This website uses cookies to ensure you have the best experience. Learn more

Electoral Systems Essay

1806 words - 8 pages

There is an on-going debate in Africa in general and Zambia in particular on what type of electoral system suits African contemporary political systems. In Zambia the debate is on wheter to adopt the majoritarian system (50%+1) in the current constitution making process or to remain with the current system which is the First Past The Post electoral system. The aim of this essay is to discuss the features of the two types of electoral system and point out of the two, which best suits the contemporary political system of Zambia. It will begin which describing the two electoral systems and then move on to the main aim, thereafter a conclusion will follow.
A first-past-the-post (abbreviated ...view middle of the document...

The most often cited advantages are that: It provides a clear-cut choice for voters between two main parties (Lijphart, 1999).
It advantages broadly-based political parties. In severely ethnically or regionally divided societies, FPTP is commended for encouraging political parties to be ‘broad churches’, encompassing many elements of society, particularly when there are only two major parties and many different societal groups. These parties can then field a diverse array of candidates for election (Powell, 1982).
The Majoritarian electoral system is also called the 50 plus one system in Political Science. This system allows a winning candidate to have more than 50% of the votes, hence having the majority votes in an election. 50 plus one also helps the incumbent president to have legitimacy from the voters as most people will see the power of their votes being manifested in the man or woman they eventually send to State House. Further, the majoritarian system will also reduce cases of electoral disputes as the person who becomes president wins outright unlike the current situation were a president can win with a meagre 35,000 votes and the losers live with suspicions of fraud and the stealing of votes. This system ensures that if no candidate wins more than 50% in the first round, the first two candidates head for a run-off election in which the voters choose a candidate who evntually presides over their nation for a prescribed number of years (Reilly, 2002).
Also called “second ballot” systems, majority electoral systems attempt to provide for a greater degree of representativeness by requiring that candidates achieve a majority of votes in order to win. “Majority” is normally defined as 50%-plus-one-vote. If no candidate gets a majority of votes, then a second round of voting is held (often a week or so after the initial ballot). In the second round of voting, only a select number of candidates from the first round are allowed to participate. Like plurality systems, majority systems usually rely on single-member constituencies, and allow voters to indicate only one preference on their ballot (ibid).
In large-scale public elections the two rounds of the majoritarian system are held on separate days, and so involve voters going to the polls twice. In smaller elections, such as those in assemblies or private organisations, it is sometimes possible to conduct both rounds in quick succession. However the fact that it involves two rounds means that, for large elections, majoritarian system is more expensive than some other electoral systems. It may also lead to voter fatigue and a reduced turn-out in the second round (Lijphart, 1999).
One of the strongest criticisms against the two-round voting system is the cost required to conduct two ballots. The two-round voting system also has the potential to cause political instability between the two rounds of voting, adding further to the economic impact of the two-round electoral system (Powell,...

Other Papers Like Electoral Systems

Electoral College Essay

1721 words - 7 pages of several systems. One is the winner-take-all system, where all electors go with the candidate that wins the popular vote, no matter how close it is. Another is the congressional district method, which is used in Maine and Nebraska where the vote is split between the electoral vote and the congressional district vote. The state is split into congressional districts and the winner of the popular vote in each district will receive an electoral vote

Defense for the Electoral College Essay

1633 words - 7 pages Chapter 6 Electoral College Assignment Explain the electoral college and its purpose as presented in the videos posted in the "Lecture and Video" tab. Do you think the electoral college is effective? Why? Yes I do believe the Electoral College is effective. I think the Electoral College is one of the most elegant systems in our republic. The key word here is republic and not democracy. We are not a true democracy in the sense that we

Electoral Dysfunction

1096 words - 5 pages What is the plot of Electoral Dysfunction? It’s fall of 2008, Mo (the Director) goes on a road trip to look closely at American election or voting system. He ends up visiting Indiana, which is said to have some of the strictest laws in country. How? It was one of the first states to pass a strict photo ID law and has never convicted anyone for it. Texas is a follower in which we also need to have an ID to cast a vote; We all students were

Voter Turnout in Canada

1815 words - 8 pages been associated with higher voter turnouts; as opposed to Single member plurality systems, the system used in Canada, where voters feel their efforts to make a difference are futile due to the “First Past the Post” functionality of the system (Dickerson, Flanagan & O'Neill, 2010). This is but one the many electoral systems practised in democratic nations all around the world. There are three varieties of electoral systems within the umbrella

