refers to the hierarchy of the organization. Three Actors: Unions: This is the body which represents the employees/workers. Management: This refers to the employers Government: It is linked by an ideology. It is the direct employment relation system in the country. Outcome: Rules of the workplace