Democratic Leadership Style

986 words - 4 pages other leadership styles. References Billsberry, J., (2009) (Ed) Discovering Leadership, Palgrave Macmillan, Basingstoke ( Part I, II, III- chapter 7, 9; Part IV chapter 11, 12; Part V, VI Chapters, 16, 18, Part VII, VIII Chapter 22) Caruso, D., & Mayer, P., (2004) The Emotionally Intelligent Manager, Jossey-Bass, San Francisco. Diamond L & Plattner MF. (2006) Electoral systems and democracy p.168. Goleman, D., Boyatzis, R., & McKee, A

Constitutional Reform Since 1997 Has Not Gone Far Enough. Discuss

1093 words - 5 pages on their rights and freedoms, however this Act of Parliament is not entrenched within the UK’s constitution. The electoral system has also been subject to interpretation under constitutional reform such as PR systems used for Scottish Parliament and devolved assemblies. The House of Lords Act 1999 put through under the Blair government removed all but 92 hereditary peers from the House of Lords. This meant that Parliament’s lower chamber could

Should Fptp Be Reformed?

1485 words - 6 pages to the House of Commons. There has been a long running debate on this issue, as there are other electoral systems being currently used I the UK for other things for example the Supplementary vote used the elections of the London Mayer. People argue that one of the other electoral systems could replace the First past the Post, in May 2011 a referendum was held asking the public if they would want to change to the system to AV. This was a

Us Politics

406 words - 2 pages human institutions are likely to become self-perpetuating. So it has been with the two-party system. The very fact that the nation began with a two-party system has been a leading reason for the retention of a two-party system. Over time, it has become an increasingly important, self-reinforcing reason. Many argue these criteria are used in US politics as the first-past-the-post electoral system in the USA makes life difficult for national third

International Relationals

2994 words - 12 pages . Within each constituency the candidate winning the most votes, whether or not the tally amounts to a majority, becomes the MP. Other bodies within the UK are most commonly elected by forms of PR. The first point I wish to draw your attention to is the matter of the electoral system and the proposed changes to the system. As you know electoral systems are very diverse and complex and ’the rules that govern how votes are cast and seats allocated


722 words - 3 pages The current electoral system has been constantly assessed and targeted by civilians who believe that First Past The Post is no longer effective and should be gotten rid of. Even though it lost in the 2011 referendum, People still believe the electoral system should be changed, especially the liberal democrats who are in favour of this change because they would benefit. FPTP is a simple plurality system the candidate with the most votes in one

The Electoral System In The U.S

1869 words - 8 pages world and it is utterly impossible to declare that one or the other is the best. It was obvious to me that I should just point to the differences without grading them or establishing a best. Farrell, David M. with his work :"Electoral Systems: A Comparative Introduction(2001)" was a great help for me but so where the internet with its only encyclopedias where everything is handy and paper encyclopedias also. Farrell was the one to point out that

Related Essays

Electoral Systems Of Germany And Finland

1184 words - 5 pages Two Countries and governments that have electoral system similarities are those of Germany and Finland. They both use systems of the proportional representation model. Proportional representation, also called "full representation" is the voting system used in most Western democracies and is widely considered to be fairer and more democratic than the current U.S. system.THE FINNISH SYSTEMHistoryThe Finnish system came into being in 1906

Proportional Electoral Systems Cause As Many Problems As They Solve

1038 words - 5 pages are transferred to the remaining candidates. The purpose of this essay is to discuss both the advantages and disadvantages of proportional electoral systems as well as systems that don’t use proportional representation to come to the conclusion as to whether Proportional electoral systems cause as many problems as they solve. One example of a proportional electoral system is the Additional Member System ; this is where the elector casts two votes

Assess The Advantages Of The Various Electoral Systems

978 words - 4 pages Assess the advantages of the various electoral systems One of the many electoral systems is the First-Past-The-Post system (FPTP), the current system for electing MPs to the House of Commons. There are 659 separate constituencies across the UK each electing one single Member of Parliament. In order to vote you simply put an ‘X’ next to the name of the candidate you support. The candidate who gets the most votes wins, regardless of whether he or

Explain The Main Impacts Of Any Two Electoral Systems Other Than First Past The Post

537 words - 3 pages Explain the main impacts of any two electoral systems other than First Past the Post (10 marks) Proportional systems such as closed party list are distinctly more in favour of smaller parties than most other systems. This is attributed to the fact that the percentage of votes cast in favour of a party directly corresponds to the percentage of seats they gain; this leads to an exceptionally more accurate result than majoritarian systems. Because